Industry
Retail banking & cards
How retail banking customers choose, stay and leave: switching, cards, savings behaviour under rate moves, and the gap between what people say they will do and what they do.
What makes a banking customer move, and how big does the reason have to be?
- #
44%
44.0% (88 of 200) would pay for a $1,200 appliance in four interest-free payments of $300 every two weeks rather than use their credit card, against 40.5% (81) at $300 and 19.5% (39) at $3,000. — Buy now, pay later vs credit card: 44.0% of US card holders would split a $1,200 appliance into four interest-free payments, but only 19.5% would at $3,000, where 29.5% would rather wait
base 200
- #
64%
64.0% (128 of 200) would be likely to take an unfamiliar online lender's $10,000 three-year loan at 8% APR rather than their own bank's at 14%, against 42.0% (84) at 11% and 15.0% (30) at 13%. — Personal loans: 64.0% of US borrowers would leave their own bank's 14% offer for an unfamiliar online lender at 8%, though 193 of 200 would ask the bank first and only 3 would reach for a credit card
base 200
- #
22%
22.0% (44 of 200) would be likely to move their main checking account if their bank's mobile app stopped working for several hours every week, against 1.5% (3) at once a month and 0 of 200 at twice a year, with fees, interest and everything else held the same. Likely means 5, 6 or 7 on a 7-point scale. — Banking apps and switching banks: only 5.0% of US checking customers name a failing app as their reason to leave, but weekly outages leave 22.0% likely to move, and 81.5% would stay for a website and phone line that keep working
base 200
- #
12%
12.0% (24 of 200) would be likely to move their main checking account within three months if a $400 fraudulent debit card charge took 30 days to come back, against 0.5% (1) at 10 business days and 0.0% (0) when it came back the same day. Likely means 5, 6 or 7 on a 7-point scale. — Card fraud refunds and bank loyalty: a 30-day wait leaves 12.0% of US debit card holders likely to move their main account, against 0.5% at 10 business days, and 71.0% would stay for a 24-hour refund promise
base 200
- #
58.5%
58.5% (117 of 200) would be likely to refinance at a rate 1.5 points below their own with $5,000 in closing costs paid up front, against 47.0% (94) at one point lower and 0.0% (none) at half a point. — Mortgage refinancing: none of 200 would switch for half a point off their rate, 47.0% would for a full point
base 200
Which questions does Brox answer in retail banking & cards?
What has Brox published on retail banking & cards?Newest first
-
Buy now, pay later vs credit card: 44.0% of US card holders would split a $1,200 appliance into four interest-free payments, but only 19.5% would at $3,000, where 29.5% would rather wait
44% 44.0% (88 of 200) would pay for a $1,200 appliance in four interest-free payments of $300 every two weeks rather than use their credit card, against 40.5% (81) at $300 and 19.5% (39) at $3,000. (base 200)
Read -
Personal loans: 64.0% of US borrowers would leave their own bank's 14% offer for an unfamiliar online lender at 8%, though 193 of 200 would ask the bank first and only 3 would reach for a credit card
64% 64.0% (128 of 200) would be likely to take an unfamiliar online lender's $10,000 three-year loan at 8% APR rather than their own bank's at 14%, against 42.0% (84) at 11% and 15.0% (30) at 13%. (base 200)
Read -
Banking apps and switching banks: only 5.0% of US checking customers name a failing app as their reason to leave, but weekly outages leave 22.0% likely to move, and 81.5% would stay for a website and phone line that keep working
22% 22.0% (44 of 200) would be likely to move their main checking account if their bank's mobile app stopped working for several hours every week, against 1.5% (3) at once a month and 0 of 200 at twice a year, with fees, interest and everything else held the same. Likely means 5, 6 or 7 on a 7-point scale. (base 200)
Read -
Card fraud refunds and bank loyalty: a 30-day wait leaves 12.0% of US debit card holders likely to move their main account, against 0.5% at 10 business days, and 71.0% would stay for a 24-hour refund promise
12% 12.0% (24 of 200) would be likely to move their main checking account within three months if a $400 fraudulent debit card charge took 30 days to come back, against 0.5% (1) at 10 business days and 0.0% (0) when it came back the same day. Likely means 5, 6 or 7 on a 7-point scale. (base 200)
Read -
Mortgage refinancing: none of 200 would switch for half a point off their rate, 47.0% would for a full point
58.5% 58.5% (117 of 200) would be likely to refinance at a rate 1.5 points below their own with $5,000 in closing costs paid up front, against 47.0% (94) at one point lower and 0.0% (none) at half a point. (base 200)
Read -
Overdraft fees and switching banks: a $35 charge leaves 46.0% of US checking customers likely to move to a fee-free rival, against 19.5% at $5, while 54.0% stay put at every fee
46% After one overdraft fee on a $4 shortfall, with a fee-free rival of similar size and convenience on offer, 19.5% (39 of 200) would be likely to move their main checking account within three months at $5, 32.0% (64) at $15 and 46.0% (92) at $35. (base 200)
Read -
Savings rate gap: 59.0% of US savers would move for 4.00% against 0.50%, but 41.0% would stay put at every rate tested
59% With their own savings account at 0.50%, 45.5% (91 of 200) would be likely to move most of their savings to an FDIC-insured online bank paying 1.50%, 54.5% (109) at 2.50% and 59.0% (118) at 4.00%. (base 200)
Read -
Lock in a CD or wait? A half-point rate-hike forecast cuts US savers likely to lock in from 85.5% to 18.5%, with the CD and savings rates unchanged
18.5% With a 12-month CD at 4.50% and high-yield savings at 4.00% held fixed, 85.5% (171 of 200) would be likely to lock $5,000 into the CD when forecasters expect rates to stay flat, 18.5% (37) when they expect a half-point rise and 2.0% (4) when they expect a full-point rise. (base 200)
Read -
Bank switching bonuses buy deposits, not customers: at $500, 54.5% of US checking customers would move their direct deposit but only 13% would make the new bank their main bank
13% At a $500 sign-up bonus, 41.5% (83 of 200) would move their direct deposit only long enough to collect the bonus and 13.0% (26) would make the new bank their main bank; at $300 the figures are 27.5% (55) and 9.5% (19), and at $100 9.5% (19) and 5.5% (11). (base 200)
Read -
CD or high-yield savings after the Fed hike: 52% of US savers are very likely to lock in at a 0.75-point premium, against 11% at 0.25 points, and emergencies, not rate bets, keep the rest liquid
52% 52.0% (104 of 200) would be very likely to put $5,000 they will not need for a year into a 12-month CD paying 4.75% against 4.00% in high-yield savings, against 11.0% (22) at 4.25% and 72.5% (145) at 5.25%. (base 200)
Read -
Switching credit cards: 78% would move their everyday spending for 3% cash back, but only 40.5% for 2%, and a better rate beats a welcome bonus 129 to 11
78% 78.0% (156 of 200) would be likely, 4 or 5 on a five-point scale, to apply for a no-annual-fee card and move their everyday spending to it at 3% cash back on every purchase, against 40.5% (81) at 2% and 94.5% (189) at 5%. (base 200)
Read -
I'll switch tomorrow: 65% said they would move banks for a better deal, and 44% did
65% said they would move banks for a better deal (base 1,053)
Read -
In a severe downturn, 90% would protect the mortgage or rent at all costs, and buy now, pay later loans and credit cards are cut first
90% would protect the mortgage at all costs in a severe downturn (base 476)
Read -
米国トップ4の銀行がクローン手法を検証 | US Bank Clone Study (JP)
とある米国を代表する大手銀行チームは、複数の顧客セグメントにわたって FinTech(フィンテック)企業がもたらす市場脅威 を理解する必要がありました。
Read -
Ask Brox に何でもご質問下さい | Ask Brox Anything (JP)
Ask Brox の金融テンプレート集。顧客行動、トレードオフ分析、競合分析、商品採用、経済見通しといった基本的なビジネス課題に、実在する人々のクローンが迅速に回答する例をまとめたもの。
Read -
Prediktif Bankacılık Analizi | Predictive Banking Analysis (TR)
4 financial institutions modelled under the same events
Read -
Eight bank crises: a liquidity squeeze leaves 67% ready to withdraw deposits and 51% ready to switch banks
3.47 highest composite risk score (of 5) of the eight crisis scenarios (base 435)
Read -
Predicting bank momentum: a cyber attack cuts a digital-first bank's net momentum by 42% and a big bank's by 2%
4 financial institutions modelled under the same events
Read -
Fees and Interest Dominate: 11 of the Top 15 Credit Card Fixes Lower-Income Customers Want
226 customer-sourced credit card ideas tested (base 2,000)
Read
What do people ask about retail banking & cards?
- Would people use buy-now-pay-later instead of a credit card to pay for something big, and why?
- 44.0% of US adults with a credit card would split a $1,200 home appliance into four interest-free buy-now-pay-later payments rather than use their card, but at $3,000 that falls to 19.5% and 29.5% would wait or not buy at all (n=200, November 2026).Read the insight
- Where do people go first for a $10,000 personal loan: their own bank, an online lender, a credit card or pay-later, and what decides it?
- 193 of 200 US adults on a finance panel would go to their own bank or credit union first for a $10,000 personal loan, but the rate decides where they borrow: 64.0% would take an unfamiliar online lender's loan at 8% APR over their own bank's 14% (n=200, November 2026).Read the insight
- What would make a customer leave a bank over its app alone?
- If their bank's mobile app stopped working for several hours every week, 22.0% of US checking customers would be likely to move their main checking account, against 1.5% at once a month and none at twice a year, yet only 5.0% name a failing app as the thing most likely to make them leave (n=200, November 2026).Read the insight
- How fast does a bank need to refund card fraud to keep the customer?
- If a bank takes 30 days to return a $400 fraudulent debit card charge, 12.0% of US debit card holders would be likely to move their main checking account within three months, against 0.5% when it takes 10 business days and none when it is refunded the same day (n=200, November 2026).Read the insight
- How many people would move their mortgage to get a better rate, and what stops the rest?
- 58.5% of US mortgage holders (117 of 200 Brox clones) would be likely to refinance at a rate 1.5 points below their own with $5,000 in closing costs, against 47.0% at one point lower and none at half a point (n=200, November 2026).Read the insight
- At what overdraft fee do customers switch banks, and do they really leave over one fee?
- After one $35 overdraft fee on a $4 shortfall, 46.0% of US checking customers would be likely to move their main account to a fee-free rival bank within three months, against 32.0% at $15 and 19.5% at $5 (n=200, November 2026).Read the insight
- How big a savings-rate gap does it take for US savers to move their money, and how fast do they move?
- Offered 4.00% at an FDIC-insured online bank against 0.50% on their own savings account, 59.0% of US savers would be likely to move most of their savings, against 45.5% at 1.50%, while 41.0% stayed unlikely at all three rates tested (n=200, October 2026).Read the insight
- When rates are rising, do savers lock money into a CD or wait for a better rate?
- With a 12-month CD paying 4.50% and a high-yield savings account 4.00%, 85.5% of US savers would be likely to lock $5,000 into the CD if forecasters expect rates to stay flat, but only 18.5% if they expect a half-point rise (n=200, October 2026).Read the insight
- What makes people move their main checking account to a new bank: a cash bonus, a higher rate or a better app?
- Asked what would most make them move their main checking account, 33.5% of US checking customers chose no fees, 28.5% a cash bonus, 18.0% a higher savings rate and 2.5% a better app, yet even at a $500 bonus only 13.0% would make the new bank their main bank while 41.5% would move their direct deposit just long enough to collect it (n=200, October 2026).Read the insight
- After the September 2026 Fed rate hike, will US savers lock money into a CD or keep it liquid in savings?
- 52.0% of US savers would be very likely to put $5,000 they will not need for a year into a 12-month CD paying 4.75% against 4.00% in a high-yield savings account, up from 11.0% when the CD pays 4.25% (n=200, October 2026).Read the insight
Other industries
How should you read these findings?
Where the numbers come from. Every figure on this site is a predicted response from Brox clones: behavioural replicas of real people, each built from a long-form interview with that person. The base under each figure is the number of clones behind it.
Where the real data comes from. The long-form video interviews with the real people the clones are built from. A quote is always shown with the interview line it was predicted from.
What you can take away. Insights publish their tabulation as CSV and JSON: question, option, count, percentage and base. Never per-person rows.
Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai