Bank switching bonuses buy deposits, not customers: at $500, 54.5% of US checking customers would move their direct deposit but only 13% would make the new bank their main bank
Asked what would most make them move their main checking account, 33.5% of US checking customers chose no fees, 28.5% a cash bonus, 18.0% a higher savings rate and 2.5% a better app, yet even at a $500 bonus only 13.0% would make the new bank their main bank while 41.5% would move their direct deposit just long enough to collect it (n=200, October 2026).
- Who was asked
- US checking customers, 200 clones, US
- When
- October 2026 (fielded 21 October 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- The obvious question, why people switch banks, is answered by satisfaction surveys that report switching rates and reasons. We turned it into a tipping point on the part they do not measure: at $100, $300 and $500, does a sign-up bonus win the account the pay goes into for good, or only for the 90 days it takes to collect, and how does a bonus rank against no fees, a savings rate, a branch and an app?
Section 01: What the panel said
- #
13%
At a $500 sign-up bonus, 41.5% (83 of 200) would move their direct deposit only long enough to collect the bonus and 13.0% (26) would make the new bank their main bank; at $300 the figures are 27.5% (55) and 9.5% (19), and at $100 9.5% (19) and 5.5% (11).
base 200
- #
2.5%
Only 2.5% (5 of 200) name a better mobile banking app as the one thing most likely to make them move their main checking account, against 33.5% (67) for no monthly and no overdraft fees, 28.5% (57) for a cash bonus, 18.0% (36) for a higher savings rate and 17.5% (35) for a branch nearby.
base 200
- #
53.1%
Of the 128 who say being happy with their current bank would most stop them moving, 53.1% (68) would still move their direct deposit for a $500 bonus, 43.0% (55) only to collect it and 10.2% (13) to make the new bank their main bank.
base 128 · Say being happy with their current bank would most stop them moving · contrast
- #
71.4%
The bonus works mainly on younger customers: at $500, 71.4% of 18 to 44 year olds (60 of 84) would move their direct deposit, against 48.9% of 45 to 64 year olds (46 of 94) and 3 of the 22 clones aged 65 or over.
base 84 · Aged 18-44 · caveat
At a $500 sign-up bonus, 41.5% (83 of 200) would move their direct deposit only long enough to collect the bonus and 13.0% (26) would make the new bank their main bank; at $300 the figures are 27.5% (55) and 9.5% (19), and at $100 9.5% (19) and 5.5% (11).
02How much does a bigger sign-up bonus actually buy a bank?
Mostly a deposit that leaves again. Each clone was offered a free checking account at a bank it does not use, with no monthly fee and an app that does everything its own bank's app does, plus a cash bonus for having its pay paid in by direct deposit for at least 90 days. At $100, 15.0% (30 of 200) would take the offer; at $300, 37.0% (74); at $500, 54.5% (109). Most of that rise is people who would move their direct deposit only long enough to collect the bonus and then move it back: 9.5% (19) at $100, 27.5% (55) at $300 and 41.5% (83) at $500. Those who would make the new bank their main bank climb far more slowly, from 5.5% (11) to 9.5% (19) to 13.0% (26).
Each bonus was written out in full as its own question, and each clone's reasoning named the amount it was given: the $500 question's reasoning names $500 in 173 of 200 answers. Only 2 of the 200 clones gave a less committed answer at a higher bonus than at a lower one.
The reading a researcher would find interesting is that a sign-up bonus wins deposits rather than primary banking relationships, and that the bigger the bonus, the larger the share of takers who would leave: 19 of the 30 takers at $100, and 83 of the 109 at $500. The strictest reading is narrower: in stated intent, with the new account matching the old one on fees and app, collecting and leaving grows faster than switching for good at every step, and the absolute levels probably overstate what people would actually do. The offers we tested sit inside the real market, where checking bonuses listed in October 2026 mostly run from about $100 to $900 and ask for direct deposits over 30 to 90 days.
03Who would take the bonus and leave?
Younger customers, men and lower earners take the bonus most often, but collectors outnumber permanent movers in every group. At $500, 71.4% of 18 to 44 year olds (60 of 84) would move their direct deposit, 56.0% (47) of them only to collect it, against 48.9% of 45 to 64 year olds (46 of 94) and 3 of the 22 clones aged 65 or over. 67.2% of men (43 of 64) would take the $500, against 48.5% of women (66 of 136), and 65.1% of those with household incomes under $50,000 (41 of 63), against 48.5% of those on $100,000 or more (33 of 68).
Wanting the bonus does not mean wanting the bank. Of the 57 clones who named a cash bonus as the thing most likely to make them move, 24.6% (14) would make the new bank their main bank at $500, and 45.6% (26) would collect the bonus and move their direct deposit back.
04If not a bonus, what would make people move their main checking account?
No fees, roughly level with a cash bonus, and both far ahead of a better app. Asked for the one thing most likely to make them move the account their pay goes into, 33.5% (67 of 200) chose no monthly fees and no overdraft fees, 28.5% (57) a cash bonus, 18.0% (36) a higher interest rate on savings at the new bank, 17.5% (35) a branch close to where they live or work, and 2.5% (5) a better mobile banking app. Fees came first among women and among 18 to 44 year olds, while men and 45 to 64 year olds put the bonus first, so the two work as a pair rather than a ranking.
What holds people back is mostly contentment rather than friction. Of the 199 clones who answered, 64.3% (128) chose being happy with their current bank as the thing that would most stop them moving, 15.6% (31) not trusting a bank they have not used before, 12.1% (24) moving their automatic bill payments and subscriptions, 6.5% (13) the time and paperwork of opening an account, and 1.5% (3) keeping their savings, cards and loans with one bank.
The interesting reading is that the banking app, where so much of the industry's investment goes, is close to irrelevant as a reason to switch. The defensible reading is that 5 of 200 pick it as their single top reason; an app may still matter for keeping customers, which this study did not ask.
05What would a deposit or acquisition marketer do with this?
- A reading, not the panel's answer: price a bonus for the deposit it holds for 90 days, not for the main-bank customer it might win. At $500, those who would collect and leave outnumber those who would stay 83 to 26.
- A reading: lead the offer with no monthly and no overdraft fees, the reason most often named for moving (33.5%), and use the bonus to get the account opened, since the two are named about equally and only one of them lasts past the qualifying period.
- A reading: after contentment, the barriers are trust in an unfamiliar bank (31 of 199) and moving automatic payments (24), so help with moving payments and plain evidence that the new bank is safe are the levers left once the bonus has done its work.
It sits beside two earlier Brox pages on the same panels: 78% of US credit card users would move their everyday spending for 3% cash back, and 52% of US savers would lock into a CD at a 0.75-point premium. The CFPB's guide to bank accounts and services covers what moving a checking account involves.
06What do people also ask about bank switching bonuses?
- What share of people would switch banks for a $500 bonus? 54.5% of US checking customers (109 of 200, October 2026) would move their direct deposit to a new bank for a $500 bonus, but only 13.0% (26) would make it their main bank.
- At what bonus do people start moving their direct deposit? At $100, 15.0% would move their direct deposit; at $300, 37.0%; at $500, 54.5% (n=200), and most of them would move it back once the bonus was paid.
- How many people would switch banks for a better banking app? 2.5% (5 of 200) name a better mobile banking app as the thing most likely to make them move their main checking account, against 33.5% for no fees and 28.5% for a cash bonus.
Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“I think I would probably move my pay over just long enough to get that $500 bonus and then move it back to my regular bank. A $500 cash bonus is a really good value and something that would be worth doing, especially since there are no monthly fees and the app has what I need. But when it comes to my main bank, I really value trust and familiarity. I trust my primary bank because I've been with them for so long and I know what to expect from them as a customer. So while I wouldn't want to pass up that kind of reward, I wouldn't want to leave my main bank permanently either.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“Right now, my primary bank is what I would say I trust the most because I've used them the longest. I've known them more. I know what I can expect from them. I know what they can provide me as a customer.”
“Honestly, I'm very loyal to my bank and it's hard to get me to move, but if anything could even tempt me or matter at all, it would definitely be no monthly fees and no overdraft fees. Not charging me fees to keep or access my own money is number one in my book. I can't stand hidden costs or being charged obsessive amounts just to use my money, so having zero monthly maintenance fees and perks like overdraft coverage would be the only thing that would make a genuine difference to me.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“they don't charge me to keep or use my own money. That's number one in my book.”
“Five hundred dollars is five hundred dollars, so I would definitely move my direct deposit over for the 90 days to get that bonus, but I would switch it right back to my credit union as soon as I got it. Anyone who knows me knows I am all about a side hustle and finding ways to make extra money, especially with having bills and trying to pay off my personal loan. Free money is free money, and $500 is a really nice chunk of change to pass up. But there is no way I would keep that new bank as my main everyday bank permanently. I love my local credit union in town, I've always banked there, I trust them completely, and I need a real physical branch with real people I can go talk to face-to-face if something goes wrong. So I'd play the game, grab the bonus, and take my direct deposit straight back home.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“Well, my main account is a credit union actually and I love it. I actually am not quite sure I should do more research on what the difference is between a credit union and a bank. I personally do use a credit union in my small town and it's been a great experience. I've never had a problem. Never. It's awesome. I do love it.”
Section 08: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- Within the same 200 clones, collecting and leaving grows faster than switching for good at every bonus level: 9.5% to 27.5% to 41.5%, against 5.5% to 9.5% to 13.0%, and at $500 collectors outnumber permanent movers in every age, gender and income group.
- No fees and a cash bonus are the two reasons most often named for moving a main checking account (62.0%, 124 of 200, together), and a better app is named by 2.5% (5), last in every age and gender group.
- Being happy with one's bank stops a switch of main bank more than it stops bonus collecting: of the 128 who chose it, 13 would make the new bank their main bank at $500 and 55 would collect and leave.
What we would not
- The take-up levels as a forecast: these are stated intentions in a scenario where the new account matches the old one on fees and app, so real take-up is probably lower.
- No fees ahead of a cash bonus as a ranking: 67 against 57 of 200, and men and 45 to 64 year olds put the bonus first.
- The over-65 figure as more than a count (3 of 22), or any income cut finer than three bands.
- The step from $300 to $500 as a precise price response: three bonus levels show the shape, not the curve.
The main limitation
The panel is the Finance (US) audience, 68% women (136 of 200) and interested in money, answering a stated-intent scenario that spells out the 90-day direct deposit condition; the robust result is the split between collecting and staying within the same clones, not the absolute levels.
Section 09: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Women | 136 |
| Men | 64 |
Question wording as fielded
- Is your pay or main income paid into a checking account in your name? (screener; 315 of 353 qualified, 200 fielded)
- Which one of these would be most likely to make you move your main checking account, the one your pay goes into, to a different bank?
- A bank you do not use today offers a $100 cash bonus if you open its free checking account and have your pay paid into it by direct deposit for at least 90 days. The account has no monthly fee, and its app does everything your current bank's app does. What would you most likely do? (fielded by Ask Brox as one question with three series: $100, $300, $500)
- A bank you do not use today offers a $300 cash bonus if you open its free checking account and have your pay paid into it by direct deposit for at least 90 days. The account has no monthly fee, and its app does everything your current bank's app does. What would you most likely do? (fielded by Ask Brox as one question with three series: $100, $300, $500)
- A bank you do not use today offers a $500 cash bonus if you open its free checking account and have your pay paid into it by direct deposit for at least 90 days. The account has no monthly fee, and its app does everything your current bank's app does. What would you most likely do? (fielded by Ask Brox as one question with three series: $100, $300, $500)
- What would most stop you moving your main checking account, the one your pay goes into, to a different bank?
What was not asked, and why
No bank, card or brand was named or asked about. We did not test bonuses above $500, minimum deposit amounts, how long people would keep their pay at the new bank after the 90 days, or whether an app matters for keeping customers rather than winning them. Ask Brox fielded the three bonus questions as one question with three series and added no questions of its own.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question, why people switch banks, is answered by satisfaction surveys that report switching rates and reasons. We turned it into a tipping point on the part they do not measure: at $100, $300 and $500, does a sign-up bonus win the account the pay goes into for good, or only for the 90 days it takes to collect, and how does a bonus rank against no fees, a savings rate, a branch and an app?
Fielded through Ask Brox on 21 October 2026.
More on Choosing and leaving a primary bank · Switching and churn · Retail banking & cards · Finance (US) panel
Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai
Related insights
All in this topic-
Mortgage refinancing: none of 200 would switch for half a point off their rate, 47.0% would for a full point
58.5% 58.5% (117 of 200) would be likely to refinance at a rate 1.5 points below their own with $5,000 in closing costs paid up front, against 47.0% (94) at one point lower and 0.0% (none) at half a point. (base 200)
Read -
Overdraft fees and switching banks: a $35 charge leaves 46.0% of US checking customers likely to move to a fee-free rival, against 19.5% at $5, while 54.0% stay put at every fee
46% After one overdraft fee on a $4 shortfall, with a fee-free rival of similar size and convenience on offer, 19.5% (39 of 200) would be likely to move their main checking account within three months at $5, 32.0% (64) at $15 and 46.0% (92) at $35. (base 200)
Read -
Car insurance loyalty penalty: a $225 new-customer discount moves 0 of 200 to leave, the same $225 from a rival moves 28%, though 70.5% think new customers pay less
28% 28.0% (56 of 200) would move as soon as they can when a different insurer quotes $1,275 against a $1,500 renewal. When the $1,275 is what their own insurer is quoting new customers, 0 of 200 would move: 66.0% (132) would ask it to match and 34.0% (68) would get quotes first. (base 200)
Read -
Switching a stable patient: 59% of US clinicians, mostly dermatologists, keep the current therapy at a 15-point efficacy gain, and a third still do at 30 points
58.6% 58.6% of US clinicians would keep a patient stable for two years on the current therapy when a newer one gets 75 patients in 100 to the treatment goal against 60, with similar safety and the same cost to the patient; 85.8% keep at 65 against 60 and 32.5% still keep at 90 against 60. (base 169)
Read