Personal loans: 64.0% of US borrowers would leave their own bank's 14% offer for an unfamiliar online lender at 8%, though 193 of 200 would ask the bank first and only 3 would reach for a credit card
193 of 200 US adults on a finance panel would go to their own bank or credit union first for a $10,000 personal loan, but the rate decides where they borrow: 64.0% would take an unfamiliar online lender's loan at 8% APR over their own bank's 14% (n=200, November 2026).
- Who was asked
- Finance, 200 clones, US
- When
- November 2026 (fielded 19 November 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- The obvious question asks where people borrow. We asked 200 clones on our US finance panel where they would go first and what matters most, both in general and before anything else, then showed the same 200 the same $10,000 loan from their own bank at 14% against an online lender they have never used at 13%, 11% and 8%. That turns a preference into a price: how big a rate gap it takes to win the loan away from the bank they would ask first.
Section 01: What the panel said
- #
64%
64.0% (128 of 200) would be likely to take an unfamiliar online lender's $10,000 three-year loan at 8% APR rather than their own bank's at 14%, against 42.0% (84) at 11% and 15.0% (30) at 13%.
base 200
- #
193
193 of 200 would go to their own bank or credit union first for a $10,000 loan; 4 would go to an online lender, 3 to a credit card and none to buy now, pay later. Read this as direction, because it is near-unanimous.
base 200 · contrast
- #
43.5%
43.5% (30 of 69) of clones who say borrowing from a company they already bank with matters most would take the online loan at 8%, against 77.3% (75 of 97) of those who put the lowest rate first; at 11% the split is 8.7% (6 of 69) against 62.9% (61 of 97).
base 69 · Say borrowing from a company they already bank with matters most · contrast
- #
36%
36.0% (72 of 200) were unlikely to take the online loan at all three rates, even 6 points lower and $29 a month cheaper; their answers turn on not knowing or trusting a lender they have never used.
base 200 · caveat
64.0% (128 of 200) would be likely to take an unfamiliar online lender's $10,000 three-year loan at 8% APR rather than their own bank's at 14%, against 42.0% (84) at 11% and 15.0% (30) at 13%.
02How big a rate gap wins a $10,000 loan away from a customer's own bank?
Three points does most of the work. We held everything else fixed: the same $10,000 over three years, no fees at either lender and the money in two business days at both. Only the online lender's rate changed. At 13% against the bank's 14%, a saving of $5 a month, 15.0% (30 of 200) were likely to take the online loan. At 11%, $15 a month cheaper, that rose to 42.0% (84). At 8%, $29 a month cheaper, it reached 64.0% (128). Widening the gap from 1 point to 3 won over 54 more clones, and from 3 points to 6 another 44.
The interesting reading is that the bank's first look is a habit, not loyalty at any price. Almost everyone would ask their own bank first, yet a gap of three points is enough to move 42.0% of the panel to a lender they have never used. What the numbers support is narrower: within the same 200 clones the share likely to switch rises at every rung, and none went from likely to unlikely as the gap widened.
03Who needs the biggest gap before they switch?
Older and lower-income clones. At 8%, 50.0% (21 of 42) of clones aged 65 or over are likely to take the online loan, against 73.2% (30 of 41) aged 18-29. At 13%, only 3 of the 42 aged 65 or over would. By household income, 54.3% (38 of 70) under $50,000 would switch at 8%, against 73.7% (42 of 57) on $100,000 or more. Women and men end at the same place, 64 clones each at 8%, but men move sooner: 18 of 96 at 13% against 12 of 104 women.
The rise appears in every age, income, gender and region group we cut, so the shape holds even where the level is lower.
04Where do credit cards and pay-later fit for a $10,000 expense?
Hardly at all. Asked in general where they would go first for $10,000 repaid over three years, 3 of 200 picked a credit card, including a new card with a 0% introductory rate, and none picked buy now, pay later financing from the seller. 4 picked an online lender. For a sum this size, the competitor to the bank is the online lender, and it wins on price.
What matters most splits the panel in two. 48.5% (97 of 200) put the lowest interest rate first and 34.5% (69) borrowing from a company they already bank with. Being confident of approval came third at 8.5% (17), low or no fees at 7.0% (14) and speed at 1.5% (3). We set the bank's offer at 14% and did not vary it; the Federal Reserve's G.19 release tracks what banks actually charge on personal loans.
05What would a lending or card team do with this?
- A reading for banks: the first call is yours, so the offer you make on it matters more than the marketing that gets you the call. Inside a point of the best online rate, 170 of 200 clones stay put.
- A reading for online lenders: the price of a stranger's loan is roughly three points. Below that gap most customers do not move, and trust, not rate, is what the remaining third talk about.
- A reading for card issuers: a $10,000 three-year need is personal loan territory for nearly everyone here, so a card offer competes for the smaller, shorter spend.
06What else do people ask about where to get a personal loan?
- What share of borrowers go to their own bank first for a personal loan? 193 of 200 clones would go to their own bank or credit union first for a $10,000 loan (n=200, November 2026).
- At what rate gap do borrowers leave their bank for an online lender? 15.0% would switch at 1 point lower, 42.0% at 3 points and 64.0% at 6 points, on a 14% bank offer (n=200).
- How many people would use a credit card for a $10,000 expense? 3 of 200 clones would turn to a credit card first, and none to buy now, pay later (n=200).
Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“I am very likely to go with the online lender. An 8% APR compared to 14% is a huge difference, saving around $30 every single month and a lot over three years. There's no reason to pay extra just to borrow from a traditional bank when an online lender offers the exact same funds, zero fees, and the same payout speed. I already do most of my finances online and find newer fintech and online lending platforms to be lean, convenient, and safe. Taking the lower rate from the online lender just makes total financial sense.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I think the newer financial applications are doing an outstanding job doing much better job than the banks with not very much overhead in real estate I think they're lean I think they're safe I think they're convenient I find myself using them”
“If I needed to borrow $10,000 for a major expense like a car or home repair, my credit union would definitely be my first stop. I have always preferred credit unions over big banks or other financing because they are customer-owned and focused on regular people, and I already do all of my day-to-day banking there. I'd go in and speak directly with them to see what options they could give me. Going to an unfamiliar online lender or racking up credit card debt wouldn't be my approach at all, so starting with my own credit union is hands down my first choice.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I am very pro-credit union, so that would always be my first choice.”
“I would say I'm very unlikely to take the online lender's loan. Even though an 8% APR sounds better than 14% and would save some money each month, I'm just very skeptical of financial companies or online lenders I've never used before. Trust and security mean everything to me when it comes to money. With an unknown online lender, you don't know if they're shady, if there are hidden issues, or what happens if something goes wrong. With my own bank, I've been with them for years, they're vetted, and they've always been reliable and had my back. I'd rather stick with an institution I know and trust than take a chance on a stranger.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I stay with my branch because with my bank because I don't know if something's gonna go wrong with this startup. There's no guarantee, there's no trust there so no I would not do anything.”
Section 08: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- Within the same 200 clones, the share likely to take the online loan rises at every rung, 15.0% to 42.0% to 64.0%, and no clone went from likely to unlikely as the gap widened.
- The rise appears in every gender, age, income and region group we cut.
- The clones answered the rate they were given: 81, 114 and 161 of 200 name 13%, 11% and 8% on their own rung, and none names another rung's rate or payment.
- Clones who put an existing bank first need a far bigger gap to move: 6 of 69 at 3 points, against 61 of 97 of those who put the lowest rate first.
What we would not
- The levels as a population estimate: this is a finance panel, not a nationally representative one, and it holds 42 clones aged 65 or over, the group least likely to move (21 of 42 at 8%).
- Any figure as a forecast of loans taken: they are stated intentions about a written offer, and a stated intention is not a signed loan.
- 193 of 200 going to their own bank first as a measured share: it is near-unanimous, and 164 of the 200 answers are inferred from the person's wider interview rather than a direct statement about borrowing.
- The age and income splits to the decimal: bases run from 41 to 73, so read them as direction.
- Anything about what makes a clone choose speed, fees or approval odds: 3, 14 and 17 clones picked those as what matters most.
The main limitation
These are stated intentions about a written loan offer, and all 200 answers on each rung are reasoned from each person's wider interview rather than a direct statement about this offer. Read the levels as direction and the shifts within the same clones as the result.
Section 09: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Women | 104 |
| Men | 96 |
| Aged 18-29 | 41 |
| Aged 30-44 | 49 |
| Aged 45-64 | 68 |
| Aged 65 or over | 42 |
| Household income under $50,000 | 70 |
| Household income $50,000 to $99,999 | 73 |
| Household income $100,000 or more | 57 |
Question wording as fielded
- In general, if you needed to borrow $10,000 for a large one-off expense, such as a major car or home repair, and would pay it back over about three years, where would you go first?
- In general, which one thing would matter most to you in deciding where to borrow $10,000?
- Your own bank offers you a $10,000 personal loan, repaid over three years at 14% APR, which is about $342 a month. An online lender you have never used before offers you the same $10,000 loan, repaid over three years at 13% APR, which is about $337 a month. Neither charges any fees, and both would pay the money into your account within two business days. How likely are you to take the online lender's loan instead of your own bank's?
- Your own bank offers you a $10,000 personal loan, repaid over three years at 14% APR, which is about $342 a month. An online lender you have never used before offers you the same $10,000 loan, repaid over three years at 11% APR, which is about $327 a month. Neither charges any fees, and both would pay the money into your account within two business days. How likely are you to take the online lender's loan instead of your own bank's?
- Your own bank offers you a $10,000 personal loan, repaid over three years at 14% APR, which is about $342 a month. An online lender you have never used before offers you the same $10,000 loan, repaid over three years at 8% APR, which is about $313 a month. Neither charges any fees, and both would pay the money into your account within two business days. How likely are you to take the online lender's loan instead of your own bank's?
What was not asked, and why
No bank, lender or brand was named or asked about. We did not test a loan amount other than $10,000, a term other than three years, a bank rate other than 14%, a lender the clone already knows, fees, a slower payout, or a credit card's own rate. We did not ask anyone to recall a loan they have taken.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question asks where people borrow. We asked 200 clones on our US finance panel where they would go first and what matters most, both in general and before anything else, then showed the same 200 the same $10,000 loan from their own bank at 14% against an online lender they have never used at 13%, 11% and 8%. That turns a preference into a price: how big a rate gap it takes to win the loan away from the bank they would ask first.
Fielded through Ask Brox on 19 November 2026.
More on Switching credit cards · Retail banking & cards · Finance (US) panel
Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai
Related insights
All in this topic-
Buy now, pay later vs credit card: 44.0% of US card holders would split a $1,200 appliance into four interest-free payments, but only 19.5% would at $3,000, where 29.5% would rather wait
44% 44.0% (88 of 200) would pay for a $1,200 appliance in four interest-free payments of $300 every two weeks rather than use their credit card, against 40.5% (81) at $300 and 19.5% (39) at $3,000. (base 200)
Read -
Switching credit cards: 78% would move their everyday spending for 3% cash back, but only 40.5% for 2%, and a better rate beats a welcome bonus 129 to 11
78% 78.0% (156 of 200) would be likely, 4 or 5 on a five-point scale, to apply for a no-annual-fee card and move their everyday spending to it at 3% cash back on every purchase, against 40.5% (81) at 2% and 94.5% (189) at 5%. (base 200)
Read