Overdraft fees and switching banks: a $35 charge leaves 46.0% of US checking customers likely to move to a fee-free rival, against 19.5% at $5, while 54.0% stay put at every fee
After one $35 overdraft fee on a $4 shortfall, 46.0% of US checking customers would be likely to move their main account to a fee-free rival bank within three months, against 32.0% at $15 and 19.5% at $5 (n=200, November 2026).
- Who was asked
- US checking customers, 200 clones, US
- When
- November 2026 (fielded 5 November 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- The obvious question, how overdraft fees make customers feel about their bank, is one satisfaction trackers already cover. We turned it into a tipping point on one customer's choice: the same first-of-the-year fee on the same $4 shortfall at $5, $15 and $35, each written in full with a fee-free rival of similar size and convenience, then asked what they would do first at $35.
Section 01: What the panel said
- #
46%
After one overdraft fee on a $4 shortfall, with a fee-free rival of similar size and convenience on offer, 19.5% (39 of 200) would be likely to move their main checking account within three months at $5, 32.0% (64) at $15 and 46.0% (92) at $35.
base 200
- #
54%
54.0% (108 of 200) were unlikely to move at all three fees, 19.5% (39) were likely at all three and 26.5% (53) went from unlikely at $5 to likely at $15 or $35; none moved the other way.
base 200 · contrast
- #
28.9%
At $35, 28.9% (13 of 45) of clones in households on $100,000 or more are likely to move, against 52.3% (45 of 86) under $50,000 and 50.0% (34 of 68) on $50,000 to $99,999.
base 45 · Household income $100,000 or more · contrast
- #
196
After a $35 fee, 196 of 200 say their first move would be to ask the bank to refund it, including 91 of the 92 likely to move; read this as direction only, because it is near-unanimous, the cheapest step listed and inferred in all 200 answers.
base 200 · caveat
After one overdraft fee on a $4 shortfall, with a fee-free rival of similar size and convenience on offer, 19.5% (39 of 200) would be likely to move their main checking account within three months at $5, 32.0% (64) at $15 and 46.0% (92) at $35.
02How much does each extra dollar of overdraft fee move customers?
Steadily, with no cliff. We held everything else fixed: a $12 purchase, a balance $4 below zero, the first fee of the year and a rival bank of similar size and convenience with no overdraft fees. Only the fee changed. The share likely to move their main account within three months went from 19.5% (39 of 200) at $5 to 32.0% (64) at $15 and 46.0% (92) at $35. The first step of $10 won over 25 clones and the next step of $20 won over 28. The $5 rung is the cap in the CFPB rule that Congress repealed in 2025, and the same report puts overdraft fees often around $35. With nothing new at their bank and no rival on offer, 2.0% (4 of 200) were likely to move in the next 12 months.
The interesting reading is that customers judge the fee against the shortfall, not as a sum of money. At $5, 16 of 200 answers mention the $4 shortfall or the $12 purchase; at $35, 138 of 200 do. We wrote those two figures into the scenario and did not vary them, so this is a reading and not a measurement. The strictest reading is narrower: within the same 200 clones the share likely to move rises at every rung, and none went from likely to unlikely as the fee rose.
03Who would stay whatever the overdraft fee?
More than half. 54.0% (108 of 200) were unlikely to move at $5, $15 and $35 alike. Of those 108, 98 say in their $35 answer that this is only a first or single fee, and 64 name the hassle of moving direct deposits and automatic payments. A first fee is a weak reason to leave a main account. We did not test a second or third fee.
Between 30 and 64, age makes little difference. At $35, 49.3% (33 of 67) of clones aged 30-44 and 46.5% (40 of 86) aged 45-64 are likely to move, with 12 of 22 aged 18-29 and 7 of 25 aged 65 or over. Women and men sit at 48.2% (66 of 137) and 41.3% (26 of 63).
04What do customers do first after a $35 overdraft fee?
They ask for it back. 196 of 200 clones say their first move would be to ask the bank to refund the fee and 4 would pay it and carry on. None picked turning off overdraft coverage, moving most of their money or closing the account. That group includes 91 of the 92 clones likely to move at $35, so the intention to leave and the request for a refund sit in the same people.
We read the 196 as direction only. Asking is the cheapest first step on the list, near-unanimity is not a forecast, and all 200 answers are inferred. The better evidence is on the ladder, where no refund was on offer and clones raised one anyway: 3 of 200 answers at $5, 27 at $15 and 42 at $35. The interesting reading is that the fee opens a conversation before it closes an account. We did not test what happens when the bank says yes or no.
05What would a bank or credit union do with this?
- A reading, not the panel's answer: treat the first refund request as a retention moment. If 196 of 200 ask first, the person answering that call is deciding what happens to the 92 of 200 who are likely to move.
- A reading: a fee is judged against the shortfall, so a buffer that stops a $35 charge on a $4 overdraft may do more than a lower headline fee. We did not test a buffer or a different shortfall.
- A reading for a bank with no overdraft fees: the claim lands hardest among households under $100,000, where 79 of 154 clones are likely to move at $35.
06What do people also ask about overdraft fees and switching banks?
- What share of customers would switch banks over an overdraft fee? 46.0% (92 of 200) would be likely to move their main account to a fee-free rival after one $35 fee, and 19.5% (39) after one $5 fee (November 2026).
- At what overdraft fee do customers start to leave? There is no single cliff: 19.5% are likely to move at $5, 32.0% at $15 and 46.0% at $35 (n=200), while 54.0% stay unlikely at all three.
- How many customers would ask for an overdraft fee to be refunded? 196 of 200 say asking for a refund would be their first move after a $35 fee, a figure we read as direction only.
Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“I would say I'm very likely to move my account. A $35 charge for being just $4 over on a $12 purchase is completely unfair and unreasonable. If I ever feel treated unfairly, disrespected, or taken advantage of by a financial institution, I have no problem taking my business elsewhere. Since the rival bank is of similar size and convenience and won't penalize me with overdraft fees, moving my main checking account would be an easy decision.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“at any time if I feel disrespected, pushed aside, if I feel like I was treated unfairly or insignificantly, then I would switch banks.”
“I would say somewhat unlikely. Getting charged a $35 fee when going just $4 negative is definitely frustrating, but since it is only the first fee I've had this year, it isn't an ongoing issue yet. I generally only consider switching banks if I consistently experience high fees or poor customer service. Moving a main checking account is a hassle that involves updating payment details and risking delays or disruption to my finances, so the overall convenience of staying put outweighs a single isolated charge. I'd likely reach out to see if they could reverse it first before making a major move.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I would consider switching banks if I consistently experience high fees, poor customer services, or better benefits are offered elsewhere.”
“I would say I'm somewhat likely to switch. First, I would probably call up my current bank to see if they'd be willing to reverse the $35 fee, especially since it's the first time and it was only a four-dollar overdraft on a twelve-dollar purchase. I'm fairly old-fashioned and don't like switching just for the sake of it, but if they refused to work with me on reversing that fee, that would definitely rub me the wrong way. Since the rival bank has the same convenience and physical presence without those nickel-and-dime fees, that would be a good reason for me to make the move.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“Or if I had an issue with them, for example, a balance check or something that I didn't think was 100% my responsibility, and they didn't... Work on reversing fees, then that would be a good reason to switch as well.”
Section 08: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- Within the same 200 clones, the share likely to move rises at every rung, 19.5% to 32.0% to 46.0%, and no clone went from likely to unlikely as the fee rose.
- The rise appears in every gender, age, income and region group we cut.
- The clones answered the fee they were given: 189 of 200 name $5 at $5, 178 name $15 at $15 and 184 name $35 at $35, and at most 5 name a neighboring rung's fee.
- More than half stay put on a first fee: 108 of 200 are unlikely to move at all three fees, and 98 of those 108 say in their $35 answer that it is only a first or single fee.
What we would not
- The levels as a population estimate: the panel is 137 women of 200 and holds 25 clones aged 65 or over, the group least likely to move (7 of 25 at $35), so the share likely to move is if anything overstated.
- Any of these figures as a forecast of accounts closed: they are stated intentions with a fee-free rival written into the scenario, and a stated intention is not a closed account.
- The rise from the baseline to the $5 rung as the effect of a $5 fee: the 2.0% (4 of 200) baseline had no rival on offer and a 12-month time frame, so only rung-to-rung comparisons are clean.
- 196 of 200 asking for a refund as a measured share: it is near-unanimous on the cheapest step listed, and every answer is inferred.
- The shortfall reading as a measurement: we wrote the $4 and the $12 into the scenario and did not vary them.
- The income split to the decimal: a clone's recorded income differs between questions for 6 of 200, and on another question's record the $100,000-or-more figure is 12 of 43 or 14 of 46. The direction holds on each record.
- Anything about clones aged 18-29 or 65 and over beyond a count: 12 of 22 and 7 of 25 at $35.
The main limitation
These are stated intentions about a written scenario, and 199 of 200 answers on each rung are reasoned from each person's wider interview rather than a direct statement about an overdraft fee: their own lines about switching banks sit behind 173 to 178 of 200 answers per rung and lines about fees behind 69 to 80, but lines about overdraft specifically behind only 7 to 9. Read the levels as direction and the within-clone shifts as the result.
Section 09: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Have a checking account at a bank or credit union (screened: 699 of 755 qualified, 200 sampled) | 200 |
| Women | 137 |
| Men | 63 |
| Aged 18-29 | 22 |
| Aged 30-44 | 67 |
| Aged 45-64 | 86 |
| Aged 65 or over | 25 |
| Household income under $50,000 | 86 |
| Household income $50,000 to $99,999 | 68 |
| Household income $100,000 or more | 45 |
Question wording as fielded
- Do you currently have a checking account at a bank or credit union? (screener; 699 of 755 qualified, 200 sampled)
- Today, with nothing new at your bank, how likely are you to move your main checking account to a different bank or credit union in the next 12 months?
- Your bank charges you a $5 overdraft fee after a $12 purchase takes your checking account $4 below zero. It is the first fee you have had from them this year. A rival bank of similar size and convenience charges no overdraft fees at all. How likely are you to move your main checking account to the rival bank in the next three months?
- Your bank charges you a $15 overdraft fee after a $12 purchase takes your checking account $4 below zero. It is the first fee you have had from them this year. A rival bank of similar size and convenience charges no overdraft fees at all. How likely are you to move your main checking account to the rival bank in the next three months?
- Your bank charges you a $35 overdraft fee after a $12 purchase takes your checking account $4 below zero. It is the first fee you have had from them this year. A rival bank of similar size and convenience charges no overdraft fees at all. How likely are you to move your main checking account to the rival bank in the next three months?
- Your bank charges you a $35 overdraft fee after a $12 purchase takes your checking account $4 below zero. It is the first fee you have had from them this year. Which is closest to what you would actually do first?
What was not asked, and why
No bank or brand was named or asked about. We did not test a second or third fee, a shortfall other than $4, a fee buffer or grace period, whether a refund keeps the customer, or how a fee changes satisfaction or trust. We did not ask anyone to recall an overdraft fee they had paid. Ask Brox fielded the six questions as written and added none of its own.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question, how overdraft fees make customers feel about their bank, is one satisfaction trackers already cover. We turned it into a tipping point on one customer's choice: the same first-of-the-year fee on the same $4 shortfall at $5, $15 and $35, each written in full with a fee-free rival of similar size and convenience, then asked what they would do first at $35.
Fielded through Ask Brox on 5 November 2026.
More on Choosing and leaving a primary bank · Retail banking & cards · U.S. nat. rep. (US) panel
Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai
Related insights
All in this topic-
Mortgage refinancing: none of 200 would switch for half a point off their rate, 47.0% would for a full point
58.5% 58.5% (117 of 200) would be likely to refinance at a rate 1.5 points below their own with $5,000 in closing costs paid up front, against 47.0% (94) at one point lower and 0.0% (none) at half a point. (base 200)
Read -
Bank switching bonuses buy deposits, not customers: at $500, 54.5% of US checking customers would move their direct deposit but only 13% would make the new bank their main bank
13% At a $500 sign-up bonus, 41.5% (83 of 200) would move their direct deposit only long enough to collect the bonus and 13.0% (26) would make the new bank their main bank; at $300 the figures are 27.5% (55) and 9.5% (19), and at $100 9.5% (19) and 5.5% (11). (base 200)
Read