Mortgage refinancing: none of 200 would switch for half a point off their rate, 47.0% would for a full point

58.5% of US mortgage holders (117 of 200 Brox clones) would be likely to refinance at a rate 1.5 points below their own with $5,000 in closing costs, against 47.0% at one point lower and none at half a point (n=200, November 2026).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published
Who was asked
Finance, 200 clones, US
When
November 2026 (fielded 12 November 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
We asked 200 clones of US adults who hold a mortgage how likely they would be to refinance at three offers: a rate 0.5, 1.0 and 1.5 points below their own, each with the same loan term and $5,000 in closing costs paid up front. Before the offers, we asked which one thing would most stop them refinancing in general. The obvious question, "would you refinance for a better rate?", has no price on it; this one makes every clone weigh a specific saving against a specific cost.

Section 01: What the panel said

  1. #

    58.5%

    58.5% (117 of 200) would be likely to refinance at a rate 1.5 points below their own with $5,000 in closing costs paid up front, against 47.0% (94) at one point lower and 0.0% (none) at half a point.

    base 200

  2. #

    11.5pp

    11.5 points is all the second half point adds: 23 more of 200 clones become likely to refinance between a one-point and a 1.5-point cut, after 94 between half a point and one point.

    base 200

  3. #

    5

    5 of 35 clones with household income under $50,000 would be likely to refinance at 1.5 points lower, against 66 of 87 with $100,000 or more.

    base 35 · Household income under $50,000 · contrast

  4. #

    76.3%

    76.3% (151 of 198) name closing costs and fees as the main thing that would stop them refinancing; read it as a direction, because our question set aside an already low rate.

    base 198 · caveat

58.5% (117 of 200) would be likely to refinance at a rate 1.5 points below their own with $5,000 in closing costs paid up front, against 47.0% (94) at one point lower and 0.0% (none) at half a point.

0.5 points lower (base 200)
0%
1.0 point lower (base 200)
47%
1.5 points lower (base 200)
58.5%

Base 200 clones.

02Where is the tipping point for refinancing a mortgage?

It sits between half a point and a full point. With $5,000 in closing costs paid up front, none of 200 clones of US mortgage holders would be likely to refinance for a rate half a point below their own. At a full point, 47.0% (94 of 200) would. At 1.5 points, 58.5% (117 of 200) would.

The interesting reading: the cliff lands where the old one-point rule of thumb says it should, and past it each extra half point buys far less. The first full point brings in 94 clones; the next half point brings in 23 more. What the numbers support: the order of the three offers and the size of each step, on the same 200 clones, as stated likelihood. Every clone likely at one point was also likely at 1.5 points.

03What stops the 41.5% who would not refinance even at 1.5 points lower?

Mostly the cash, not the rate. Of the 83 clones not likely to refinance at 1.5 points lower, 42 say in their own answer that they do not have the $5,000 to pay up front. Others are close to paying the mortgage off, and a smaller group worries about being turned down: 15 of the 17 who named that worry stay very unlikely even at 1.5 points.

Income draws the line most clearly. At 1.5 points lower, 66 of 87 clones with household income of $100,000 or more would be likely to refinance, against 5 of 35 below $50,000. Age splits the same way: 49 of 61 aged 30 to 44, against 10 of 31 aged 65 and over.

04What would a lender or mortgage marketer do with this?

  1. Our reading: a refinance offer worth making starts at a full point below the borrower's rate. Half a point moved none of 200 clones when closing costs were paid up front.
  2. Our reading: the next thing to test is the up-front cost, not a deeper rate cut. A no-closing-cost offer, or costs rolled into the loan, speaks to the 42 clones who said they lack the cash. We did not ask about either.
  3. Our reading: the households most ready to move are aged 30 to 44 and earn $100,000 or more; lower-income and retired owners need a different offer, not a louder one.

05What do people also ask about refinancing a mortgage?

  • What share of homeowners would refinance for a mortgage rate 1 point lower? 47.0% (94 of 200 clones of US mortgage holders) would be likely to, with $5,000 in closing costs paid up front.
  • At what rate cut would homeowners refinance their mortgage? None of 200 clones would be likely to at half a point lower, 47.0% at one point lower and 58.5% at 1.5 points lower.
  • How many homeowners say closing costs are the main thing stopping them refinancing? 76.3% (151 of 198) name closing costs and fees as the main reason, a direction only, because our question set aside an already low rate.

Section 06: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“I would be very likely to refinance. My main financial goal right now is saving more money at the end of each month so I can pay off my mortgage faster, and lowering my interest rate by 1.5 percentage points would significantly reduce my monthly interest costs. Even with the $5,000 upfront closing costs, the monthly savings would help me reach my goal much sooner.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“My current goal is saving more money at the end of the month so I can pay my mortgage faster.”

Man aged 30 to 44, Texas, mortgage holder supports finding 1

“I would say somewhat likely. A rate that is 1.5 percentage points lower is a good rate, and one of my main goals is saving money and paying down the debt and mortgage on our house. But having to pay about $5,000 upfront for closing costs is quite a bit, so I would want to be cautious, look at the details, and make sure the numbers really work out to save money before switching.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“the only thing that would make me switch would be having good rates and things of that nature.”

Man aged 65 or over, Indiana, mortgage holder supports finding 2

“Very unlikely. I live on a fixed retirement income every month and I don't have anything in savings, so I definitely wouldn't have $5,000 to pay up front for closing costs. Even if lowering the interest rate sounds good, I just don't have the funds to do something like that. Thank you.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I don't have anything in my savings. My Social Security goes in checking every month and that's $1,442.”

Woman aged 65 or over, Louisiana, mortgage holder supports finding 3

Section 07: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • The order of the three offers: none of 200 clones likely at half a point, 94 at one point and 117 at 1.5 points, with every clone likely at one point also likely at 1.5 points.
  • The income gradient at 1.5 points lower: 5 of 35 clones under $50,000 against 66 of 87 at $100,000 or more.

What we would not

  • The exact share naming closing costs as the main barrier, 76.3% (151 of 198). Our question said "even if a lender offered you a lower rate", which led clones to set aside "my current rate is already low" (4 of 198). US borrowers holding older, lower rates are a bigger group than that suggests.
  • The cash reading in the story (42 of the 83 not likely at 1.5 points say they do not have the $5,000) is our count of the clones' written answers, not a question they were asked.
  • Stated likelihood is not refinancing behavior: real take-up also depends on approval, appraisal and timing.
  • None of 200 at half a point is a direction: with $5,000 up front, a half-point saving takes years to pay back, and the clones did that arithmetic.

The main limitation

These are clones' predicted answers to a hypothetical offer, reasoned from what 200 real US mortgage holders said in long interviews about money, debt and their home loan (116 of the 200 draw on their own mortgage lines at the top offer). Read the shares as direction with size, not a forecast of refinancing volumes. 4 of the 200 clones answered as if they had no mortgage; without them the top offer reads 116 of 196.

Section 08: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Aged 18 to 293
Aged 30 to 4461
Aged 45 to 64105
Aged 65 and over31
Women134
Men66

Question wording as fielded

  1. Do you currently have a mortgage on the home you live in?
  2. In general, which one of these is the main reason you might not refinance your mortgage, even if a lender offered you a lower rate?
  3. Suppose a lender offered to refinance your mortgage at an interest rate 0.5 percentage points lower than the rate you pay now, with the same loan term and about $5,000 in closing costs paid up front. How likely would you be to refinance your mortgage at 0.5 points lower?
  4. Suppose a lender offered to refinance your mortgage at an interest rate 1.0 percentage points lower than the rate you pay now, with the same loan term and about $5,000 in closing costs paid up front. How likely would you be to refinance your mortgage at 1.0 points lower?
  5. Suppose a lender offered to refinance your mortgage at an interest rate 1.5 percentage points lower than the rate you pay now, with the same loan term and about $5,000 in closing costs paid up front. How likely would you be to refinance your mortgage at 1.5 points lower?

What was not asked, and why

We did not offer a no-closing-cost refinance or closing costs rolled into the loan, so the study cannot say how much of the refusal is about paying up front. We did not ask clones their current rate, so it cannot measure how many are holding on to an older, lower rate. No lender or brand was named.

What changed from the obvious question

We asked 200 clones of US adults who hold a mortgage how likely they would be to refinance at three offers: a rate 0.5, 1.0 and 1.5 points below their own, each with the same loan term and $5,000 in closing costs paid up front. Before the offers, we asked which one thing would most stop them refinancing in general. The obvious question, "would you refinance for a better rate?", has no price on it; this one makes every clone weigh a specific saving against a specific cost.

Fielded through Ask Brox on 12 November 2026.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai

Related insights

All in this topic