Savings rate gap: 59.0% of US savers would move for 4.00% against 0.50%, but 41.0% would stay put at every rate tested

Offered 4.00% at an FDIC-insured online bank against 0.50% on their own savings account, 59.0% of US savers would be likely to move most of their savings, against 45.5% at 1.50%, while 41.0% stayed unlikely at all three rates tested (n=200, October 2026).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
US savers, 200 clones, US
When
October 2026 (fielded 29 October 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question, whether savers move money when rates move, is answered by research on aggregate deposit flows. We turned it into a tipping point on one saver's own choice: the same account at 0.50% against an FDIC-insured online bank at 1.50%, 2.50% and 4.00%, each with the extra interest on $10,000 written out, then asked how soon they would move at the top rate and, separately and first, what would hold them back.

Section 01: What the panel said

  1. #

    59%

    With their own savings account at 0.50%, 45.5% (91 of 200) would be likely to move most of their savings to an FDIC-insured online bank paying 1.50%, 54.5% (109) at 2.50% and 59.0% (118) at 4.00%.

    base 200

  2. #

    41%

    41.0% (82 of 200) were unlikely to move at all three rates, 45.5% (91) were likely at all three, and only 13.5% (27) went from unlikely at 1.50% to likely at 2.50% or 4.00%; none moved the other way.

    base 200

  3. #

    33%

    Asked in general what would most hold them back from moving savings to a bank paying more, 33.0% (66 of 200) chose not trusting a bank they have never used and 31.0% (62) the hassle of opening an account and moving the money; 21.0% (42) said nothing would.

    base 200 · contrast

  4. #

    93.2%

    Of the 118 clones likely to move at 4.00%, 93.2% (110) say they would move within a month and 7.6% (9) within a week; read this as direction, because 38 of the 82 unlikely to move also answered within a month.

    base 118 · Likely to move at 4.00% · caveat

With their own savings account at 0.50%, 45.5% (91 of 200) would be likely to move most of their savings to an FDIC-insured online bank paying 1.50%, 54.5% (109) at 2.50% and 59.0% (118) at 4.00%.

Online bank pays 1.50% ($100 more a year on $10,000)
45.5%
Online bank pays 2.50% ($200 more)
54.5%
Online bank pays 4.00% ($350 more)
59%

Base 200 clones.

02How much does a bigger savings-rate gap move savers?

Less than the size of the gap suggests. We held each clone's own savings account at 0.50% and changed only what an FDIC-insured online bank offered: 1.50%, 2.50% and then 4.00%, with the extra interest on $10,000 written out each time ($100, $200 and $350 a year). The share likely to move most of their savings went from 45.5% (91 of 200) to 54.5% (109) to 59.0% (118). Going from 1.50% to 4.00%, an extra $250 a year, won over 27 more clones.

The interesting reading is that the rate moves conviction more than it moves people. The share very likely to move doubled, from 16.5% (33 of 200) at 1.50% to 34.0% (68) at 4.00%, and 65 clones rated themselves more likely at the top rate than at the bottom one, yet only 27 crossed from unlikely to likely. Savers look sorted into movers and stayers before any rate is quoted. The strictest reading is narrower: within the same 200 clones the share likely to move rises at every rung, and none moved the other way.

03Who stays put whatever the rate?

Older savers, far more than poorer or richer ones. At 4.00%, 80.5% (33 of 41) of clones aged 18-29 and 66.1% (41 of 62) aged 30-44 are likely to move, against 46.8% (37 of 79) aged 45-64 and 6 of 17 aged 65 or over. Income makes almost no difference: every income band sits between 57.9% and 59.2%. Of the 82 clones unlikely to move at any of the three rates, 42 are aged 45-64.

The stayers split almost evenly between two reasons. Among those 82, 33 named not trusting a bank they have never used and 32 the hassle of opening an account and moving the money; 14 said the extra interest would not be worth the effort.

04How fast do savers move once they decide to?

Within weeks rather than days. Of the 118 clones likely to move at 4.00%, 110 say they would move their money within a month of hearing about the offer and 9 within a week. A week is rare, which leaves time for a saver's own bank to answer an offer before the money goes.

We read this as direction only. Of the 82 clones unlikely to move at 4.00%, 38 also answered within a month, so many read the question as how soon they would move if they did, not whether they would.

05What would a bank or fintech do with this?

  1. A reading, not the panel's answer: a higher headline rate wins the savers already open to moving and few others. Going from 1.50% to 4.00% added 27 of 200, so beyond a point the money is better spent on the switch itself.
  2. A reading: for the stayers, trust and effort are the product. Of the 82 who would not move at any rate, 65 named trust in an unfamiliar bank or the hassle of moving, which points to making the move feel safe and easy rather than to paying more.
  3. A reading for the bank losing the deposit: most movers say a month, not a week, which gives a retention offer a window.

06What do people also ask about moving savings for a better rate?

  • What share of savers would switch banks for a higher savings rate? 59.0% (118 of 200) would be likely to move most of their savings to an FDIC-insured online bank paying 4.00% against 0.50% on their own account, and 45.5% (91) at 1.50% (October 2026).
  • How many savers would not move their savings even for a much higher rate? 41.0% (82 of 200) were unlikely to move at 1.50%, 2.50% and 4.00% alike, even with $350 a year more interest on $10,000 at the top rate.
  • How fast do savers move money for a better rate? Of the 118 likely to move at 4.00%, 110 would move within a month of hearing about the offer and 9 within a week.

Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“Very unlikely. No, I would not consider switching to banks. Not ever, ever, ever. No. It doesn't matter if it's paying more interest or anything like that. I do things my way, I put my money in the bank and savings I've used, and I don't switch. What you see is what you get, and I stick to what I know.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“No, I would not consider switching to banks. Not ever, ever, ever. No.”

Woman, 45-64, Missouri; very unlikely to move at 1.50%, 2.50% and 4.00% supports finding 2

“I would be very likely to move my savings. I already do my banking online and love how convenient it is to handle everything right from home without dealing with branch locations or waiting on people. If my account was only earning 0.50% and an FDIC-insured online bank came along offering 4.00% with no fees or minimum balance, that is a huge difference. Earning an extra $350 a year on your money is definitely worth making the move.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“And unless there's another online bank that offers more than my current bank does, I don't have any plans on switching.”

Woman, 45-64, West Virginia; very unlikely to move at 1.50% and 2.50%, very likely at 4.00% supports finding 1

“For me, trust is everything when it comes to where I put my money. If I'm already using a bank and it works well, I'd be very hesitant to move my savings over to some unfamiliar institution just for a slightly higher interest rate. I need to know and trust who I'm dealing with before handing over my savings, so not trusting a bank I've never used before would be the biggest thing holding me back.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Unless it goes up a lot, I'm probably going to use the same product because I trust it.”

Woman, 45-64, Nevada; named trust in an unfamiliar bank as the biggest barrier supports finding 3

Section 08: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • Within the same 200 clones, the share likely to move rises at every rung, 45.5% to 54.5% to 59.0%, and no clone moved from likely to unlikely as the rate went up.
  • The stayers are a fixed core: 82 of 200 are unlikely to move at 1.50%, 2.50% and 4.00% alike, and at 4.00% between 29.6% and 31.6% are very unlikely in every income band.
  • The clones answered the rate they were given: 108 of 200 name 4.00% in the 4.00% question, 67 name 2.50% in the 2.50% question, and none names a neighboring rung's rate.
  • Age, not income, separates movers from stayers: at 4.00%, 80.5% (33 of 41) of clones aged 18-29 are likely to move against 46.8% (37 of 79) aged 45-64, while every income band sits between 57.9% and 59.2%.

What we would not

  • The levels as a population estimate: the panel is younger than US adults (41 clones aged 18-29, 17 aged 65 or over) and the older clones are the ones who stay, so the share likely to move is if anything overstated.
  • The speed figure as a forecast of behavior: 38 of the 82 clones unlikely to move also said within a month, so the question was read as 'if I moved', and 110 of 118 agreeing is direction only.
  • Anything about the 65-and-over group beyond a count: 6 of 17 likely to move at 4.00%.
  • The barrier question as a measure of size: it is a forced pick of one barrier, and it ranks reasons rather than weighing them.

The main limitation

These are stated intentions about a written offer, and almost every rung answer (195 to 197 of 200) is reasoned from each person's wider interview rather than a direct statement about moving savings for a rate; their own interview lines about moving money, transferring it or opening accounts sit behind 132 to 143 of 200 answers per rung, and lines about banking online behind 85 to 98, so read the levels as direction and the within-clone shifts as the result.

Section 09: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Keep money in a savings account at a bank or credit union (screened: 526 of 742 qualified, 200 sampled)200
Women127
Men70
Aged 18-2941
Aged 30-4462
Aged 45-6479
Aged 65 or over17
Household income under $50,00071
Household income $50,000 to $99,99971
Household income $100,000 or more57

Question wording as fielded

  1. Do you currently keep any money in a savings account at a bank or credit union? (screener; 526 of 742 qualified, 200 sampled)
  2. In general, what would most hold you back from moving your savings to a different bank that pays a higher interest rate?
  3. Your savings account pays 0.50% a year. An FDIC-insured online bank offers a savings account paying 1.50% a year, with no fees and no minimum balance; on $10,000 of savings that is $100 more interest a year. How likely are you to move most of your savings to the online bank?
  4. Your savings account pays 0.50% a year. An FDIC-insured online bank offers a savings account paying 2.50% a year, with no fees and no minimum balance; on $10,000 of savings that is $200 more interest a year. How likely are you to move most of your savings to the online bank?
  5. Your savings account pays 0.50% a year. An FDIC-insured online bank offers a savings account paying 4.00% a year, with no fees and no minimum balance; on $10,000 of savings that is $350 more interest a year. How likely are you to move most of your savings to the online bank?
  6. Your savings account pays 0.50% a year. An FDIC-insured online bank offers a savings account paying 4.00% a year, with no fees and no minimum balance; on $10,000 of savings that is $350 more interest a year. How soon after hearing about this offer would you actually move your money?

What was not asked, and why

No bank or brand was named or asked about. We did not test sums other than $10,000, a current rate other than 0.50%, a branch bank or credit union as the destination, sign-up bonuses, or what each saver earns today. We did not ask anyone to recall past moves. Ask Brox fielded the six questions as written and added none of its own.

What changed from the obvious question

The obvious question, whether savers move money when rates move, is answered by research on aggregate deposit flows. We turned it into a tipping point on one saver's own choice: the same account at 0.50% against an FDIC-insured online bank at 1.50%, 2.50% and 4.00%, each with the extra interest on $10,000 written out, then asked how soon they would move at the top rate and, separately and first, what would hold them back.

Fielded through Ask Brox on 29 October 2026.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai

Related insights

All in this topic