Topic hub

Switching insurers

What makes an insurance customer shop around, what price gap is enough, and what makes them actually leave.

7 insights·0 studies

What did the panels say about switching insurers?

  1. #

    73.5%

    73.5% would switch health plans at open enrollment if a medicine they take every month moved to a higher cost tier and cost $75 a month more, against 24.0% at $25 a month more and 96.0% at $200: the same 200 clones, three times as many between $25 and $75. — Health plan formulary changes: 24% would switch plans if a monthly medicine cost $25 more, 73.5% at $75, but 94% would ask their doctor first if it were dropped

    base 200

  2. #

    47%

    47.0% would switch health plans at open enrollment if their main doctor left the plan’s network with the premium unchanged, against 7.5% for a $40 a month premium increase with nothing else changed: the same 200 clones, six times as many moved by the network. — Health plan switching at open enrollment: 47% would leave if their doctor left the network, 7.5% for a $40 a month premium increase

    base 200

  3. #

    28%

    28.0% (56 of 200) would move as soon as they can when a different insurer quotes $1,275 against a $1,500 renewal. When the $1,275 is what their own insurer is quoting new customers, 0 of 200 would move: 66.0% (132) would ask it to match and 34.0% (68) would get quotes first. — Car insurance loyalty penalty: a $225 new-customer discount moves 0 of 200 to leave, the same $225 from a rival moves 28%, though 70.5% think new customers pay less

    base 200

  4. #

    58%

    Offered the same $500,000, 20-year term life policy through a financial advisor at $40 a month or online on their own, 28.0% would buy online at the same price, 58.0% at 10% cheaper ($36 a month) and 80.0% at 25% cheaper ($30 a month). — Life insurance: 71.5% would buy through an advisor at the same price, but 10% cheaper online ($4 a month) moves 58% to buy on their own

    base 200

  5. #

    65.5%

    65.5% keep a well-known national insurer at $1,500 over an insurer they have never heard of at $1,350 (10% cheaper); at $1,200 (20% cheaper) 52.5% still do. — Choosing a car insurer: 76% say price decides, yet 65.5% keep a known brand over one 10% cheaper and 73.5% keep a friend's recommendation

    base 200

What has Brox published on switching insurers?Newest first

What do people ask about switching insurers?

Why do members leave a health plan after a formulary change drops or re-tiers a medicine they take?
Told a medicine they take every month was moving to a higher cost tier, 24.0% of 200 US health plan members on employer, marketplace or Medicare coverage would switch plans at their next open enrollment if their share rose by $25 a month, against 73.5% at $75 a month (n=200, November 2026).Read the insight
What makes a health plan member switch plans at open enrollment, and what keeps them?
Told their main doctor would leave their health plan’s network with the premium unchanged, 47.0% of 200 US adults on employer, marketplace or Medicare coverage would switch plans at open enrollment, against 7.5% for a $40 a month premium increase with nothing else changed (n=200, November 2026).Read the insight
Do people believe loyal customers get worse insurance prices than new ones, and does that belief make them switch?
Told their car insurer is quoting new customers $225 less, 0 of 200 US car insurance customers would move straight away and 66.0% would ask it to match, against 28.0% who would move for a rival quoting the same $225 less, even though 70.5% think new customers pay less (n=200, November 2026).Read the insight
How do people choose a life insurer or an annuity, and what makes them buy through a financial advisor rather than direct?
73.0% of US adults who hold or recently shopped for life insurance say price would most decide their insurer, and while 71.5% would take a financial advisor over buying online at the same price, 58.0% would buy online on their own at 10% cheaper and 80.0% at 25% cheaper (n=200, October 2026).Read the insight
Which matters more when choosing an insurer for the first time: price, brand or a recommendation?
76.0% of US car insurance customers say the lowest price would decide their next insurer, yet 65.5% would still pay $1,500 for a well-known national insurer over an unknown one at $1,350, and 73.5% would pay it for an insurer a friend recommends (n=200, October 2026).Read the insight
How many people would switch insurers for a better app alone, with the price unchanged?
In October 2026, 17.0% of US insurance policyholders (34 of 200) leaned towards switching to an insurer whose app handles a whole claim on the phone at the same price and cover, but only 2.5% would definitely switch, and an app that only eased everyday tasks moved 1.5% (n=200).Read the insight
What actually makes a US insurance customer switch, and what price gap is enough?
At a 15% cheaper quote ($300 a year on a $2,000 policy), 33.5% of US insurance customers would switch outright and a further 25.5% would switch unless their current insurer matched it (n=200, September 2026); at 5% cheaper only 9.5% would switch.Read the insight

Other topics

How should you read these findings?

Where the numbers come from. Every figure on this site is a predicted response from Brox clones: behavioural replicas of real people, each built from a long-form interview with that person. The base under each figure is the number of clones behind it.

Where the real data comes from. The long-form video interviews with the real people the clones are built from. A quote is always shown with the interview line it was predicted from.

What you can take away. Insights publish their tabulation as CSV and JSON: question, option, count, percentage and base. Never per-person rows.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai