Health plan switching at open enrollment: 47% would leave if their doctor left the network, 7.5% for a $40 a month premium increase
Told their main doctor would leave their health plan’s network with the premium unchanged, 47.0% of 200 US adults on employer, marketplace or Medicare coverage would switch plans at open enrollment, against 7.5% for a $40 a month premium increase with nothing else changed (n=200, November 2026).
- Who was asked
- US adults with health coverage, 200 clones, US
- When
- November 2026 (fielded 11 November 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- The obvious question asks what members say would make them switch. This study asks that, then puts the same clones through two concrete changes to next year’s plan, one to the network and one to the price, so the page can compare what members say with what each change does to their stated choice.
Section 01: What the panel said
- #
47%
47.0% would switch health plans at open enrollment if their main doctor left the plan’s network with the premium unchanged, against 7.5% for a $40 a month premium increase with nothing else changed: the same 200 clones, six times as many moved by the network.
base 200
- #
85%
A $40 a month premium increase mostly sends members to look, not to leave: 85.0% would compare plans but probably stay, and 7.5% would stay without comparing.
base 200 · contrast
- #
66%
66.0% say their doctors and hospital being in the network is what most keeps them on their health plan, against 15.5% the premium and 1 of 200 the effort of comparing plans.
base 200
- #
9
9 of 30 Medicare Advantage members name a medicine being dropped or costing more as the change most likely to make them switch, against 6 of 126 on employer plans.
base 30 · Medicare Advantage members · contrast
47.0% would switch health plans at open enrollment if their main doctor left the plan’s network with the premium unchanged, against 7.5% for a $40 a month premium increase with nothing else changed: the same 200 clones, six times as many moved by the network.
02What should a health plan take from this first?
The same 200 clones were given two changes to next year's plan, one at a time. When their main doctor left the network and the premium stayed the same, 94 of 200 would switch plans at open enrollment. When the premium went up by $40 a month and nothing else changed, 15 of 200 would. That is six times as many people moved by a network change as by a price change.
The more interesting reading is that the network, not the premium, is what a plan is really competing on at open enrollment. The strictest reading is narrower: on the same clones, losing a doctor moves far more people than a $40 rise, and a price increase of that size mostly sends people to compare and then stay (85.0%, n=200).
03Does it hold for Medicare and employer plans alike?
It does. On employer plans, 46.0% would switch if their doctor left the network (n=126), against 4.0% for the $40 rise. Among Medicare Advantage members it was 13 of 30 against 5 of 30, and the gap held in every age group with a base over 30.
Medicare Advantage members also stood out on medicines. Asked which single change would be most likely to make them switch, 9 of 30 named a medicine being dropped or costing more, against 6 of 126 on employer plans. That is a count on a small base, but it points at the formulary as the second lever for Medicare plans.
04Why does a $40 rise move so few, when price is named so often?
Asked in general, 38.0% named the premium going up as the change most likely to make them switch (n=200), second only to a doctor or hospital leaving the network at 52.0%. Yet a specific $40 a month rise moved 7.5%. Price is on people's minds, but $40 a month was not enough on its own to break the habit of staying.
Only one price was tested, and marketplace premiums are rising again for 2027, so a larger rise could move more people. This study says where $40 sits, not where the tipping point is.
05What would a retention team do with this?
- Treat network changes as the open enrollment risk to manage, and tell affected members early which of their doctors are staying. This is a reading of the finding, not something the clones were asked.
- Expect a premium increase of about $40 a month to send most members to compare rather than to leave, so the comparison they make is the moment to win.
- For Medicare Advantage, watch formulary changes as closely as network changes, and test that on a larger Medicare base before acting on it.
Section 06: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“I would definitely switch to a different plan. I've had the same primary care doctor for about 15 years now, and I've literally followed her across different hospital systems and job changes. Good doctors who actually listen to you, understand your personal health goals, and don't just push prescription drugs on you are extremely hard to come by. Finding someone I trust that much is rare, so keeping my doctor is way more important to me than sticking with a specific insurance plan just because the premium didn't go up. If she left the network, I would immediately look at the other options during open enrollment and switch to a plan that covers her.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“And I've followed her wherever she's gone because even when there was a time period, her primary care practice did not accept the current insurance I had from with my employer. I would have to pay a little bit out of pocket because of how the relationship we've built”
“Well, an extra $40 a month is definitely noticeable for us since we're retired and living on Social Security, so we have to watch every penny. I would certainly look into things, do my homework, and maybe talk with my kids to see what other plans are out there and compare them. But my husband has cancer, and our insurance has covered so much of what he needs, including our prescriptions. You don't want to mess around with something that is working when you're dealing with serious health problems. So I'd look and compare, but I would probably stay right where we are.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“my husband has cancer, and it's been very costly. But on the other hand, I am very thankful for insurance. It has covered so much. Much of it.”
Section 07: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- The gap between the two changes on the same 200 clones: 94 would switch when their doctor leaves the network against 15 for a $40 a month rise, identical on two pulls of the data.
- That the gap is not one group’s: 46.0% against 4.0% on employer plans (n=126), 13 of 30 against 5 of 30 in Medicare Advantage, and it holds in every age group with a base over 30.
- That the clones read each change on its own terms: the $40 figure appears in 193 of 200 premium answers and in none of the doctor answers.
- The ranking of what keeps members on a plan: the network at 66.0% (n=200), well ahead of the premium at 15.5%.
What we would not
- 47.0% as a forecast of how many members actually leave when a doctor exits a network. These are stated choices, and KFF finds about one in ten Medicare Advantage enrollees switch plans at a typical open enrollment.
- Any claim that price does not move members. Only a $40 a month rise was tested, and 38.0% (n=200) name a premium increase as the change most likely to make them switch.
- The Original Medicare figure (16 of 31 would switch). Original Medicare has no network, so for those clones the question means a doctor no longer taking their coverage. Without them the headline is 78 of 169 (46.2%).
- 85.0% very likely to stay as a precise share: near-unanimity on a stated intention is a direction only.
- Any figure for ACA marketplace members (13 clones) or adults aged 18 to 29 (9 clones).
The main limitation
Every answer is inferred from each person’s wider interview rather than stated on this question (0 of 200 direct statements in either scenario), and the interviews behind this panel say much more about doctors than about premiums: 186 of 200 doctor-scenario answers rest on the person’s own lines about their doctors, against 18 of 200 premium-scenario answers on their own lines about premiums or insurance costs. The panel is also older and more female than US adults with coverage (57 of 200 aged 65 or over, 136 women).
Section 08: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Employer or union plan | 126 |
| Original Medicare | 31 |
| Medicare Advantage | 30 |
| ACA marketplace plan | 13 |
Question wording as fielded
- Which of these is your main health coverage today? (screener; 547 of 779 qualified, 200 sampled)
- At the coming open enrolment, how likely are you to move to a different health plan from the one you have now?
- Which one of these would be most likely to make you switch health plans at open enrolment?
- Which one of these most keeps you on your current health plan?
- Suppose your health plan for next year costs $40 a month more in premium and nothing else about it changes. At open enrolment, what would you do?
- Suppose your health plan for next year keeps the same premium, but your main doctor leaves its network. At open enrolment, what would you do?
What was not asked, and why
No insurer or plan was named. Only one price change ($40 a month) and one network change (the main doctor leaving) were tested, each on its own and with nothing else changing. Nobody was asked about a hospital leaving the network, a formulary change on its own, or out-of-pocket maximums, and Medicaid members were screened out. Ask Brox added no questions of its own.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question asks what members say would make them switch. This study asks that, then puts the same clones through two concrete changes to next year’s plan, one to the network and one to the price, so the page can compare what members say with what each change does to their stated choice.
Fielded through Ask Brox on 11 November 2026.
More on Switching insurers · Pricing and price sensitivity · Insurance · Healthcare (US) panel
Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai
Related insights
All in this topic-
Health plan formulary changes: 24% would switch plans if a monthly medicine cost $25 more, 73.5% at $75, but 94% would ask their doctor first if it were dropped
73.5% 73.5% would switch health plans at open enrollment if a medicine they take every month moved to a higher cost tier and cost $75 a month more, against 24.0% at $25 a month more and 96.0% at $200: the same 200 clones, three times as many between $25 and $75. (base 200)
Read -
Car insurance loyalty penalty: a $225 new-customer discount moves 0 of 200 to leave, the same $225 from a rival moves 28%, though 70.5% think new customers pay less
28% 28.0% (56 of 200) would move as soon as they can when a different insurer quotes $1,275 against a $1,500 renewal. When the $1,275 is what their own insurer is quoting new customers, 0 of 200 would move: 66.0% (132) would ask it to match and 34.0% (68) would get quotes first. (base 200)
Read -
Life insurance: 71.5% would buy through an advisor at the same price, but 10% cheaper online ($4 a month) moves 58% to buy on their own
58% Offered the same $500,000, 20-year term life policy through a financial advisor at $40 a month or online on their own, 28.0% would buy online at the same price, 58.0% at 10% cheaper ($36 a month) and 80.0% at 25% cheaper ($30 a month). (base 200)
Read -
Choosing a car insurer: 76% say price decides, yet 65.5% keep a known brand over one 10% cheaper and 73.5% keep a friend's recommendation
65.5% 65.5% keep a well-known national insurer at $1,500 over an insurer they have never heard of at $1,350 (10% cheaper); at $1,200 (20% cheaper) 52.5% still do. (base 200)
Read