Health plan formulary changes: 24% would switch plans if a monthly medicine cost $25 more, 73.5% at $75, but 94% would ask their doctor first if it were dropped

Told a medicine they take every month was moving to a higher cost tier, 24.0% of 200 US health plan members on employer, marketplace or Medicare coverage would switch plans at their next open enrollment if their share rose by $25 a month, against 73.5% at $75 a month (n=200, November 2026).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published
Who was asked
Healthcare, 200 clones, US
When
November 2026 (fielded 12 November 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question is why members leave a plan after a formulary change. We asked 200 clones of US adults on employer, marketplace or Medicare coverage the same tier change three times, with their share of the cost rising by $25, $75 or $200 a month and nothing else changing, to find where switching starts. Then we asked, separately, what they would do first if the plan stopped covering the medicine altogether.

Section 01: What the panel said

  1. #

    73.5%

    73.5% would switch health plans at open enrollment if a medicine they take every month moved to a higher cost tier and cost $75 a month more, against 24.0% at $25 a month more and 96.0% at $200: the same 200 clones, three times as many between $25 and $75.

    base 200

  2. #

    94%

    94.0% would first ask their doctor to move them to a medicine the plan covers if their health plan stopped covering one they take every month; 1 of 200 would start by planning to switch plans.

    base 200

  3. #

    63.5%

    63.5% say their doctors and hospitals being in the network is what most keeps them on their health plan, against 18.5% the monthly premium and 6.5% what they pay for their prescription medicines.

    base 200

  4. #

    31%

    31.0% of Medicare Advantage members would switch at $25 a month more (n=42), almost twice the 16.7% on employer plans (n=108); at $75 the order flips, 64.3% against 72.2%.

    base 42 · Medicare Advantage members · contrast

73.5% would switch health plans at open enrollment if a medicine they take every month moved to a higher cost tier and cost $75 a month more, against 24.0% at $25 a month more and 96.0% at $200: the same 200 clones, three times as many between $25 and $75.

$25 a month more ($300 a year) (base 200)
24%
$75 a month more ($900 a year) (base 200)
73.5%
$200 a month more ($2,400 a year) (base 200)
96%

Base 200 clones.

02Where is the tipping point when a medicine moves to a higher cost tier?

The same 200 clones were told three times that a medicine they take every month was moving to a higher cost tier, with nothing else about their health plan changing. At $25 a month more, 24.0% would switch plans at their next open enrollment (n=200). At $75 a month more, 73.5% would. At $200 a month more, 96.0% would, which is close enough to everyone to read as direction only. Every one of the 200 clones moved the same way up the ladder: nobody who would switch at $25 would stay at $75.

The interesting reading is that a re-tier worth about $75 a month turns a formulary change from an annoyance into a reason to leave. What the numbers support is narrower: on the same clones, the share saying they would switch roughly triples between $25 and $75 a month, so the tipping point sits somewhere in that range.

03Do Medicare and employer plan members react the same way?

Medicare Advantage members start looking sooner. At $25 a month more, 31.0% of them would switch (n=42), almost twice the 16.7% on employer plans (n=108). At $75 the order flips: 72.2% on employer plans against 64.3% in Medicare Advantage. Marketplace members were the most price-sensitive, 12 of 29 at $25 and 28 of 29 at $75, though that is a small group. Members aged 65 and over held on longest at $75, 63.3% (n=60) against 83.0% of those aged 30 to 44 (n=53).

04Why does losing coverage altogether move fewer people to switch first?

When the plan stopped covering the medicine entirely, 94.0% said the first thing they would do is ask their doctor to move them to a medicine the plan covers (n=200). Only 1 of 200 would start by planning to switch health plans, 6 would pay full price or use a discount card and 4 would ask the plan for an exception.

This looks like a contradiction but it is a question of order. The tier questions asked about switching at open enrollment with no alternative on the table; the coverage question asked what members would do first, and the doctor came first for almost everyone. 53 of the 147 clones who would switch at $75 brought their doctor or pharmacist into the answer, often as the step before shopping for a new plan. The reading is that switching is what members do when the doctor cannot get the cost down.

It also fits what keeps members on a plan in the first place: 63.5% named their doctors and hospitals being in the network (n=200), against 18.5% the monthly premium and 6.5% what they pay for their prescription medicines. Our earlier study on health plan switching found the same pull of the network.

05What would a health plan do with this?

  1. Treat a tier change that adds more than about $25 a month for a member as a retention risk, and size it by how many members it pushes past that range. This is a reading of the finding, not something the clones were asked.
  2. Put the covered alternative in the member's letter and in front of their doctor, because the doctor is where nearly every member goes first.
  3. Watch Medicare Advantage members at small increases, since they start looking sooner than employer plan members.

06What do people also ask about formulary changes and switching?

  • What share of health plan members would switch plans over a $25 a month rise in a medicine's cost? 24.0% would switch at their next open enrollment (n=200, November 2026).
  • At what monthly cost increase would most members switch health plans? Somewhere between $25 and $75 a month: at $75, 73.5% would switch (n=200).
  • How many members would switch plans first if their plan dropped their medicine? 1 of 200; 94.0% would first ask their doctor to move them to a covered medicine.

Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“Well, an extra $75 a month comes out to $900 a year, and that is a lot of money. I'm pretty frugal with my money and I try to protect my savings as much as I can, so I would definitely not be happy about a jump like that. I would probably talk to my doctor first to see if there was another medication that worked just as well that was more affordable, but when open enrollment rolled around, I would definitely shop around and look at what other plans were offering. It takes a lot for me to switch because switching can be a hassle, but saving $900 a year is certainly enough to make me take a serious look. If another good plan covered my medication at a reasonable price and kept my doctors, I would make the move. So I'd say I would probably switch.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I'd rather protect my savings and make sure I have money there in case I need it or an unexpected expense or if I become ill.”

Woman, 65 or over, Ohio, Original Medicare with a Part D plan; would probably switch at $75 a month more supports finding 1

“I would probably stay with my current plan. I'm not really one to go switching things around unless there's a major problem or big issues. If nothing else about the plan changes and everything else is working fine, an extra $25 a month wouldn't be enough to make me switch to a whole new health plan. I would probably just check with my doctor or the pharmacy first to see if there are any cheaper alternative medicines or generic options available, and go from there.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Not likely to switch anytime soon unless there's major problems and so forth. I've been using the same one for over 30 plus years. I don't foresee changing anytime soon.”

Man, 65 or over, Indiana, Medicare Advantage; would probably stay at $25 a month more supports finding 1

“The first thing I would do is talk to my doctor to see if they can switch me to an alternative medication that my insurance plan actually covers. I always prefer to choose a generic or lower-cost option whenever possible to keep costs down, and I definitely don't want to be paying full price out of pocket for healthcare expenses if I can avoid it. Asking my doctor to prescribe an equivalent medicine that is on the formulary is the most practical and cost-effective first step.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“And also, if it's possible to choose a generic or a name brand, I would always do that because of lower cost.”

Woman, 30-44, Texas, employer plan; would ask her doctor first if the medicine were dropped supports finding 2

Section 08: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • The jump between $25 and $75 a month on the same 200 clones: 48 would switch at $25 and 147 at $75, identical on two pulls of the data, and not one clone who would switch at a lower amount would stay at a higher one.
  • That the jump is not one group’s: on employer plans it runs from 16.7% to 72.2% (n=108), in Medicare Advantage from 31.0% to 64.3% (n=42), and it holds in every age group with a base over 30.
  • That the clones answered each amount on its own terms: each amount appears in its own answers 198, 199 and 200 times out of 200, and any other single amount in 15 or fewer.
  • That the network, not the premium or the drug bill, is what most keeps members on a plan: 63.5% (n=200), in line with our earlier health plan study.

What we would not

  • That 73.5% of real members would actually leave their plan over a $75 a month re-tier: this is stated intent at open enrollment, and KFF has found that only a small share of Medicare enrollees switch plans in a given year.
  • The $200 figure (96.0%, n=200) and the doctor-first figure (94.0%, n=200) as more than direction: both are close to everyone, and asking the doctor is the easiest option on the list.
  • Switching figures for employer plan members as moves between insurers: 14 of 108 said they have no other plan they could realistically pick, so for many a switch would mean another option from the same employer.
  • Any figure for marketplace (29) or Original Medicare (21) members on its own: those groups are reported as counts.

The main limitation

Every answer on the cost ladder is inferred from each person’s wider interview rather than stated on this question: their own words bear on it, but none of the 200 described this exact choice. The tier questions also left out whether a covered alternative existed. The panel is older and more female than US adults with coverage (128 of 200 women, 60 aged 65 or over).

Section 09: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Employer or union plan108
Medicare Advantage42
Marketplace (ACA) plan29
Original Medicare with a Part D plan21

Question wording as fielded

  1. What kind of health coverage do you mainly have today?
  2. In general, what most keeps you with your current health plan from one year to the next?
  3. Imagine your health plan writes to tell you that from January 1 a prescription medicine you take every month moves to a higher cost tier on its drug list, so your share of the cost rises by $25 a month ($300 a year) and nothing else about the plan changes. How likely are you to switch to a different health plan at your next open enrollment because of this change?
  4. Imagine your health plan writes to tell you that from January 1 a prescription medicine you take every month moves to a higher cost tier on its drug list, so your share of the cost rises by $75 a month ($900 a year) and nothing else about the plan changes. How likely are you to switch to a different health plan at your next open enrollment because of this change?
  5. Imagine your health plan writes to tell you that from January 1 a prescription medicine you take every month moves to a higher cost tier on its drug list, so your share of the cost rises by $200 a month ($2,400 a year) and nothing else about the plan changes. How likely are you to switch to a different health plan at your next open enrollment because of this change?
  6. Imagine your health plan writes to tell you that from January 1 it will stop covering a prescription medicine you take every month, so you would pay the full price at the pharmacy unless something changes. What would you do first?

What was not asked, and why

We did not name any plan, insurer or medicine, did not say whether a covered alternative existed in the cost tier questions, did not change the premium alongside the drug cost, and did not ask what members did at past open enrollments. People on Medicaid, another kind of coverage or none were screened out (151 of 498 screened).

What changed from the obvious question

The obvious question is why members leave a plan after a formulary change. We asked 200 clones of US adults on employer, marketplace or Medicare coverage the same tier change three times, with their share of the cost rising by $25, $75 or $200 a month and nothing else changing, to find where switching starts. Then we asked, separately, what they would do first if the plan stopped covering the medicine altogether.

Fielded through Ask Brox on 12 November 2026.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai

Related insights

All in this topic