A better claims app tempts 17% of US policyholders to switch at the same price; an easier everyday app tempts 1.5%

In October 2026, 17.0% of US insurance policyholders (34 of 200) leaned towards switching to an insurer whose app handles a whole claim on the phone at the same price and cover, but only 2.5% would definitely switch, and an app that only eased everyday tasks moved 1.5% (n=200).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
US policyholders, 200 clones, US
When
October 2026 (fielded 2 October 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
Instead of asking whether people would switch for a better app, the study held cover and price equal and split the app into two scenarios, one that handles claims end to end and one that only eases everyday servicing, then asked what would stop them and whether they would pay more.

Section 01: What the panel said

  1. #

    17%

    17.0% of policyholders (34 of 200) leaned towards switching (4 or 5 on a 5-point scale) to an insurer whose app handles a whole claim on the phone, with cover and price unchanged; 2.5% (5 of 200) would definitely switch and 74.5% (149 of 200) would definitely stay.

    base 200

  2. #

    1.5%

    An app that only made everyday tasks easier moved 1.5% (3 of 200) towards switching, against 17.0% for the claims app; claims handling was the top choice factor apart from price for 47.5% (95 of 200), a good app for 2.5% (5 of 200).

    base 200 · contrast

  3. #

    28.9%

    Openness is younger: 28.9% of 30 to 44 year olds (11 of 38) leaned towards switching for the claims app, against 20.2% of 45 to 64 year olds (19 of 94) and 1 of 62 aged 65 and over.

    base 38 · Aged 30 to 44 · contrast

  4. #

    34%

    The brakes are a person and the move itself: 34.0% (68 of 200) said a preference for talking to a person would stop them switching for a better app, and 32.0% (64 of 200) named the hassle of switching; 198 of 200 would pay nothing more a month for the claims app.

    base 200 · caveat

17.0% of policyholders (34 of 200) leaned towards switching (4 or 5 on a 5-point scale) to an insurer whose app handles a whole claim on the phone, with cover and price unchanged; 2.5% (5 of 200) would definitely switch and 74.5% (149 of 200) would definitely stay.

Claims app: leaning to switch (4-5)
17%
Claims app: definitely switch (5)
2.5%
Everyday-tasks app: leaning to switch (4-5)
1.5%

Base 200 clones.

02Is a better app enough to win an insurance customer?

Mostly not. With cover and price held exactly equal, 74.5% of policyholders (149 of 200) said they would definitely stay with their current insurer even when the rival's app handled a whole claim on the phone. About one in six, 17.0% (34 of 200), leaned towards switching, and only 2.5% (5 of 200) said they would definitely switch.

That is the defensible reading: an app advantage on its own opens a door for a minority and does not push anyone through it. Nobody priced it as an upgrade either, since 198 of 200 would pay nothing extra a month for the claims app.

03Which kind of app actually moves people?

The interesting reading is that the pull of the app is really the pull of claims. The same panel, offered an app that only made everyday tasks easier (paying the premium, downloading ID cards, changing cover), produced 3 leaners out of 200, against 34 for the claims app. Claims handling was also the top reason to choose an insurer apart from price, for 47.5% (95 of 200), while a good app and online tools came top for 2.5% (5 of 200).

04Who is open to switching, and what holds the rest back?

The openness is a younger one. Among 30 to 44 year olds 28.9% leaned towards switching for the claims app (11 of 38), against 20.2% of 45 to 64 year olds (19 of 94) and 1 of 62 aged 65 and over. Men and women answered alike.

What stops people is a person and the paperwork of moving. Asked what would most stop them switching to a better app at the same price, 34.0% said they prefer talking to a person (68 of 200) and 32.0% named the hassle of switching (64 of 200). Among the 34 who leaned towards switching, the hassle was the main brake for 16.

05What would an insurer do with this?

  1. A reading, not the panel's answer: put digital investment into the claim, from first notice to payment, rather than into everyday servicing, and say so in acquisition messaging aimed at under-45s.
  2. A second reading: a claims app will not carry a higher price, so it is a reason to choose at parity, and switching friction (moving a bundle, re-keying details) is the cost that decides whether a leaner actually moves.

Section 06: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“I'd probably say a 4. I'm very comfortable using mobile-only services and apps, so being able to file a claim, upload pictures, and handle everything directly on my phone rather than dealing with clunky phone calls and paperwork sounds really appealing to me. When it comes to claims, the initial reporting is usually the most frustrating and least smooth part of the whole process. If the coverage and the price are completely identical, why not make the switch for something smoother and more convenient? I wouldn't say a 1 or 2 at all, but probably a solid 4 since switching always takes a tiny bit of effort.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I think it's just a lot of the reporting initially is really just kind of like not very smooth in and of itself. And like having to submit pictures of your own, I don't know, coordinating with a shop is also kind of like clunky, but definitely think like the initial reporting is always probably the most difficult and less smooth part of the process overall.”

Woman, 30 to 44, Alaska, leaned towards switching for the claims app supports finding 1

“I would say a 4. I really prefer interacting with an insurance company online or through an app because I really don't like talking to people on the phone. I don't like talking on the phone at all unless I absolutely have to, and it seems like it just takes forever to get someone on the line. So being able to handle a claim, upload photos, and track everything right on an app without phone calls and paperwork would be so much better for me. Now, if the price is exactly the same, it does make you hesitate a little because switching means you've got to change everything, and usually price is the number one thing that makes me change. But having to deal with phone calls and paperwork is something I really try to avoid, so I would definitely lean toward switching for an app. I'd give it a 4.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I really don't like talking to people on the phone. I really don't like talking to people at all unless I have to.”

Woman, 45 to 64, Missouri, leaned towards switching for the claims app supports finding 1

“For me, having a better mobile app wouldn't be enough to make me switch, especially if the coverage and price are the same. What matters most to me is being able to actually talk to a real person. In this day and age, everything is moving toward apps, automated systems, and chatbots, and it has gotten so frustrating trying to get answers when something goes wrong. I want to know that if I have a question or an issue with a claim, I can pick up the phone or walk into a local office and speak face-to-face with an actual human being who knows what they're doing. An app might be convenient for basic things, but having that direct personal connection and reassurance is far more important to me than a flashy interface.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Just because I want the reassurance that there is a physical location with actual people I can talk to and reach out and go to to meet in person if there ever is an issue that comes up.”

Woman, 30 to 44, Wisconsin, would stay because she prefers talking to a person supports finding 4

Section 07: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • That a claims app at equal price moves far more policyholders (34 of 200) than an everyday-tasks app (3 of 200).
  • That definite switching for an app alone is rare: 5 of 200.
  • That the openness sits with under-45s and almost vanishes at 65 and over (1 of 62).

What we would not

  • The 17.0% as a real switching rate: it is stated intent with no switching effort attached, so actual switching would be lower.
  • 198 of 200 paying nothing more as a precise figure: near-unanimity is direction only.
  • Any figure for 18 to 29 year olds: only 6 in the base (3 of 6 leaned).
  • The size of the claims-versus-everyday gap: the claims scenario was asked first, so some order effect is possible.

The main limitation

The panel skews older (156 of 200 are 45 or over) and female (136 of 200), and the age group most open to switching is the smallest in it, so the overall share likely understates a younger market.

Section 08: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Aged 18 to 296
Aged 30 to 4438
Aged 45 to 6494
Aged 65 and over62

Question wording as fielded

  1. Do you currently hold an auto, home or renters insurance policy in your own name?
  2. Imagine another insurer offers exactly the same cover as your current policy at exactly the same price. The only difference is its mobile app: you could file a claim, upload photos, track the claim and get paid entirely on your phone, while your current insurer handles claims by phone calls and paperwork. How likely would you be to switch to it, on a scale from 1 (definitely stay) to 5 (definitely switch)?
  3. Imagine instead that the other insurer offers exactly the same cover at exactly the same price, and handles claims the same way as your current insurer. The only difference is that its app makes everyday tasks easier: paying your premium, downloading ID cards and changing your cover in a few taps. How likely would you be to switch to it, on a scale from 1 (definitely stay) to 5 (definitely switch)?
  4. If an insurer's app let you file, track and get paid on a claim entirely on your phone, how much more per month would you pay for that insurer than for your current one, with the same cover?
  5. Apart from price, which one of these matters most to you when choosing an insurer?
  6. What would be most likely to stop you switching to an insurer with a better app, even at the same price?

What was not asked, and why

No brands were named or asked about, and no specific app was shown; the scenarios described what each app could do. Price sensitivity beyond a small monthly premium was not tested, and past switching behavior was not asked because the panel does not hold it as data.

What changed from the obvious question

Instead of asking whether people would switch for a better app, the study held cover and price equal and split the app into two scenarios, one that handles claims end to end and one that only eases everyday servicing, then asked what would stop them and whether they would pay more.

Fielded through Ask Brox on 2 October 2026.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai

Related insights

All in this topic