Topic hub
Claims and the moment of truth
How a claim experience changes loyalty, what a good one looks like, and what a bad one costs the insurer.
What did the panels say about claims and the moment of truth?
- #
45%
45.0% would shop around for another insurer at renewal if no person contacted them until the next day after they reported a car accident, against 25.0% after a four-hour wait and 3.5% when a named claims handler calls within the hour. — After a car accident: 45% would shop around at renewal if no person calls for 24 hours, against 3.5% after a call within the hour
base 200
- #
57%
57% of US insurance customers (114 of 200) would refuse an app-only version of their current policy at the same price, keeping or finding one with a person to call; 21% would take it happily and 21.5% only if it were cheaper. — Insurance apps: US customers trust one to take a premium but not to run a claim, and 57% would refuse an app-only policy at the same price
base 200
- #
48%
The exit is at the first step, where the app asks them to describe the crash in their own words. — Nearly half of US drivers would quit an AI-led car claim intake at the opening question, and none would quit at the photos
base 200
What has Brox published on claims and the moment of truth?Newest first
-
After a car accident: 45% would shop around at renewal if no person calls for 24 hours, against 3.5% after a call within the hour
45% 45.0% would shop around for another insurer at renewal if no person contacted them until the next day after they reported a car accident, against 25.0% after a four-hour wait and 3.5% when a named claims handler calls within the hour. (base 200)
Read -
Insurance apps: US customers trust one to take a premium but not to run a claim, and 57% would refuse an app-only policy at the same price
57% 57% of US insurance customers (114 of 200) would refuse an app-only version of their current policy at the same price, keeping or finding one with a person to call; 21% would take it happily and 21.5% only if it were cheaper. (base 200)
Read -
Nearly half of US drivers would quit an AI-led car claim intake at the opening question, and none would quit at the photos
48% The exit is at the first step, where the app asks them to describe the crash in their own words. (base 200)
Read
What do people ask about claims and the moment of truth?
- What do customers expect in the first hour after they report a car accident, and how long can an insurer wait before a person calls?
- 45.0% of US car insurance customers would shop around at renewal if no person contacted them for 24 hours after they reported an accident, against 25.0% after four hours and 3.5% when a named claims handler calls within the hour (n=200, October 2026).Read the insight
- Do customers trust an insurer's app enough to manage their whole policy without a human?
- 57% of US insurance customers (114 of 200) would refuse an app-only version of their policy at the same price, and 68% name disputing a claim decision as the moment they most want a person (n=200, October 2026).Read the insight
- Where do customers stop and ask for a human when an AI runs their car insurance claim intake?
- Asked which single step they would be most likely to leave at, 48% of 200 US auto insurance policyholders chose the opening incident description, where the app asks them to describe the crash in their own words, and none chose photo capture (n=200, September 2026).Read the insight
Other topics
How should you read these findings?
Where the numbers come from. Every figure on this site is a predicted response from Brox clones: behavioural replicas of real people, each built from a long-form interview with that person. The base under each figure is the number of clones behind it.
Where the real data comes from. The long-form video interviews with the real people the clones are built from. A quote is always shown with the interview line it was predicted from.
What you can take away. Insights publish their tabulation as CSV and JSON: question, option, count, percentage and base. Never per-person rows.
Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai