197 of 200 US insurance customers would pay nothing extra for a guaranteed 72-hour claim settlement

Asked the most they would realistically pay for a written guarantee to settle an approved claim within 72 hours or pay a penalty, 197 of 200 US insurance customers said nothing at all, and take-up turns negative once it costs $50 a year (n=200, September 2026).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
US insurance customers, 200 clones, US
When
September 2026 (fielded 29 September 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question is whether customers would like faster claims, which only ever comes back yes. This asked what the speed is worth in money instead, and put the ceiling twice in different words so the two answers could be checked against a four-step price ladder.

Section 01: What the panel said

  1. #

    47%

    At fifty dollars a year the guarantee already loses more customers than it wins.

    base 200

  2. #

    197

    Asked the most they would realistically pay, almost every customer said nothing.

    base 200

  3. #

    0

    Not one person chose the penalty clause as their reason to pay.

    base 200

  4. #

    28

    Only 28 of 200 customers describe their most recent claim as slow, disputed or stressful, so the group with a problem to solve is small.

    base 200 · contrast

At fifty dollars a year the guarantee already loses more customers than it wins.

$25 more a year
67%
$50 more a year
47%
$100 more a year
20%
$200 more a year
4%

Base 200 clones.

02What should a buyer take from this?

Asked the highest extra amount they would realistically pay each year for a written guarantee that an approved claim is settled within 72 hours, 197 of 200 US insurance customers said nothing at all. Asked separately, in different words, at what extra annual cost the guarantee would stop feeling worth it, 189 of 200 said the moment it costs anything. Only two people put a ceiling above fifty dollars.

Two differently worded questions landing in the same place is the strongest signal in this study. Fast settlement is not read as an upgrade worth buying. It is read as part of what the policy was supposed to do already.

03Where does the answer change, and at what price?

Priced as a choice between insurers rather than as a sum to hand over, the same guarantee looks far more attractive, and then falls away quickly. At twenty-five dollars more a year, 67% (n=200) would be at least somewhat likely to choose an insurer offering it. At fifty dollars that is 47% (n=200), which is the point where the room splits against it. At one hundred dollars it is 20% (n=200), and at two hundred dollars 4% (n=200).

04Why do the two questions disagree?

They disagree because they cost the respondent different things. Picking the insurer with the better promise is free, so 67% (n=200) will do it at twenty-five dollars. Naming the most you would pay is a commitment, and there 197 of 200 said zero. Where a laddered choice and a direct ceiling pull apart like this, the ceiling is the more conservative of the two, and it is the one worth planning against.

The stated reasons point the same way. Price was the main barrier for 123 of 200, well ahead of thinking current service is already fast enough at 27 of 200. Among the reasons to pay, lower stress led on 51 of 200 and trusting the company on 23 of 200, while not one person out of 200 picked the penalty clause. The enforcement mechanism that makes the promise credible persuades nobody on its own.

05What would a product team do with this?

Two readings, and both are readings rather than the panel's own words.

  1. Treat a settlement-speed promise as a tie-breaker priced at or near nothing, not as a paid tier. It moves the choice while it is close to free, and 20% (n=200) is all that is left by one hundred dollars.
  2. Size the audience honestly before building for it. Only 28 of 200 describe their most recent claim as slow, disputed or stressful, and 156 of 200 either had a quick, smooth claim or have filed none at all, so most customers have no lived problem that this solves.
  3. Do not lead on the penalty. It is what makes the promise enforceable, and as a reason to pay it drew nobody out of 200, so it belongs in the wording rather than in the pitch.

Section 06: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“Why am I gonna pay extra money for something you're supposed to be doing in the first place? A claim is not supposed to take that long, two, three days and you should be settled already. That's 72 hours right there.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“they gotta be faster ... it's not supposed to be that long ... two three days you should be settled”

Man, 18-29, Texas, chooses his own cover supports finding 2

Section 07: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • At fifty dollars a year the guarantee already loses more customers than it wins.
  • Asked the most they would realistically pay, almost every customer said nothing.
  • Not one person chose the penalty clause as their reason to pay.

What we would not

  • Appeal was asked on a scale and 130 of 200 answered that it depends, saying they would need to know what counts as an approved claim and how large the penalty is. The enthusiasm in the positive answers is therefore conditional, and the appeal question separates people only weakly.
  • No segment cut stands behind any of this. Only three respondents would pay anything at all, so the reading that willingness concentrates among low-trust customers rests on a base of three and is not reproduced here.

The main limitation

The ladder and the ceiling disagree. 134 of 200 would choose an insurer offering the guarantee at $25 a year, yet 197 of 200 would pay nothing for it. Picking between hypothetical insurers costs nothing, whereas naming a sum does, so the ceiling is the more conservative reading and it is the one this brief leads with.

Section 08: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Most recent claim quick and smooth88
No claim filed68
Fair, resolved15
Denied or disputed13
Stressful, a hassle8
Slow, delayed7
Other1

Question wording as fielded

  1. Thinking about your own insurance preferences, how appealing is this offer: if an insurer guaranteed in writing to settle an approved claim within 72 hours or pay a penalty?
  2. Which of these best describes your most recent experience with an insurance claim?
  3. What is the main reason this guarantee would not be worth paying more for to you?
  4. What is the main reason you would pay extra for a written 72-hour approved-claim settlement guarantee, if you would pay anything at all?
  5. If this guarantee cost the following extra amount per year, how likely would you be to choose an insurer that offered it?
  6. At what extra amount per year would this 72-hour approved-claim settlement guarantee stop feeling worth it to you?
  7. Which of these best describes how you usually choose insurance?
  8. How much do you trust insurers in general to actually pay approved claims fairly and promptly today?
  9. If this 72-hour approved-claim settlement guarantee were added to your insurance policy, what is the highest extra amount per year you would realistically be willing to pay for it?

What was not asked, and why

Nobody was asked about a named insurer, a particular policy type or a real quoted premium, so the prices here are abstract annual add-ons rather than money set against a product somebody was actually buying.

What changed from the obvious question

The obvious question is whether customers would like faster claims, which only ever comes back yes. This asked what the speed is worth in money instead, and put the ceiling twice in different words so the two answers could be checked against a four-step price ladder.

Fielded through Ask Brox on 29 September 2026.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai

Related insights

All in this topic