Electric car insurance: at $1,300 a year more only 5.5% of US EV considerers still choose the EV, and a $700 gap halves even the keenest buyers
Among US car buyers open to an electric car, 32.5% would still choose it over a same-price gas car if it cost $300 a year more to insure, 15.0% at $700 more and 5.5% at $1,300 more (n=200, October 2026).
- Who was asked
- US drivers considering an electric car, 200 clones, US
- When
- October 2026 (fielded 13 October 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- The obvious question asks about electric vehicle owners. The panel holds few owners, so the study screened for people who would consider an electric car next (203 of 614 qualified) and asked them to choose between two cars at the same purchase price with the insurance gap written in dollars at three levels, close to the real gap, so the page can name the price at which the choice flips rather than only whether insurance matters.
Section 01: What the panel said
- #
5.5%
With the electric car and a comparable gas car at the same purchase price, 32.5% of US buyers open to an electric car would still choose it at $300 a year more to insure, 15.0% at $700 more and 5.5% at $1,300 more.
base 200
- #
48.2%
Among buyers very likely to consider an electric car, 85.7% still choose it at a $300 gap, 48.2% at $700 and 19.6% at $1,300; among the somewhat likely, 13.8% choose it at $300 and none at $1,300.
base 56 · Very likely to consider an electric car · contrast
- #
79.5%
79.5% would check what a car costs to insure only after choosing the model, and 15.0% before choosing which model to buy.
base 200
- #
44%
44.0% say lower fuel and charging costs would most make up for higher electric car insurance and 34.5% a purchase discount or incentive; 12.5% name an insurer's lower rate for electric cars and 6.0% say nothing would.
base 200 · contrast
With the electric car and a comparable gas car at the same purchase price, 32.5% of US buyers open to an electric car would still choose it at $300 a year more to insure, 15.0% at $700 more and 5.5% at $1,300 more.
02At what insurance gap do buyers stop choosing the electric car?
Early. With the electric car and a comparable gas car at the same purchase price, 32.5% of US car buyers open to an electric car (n=200) would still choose it when it costs $300 a year more to insure. At $700 a year more, 15.0% would. At $1,300 a year more, 5.5% would.
The same 200 clones answered all three versions and nobody moved the wrong way: no clone chose the electric car at a bigger gap after turning it down at a smaller one. As the gap grows, more people walk away from both cars. 2.0% would keep looking at $300, 8.5% at $700 and 15.0% at $1,300.
03Who holds on to the electric car, and who drops out at $300?
Commitment decides it. Of the 56 clones very likely to consider an electric car, 48 (85.7%) would still choose it at $300 a year more, 27 (48.2%) at $700 and 11 (19.6%) at $1,300. Of the 123 only somewhat likely, 17 (13.8%) would choose it at $300, 3 at $700 and none at $1,300.
Committed buyers who give up at the top rung mostly do not switch to gas. At $1,300 a year more, 18 of the 56 would keep looking rather than buy either car, against 27 who would take the gas car.
04When do car buyers find out what a car costs to insure?
After they have picked the car. 79.5% (n=200) would check the insurance cost after choosing the model but before buying it, and only 15.0% before choosing which model to buy. 4.0% would find out only after buying.
That timing turns the premium gap into a late veto. A buyer settles on an electric car, gets the quote at the point of sale, and that is where the gap does its damage. Of the 30 who check before choosing a model, none would choose the electric car at $1,300 a year more.
05What would make up for higher electric car insurance?
Running-cost savings first. 44.0% (n=200) say lower fuel and charging costs would most make up for the gap, and 34.5% a discount or incentive on the purchase price. 12.5% name an insurer offering a lower rate for electric cars, 3.0% lower maintenance, and 6.0% say nothing would.
The saving people name is not enough at the moment of choice: 48 of the 88 who point to fuel and charging savings still take the gas car at a $300 gap, and 2 more would keep looking. The low 12.5% for an insurer's electric car rate reads as low expectation of insurers rather than proof that a lower rate would not work, because the study did not test one.
06What do people also ask about electric car insurance and which car to buy?
- What share of buyers would still choose an electric car if it cost $1,300 a year more to insure? 5.5% (11 of 200) of US buyers open to an electric car in October 2026, against 32.5% at $300 a year more.
- At what insurance gap do keen electric car buyers start to give up? At $700 a year more, 48.2% of those very likely to consider one (27 of 56) still choose it, against 85.7% at $300.
- How many car buyers check insurance cost before choosing a model? 15.0% (30 of 200); 79.5% check only after choosing the model.
Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“I would definitely choose neither and keep looking. I mean, I'm a green person and I'm very pro eco-friendly features on a car, so I really love the idea of an electric car. But $1,300 a year more just for insurance? No way. That's over $100 extra every single month, and you're already dealing with car payments, insurance, tollways, and everything else. Insurance is already way too expensive, and I hate paying more than I need to or throwing money away. I always check insurance costs before making a big decision because you need to know what you're getting into. But I wouldn't just turn around and buy the gas car either if I have my mind set on something eco-friendly. We're already putting money aside and holding off until we find a good deal, so if that electric car costs that much extra to insure, I would just walk away and keep looking for a better deal or another option.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“yeah, I'm pro eco friendly, uh, features on the car and, uh, I'm a green person, so yeah.”
“I would definitely go with the gas car. I'm just used to riding in a regular gas automobile, so making the switch over to an electric vehicle would already be a pretty hard thing for me to do. On top of that, having to pay an extra $300 every year just for insurance doesn't make much sense when I can stick with what's familiar and not spend the extra money.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I think electric vehicles are fine. I saw a hybrid hydropower and the other ones But I'm used to riding in a regular gas Automobile, so it would be a hard hard thing to switch over, you know”
“I would check after choosing the model but before buying it. When I buy a vehicle, I plan on keeping it until it runs into the ground, and I'm pretty careful about not exceeding my budget. I've already set a hard limit that I wouldn't pay more than $500 a month on a vehicle payment, so I'd need to know upfront what insurance is going to run me before I actually pull the trigger and sign any paperwork. It makes the most sense to settle on the vehicle you actually want, check what the insurance premium would look like with my provider, and make sure the overall numbers work before committing.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“Buying new or some of my new vehicles is ridiculous right now. So, I know realistically I would probably be paying at least $500, but I would not pay any more than that.”
Section 08: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- The ladder: 32.5%, 15.0% and 5.5% choose the electric car (n=200) at $300, $700 and $1,300 a year more to insure, with the same clones answering every rung and none moving against the ladder.
- The commitment split: 48 of 56 very likely considerers choose the electric car at $300 against 17 of 123 somewhat likely.
- The timing: 79.5% (n=200) say they would price insurance only after choosing the model.
What we would not
- The $300 figure as a pure insurance effect: there was no rung with no insurance gap, so part of the 65.5% choosing gas at $300 reflects hesitancy about electric cars (49 of the 131 also mention range, charging or batteries).
- A forecast of electric car sales: these are stated choices between two written cars, not purchases, and only a third of the panel qualified as considerers.
- The top rung as anything but direction: 94.5% not choosing the electric car at $1,300 is close to unanimous.
- Any figure for buyers aged 18-29 (16 clones), the not-sure group (21) or any income band.
- Where between $700 and $1,300 the line sits, or what an insurer's lower electric car rate would do: neither was tested.
The main limitation
The panel is people who hold insurance and say they would consider an electric car, not current electric car owners, and the study had no zero-gap baseline, so the ladder measures how fast choice falls rather than how many would choose an electric car with no insurance gap at all.
Section 09: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Very likely to consider an electric car | 56 |
| Somewhat likely to consider an electric car | 123 |
| Not sure | 21 |
| Aged 45-64 | 84 |
| Aged 30-44 | 67 |
| Aged 65 or over | 32 |
| Aged 18-29 | 16 |
Question wording as fielded
- How likely are you to consider an electric car when you next buy a car? (screener: 203 of 614 qualified, 200 sampled)
- You are choosing between an electric car and a comparable gas car with the same purchase price. Which would you buy? (fielded as one grid with three rows: the electric car costs $300, $700 or $1,300 a year more to insure than the gas car)
- When buying your next car, at what point would you find out what it costs to insure?
- Which of these would most make up for an electric car costing more to insure than a comparable gas car?
What was not asked, and why
No car brand, model or insurer was named, no rung with no insurance gap was written, and no rung between $700 and $1,300. Clones were not asked about their own past car purchases. Ask Brox fielded the three premium questions as one grid and added no questions or brands of its own.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question asks about electric vehicle owners. The panel holds few owners, so the study screened for people who would consider an electric car next (203 of 614 qualified) and asked them to choose between two cars at the same purchase price with the insurance gap written in dollars at three levels, close to the real gap, so the page can name the price at which the choice flips rather than only whether insurance matters.
Fielded through Ask Brox on 13 October 2026.
More on Premiums, renewals and price sensitivity · Pricing and price sensitivity · Insurance · Insurance (US) panel
Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai
Related insights
All in this topic-
Health plan pharmacy benefits: 56.5% of members judge them on the price per prescription, and 73.5% would give up their local pharmacy for mail delivery to save $5 a month
56.5% 56.5% of health plan members (113 of 200) say what they pay at the pharmacy for each prescription is the part of their drug coverage that matters most, 41.0% (82) say whether their medicines are covered at all, and 1.5% (3) say using the pharmacy they want near home. (base 200)
Read -
Higher deductible for a lower premium: 33% of drivers take a $1,000 car insurance deductible for $100 a year off, 74% for $250, and cash on the day holds the rest back
74% 33.0% (66 of 200) would move from a $500 to a $1,000 car insurance deductible for $100 a year off their premium, 74.0% (148) for $250 a year and 90.0% (180) for $400. The biggest step is between $100 and $250, where 82 clones say yes for the first time. (base 200)
Read -
Car insurance data: 38% would switch insurer at the same price over secretly bought driving data, yet 60% would let an app track them for 30% off
38% 38.0% (76 of 200) would switch to another insurer even at the same price if they learned their car insurer had bought records of their driving from their car's maker without asking and used them to set their premium; 28.5% would renew but opt out of all data sharing, 16.0% would get quotes but probably stay and 17.5% would renew as normal. (base 200)
Read -
Human insurance agents: 61.5% of customers would pay $5 a month more to keep one, only 35.5% would pay $15
61.5% 61.5% would choose the policy with a human agent at $5 a month more, falling to 35.5% at $15 and 18.5% at $30. (base 200)
Read