Higher deductible for a lower premium: 33% of drivers take a $1,000 car insurance deductible for $100 a year off, 74% for $250, and cash on the day holds the rest back
33.0% of US car insurance customers would raise a $500 deductible to $1,000 for $100 a year off their premium, against 74.0% for $250 a year off, so the tipping point sits between $100 and $250 a year (n=200, November 2026).
- Who was asked
- US car insurance customers, 200 clones, US
- When
- November 2026 (fielded 10 November 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- The obvious question asks whether people prefer a high or a low deductible, and stops at a share. This study puts a price on the trade: three written offers of $100, $250 and $400 a year off to double a $500 deductible, then the main reason to keep the lower one, so the page can say where the switch happens and what holds the rest back.
Section 01: What the panel said
- #
74%
33.0% (66 of 200) would move from a $500 to a $1,000 car insurance deductible for $100 a year off their premium, 74.0% (148) for $250 a year and 90.0% (180) for $400. The biggest step is between $100 and $250, where 82 clones say yes for the first time.
base 200
- #
29.5%
For most who would not move, the barrier is cash on the day, not claims: 29.5% (59 of 200) say finding $1,000 on short notice after an accident would be hard and 0 of 200 say they are fairly likely to claim, while 66.5% (133) would move if the saving were big enough.
base 200 · contrast
- #
50%
Income draws the sharpest line at $100 a year: 50.0% (31 of 62) of clones in households on $100,000 or more would take the higher deductible, against 15.4% (10 of 65) under $50,000, where 53.8% (35 of 65) say $1,000 on short notice would be hard.
base 62 · Households on $100,000 or more, against under $50,000 · contrast
- #
61.6%
86.0% (172 of 200) say a low premium matters more to them than a low deductible, yet 61.6% (106 of 172) of those clones turn down $100 a year off for a $1,000 deductible.
base 172 · Clones who say they prefer a low premium · caveat
33.0% (66 of 200) would move from a $500 to a $1,000 car insurance deductible for $100 a year off their premium, 74.0% (148) for $250 a year and 90.0% (180) for $400. The biggest step is between $100 and $250, where 82 clones say yes for the first time.
02Where is the tipping point between a higher deductible and a lower premium?
Between $100 and $250 a year. Offered $100 a year off to move from a $500 to a $1,000 car insurance deductible, 33.0% (66 of 200) would take it. At $250 a year off, 74.0% (148) would. That is the biggest step on the ladder: 82 clones (41.0%) say yes for the first time at $250, against 32 more at $400, and 20 (10.0%) turn down all three offers.
The arithmetic is simple. Doubling the deductible adds $500 to what a driver pays on a claim, so $100 a year pays that back after five claim-free years and $250 a year after two. Most clones accept the two-year payback and most refuse the five-year one. No clone said yes at a lower saving and then no at a higher one.
03Why do some drivers keep a low deductible when a higher one is cheaper?
Not because they expect to claim: 0 of 200 chose "I think I am fairly likely to make a claim" as their main reason. 29.5% (59) chose "Finding $1,000 on short notice after an accident would be hard for me", and 66.5% (133) said they would move to the $1,000 deductible if the saving were big enough. Of the 59 who named the cash problem, 1 would take the offer at $100 a year, 20 at $250 and 44 at $400.
That fits what is known about household cash. The Federal Reserve's Survey of Household Economics and Decisionmaking found 63% of US adults would cover a $400 emergency expense with cash or its equivalent in 2025, and a car insurance deductible is exactly that kind of expense. Economists have long read the pull towards low deductibles as aversion to small risks; Sydnor's study of about 50,000 homeowners policies found most people paying well over the odds to keep one. These clones put it in more practical terms: they could not find the money on the day.
04Who takes the higher deductible at $100 a year, and who holds out?
Income draws the sharpest line. At $100 a year, 50.0% (31 of 62) of clones in households on $100,000 or more would double their deductible, against 15.4% (10 of 65) under $50,000. Under $50,000, 53.8% (35 of 65) say finding $1,000 on short notice would be hard, against 12.9% (8 of 62) at $100,000 or more. Age points the same way: 54.8% (23 of 42) of clones aged 65 or over take the $100 offer, against 21.1% (12 of 57) aged 30 to 44.
Saying you prefer a low premium is not the same as taking one. 86.0% (172 of 200) say a low premium matters more to them than a low deductible, yet 61.6% (106 of 172) of those clones turn down $100 a year for the higher deductible.
05What would an insurer or a comparison site do with this?
- A reading, not the panel's answer: quote the higher-deductible option with its payback in claim-free years. On this panel, a two-year payback converts most drivers and a five-year one does not.
- A reading: for lower-income drivers the objection is the cash on the day, so the offer that moves them may be a way to spread a deductible payment rather than a bigger discount.
06What do people also ask about deductibles and premiums?
- What share of drivers would raise their deductible to save $100 a year? 33.0% (66 of 200) would move from a $500 to a $1,000 car insurance deductible for $100 a year off.
- At what saving do most drivers accept a $1,000 deductible? At $250 a year off, 74.0% (148 of 200) would take it, up from 33.0% at $100.
- How many drivers say a $1,000 deductible would be hard to pay on short notice? 29.5% (59 of 200) give it as their main reason to keep a $500 deductible, rising to 53.8% (35 of 65) in households under $50,000.
Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“Definitely yes: Having worked in the insurance industry for over 20 years, I look at the numbers and how long it takes to recoup the difference in risk. Increasing the deductible from $500 to $1,000 means I am taking on an extra $500 of out-of-pocket risk if I have a claim. But if the insurer is cutting my premium by $250 a year, that extra $500 is completely recouped in just two claim-free years. I've looked at deductible changes on my own before where saving something like $50 a year to raise a deductible by $400 didn't make sense because it would take eight years to break even. But breaking even in two years makes complete financial sense. Plus, my wife and I keep an emergency fund set aside for things like vehicle repairs or unexpected expenses anyway, so coming up with the $1,000 deductible wouldn't be an issue.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“Like, sometimes I do some things on my own, like look at changing deductibles or dropping a coverage. And, you know, the... The difference in premium does not make sense. So, you know, if an insurance company is going to attempt this, you know, make the savings worth, you know, the difference. For example, say if I had a 100 deductible on comprehensive, you know, that would cover glass breakage as well. And, you know, if you're going to change it to... 500, but it only saves me $50 a year, that's really not sensible to me. You know, it would take over eight years to recoup the loss of, say, a windshield was $500. So, it needs to be sensible if you're going to send out information to save money.”
“Definitely not. I would not take that offer. Saving about $8 a month or $100 a year is just not worth doubling my deductible to $1,000. Right now, any kind of extra bill or major expense severely impacts our finances because we've been working to climb out of debt, and I don't have that kind of money just laying around. If I were to get into an accident, having to come up with $1,000 out of pocket would mean having to decide between food shopping and paying bills. The tiny monthly savings simply isn't worth putting ourselves in that kind of financial risk.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“Any kind of extra bill right now today as we speak would have a significant impact on my finances because we've been in debt and trying to climb out of the hole.”
“Finding $1,000 on short notice after an accident would definitely be hard for me. I'm just not financially stable enough to handle coming up with a giant $1,000 deductible all at once just to get my vehicle back and repaired. I specifically keep my deductible as low as I can get it because having that smaller amount is something I can actually manage without it ruining my finances.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“And luckily, I was smart and knew that I'm not really financially stable enough to have some kind of giant $1,000 deductible just to get my car back. So I made mine as low as I could possibly have it.”
Section 08: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- Where the tipping point sits: 33.0% (66 of 200) at $100 a year against 74.0% (148) at $250, identical on two pulls of the data, and the step from $100 to $250 is the biggest in every age, income and gender group with a base over 30.
- That the clones read each offer on its own terms: each rung's own figure appears in 196 to 200 of 200 replies, and no clone says yes at a lower saving and no at a higher one.
- The income split at $100 a year, 50.0% (31 of 62) against 15.4% (10 of 65), as a difference between two groups in this panel, with the cash reason following the same line (12.9% against 53.8%).
- That expected claims are not the stated reason: 0 of 200 chose it.
What we would not
- The levels as a forecast of take-up. These are stated choices on written offers, and studies of real policies, such as Sydnor's on about 50,000 homeowners policies, find people keep low deductibles more than their stated preferences suggest.
- 90.0% (180 of 200) at $400 a year as a precise share: near-unanimity on a written offer is a direction only.
- The exact size of the step: the same clones saw the three offers in rising order, which can sharpen the contrast between them.
- 29.5% as a precise share of drivers short of cash. Ask Brox marks 197 of 200 answers to the reason question as inferred, and 64 to 82 of 200 clones per question rest on their own lines about emergencies, savings or affording bills.
- Any figure for drivers aged 18 to 29 (3 clones), or for home or health insurance deductibles, which were not asked about.
The main limitation
These are stated choices on written offers, inferred from each person's wider interview: 0 to 3 of 200 answers per main question are marked as a direct statement, while 137 to 149 of 200 clones per question rest on their own interview lines about deductibles. The panel skews female (126 of 200) and older (3 clones aged 18 to 29), and men took the $100 offer more often than women (35 of 73 against 31 of 126), so the $100 figure depends on the panel's make-up more than the location of the tipping point does.
Section 09: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Aged 45-64 | 98 |
| Aged 30-44 | 57 |
| Aged 65 or over | 42 |
| Aged 18-29 | 3 |
Question wording as fielded
- Do you currently have a car insurance policy, either in your own name or shared with someone in your household? (screener; 527 of 625 qualified, 200 sampled)
- In general, when you choose car insurance, which matters more to you: a low premium (what you pay each month or year) or a low deductible (what you pay yourself on a claim before the insurer pays)?
- Imagine your car insurance has a $500 deductible. Your insurer offers to raise it to a $1,000 deductible and cut your premium by $100 a year (about $8 a month), with nothing else changing. Would you take the $1,000 deductible?
- Imagine your car insurance has a $500 deductible. Your insurer offers to raise it to a $1,000 deductible and cut your premium by $250 a year (about $21 a month), with nothing else changing. Would you take the $1,000 deductible?
- Imagine your car insurance has a $500 deductible. Your insurer offers to raise it to a $1,000 deductible and cut your premium by $400 a year (about $33 a month), with nothing else changing. Would you take the $1,000 deductible?
- What is the biggest reason you would keep a $500 car insurance deductible rather than move to a $1,000 deductible for a lower premium?
What was not asked, and why
No insurer was named. No question asked for the clone's current deductible or claims history, about home or health insurance deductibles, or about paying a deductible in instalments. Only one move was offered, from $500 to $1,000, at three savings shown in rising order after the general preference question. Ask Brox added no questions of its own.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question asks whether people prefer a high or a low deductible, and stops at a share. This study puts a price on the trade: three written offers of $100, $250 and $400 a year off to double a $500 deductible, then the main reason to keep the lower one, so the page can say where the switch happens and what holds the rest back.
Fielded through Ask Brox on 10 November 2026.
More on Premiums, renewals and price sensitivity · Pricing and price sensitivity · The say-do gap · Insurance · Insurance (US) panel
Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai
Related insights
All in this topic-
Health plan pharmacy benefits: 56.5% of members judge them on the price per prescription, and 73.5% would give up their local pharmacy for mail delivery to save $5 a month
56.5% 56.5% of health plan members (113 of 200) say what they pay at the pharmacy for each prescription is the part of their drug coverage that matters most, 41.0% (82) say whether their medicines are covered at all, and 1.5% (3) say using the pharmacy they want near home. (base 200)
Read -
Car insurance data: 38% would switch insurer at the same price over secretly bought driving data, yet 60% would let an app track them for 30% off
38% 38.0% (76 of 200) would switch to another insurer even at the same price if they learned their car insurer had bought records of their driving from their car's maker without asking and used them to set their premium; 28.5% would renew but opt out of all data sharing, 16.0% would get quotes but probably stay and 17.5% would renew as normal. (base 200)
Read -
Electric car insurance: at $1,300 a year more only 5.5% of US EV considerers still choose the EV, and a $700 gap halves even the keenest buyers
5.5% With the electric car and a comparable gas car at the same purchase price, 32.5% of US buyers open to an electric car would still choose it at $300 a year more to insure, 15.0% at $700 more and 5.5% at $1,300 more. (base 200)
Read -
Human insurance agents: 61.5% of customers would pay $5 a month more to keep one, only 35.5% would pay $15
61.5% 61.5% would choose the policy with a human agent at $5 a month more, falling to 35.5% at $15 and 18.5% at $30. (base 200)
Read