85.2% of UK home insurance policyholders shopped or switched at their last renewal, and shown £50 cheaper elsewhere 63% would ask their insurer to match before leaving
85.2% of UK home insurance policyholders checked prices elsewhere or switched at their last renewal and 14.8% let it renew unchecked, and shown the same cover £50 cheaper 63% would ask their insurer to match the price before switching (n=54, September 2026).
- Who was asked
- UK home insurance policyholders, 54 clones, GB
- When
- September 2026 (fielded 19 September 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- The obvious question is whether people shop around at renewal. This study separated what the customer did at the last renewal from why they stayed, and put two concrete renewals in front of them, a flat one with £50 cheaper available and a claim-free rise of £40, so that shopping could be read against the two things a customer can actually do with a cheaper quote: leave, or use it to ask the incumbent to match.
Section 01: What the panel said
- #
85.2%
85.2% of UK home insurance policyholders checked prices elsewhere or switched at their last renewal: 64.8% say they switched to a different insurer, 16.7% checked and stayed at the renewal price and 3.7% checked and got their insurer to lower its price, while 14.8% let the policy renew automatically without checking
base 54
- #
63%
Shown the same cover £50 cheaper elsewhere at a flat £320 renewal, 63% would ask their current insurer to match the price and switch only if it refused, 24.1% would switch outright and 13% would stay at £320
base 54
- #
66.7%
A £40 rise on a claim-free £320 renewal sends 66.7% to check prices elsewhere while probably staying if nothing is much cheaper and 14.8% to call their insurer and challenge it; 11.1% would pay the new price without checking and 7.4% say they would switch outright
base 54 · contrast
- #
15
Of the 27 policyholders who gave a reason for staying at their last renewal, 15 said the renewal price seemed fair, 6 that switching was too much hassle for the money they would save, 5 that they trust their insurer to pay a claim and did not want to risk a new one, and 1 forgot or ran out of time
base 27 · Policyholders who gave a reason for staying with their insurer at their last renewal · contrast
85.2% of UK home insurance policyholders checked prices elsewhere or switched at their last renewal: 64.8% say they switched to a different insurer, 16.7% checked and stayed at the renewal price and 3.7% checked and got their insurer to lower its price, while 14.8% let the policy renew automatically without checking
02How many UK policyholders shopped around at their last home insurance renewal?
Most of them, on this panel. Of the 54 clones in the Brox GB panel who pay for home insurance in their own name, 46 (85.2%) either checked prices elsewhere or switched at their last renewal, and 8 (14.8%) let the policy renew automatically without checking. Asked what they actually did, 35 (64.8%) say they switched to a different insurer, 9 (16.7%) checked prices and stayed at the renewal price, and 2 (3.7%) checked, got their insurer to lower its price and stayed. No policyholder said they could not remember.
The split holds in both cover segments: 35 of the 39 with buildings and contents cover shopped (28 of them switched, 4 auto-renewed), and 11 of the 15 with contents cover only (7 switched, 4 auto-renewed). Take the switching figure with care. When the same 54 were asked why they stayed, 10 of the 35 who had just said they switched gave a reason for staying, so the share who actually left sits somewhere between 25 and 35 of 54. The share who shopped does not move.
03What stops the ones who stay?
A price that felt fair, more than inertia. Of the 27 policyholders who gave a reason for staying, 15 said the renewal price seemed fair, 6 said switching felt like too much hassle for the money they would save, 5 said they trust their insurer to pay a claim and did not want to risk a new one, and 1 forgot or ran out of time before the renewal date.
The two kinds of stayer give different reasons. Of the 11 who checked prices and stayed, 8 said the price was fair and 2 cited trust. Of the 8 who let the policy renew unchecked, 3 cited hassle, 2 a fair price, 1 trust and 1 forgetting, and 1 said they had switched. Those are counts on small groups, and they point one way: the classic renewal inertia, a policy that rolls over because nobody looked, describes 8 policyholders in 54 here.
04What does a £50 cheaper quote do at a flat renewal?
It starts a negotiation, not an exit. Shown a renewal at £320, the same as last year, and the same cover at £270 from an insurer they had heard of but never used, 63.0% (34 of 54) would ask their current insurer to match the price and switch only if it refused. 24.1% (13 of 54) would switch straight to the cheaper insurer, and 13.0% (7 of 54) would stay at £320.
Match-first is the most common answer in every cut of the policyholders: 53.8% (21 of 39) of those with buildings and contents cover, 13 of the 15 with contents only, 65.6% (21 of 32) of the women and 11 of the 20 men. It is also the answer of the people who say they switched last time: 62.9% (22 of 35) would give the incumbent the chance to match, 34.3% (12 of 35) would leave outright and 1 would stay. Of the 8 who auto-renewed, 4 would stay at £320 even with £50 on the table.
The 112 clones in the panel who do not pay for home insurance answered the same scenario the other way round: 67.9% (76 of 112) would switch outright and 25.0% (28 of 112) would ask for a match. Holding a policy is what turns a cheaper quote into a bargaining chip, which is why every figure on this page is cut to the 54 who hold one.
05And a £40 rise on a claim-free renewal?
It sends people to look, and most expect to come back. Shown a renewal at £360, up £40 from £320 with no claim and nothing about the home changed, 66.7% (36 of 54) would check prices elsewhere but probably stay if nothing was much cheaper, 14.8% (8 of 54) would call their insurer to ask it to explain or reduce the increase and stay if it did, 11.1% (6 of 54) would pay the new price without checking, and 7.4% (4 of 54) say they would switch to another insurer. Among the 35 who say they switched last time, 27 would check and probably stay, 4 would call and 4 would switch. Among the 8 who auto-renewed, 5 would pay the £40 without checking.
Asked how likely they are to compare prices before their next renewal on a 0 to 10 scale, 92.6% (50 of 54) scored 8 or more and 61.1% (33 of 54) said certain; 30 of the 35 who say they switched last time chose 10, and 4 of the 8 who auto-renewed scored 8 or more, the other 4 between 0 and 3. That is a stated intention with nothing attached to it, and it reads as direction: the people who shopped last time expect to shop again, and half the people who did not still do not.
06What would a brand manager do with this?
- Our reading: on a panel where 46 of 54 policyholders shopped at renewal, the retention lever is the match. 63.0% would ask before leaving (n=54), so a renewal team that can say yes to a £50 match in one call keeps most of the customers a comparison site would otherwise take.
- Our reading: a claim-free £40 rise costs little in outright exits, 7.4% (n=54), but sends two in three to check prices and 14.8% to the phone, so the cost of the rise is handling that traffic rather than losing the customer; 11.1% pay without looking, and 5 of the 8 auto-renewers are in that group.
- Our reading: the reasons stayers give, a fair price for 15 of 27 and hassle for 6, say that on this panel the case for staying is made by the renewal price itself, not by the difficulty of leaving; a renewal notice that shows why the price is fair does more than a process that makes switching harder.
Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“Because my approach to money is very much based on strict budgeting, a 50 pounds saving is quite significant to me. Every penny I spend is kind of budgeted for. When dealing with services, the first thing I do is check if there is an alternative product that gives me the same benefits. Since the price comparison website shows the exact same cover, I would be very inclined to take it. However, I also know that you can ask for a discount or other incentives on certain items. So, my approach would be to reach out to my current insurer first and ask them to match that 270 pounds offer. If they refuse to match it, I would have no choice but to switch to the competing alternative to keep strictly to my budget.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“So the first thing I would do is to check if there is an alternative product that gives me the same benefits as that product. And if it does, I might switch.”
“I switched to a different insurer. Increasing prices is my biggest no-no, and since I'm not currently working so I can raise my children, making sure the basic bills are paid first is my top priority. If a company tries to raise my rates at renewal, I'll definitely check elsewhere and cancel to go with someone cheaper.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“If a subscriber increased their prices I would probably cancel a subscription.”
“I think I'd have to say switching just felt like too much hassle for the money I'd save. My daily routine is so full—waking up, getting the three kids ready, working, then running them to their clubs and activities before dinner and bed. I don't really have the time to sit and compare everything. Plus, I'm absolutely terrible with money and need to be much more disciplined anyway. Usually, if something I regularly use goes up in price, I'm not happy about it, but I still probably continue to use it just because it's easier than finding an alternative.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“If I needed it or it was like a regular or I knew that nothing else worked better or whatever, I'd still probably continue to use it, despite the price increase.”
Section 08: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- The direction of the renewal split on the 54 policyholders: 46 of 54 checked prices or switched, 8 let the policy auto-renew, no policyholder said they could not remember, and it holds in both cover segments (buildings and contents 35 of 39, contents only 11 of 15).
- Match-first as the most common response to a £50 cheaper quote: 63% of policyholders (n=54), 53.8% of the 39 with buildings and contents cover, 13 of 15 with contents only, 65.6% of the 32 women, 11 of 20 men, and 62.9% of the 35 who say they switched last time.
- That a £40 rise on a claim-free renewal prompts a check rather than an exit: 66.7% would check and probably stay against 7.4% who would switch outright (n=54), and that order holds in every segment of 30 or more.
- That a fair renewal price, not hassle, is the reason stayers give most: 15 of the 27 who gave a reason, against 6 for hassle.
What we would not
- 64.8% (35 of 54) as the share who actually switched insurer at their last renewal: 10 of those 35 then gave a reason for staying when asked why they stayed, so the switching figure sits somewhere between 25 and 35 of 54, and the FCA's own evaluation puts UK home insurance switching at renewal well below the shopping rate.
- Any percentage here as a figure for the UK market: the 54 policyholders skew to 30 to 44 (38 of 54) and to women (32 of 54), with 7 under 30 and 7 aged 45 or over, and a handful of clones moves any figure on this page by several points.
- The near-unanimous 92.6% scoring 8 or more out of 10 on comparing prices before the next renewal (50 of 54): it is a stated intention with nothing attached, 30 of the 35 who say they switched last time scored 10, and it reads as direction only.
- Anything about the 8 who let the policy auto-renew (5 of 8 would pay a £40 rise without checking, 3 of 8 cite hassle) beyond direction.
- The two scenario answers as behaviour: the cheaper insurer in the £50 scenario is one the customer has heard of but never used, and the £40 scenario names no competing price, both of which favour the incumbent.
The main limitation
The screener excluded nobody: all 166 clones in the Brox UK general population panel answered every question, and 112 of them said they do not pay for home insurance in their own name, so every figure on this page is cut to the 54 who do (39 buildings and contents, 15 contents only). Those 54 skew to 30 to 44 and to women, the panel is not representative of UK home insurance policyholders, who skew older, and the study measures recalled and stated behaviour, not observed renewals.
Section 09: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Buildings and contents insurance | 39 |
| Contents insurance only | 15 |
Question wording as fielded
- Do you currently pay for a home insurance policy, meaning buildings insurance, contents insurance or both, in your own name?
- The last time your home insurance came up for renewal, what did you actually do?
- What is the main reason you stayed with your home insurer at your last renewal rather than switching?
- Your home insurance renewal arrives at 320 pounds a year, the same price as last year, and you have made no claim. A price comparison website shows the same cover from an insurer you have heard of but never used at 270 pounds a year, which saves you 50 pounds. What would you do?
- Your home insurance renewal arrives at 360 pounds a year, up 40 pounds from the 320 pounds you paid last year, and you have made no claim and nothing about your home has changed. What would you do?
- On a scale from 0 to 10, how likely are you to compare prices from other insurers before your next home insurance renewal, where 0 means not at all likely and 10 means certain?
What was not asked, and why
Nothing here is a switching rate for the UK market. The 112 clones who do not pay for home insurance answered the price scenarios as price-takers, 67.9% of them saying they would switch outright at £50 cheaper against 24.1% of policyholders, which is why the data table on this page is cut to the 54 policyholders and only the screener is shown on all 166. The study did not ask how the last renewal price compared with the year before, whether the policy was bought through a comparison site or direct, what saving the customer found when they checked, or whether the customer knew that UK insurers may no longer charge renewing customers more than new ones. No insurer or comparison site was named in any question, and Ask Brox added no questions of its own.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question is whether people shop around at renewal. This study separated what the customer did at the last renewal from why they stayed, and put two concrete renewals in front of them, a flat one with £50 cheaper available and a claim-free rise of £40, so that shopping could be read against the two things a customer can actually do with a cheaper quote: leave, or use it to ask the incumbent to match.
Fielded through Ask Brox on 19 September 2026.
More on Premiums, renewals and price sensitivity · Insurance · G.B. nat. rep. (GB) panel
Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai
Related insights
All in this topic-
Health plan pharmacy benefits: 56.5% of members judge them on the price per prescription, and 73.5% would give up their local pharmacy for mail delivery to save $5 a month
56.5% 56.5% of health plan members (113 of 200) say what they pay at the pharmacy for each prescription is the part of their drug coverage that matters most, 41.0% (82) say whether their medicines are covered at all, and 1.5% (3) say using the pharmacy they want near home. (base 200)
Read -
Higher deductible for a lower premium: 33% of drivers take a $1,000 car insurance deductible for $100 a year off, 74% for $250, and cash on the day holds the rest back
74% 33.0% (66 of 200) would move from a $500 to a $1,000 car insurance deductible for $100 a year off their premium, 74.0% (148) for $250 a year and 90.0% (180) for $400. The biggest step is between $100 and $250, where 82 clones say yes for the first time. (base 200)
Read -
Car insurance data: 38% would switch insurer at the same price over secretly bought driving data, yet 60% would let an app track them for 30% off
38% 38.0% (76 of 200) would switch to another insurer even at the same price if they learned their car insurer had bought records of their driving from their car's maker without asking and used them to set their premium; 28.5% would renew but opt out of all data sharing, 16.0% would get quotes but probably stay and 17.5% would renew as normal. (base 200)
Read -
Electric car insurance: at $1,300 a year more only 5.5% of US EV considerers still choose the EV, and a $700 gap halves even the keenest buyers
5.5% With the electric car and a comparable gas car at the same purchase price, 32.5% of US buyers open to an electric car would still choose it at $300 a year more to insure, 15.0% at $700 more and 5.5% at $1,300 more. (base 200)
Read