Topic hub
Store loyalty programmes and memberships
Which loyalty schemes and paid memberships shoppers actually use, and whether they change where people shop.
What did the panels say about store loyalty programmes and memberships?
- #
62.6%
62.6% (82 of 131) would be unlikely, at 1 to 3 on a 7-point scale, to keep their main online retailer as their first place to shop if it charged $6.99 on orders under $50, against 1.5% (2 of 131) if it ended a 2% rewards program and kept free delivery. — Free delivery, not rewards, keeps online shoppers loyal: a $6.99 fee leaves 62.6% unlikely to keep their main store first
base 131
- #
13%
Only 13.0% (18 of 138) would keep their main weekly shop at their usual supermarket when a rival the same distance away, with a similar range, offers free-card holders a 5% member saving (£4 on an £80 shop); 2.2% (3) stay at a 10% saving (£8) and 1.4% (2) at 20% (£16). No clone that moved at a smaller saving stayed at a larger one, and nobody chose to split the shop. With everything else held equal these are directions, not switching rates. — Supermarket loyalty cards: only 13.0% of British main shoppers would stay put against a rival's 5% member saving, yet none choose a store for its card
base 138
- #
93.5%
93.5% (187 of 200) would join a chain store's free loyalty program at the till for a member price 5% below the regular price, though joining means giving an email address and phone number and having purchases recorded; 98.5% would join at 15% and 99.5% at 30%. The shares are near-unanimous at every gap, so read them as direction. — Member-only prices: 93.5% of US shoppers would join at the till for a 5% member discount, but only 19.5% call two-tier pricing very fair
base 200
- #
80.1%
80.1% would most likely move their online spending to a rival if their usual retailer got an order wrong and customer service did not fix it, ahead of a rival that is consistently 10% cheaper (18.5%). — Online shoppers leave their usual retailer over an unfixed wrong order, not a cheaper rival: 80% pick it first
base 146
What has Brox published on store loyalty programmes and memberships?Newest first
-
Free delivery, not rewards, keeps online shoppers loyal: a $6.99 fee leaves 62.6% unlikely to keep their main store first
62.6% 62.6% (82 of 131) would be unlikely, at 1 to 3 on a 7-point scale, to keep their main online retailer as their first place to shop if it charged $6.99 on orders under $50, against 1.5% (2 of 131) if it ended a 2% rewards program and kept free delivery. (base 131)
Read -
Supermarket loyalty cards: only 13.0% of British main shoppers would stay put against a rival's 5% member saving, yet none choose a store for its card
13% Only 13.0% (18 of 138) would keep their main weekly shop at their usual supermarket when a rival the same distance away, with a similar range, offers free-card holders a 5% member saving (£4 on an £80 shop); 2.2% (3) stay at a 10% saving (£8) and 1.4% (2) at 20% (£16). No clone that moved at a smaller saving stayed at a larger one, and nobody chose to split the shop. With everything else held equal these are directions, not switching rates. (base 138)
Read -
Member-only prices: 93.5% of US shoppers would join at the till for a 5% member discount, but only 19.5% call two-tier pricing very fair
93.5% 93.5% (187 of 200) would join a chain store's free loyalty program at the till for a member price 5% below the regular price, though joining means giving an email address and phone number and having purchases recorded; 98.5% would join at 15% and 99.5% at 30%. The shares are near-unanimous at every gap, so read them as direction. (base 200)
Read -
Online shoppers leave their usual retailer over an unfixed wrong order, not a cheaper rival: 80% pick it first
80.1% 80.1% would most likely move their online spending to a rival if their usual retailer got an order wrong and customer service did not fix it, ahead of a rival that is consistently 10% cheaper (18.5%). (base 146)
Read
What do people ask about store loyalty programmes and memberships?
- What makes a shopper stay loyal to one retailer?
- Free delivery, not a rewards program, is what keeps US online shoppers loyal to their main retailer: 62.6% (82 of 131) would be unlikely to keep it as their first place to shop online if it charged $6.99 on orders under $50, against 1.5% (2 of 131) if it ended a 2% rewards program instead (n=131, November 2026).Read the insight
- Does a loyalty scheme change where people do their shopping?
- Yes, when the card carries a price: only 13.0% of British adults who do the main food shop would keep it at their usual supermarket if a rival the same distance away offered free-card holders 5% off, £4 on an £80 weekly shop, and 2.2% would stay at 10% (n=138, November 2026).Read the insight
- Do people mind loyalty-only prices that non-members cannot get?
- Most US shoppers do not mind member-only prices: 93.5% call them fair, but only 19.5% very fair, and 93.5% would join a store's free loyalty program at the till for a member price just 5% below the regular price, rising to 98.5% at 15% (n=200, October 2026).Read the insight
- What would make an online shopper leave their usual retailer for a rival?
- An order that goes wrong and is not put right is what would most likely make US online shoppers move their spending to a rival: 80.1% picked it over a 10% cheaper rival, free next-day delivery or free returns (n=146, September 2026).Read the insight
Other topics
How should you read these findings?
Where the numbers come from. Every figure on this site is a predicted response from Brox clones: behavioural replicas of real people, each built from a long-form interview with that person. The base under each figure is the number of clones behind it.
Where the real data comes from. The long-form video interviews with the real people the clones are built from. A quote is always shown with the interview line it was predicted from.
What you can take away. Insights publish their tabulation as CSV and JSON: question, option, count, percentage and base. Never per-person rows.
Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai