Topic hub

Store loyalty programmes and memberships

Which loyalty schemes and paid memberships shoppers actually use, and whether they change where people shop.

4 insights·0 studies

What did the panels say about store loyalty programmes and memberships?

  1. #

    62.6%

    62.6% (82 of 131) would be unlikely, at 1 to 3 on a 7-point scale, to keep their main online retailer as their first place to shop if it charged $6.99 on orders under $50, against 1.5% (2 of 131) if it ended a 2% rewards program and kept free delivery. — Free delivery, not rewards, keeps online shoppers loyal: a $6.99 fee leaves 62.6% unlikely to keep their main store first

    base 131

  2. #

    13%

    Only 13.0% (18 of 138) would keep their main weekly shop at their usual supermarket when a rival the same distance away, with a similar range, offers free-card holders a 5% member saving (£4 on an £80 shop); 2.2% (3) stay at a 10% saving (£8) and 1.4% (2) at 20% (£16). No clone that moved at a smaller saving stayed at a larger one, and nobody chose to split the shop. With everything else held equal these are directions, not switching rates. — Supermarket loyalty cards: only 13.0% of British main shoppers would stay put against a rival's 5% member saving, yet none choose a store for its card

    base 138

  3. #

    93.5%

    93.5% (187 of 200) would join a chain store's free loyalty program at the till for a member price 5% below the regular price, though joining means giving an email address and phone number and having purchases recorded; 98.5% would join at 15% and 99.5% at 30%. The shares are near-unanimous at every gap, so read them as direction. — Member-only prices: 93.5% of US shoppers would join at the till for a 5% member discount, but only 19.5% call two-tier pricing very fair

    base 200

  4. #

    80.1%

    80.1% would most likely move their online spending to a rival if their usual retailer got an order wrong and customer service did not fix it, ahead of a rival that is consistently 10% cheaper (18.5%). — Online shoppers leave their usual retailer over an unfixed wrong order, not a cheaper rival: 80% pick it first

    base 146

What has Brox published on store loyalty programmes and memberships?Newest first

What do people ask about store loyalty programmes and memberships?

What makes a shopper stay loyal to one retailer?
Free delivery, not a rewards program, is what keeps US online shoppers loyal to their main retailer: 62.6% (82 of 131) would be unlikely to keep it as their first place to shop online if it charged $6.99 on orders under $50, against 1.5% (2 of 131) if it ended a 2% rewards program instead (n=131, November 2026).Read the insight
Does a loyalty scheme change where people do their shopping?
Yes, when the card carries a price: only 13.0% of British adults who do the main food shop would keep it at their usual supermarket if a rival the same distance away offered free-card holders 5% off, £4 on an £80 weekly shop, and 2.2% would stay at 10% (n=138, November 2026).Read the insight
Do people mind loyalty-only prices that non-members cannot get?
Most US shoppers do not mind member-only prices: 93.5% call them fair, but only 19.5% very fair, and 93.5% would join a store's free loyalty program at the till for a member price just 5% below the regular price, rising to 98.5% at 15% (n=200, October 2026).Read the insight
What would make an online shopper leave their usual retailer for a rival?
An order that goes wrong and is not put right is what would most likely make US online shoppers move their spending to a rival: 80.1% picked it over a 10% cheaper rival, free next-day delivery or free returns (n=146, September 2026).Read the insight

Other topics

How should you read these findings?

Where the numbers come from. Every figure on this site is a predicted response from Brox clones: behavioural replicas of real people, each built from a long-form interview with that person. The base under each figure is the number of clones behind it.

Where the real data comes from. The long-form video interviews with the real people the clones are built from. A quote is always shown with the interview line it was predicted from.

What you can take away. Insights publish their tabulation as CSV and JSON: question, option, count, percentage and base. Never per-person rows.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai