Free delivery, not rewards, keeps online shoppers loyal: a $6.99 fee leaves 62.6% unlikely to keep their main store first

Free delivery, not a rewards program, is what keeps US online shoppers loyal to their main retailer: 62.6% (82 of 131) would be unlikely to keep it as their first place to shop online if it charged $6.99 on orders under $50, against 1.5% (2 of 131) if it ended a 2% rewards program instead (n=131, November 2026).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published
Who was asked
E-commerce, 131 clones, US
When
November 2026 (fielded 16 November 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question asks shoppers to rank what keeps them loyal. We asked that once, then asked the same 131 clones of US online shoppers who buy online at least monthly how likely they were to keep their main online retailer as their first stop after each of two changes: the end of a 2% rewards program, and a $6.99 delivery charge on orders under $50. Comparing the two changes on the same clones shows which perk carries the loyalty, rather than which one people say they like.

Section 01: What the panel said

  1. #

    62.6%

    62.6% (82 of 131) would be unlikely, at 1 to 3 on a 7-point scale, to keep their main online retailer as their first place to shop if it charged $6.99 on orders under $50, against 1.5% (2 of 131) if it ended a 2% rewards program and kept free delivery.

    base 131

  2. #

    3.8%

    3.8% (5 of 131) name rewards points or member perks as the main reason they keep buying from their main online retailer; 46.6% (61) name free, fast delivery and 36.6% (48) the lowest prices.

    base 131 · contrast

  3. #

    5.3%

    5.3% (7 of 131) would move most of their online spending to a rival if free delivery ended; 47.3% (62) would keep using the retailer but only place orders of $50 or more, and 43.5% (57) would compare prices and delivery every time.

    base 131 · contrast

  4. #

    96.2%

    96.2% (126 of 131) gave the top score for keeping their main online retailer first with free delivery and 2% rewards in place, so the starting point is a ceiling and the two changes are compared with each other, not with it.

    base 131 · caveat

62.6% (82 of 131) would be unlikely, at 1 to 3 on a 7-point scale, to keep their main online retailer as their first place to shop if it charged $6.99 on orders under $50, against 1.5% (2 of 131) if it ended a 2% rewards program and kept free delivery.

2% rewards program ends
1.5%
$6.99 charge on orders under $50
62.6%

Base 131 clones.

02Why does a delivery charge do more damage than losing rewards?

We asked the same 131 clones of US online shoppers about both changes, so the comparison is clone by clone. On a scale of 1 to 7, the average likelihood of keeping their main online retailer as the first place they shop was 6.96 with free delivery and 2% rewards in place, 6.31 when the rewards program ended, and 2.76 when a $6.99 charge on orders under $50 replaced free delivery. 96.9% (127 of 131) rated the delivery charge lower than the end of rewards, and 51.1% (67 of 131) stayed at 6 or 7 when rewards ended but fell to 3 or below once delivery was charged.

The interesting reading is that loyalty to an online retailer is bought with delivery, and rewards are a bonus on top. What the numbers support is narrower: these two changes are not the same size in dollars. A 2% reward is worth $1 on a $50 order, while the charge is $6.99, and the clones did that sum themselves, again and again calling the 2% "pennies".

03What do shoppers do instead of paying the charge?

Very few simply pay it, and very few leave outright. Asked what they would actually do if free delivery ended, 3.8% (5 of 131) would keep ordering as before and pay, and 5.3% (7 of 131) would move most of their online spending to a rival with free delivery. The rest change how they shop: 47.3% (62 of 131) would keep using the retailer but only place orders of $50 or more, and 43.5% (57 of 131) would compare prices and delivery every time and buy wherever is cheapest.

Holding back for a $50 order keeps the wallet but not the habit. Of the 62 clones who would do that, 27 still rated keeping the retailer first at 3 or below: they would go on using it, just not as the place they look first.

04Where does the answer change, and for whom?

The charge pushed a majority of every group of 30 or more clones to 3 or below, so this is not one segment's result. Income changes how hard it lands and what shoppers do next. Among clones with household income under $50,000, 74.2% (23 of 31) would be unlikely to keep the retailer first and 67.7% (21 of 31) would start comparing every time. Among those on $100,000 or more, 53.3% (24 of 45) would be unlikely to keep it first, and the most common response was to hold orders until they reach $50, chosen by 57.8% (26 of 45).

05What would an online retailer do with this?

  1. A reading, not the panel's answer: protect free delivery before rewards. If something has to give, a cut to a small rewards rate costs far less loyalty than a delivery charge on everyday orders.
  2. A reading: a free delivery threshold keeps much of the spending but invites comparison. Shoppers on lower incomes are the ones most likely to start checking rivals on every order.
  3. A reading: rewards are not worthless. When the 2% program ended, 48.9% (64 of 131) moved down at least one point, mostly from 7 to 6, so rewards buy the very top of loyalty rather than loyalty itself.

06What else do people ask about why shoppers stay loyal?

  1. What share of online shoppers stay with a retailer mainly for its rewards? 3.8% (5 of 131) of US online shoppers name rewards points or member perks as the main reason they keep buying from their main online retailer, against 46.6% who name free, fast delivery and 36.6% who name the lowest prices (n=131, November 2026).
  2. What share of shoppers would stop putting a retailer first over a delivery charge? 62.6% (82 of 131) of US online shoppers would be unlikely to keep their main online retailer as their first place to shop if it charged $6.99 on orders under $50 (n=131, November 2026).
  3. How many shoppers would move their spending to a rival if free delivery ended? 5.3% (7 of 131) would move most of their online spending to a rival with free delivery, while 47.3% would keep using the retailer with orders of $50 or more and 43.5% would compare prices every time (n=131, November 2026).

Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“I would say 1 - not at all likely. Charging $6.99 for shipping on orders under $50 is crazy, and getting 2% back doesn't make up for that at all. A major deal breaker for me with any company is when they start raising prices or changing things up to charge more money, especially when people already have bills to pay and things to take care of. Free shipping is one of the main reasons I love shopping online on sites like Amazon. If they're going to start being greedy and tacking on fees, I'd definitely look somewhere else to find the best deals and prices instead of making them my go-to store.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“What's the deal breaker for me is really them raising the price of their service. It's like, come on, man, y'all already a certain price. You just going to go up asking for more money, knowing people got other bills and things to pay for.”

Woman, 30-44, GA supports finding 1

“I would say a 7, extremely likely. Honestly, losing a 2% back rewards program isn't going to make me stop shopping there, especially if they still keep free standard delivery on every order. When I shop online, what matters most to me is the convenience and having a wide variety of items that I might not be able to find in local stores. As long as I can still find what I need and get free shipping, I'm definitely going to keep using them as my go-to place.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“At the top of my head right now, there's nothing a company could do that would make me stop being a customer. And I have never stopped being a customer of a specific company for any particular reason.”

Woman, 18-29, SC supports finding 2

“If they started charging a $6.99 delivery fee, I wouldn't just keep ordering like normal and pay that extra cost. For me, if something increases by more than $5, that's where I draw the line and start looking at other options. I try to be smart with my money and get good deals, so I would compare prices and delivery costs across different places each time I need to buy something and just go with wherever is cheapest.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Basically, I would still pay for it if it increased at least $5, but if it increased more than $5, I would probably stop using it. And change the product or service and try to see which would cost, what other service would cost less, and I would choose between that.”

Man, 18-29, CA supports finding 3

Section 08: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • For the same 131 clones, a $6.99 charge on orders under $50 did far more harm to loyalty than ending a 2% rewards program: 82 against 2 would be unlikely to keep the retailer first, and 127 of 131 rated the charge lower.
  • Rewards are rarely the main reason shoppers stay: 5 of 131 picked them, against 61 for free, fast delivery.
  • A delivery charge changes how shoppers buy more than where they buy: 7 of 131 would move most of their spending to a rival, while 119 would either hold orders to $50 or compare prices every time.

What we would not

  • That free delivery matters more than rewards at the same cash value: the two changes were not the same size in dollars (2% of a $50 order is $1, the charge is $6.99).
  • The starting level of loyalty: 126 of 131 gave the top score with both perks in place, which is a ceiling rather than a measurement.
  • Anything about shoppers under 30: 10 clones.
  • How many real shoppers would change retailer: these are predicted answers to changes that have not happened.

The main limitation

Every answer to the three scenario questions is a prediction inferred from what each person said in interview about delivery fees, price rises and switching, not their answer to this exact question, and the panel leans toward women (85 of 131) and people aged 45 and over (84 of 131).

Section 09: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Women85
Men46
Aged 18 to 2910
Aged 30 to 4437
Aged 45 to 6459
Aged 65 and over25

Question wording as fielded

  1. Do you buy something online at least once a month?
  2. Which ONE of these is the main reason you keep buying from the online retailer you use most often?
  3. Today, the online retailer you use most often gives you free standard delivery on every order and 2% back in rewards on everything you buy. On a scale of 1 to 7, where 1 is not at all likely and 7 is extremely likely, how likely are you to keep that retailer as the first place you shop online over the next 12 months?
  4. Imagine the online retailer you use most often ends its rewards program, so you no longer earn 2% back on what you buy, while free standard delivery on every order stays exactly as it is. On a scale of 1 to 7, where 1 is not at all likely and 7 is extremely likely, how likely are you to keep that retailer as the first place you shop online over the next 12 months?
  5. Imagine the online retailer you use most often keeps giving you 2% back in rewards on everything you buy, but ends free standard delivery and charges $6.99 delivery on every order under $50. On a scale of 1 to 7, where 1 is not at all likely and 7 is extremely likely, how likely are you to keep that retailer as the first place you shop online over the next 12 months?
  6. If the online retailer you use most often ended free standard delivery and charged $6.99 delivery on every order under $50, which is closest to what you would actually do?

What was not asked, and why

We did not test a rewards cut worth the same in dollars as the delivery charge, a larger rewards rate, a different charge or order threshold, or a paid delivery membership. We named no retailer and listed no brands. We did not ask what shoppers have done in the past.

What changed from the obvious question

The obvious question asks shoppers to rank what keeps them loyal. We asked that once, then asked the same 131 clones of US online shoppers who buy online at least monthly how likely they were to keep their main online retailer as their first stop after each of two changes: the end of a 2% rewards program, and a $6.99 delivery charge on orders under $50. Comparing the two changes on the same clones shows which perk carries the loyalty, rather than which one people say they like.

Fielded through Ask Brox on 16 November 2026.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai

Related insights

All in this topic