Research study
Story beats the shelf: 24.5% of US toy and fandom fans say character worlds drive their engagement, and most buy for someone else
Story and character worlds are the top driver of engagement for 24.5% of US toy and fandom fans, ahead of nostalgia at 20.5%, and at least 58.5% say they buy toys for their children or grandchildren rather than themselves (n=200, September 2026).
- Who was asked
- US toy and fandom fans, 200 clones, US
- When
- September 2026 (fielded 1 September 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- Rather than asking which toys adults collect for themselves, the study asked what drives engagement and whom it serves, which is how the caretaker pattern (buying for children and grandchildren) surfaced.
Section 01: What the study found
- #
24.5%
name story and character worlds as the main driver of their engagement with toy brands, the top answer
base 200
- #
58.5%
say, unprompted, that they buy toys for their children or grandchildren rather than for themselves (a floor, not an estimate)
base 200
- #
25.5%
tie their toy-brand engagement most closely to caregiving support, ahead of nostalgia at 17.0%
base 200 · contrast
- #
66.5%
named no toy brand at all when asked which they buy from, describing fandom media instead
base 200 · contrast
- #
96%
do not actively seek out fellow fans
base 200 · contrast
- #
48.5%
connect with fellow fans mostly through family and in-person friends, more than every social platform combined (41.5%)
base 200 · contrast
name story and character worlds as the main driver of their engagement with toy brands, the top answer
02Who are the people still buying the toys of their childhood?
They are younger and more female than the collector stereotype. Of the 200 qualified respondents, 64% are women and 90% are Gen Z or Millennial (44.0% are 18 to 29, 45.5% are 30 to 44). Almost half live in the South (49.2%, n=199), two thirds top out at a high school diploma (66.8%, n=199), and of the 156 whose employment status was recoverable, 29.5% work full time and 25.6% are unemployed.
They came from a screen of 305 self-identified toy, anime and gaming fans, 65.6% of whom qualified. The group reads less as a set of collectors and more as fandom caretakers: engagement runs on story and nostalgia, the purchase is usually for someone else, and the community stays quiet and close to home.
03Is this a toy audience or a fandom audience?
Mostly fandom. Asked which toy brands they actively engage with and buy from, 66.5% (n=200) named no toy brand at all and described watching, streaming or wearing fandom media instead. Among named answers, posters and merch (16.0%) and anime figures (15.5%) lead; Pokémon (3.0%), Funko Pop (2.5%) and Yu-Gi-Oh (1.0%) trail, and nobody named LEGO.
The split moves by group. Gen Z leans into posters and merch (20.2%, n=84), Millennials into anime figures (19.8%, n=96). Women divide evenly between anime figures and posters (18.0% each, n=128); men spread further, across Funko Pop (5.7%), Pokémon (4.3%), anime figures (11.4%) and posters (12.9%, n=70).
Where they do engage beyond buying, collecting and display is the one style with real traction: 30.6% of the 36 respondents for whom it applied said yes, against 8.6% for sharing with others (n=58) and 1.5% for social media (n=67).
04Who is the purchase actually for?
Usually somebody else. At least 58.5% (n=200) said, without being asked, that they do not really buy toys for themselves and that purchases go to their children or grandchildren. Caregiving support is also the single largest answer when respondents are asked which part of their wellbeing the hobby is tied to (25.5%, n=200), ahead of nostalgia (17.0%) and stress relief (10.0%).
Asked when they started buying toys again as adults, only 18.5% gave an age at all, and 16.0 of those points fall between 18 and 24. For most, there was no moment of coming back: the purchase is less a personal habit than an ongoing role.
05How do you reach a fan who is not looking for other fans?
Through the people already around them. 96.0% (n=200) say they do not actively seek out fellow fans. Where they do connect, family and relatives (30.5%) and in-person friends (18.0%) together account for 48.5%, more than every social platform combined (41.5%: a short-video platform 15.5%, Discord 12.0%, Facebook groups 8.5%, YouTube comments 4.0%, Reddit 1.5%). Conventions and events reach 4.0%.
06What would a brand do with this on Monday?
Three readings of the data, offered as readings rather than as the panel's answer:
- Sell the story, not the shelf. Story and character worlds (24.5%) and nostalgia (20.5%) together outweigh aesthetics, collecting and design combined (9.5%), so narrative messaging should beat collect-them-all framing.
- Design for the proxy buyer. With at least 58.5% buying for someone else, campaigns built only around treat-yourself nostalgia miss the majority use case.
- Lead with family and word of mouth. Family and in-person friends (48.5%) outrank all platforms (41.5%), so owned, earned and family-adjacent channels should come before paid social and community-building spend.
Section 07: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- Story and character worlds (24.5%) and nostalgia (20.5%) together outweigh aesthetics, collecting and design combined (9.5%), on the full base of 200.
- The fan community is family-led: 48.5% connect mainly through family and in-person friends against 41.5% for all platforms, and 96.0% do not seek other fans out (n=200).
What we would not
- Platform splits for toy or collecting content below a base of 30 (YouTube n=15, a short-video platform n=20; four other platforms at 7 or fewer).
- The social-behavior and adjacent-interest styles, whose bases run from 16 to 54 and whose higher-rate rows sit on 5 or fewer respondents.
- The 58.5% proxy-buying figure as a precise share: it counts respondents who said so unprompted, so the true share is at least that, and could be higher.
The main limitation
This is a screened sample of 200 self-identified toy, anime and gaming fans, skewed young, female and Southern, so its shares describe this audience rather than all US adults who buy toys.
Section 08: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Women | 128 |
| Men | 70 |
| Millennials | 96 |
| Gen Z | 84 |
| Gen X | 20 |
Question wording as fielded
- What mainly drives your engagement with toy brands as an adult?
- Which toy brands do you currently actively engage with and buy from?
- Which part of your lifestyle or personal wellbeing feels most connected to your toy-brand engagement?
- Do you actively seek out fellow fans?
- Where do you most often connect with fellow fans?
- At what age did you start buying toys again as an adult?
What was not asked, and why
Spend, purchase frequency and channel of purchase were not asked, so the study says who buys and why, not how much or where.
What changed from the obvious question
Rather than asking which toys adults collect for themselves, the study asked what drives engagement and whom it serves, which is how the caretaker pattern (buying for children and grandchildren) surfaced.
More on Pop culture · Streaming & entertainment
Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai
More in Streaming & entertainment
All in Streaming & entertainment-
Concert fans buy a live stream at $15, split at $30 and turn away at $45, half the price of a $90 ticket
53% 53.0% are likely to buy the stream at $30, a third of the ticket price, down from 85% at $15: the steepest fall on the ladder, with 63 of 200 clones dropping out at exactly that step. (base 200)
Read -
US adults back only the black McQueen dress for Margot Robbie: 44% find it appealing, and 89% dislike its cheap-looking material
44% 44% find the glossy black dress very or somewhat appealing, against 4% for the cream dress with red detailing and 10% for the multicolored embellished gown (base 200)
Read -
UK adults pick the black McQueen dress for Margot Robbie by 91% to 9%, and reject both embellished gowns as overdone
91% 91% would most want her to wear the glossy black dress, 9% the multi-coloured embellished gown and none the cream dress with red detailing (base 164)
Read