Research study

US adults back only the black McQueen dress for Margot Robbie: 44% find it appealing, and 89% dislike its cheap-looking material

44% of US adults find the glossy black dress appealing, against 4% and 10% for the two embellished looks, but 89% dislike its cheap-looking material and more call it unsuitable (47%) than suitable (39%) (base 200, November 2026).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published
Who was asked
US adults, 200 clones, US
When
November 2026 (fielded 13 November 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
We showed 200 US adults clones a photograph of each of three Alexander McQueen looks, a glossy black dress, a cream dress with red detailing and a multicolored embellished gown, and asked 8 questions: how appealing and how suitable each is for Margot Robbie at the premiere, what they like and dislike, the impression it gives of her, how memorable it is and whether they would engage with it on social media. Rather than ask which look is best, we asked each judgment of each look on its own.

Section 01: What the study found

  1. #

    44%

    44% find the glossy black dress very or somewhat appealing, against 4% for the cream dress with red detailing and 10% for the multicolored embellished gown

    base 200

  2. #

    89%

    89% name cheap-looking materials as what they dislike about the black dress, and 94% describe it as plastic, vinyl or latex

    base 200 · contrast

  3. #

    47%

    47% call the black dress unsuitable for the premiere, more than the 39% who call it suitable

    base 200 · caveat

  4. #

    73%

    73% of under-45s find the black dress appealing, against 19% of those 45 and over

    base 92 · Under 45 · contrast

  5. #

    97%

    97% name an overly busy design as what they dislike about the multicolored gown, as do 173 of 200 about the cream dress with red detailing

    base 200 · contrast

  6. #

    94%

    94% say overall appeal matters most when judging what she should wear, ahead of memorability, fit for the premiere or social media impact

    base 200

44% find the glossy black dress very or somewhat appealing, against 4% for the cream dress with red detailing and 10% for the multicolored embellished gown

Glossy black dress (base 200)
44%
Cream-and-red dress (base 200)
4%
Multicolored gown (base 200)
10%

Base 200 clones.

02Which look do US adults back for Margot Robbie?

Only the glossy black dress. It is very or somewhat appealing to 44% of US adults (n=200), against 4% for the cream dress with red detailing and 10% for the multicolored embellished gown. 94% (n=200) say overall appeal is what matters most when judging her red carpet look, so appeal is the measure that counts.

It is not a comfortable winner. More call it unsuitable for the premiere (47%) than suitable (39%), and 35% give it the strongest negative on the appeal scale (n=200).

03What holds the black dress back?

Its material. 89% of US adults (n=200) name cheap-looking materials as what they dislike about it, and 94% describe it as plastic, vinyl or latex in their answer; 82% use the word "cheap".

The same finish is what its fans like: they point to its details, mostly the gloss (40%), and to how confident and sexy it would make her look (33%). The black dress makes her come across as dark and mysterious to 99%.

04Who likes the black dress, and who does not?

Age divides it more than anything else. 73% of under-45s (n=92) find it appealing, against 19% of those 45 and over (n=108). It runs from 83% of 18 to 29s (n=41) to 3% of those 65 and over (n=40).

Men are warmer than women: 54% of men (n=95) find it appealing, against 35% of women (n=105).

05Why are the two embellished looks rejected?

They are too busy. 173 of 200 US adults name an overly busy design as what they dislike about the cream dress with red detailing, and 97% (n=200) say the same of the multicolored embellished gown. 78% and 56% give them the strongest negative on the appeal scale.

Both are memorable, and the cream dress reads as artistic and avant-garde to 99% (n=200), but memorable is not the same as wanted. At most 3% (n=200) would be at all likely to like, comment on or share photos of any of the three looks.

06How does the US compare with the UK and Japan?

The same order holds in all three markets, from three separate studies of the same looks. The black dress is very or somewhat appealing to 44% of US adults (n=200), 70% of UK adults (n=164) and 48% of adults in Japan (n=200); neither embellished gown reaches 17% anywhere.

What differs is the objection to the black dress. 82% of US adults (n=200) use the word "cheap" when saying what they dislike about it, against 1% in the UK and 0% in Japan. In the UK and Japan the objection is wearability: 99% (n=164) and 91% (n=200) say it looks uncomfortable and impractical, against 12% in the US.

The UK sample is younger than the other two (85% under 45, against 46% in the US and 51% in Japan), so the fairest comparison is among under-45s: the black dress is appealing to 73% of US under-45s (n=92), 74% in the UK (n=139) and 59% in Japan (n=101), and suitable to 60%, 88% and 96%.

Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“I'd say this is somewhat appealing. Honestly, it's got a really sleek, edgy vibe to it with the shiny black material and the fit. It kind of gives off an adventurous, Catwoman sort of look. I don't know if the plastic-y material is completely my thing or what everyone expects for a red carpet, but it's cool and Margot Robbie could definitely pull it off.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“playing video games, hanging out with my friend, wine tasting, going shopping, walking.”

Gen Z man, US adult, on the black dress supports finding 1

“To me, the material just looks like shiny plastic or a black garbage bag. Fashion nowadays has so much nonsense going on instead of just sticking to something classic, clean, and sharp. Margot Robbie is a gorgeous woman, and putting her in something that looks like crinkled vinyl or plastic wrap just doesn't look quality or high-end at all. It looks cheap and ridiculous.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“fashion, especially it's just like, Oh, it's nonsense. Wear something classic, sharp shirt, uh, nice pants, uh, shoes that are kept up as a guy. And, uh, that's it. That's all you need to wear. Um, none of this other nonsense”

Gen X man, US adult, on the black dress supports finding 2

“That looks terribly uncomfortable. It looks like stiff, tight plastic or patent leather wrapped so tightly around her that she can barely move or breathe. For me, clothing has to feel wearable and comfortable, and having something that stiff, hot, and constricting on a red carpet just seems completely impractical.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Well, it's just, it's all about comfort, especially in the wintertime.”

Baby Boomer woman, US adult, on the black dress supports finding 3

“I think this is just an overly busy design. There is way too much going on visually with all the detailed red embroidery and the long fringe hanging down off the sides. It looks chaotic and distracting rather than stylish. I usually prefer things that look clean and modern, and to me, this is just a little too shocking and way too much for a red-carpet event.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Just because it's clean, it's modern, it's easy to use.”

Millennial woman, US adult, on the cream dress with red detailing supports finding 5

“I really don't find this appealing at all. To me, it looks like a shredded, messy bundle of tinsel or wrapping paper that someone caught on fire. It's garish and bizarre rather than elegant or classy, and I can't imagine why someone would want to wear something that looks so torn up and chaotic on a red carpet. It's just not something I think looks good.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“It's very unappealing to me.”

Baby Boomer man, US adult, on the multicolored gown supports finding 5

“What I really like about this look for Margot Robbie would definitely have to be the colors. Looking at it, the colors are really what automatically appeal to me. I love how the bright, fiery red and gold and yellow blend together against the black. It has that really pretty multicolored look that makes it stand out and look really eye-catching.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I like the colors. I feel like the colors would, would automatically make me appeal to it. I feel like the colors would automatically appeal me to, to the advertising.”

Millennial woman, US adult, on the multicolored gown supports finding 5

Section 08: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • the black dress as the only look with real support (44% appealing, against 4% and 10%)
  • its material as the objection: 89% name cheap-looking materials as what they dislike
  • the age split on the black dress (73% of under-45s against 19% of those 45 and over)

What we would not

  • coded shares near 100% as unanimity: Ask Brox codes each open answer into one main theme, so a figure near 100% is the dominant theme, not every clone saying the same words
  • memorability and social media figures as a way to choose between looks: every look came back memorable and almost none shareable
  • the comparison with the UK and Japan as exact: each market's study was written and coded separately and the UK sample is younger

The main limitation

these are clones reacting to three photographs, not to the event, and the like, dislike and impression answers rest on Ask Brox's own coding of open answers

Section 09: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Under 4592
45 and over108

Question wording as fielded

  1. Which of these matters most to you when judging what Margot Robbie should wear on this red carpet: overall appeal, fit for the Untitled Ocean’s Prequel premiere, memorability, or social-media impact?
  2. Thinking about Margot Robbie wearing this Alexander McQueen look on the red carpet for the upcoming Untitled Ocean’s Prequel, how appealing do you find it? (Look 1, glossy black dress)
  3. Thinking about Margot Robbie wearing this Alexander McQueen look on the red carpet for the upcoming Untitled Ocean’s Prequel, how appealing do you find it? (Look 2, cream dress with red detailing)
  4. Thinking about Margot Robbie wearing this Alexander McQueen look on the red carpet for the upcoming Untitled Ocean’s Prequel, how appealing do you find it? (Look 3, multicolored embellished gown)
  5. How suitable does this Alexander McQueen look feel for Margot Robbie to wear at a red-carpet event for the upcoming Untitled Ocean’s Prequel? (Look 1, glossy black dress)
  6. How suitable does this Alexander McQueen look feel for Margot Robbie to wear at a red-carpet event for the upcoming Untitled Ocean’s Prequel? (Look 2, cream dress with red detailing)
  7. How suitable does this Alexander McQueen look feel for Margot Robbie to wear at a red-carpet event for the upcoming Untitled Ocean’s Prequel? (Look 3, multicolored embellished gown)
  8. What, if anything, do you dislike about this look for Margot Robbie? (Look 1, glossy black dress)
  9. What, if anything, do you dislike about this look for Margot Robbie? (Look 2, cream dress with red detailing)
  10. What, if anything, do you dislike about this look for Margot Robbie? (Look 3, multicolored embellished gown)
  11. What do you like about this look for Margot Robbie? (Look 1, glossy black dress)
  12. What do you like about this look for Margot Robbie? (Look 2, cream dress with red detailing)
  13. What do you like about this look for Margot Robbie? (Look 3, multicolored embellished gown)
  14. What impression would Margot Robbie give if she wore this Alexander McQueen look? (Look 1, glossy black dress)
  15. What impression would Margot Robbie give if she wore this Alexander McQueen look? (Look 2, cream dress with red detailing)
  16. What impression would Margot Robbie give if she wore this Alexander McQueen look? (Look 3, multicolored embellished gown)
  17. After seeing this look, how likely would you be to remember Margot Robbie in it later on? (Look 1, glossy black dress)
  18. After seeing this look, how likely would you be to remember Margot Robbie in it later on? (Look 2, cream dress with red detailing)
  19. After seeing this look, how likely would you be to remember Margot Robbie in it later on? (Look 3, multicolored embellished gown)
  20. If Margot Robbie wore this look on the red carpet, how likely would you be to like, comment on, or share photos of it on social media? (Look 1, glossy black dress)
  21. If Margot Robbie wore this look on the red carpet, how likely would you be to like, comment on, or share photos of it on social media? (Look 2, cream dress with red detailing)
  22. If Margot Robbie wore this look on the red carpet, how likely would you be to like, comment on, or share photos of it on social media? (Look 3, multicolored embellished gown)

What was not asked, and why

prior awareness of the looks or the film, and any price or brand question: every clone saw a photograph of each look and answered about Margot Robbie wearing it; age and gender come from each clone's own profile

What changed from the obvious question

We showed 200 US adults clones a photograph of each of three Alexander McQueen looks, a glossy black dress, a cream dress with red detailing and a multicolored embellished gown, and asked 8 questions: how appealing and how suitable each is for Margot Robbie at the premiere, what they like and dislike, the impression it gives of her, how memorable it is and whether they would engage with it on social media. Rather than ask which look is best, we asked each judgment of each look on its own.

Ask this of your own audience: humans@brox.ai

More in Streaming & entertainment

All in Streaming & entertainment