Research study
Taste picks the burger, price picks the place: 60% of US burger buyers choose on taste, 54.5% say high prices are their biggest frustration
60% of US adults who buy restaurant burgers say taste matters most when choosing one, while 54.5% name high prices as their biggest frustration and a lower price is the top reason to switch brands (n=200, October 2026).
- Who was asked
- US adults who eat or buy restaurant burgers, 200 clones, US
- When
- October 2026 (fielded 15 October 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- a screener asked whether respondents eat or buy burgers from restaurants (395 of 438 said yes) and 200 of those answered 21 questions; two brands were removed from this readout at the requester's instruction, their rows dropped from the select-all questions and, in the single-choice questions, respondents whose only answer was one of them taken out of the base (196 and 193); Ask Brox coded a few answers into its own groupings, shown as fielded
Section 01: What the study found
- #
60%
say taste is what matters most when choosing a burger, well ahead of price (37%) and the quality of the ingredients (15%); health (5%) and convenience (4%) barely register
base 200
- #
54.5%
say high prices are their biggest frustration with buying burgers, almost three times the next answer, poor food quality (20%)
base 200 · contrast
- #
67%
bought from McDonald's in the past three months, yet only 17.5% call it their first choice for burgers (n=200) and 47% name a first choice outside the listed chains
base 197 · contrast
- #
50.6%
of those with household incomes under $50K say price matters most, against 35.5% on $50K to $99K (n=62) and 19.3% on $100K or more (n=57), who are three times as likely to name ingredient quality (28.1% against 8.6%)
base 81 · Household income under $50K · contrast
- #
61.5%
find a build-your-own, customisable burger very appealing, the most strongly felt proposition tested, while 59% find plant-based burgers not appealing at all
base 200 · contrast
- #
47%
name a first-choice burger brand outside the listed options, mostly regional and sit-down restaurants, so the first-choice ranking covers only about half the panel
base 200 · caveat
say taste is what matters most when choosing a burger, well ahead of price (37%) and the quality of the ingredients (15%); health (5%) and convenience (4%) barely register
02What decides the burger, and what decides the place?
Taste decides the burger: 60% (n=200) say it matters most, ahead of price (37%) and ingredient quality (15%), and nobody picked sustainability. Price decides the place. 54.5% say high prices are their biggest frustration, a lower price is the strongest reason to leave a usual brand (29.5%) and lower prices top the list of improvements (30.5%).
Burgers are a quick, occasional meal bought at the drive-thru (29%) or the counter (24.5%), against 6% through a delivery app. 52.5% (n=200) say cost decides which channel they use.
03Does the most-bought brand own the loyalty?
No. McDonald's leads every behavioral measure: 67% bought from it in the past three months (n=197), 55.5% would consider it next time (n=200) and 40.3% would recommend it (n=196), roughly double Wendy's (21.9%) or Burger King (17.9%). Yet only 17.5% call it their first choice (n=200).
47% name a first choice outside the listed chains, mostly regional and sit-down restaurants, and 13.8% would recommend a sit-down chain for a burger (n=196). Innovation is credited to nobody: 69.5% chose 'other' when asked which burger brands feel most innovative, and in their own words most mean that none does.
04How does income split the market?
Into two kinds of buyer. Price matters most for 50.6% of those with household incomes under $50K (n=81) and 19.3% of those on $100K or more (n=57). High prices are the biggest frustration for 61.7% of the lower-income group and 36.8% of the higher, and among the better-off poor food quality (38.6%) is the bigger complaint.
The same split decides switching. 44.4% of those under $50K would switch for a lower price, against 10.5% on $100K or more, who would switch for higher quality instead (33.3%, against 8.6%). Premium burgers are very appealing to 35.1% of higher earners and 6.2% of lower. Because every clone answered every question, the pattern holds within the same people.
05Which burgers pull, and which push people away?
Control and familiar formats win. 61.5% (n=200) find a build-your-own burger very appealing, often for practical reasons such as allergies, picky children or a diet. Chicken burgers have the broadest appeal (94.5% very or somewhat) and smashed burgers follow (87.5%), a men's favorite at 50% very appealing against 21.7% of women (n=56 and n=143). Plant-based burgers are the outlier: 59% find them not appealing at all.
Trust is a quiet deal-breaker: 19% would switch over food safety or hygiene, rising to 32.9% of those under 45 (n=70). Sauces finish the burger but never choose the restaurant: 82.5% usually pick ketchup and 95% say sauces are not very or not at all important in where they buy.
06What would you do with this?
Two readings, offered as readings rather than as the panel's own answer. Win on taste first and value second: a burger that disappoints on taste is not rescued by a deal, but between two good burgers the cheaper one wins. And speak to income rather than age: the value-seeker hears a price, the trade-up buyer hears a better burger, and one message rarely reaches both.
Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“For me, what matters most when choosing a burger is simply the taste, it has to be good and flavorful. If I'm going out and spending money on a meal, I want to enjoy myself and get something that tastes delicious and satisfies me.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“So basically what's important is what we like. That's number one. And then, of course, what's in our area. So I don't go by cost or anything like that. It's just what we like.”
“Without a doubt, it's the sky-high prices. The cost of getting a burger these days has gotten absolutely ridiculous. You used to be able to get a burger, fries, and a drink for three, four, maybe five dollars. Nowadays, you're lucky if you can get out of there for under ten or twelve dollars.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“Well, I think escalating prices is just getting ridiculous. What used to be four or five dollars at McDonald's now is probably 15 or 16 dollars to get a Big Mac and fries and a drink is close to 20 bucks anymore.”
“I would definitely recommend McDonald's. That's pretty much my go-to 90% of the time. You know exactly what you're going to get because it's standard everywhere, and the fries keep me coming back.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I'm going to stick with McDonald's here. Loyalty, just for the fact that, yeah, I probably would pick it over, in a food court, I would pick it over anything else just because it's standard.”
“That is very appealing to me. We customize our orders all the time, taking off onions and pickles, adding extra mayonnaise, because my kids and I are both really picky eaters. Honestly, without the ability to customize our food, it's gross and we probably wouldn't even waste our money going out to eat.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“we definitely customize our orders a lot because about customization we know it's gross and we probably wouldn't waste our money going”
Section 08: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- taste first and price second as what decides a burger, and high prices as the main frustration
- McDonald's leading on behavior (bought, considered, recommended) but not on first choice
- the income split between value and quality, which runs the same way across choice drivers, frustrations, switching and premium appeal
- the appeal of customisation and chicken against the rejection of plant-based burgers, and the minor role of sauces
What we would not
- the first-choice, innovation and new-sauce rankings as complete: 47%, 69.5% and 89% answered outside the listed options, which reflects how the questions fitted rather than a hidden brand
- stated brand purchase as a stand-in for transaction data
- differences of under 10 points between groups of this size, and anything for under-30s on their own (10 clones)
- the brand shares as a full market picture: two brands were excluded from this readout at the requester's instruction
The main limitation
the panel leans female (71.5%) and older (65% aged 45 or over), and 15% of these screened burger buyers say they eat burgers rarely or never, so the screener admitted some occasional buyers
Section 09: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Women | 143 |
| Men | 56 |
| Aged under 45 | 70 |
| Aged 45 to 64 | 92 |
| Aged 65 and over | 38 |
| Household income under $50K | 81 |
| Household income $50K to $99K | 62 |
| Household income $100K or more | 57 |
Question wording as fielded
- (Screener) Do you eat or buy burgers from restaurants? (438 screened, 395 yes; 200 of them answered)
- How often do you eat burgers?
- Where do you usually buy them?
- What occasions are most associated with eating burgers?
- Which burger brands have you purchased from in the past three months? (select all; two brands excluded)
- Which burger brands would you consider for your next purchase? (select all; two brands excluded)
- Which brand is your first choice for burgers?
- Which burger brand would you recommend to others? (two brands excluded)
- Which brands offer the best value for money? (two brands excluded)
- What matters most when choosing a burger? (select all that apply)
- How appealing is each burger proposition? (share very or somewhat appealing)
- What are the biggest frustrations with buying burgers?
- What would make you switch from your usual burger brand?
- What should burger brands improve to better meet your needs?
- Which sauces do you usually choose with a burger? (select all)
- How important are sauces when choosing where to buy a burger?
What was not asked, and why
no demographic questions: age, gender, income and region come from each clone's own record; no prices or specific menu items were tested
What changed from the obvious question
a screener asked whether respondents eat or buy burgers from restaurants (395 of 438 said yes) and 200 of those answered 21 questions; two brands were removed from this readout at the requester's instruction, their rows dropped from the select-all questions and, in the single-choice questions, respondents whose only answer was one of them taken out of the base (196 and 193); Ask Brox coded a few answers into its own groupings, shown as fielded
More on Brand loyalty at the shelf · Consumer goods & grocery
Ask this of your own audience: humans@brox.ai
More in Consumer goods & grocery
All in Consumer goods & grocery-
Grocery name-brand loyalty rests on taste: 82.6% of US shoppers who stay with a brand for its taste would leave it over a recipe change, and 13.0% over a 15% price rise
34.5% 34.5% (69 of 200) say the one reason that most often keeps them buying a name brand over the cheaper store brand beside it is that it tastes or works better; 4.0% (8) say habit, 1.5% (3) doubt the store brand is as good and 1.0% (2) a household member who insists, while 59.0% (118) say nothing does, because they usually buy the store brand. (base 200)
Read -
Store brands need a 25% price gap, not 10%: 76.6% of US national-brand laundry detergent buyers would switch at 25% cheaper, but only 45.3% of coffee buyers
76.6% 76.6% (72 of 94) of US shoppers who buy a national brand of laundry detergent would switch to the store's own brand at a gap of 25% or less, against 5.3% (5) at 10%; at 25% cheaper it is 70.5% (55 of 78) for breakfast cereal, 67.4% (29 of 43) for paper towels and 45.3% (58 of 128) for ground coffee. (base 94)
Read -
Letting a shopper pick your produce: 65.3% of US online shoppers are not at all comfortable, and 48.6% say a no-questions refund would do most to change their minds
65.3% 65.3% (94 of 144) of US online shoppers are not at all comfortable letting a store's shopper choose their fresh fruit and vegetables, rating it 1 on a scale of 1 to 7; 20.8% (30) rate it 2 to 5 and 13.9% (20) rate it 6 or 7. (base 144)
Read