Store brands need a 25% price gap, not 10%: 76.6% of US national-brand laundry detergent buyers would switch at 25% cheaper, but only 45.3% of coffee buyers
A 25% price gap wins most US national-brand buyers over to the store brand and a 10% gap does not: at 25% cheaper, 76.6% would switch for laundry detergent (n=94), 70.5% for breakfast cereal (n=78) and 67.4% for paper towels (n=43), but only 45.3% for ground coffee (n=128), against 17.2% or fewer in any category at 10% cheaper (200 clones of US grocery shoppers, November 2026).
- Who was asked
- Groceries, 200 clones, US
- When
- November 2026 (fielded 13 November 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- Whether shoppers buy store brands already has a published answer in industry scanner data. We asked 200 clones of US grocery shoppers, for four everyday categories each priced in dollars, the smallest price gap that would get them to buy the store's own brand instead of the national brand they usually buy: 10%, 25% or 40% cheaper, or that they already buy it, or that they would not switch even at 40%. We also asked, first and in general, the main reason they pick a national brand. Study pattern: tipping point.
Section 01: What the panel said
- #
76.6%
76.6% (72 of 94) of US shoppers who buy a national brand of laundry detergent would switch to the store's own brand at a gap of 25% or less, against 5.3% (5) at 10%; at 25% cheaper it is 70.5% (55 of 78) for breakfast cereal, 67.4% (29 of 43) for paper towels and 45.3% (58 of 128) for ground coffee.
base 94
- #
53.1%
53.1% (68 of 128) of shoppers who buy a national brand of ground coffee would keep buying it even with the store brand 40% cheaper, against 30.2% (13 of 43) for paper towels, 25.6% (20 of 78) for breakfast cereal and 21.3% (20 of 94) for laundry detergent.
base 128 · Buy a national brand of ground coffee
- #
62%
62.0% (124 of 200) say the main reason they pick a national brand over the store's own brand is that it tastes or works better; 15.5% (31) say they trust its quality to be the same every time, and 8.0% (16) that the store brand is not much cheaper.
base 200
- #
3
3 of 200 at most, in any one category, named 40% cheaper as the gap that would get them to switch (2 for ground coffee, 3 for breakfast cereal, 2 for laundry detergent, 1 for paper towels): shoppers a 25% gap does not win, a 40% gap does not win either.
base 200 · contrast
76.6% (72 of 94) of US shoppers who buy a national brand of laundry detergent would switch to the store's own brand at a gap of 25% or less, against 5.3% (5) at 10%; at 25% cheaper it is 70.5% (55 of 78) for breakfast cereal, 67.4% (29 of 43) for paper towels and 45.3% (58 of 128) for ground coffee.
02Why does a 10% discount do so little?
Because a 10% gap reads as a dollar, and a dollar is not worth the risk of a worse product. We asked 200 clones of US grocery shoppers the smallest price gap that would get them to buy the store's own brand instead of the national brand they usually buy, in four categories, with every gap written out in dollars. At 10% cheaper, 17.2% (22 of 128) of national-brand coffee buyers would switch, and 5.3% (5 of 94) or fewer in laundry detergent, breakfast cereal and paper towels. At 25% cheaper the picture turns: 76.6% (72 of 94) for laundry detergent, 70.5% (55 of 78) for breakfast cereal, 67.4% (29 of 43) for paper towels and 45.3% (58 of 128) for ground coffee.
The clones explain it in money, not percentages: "saving just a dollar" is not enough to give up a brand they trust, while "$2.50 off" or "$3.50 a bottle" is. The interesting reading is that the switching point sits somewhere above 10% and at or below 25%, and that past 25% almost nobody is left to win. What the numbers support is narrower: we offered 10%, 25% and 40% only, so the exact point between 10% and 25% is not measured here.
03Why is coffee the category store brands find hardest?
Because coffee buyers talk about taste and their morning routine, not price. Of the 128 clones who buy a national brand of ground coffee, 53.1% (68) would keep buying it even with the store brand 40% cheaper, against 21.3% (20 of 94) for laundry detergent. This is also the best grounded answer in the study: 60 of those 68 answers rest on the person's own words about coffee.
So store-brand resistance is mostly about the category, not the shopper. Men and women answered coffee alike: 35 of 64 women and 33 of 64 men who buy a national brand would stay with it even at 40% cheaper.
04How many shoppers say they already buy the store brand?
Most, in three of the four categories. 78.5% (157 of 200) say they already buy the store's own brand of paper towels, 61.0% (122) of breakfast cereal, 53.0% (106) of laundry detergent and 36.0% (72) of ground coffee. Count those together with the shoppers a 25% gap would win, and the store brand reaches 93.0% (186 of 200) for paper towels, 89.0% (178) for laundry detergent, 88.5% (177) for breakfast cereal and 65.0% (130) for ground coffee.
Read these as how shoppers describe their own habits, not as market share. Industry figures reported in July 2026 put store brands at nearly a quarter of all US grocery units sold.
05What would a brand manager or retailer do with this?
- A reading, not the panel's answer: a store brand priced 10% under the national brand gives up margin without winning many buyers. In laundry detergent, breakfast cereal and paper towels, it won 5 of 94, 4 of 78 and 1 of 43 national-brand buyers.
- A reading: going deeper than 25% buys very little. The 40% gap drew 1 to 3 clones of 200 in each category, and 7 of the 67 laundry detergent buyers who chose 25% said a much steeper discount would make them doubt the product works.
- A reading: in coffee, price is the wrong lever for a store brand. The holdouts give taste and routine as their reasons, so a store brand would need a sampling or quality story before a deeper discount.
06What do people also ask about store-brand price gaps?
- What share of national-brand buyers would switch to a store brand at 10% cheaper? 17.2% (22 of 128) for ground coffee, and 5.3% (5 of 94) or fewer for laundry detergent, breakfast cereal and paper towels, among US grocery shoppers in November 2026.
- How much cheaper does a store brand need to be to win national-brand buyers? At 25% cheaper, 67.4% to 76.6% of national-brand buyers of paper towels, breakfast cereal and laundry detergent would switch, and 45.3% (58 of 128) for ground coffee.
- How many coffee buyers would keep a national brand even at 40% off the store brand? 53.1% (68 of 128) of US shoppers who buy a national brand of ground coffee would keep buying it with the store brand 40% cheaper.
Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“I would say at about 25% cheaper, so around $10.50, I'd definitely be willing to give the store brand a shot. I generally stick to trusted national brands for household essentials because I know they work and I don't mind spending a little extra for proven quality. A 10% discount isn't quite enough to make me switch away from something I know works for my family, but saving several dollars per bottle at 25% off provides enough of an incentive to try it and see if it performs just as well.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“The reason I would stay consistent in choosing a certain brand and product over another would be it's a trusted brand. It's something I know works for my family and I.”
“To be honest, I would keep buying the national brand even at 40% cheaper. Coffee is one of the specific items where I really care about quality and don't mind paying more. It's an essential part of my morning routine every single day, so I prefer to stick with the beans and brands I genuinely enjoy rather than settling for a store brand just to save a few dollars.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“Definitely, meat, coffee, and cleaning products are where I don't mind paying more for quality.”
“When I choose a name brand over a store brand or generic, it really comes down to the fact that it tastes better and has higher quality. Some people claim that generics and regular name brands are made in the exact same place and they just slap a different label on them, but I don't believe that at all. I have tasted them, and you can definitely tell the difference. A national brand usually has finer, more premium ingredients, and it simply tastes much better.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“That's why I try to get... a better brand because it tastes better. And it probably has more... finer premium ingredients in it.”
Section 08: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- The cliff between 10% and 25%: in every category a 10% gap won 17.2% (22 of 128) or fewer of national-brand buyers and a 25% gap won 45.3% to 76.6%; the clones explain it in dollars (a dollar off is not worth the risk, $2.50 to $3.50 off is).
- Coffee as the hardest category: 53.1% (68 of 128) of national-brand coffee buyers stay even at 40% cheaper, and 60 of those 68 answers rest on the person's own words about coffee.
- Taste or performance as the main reason to pick a national brand: 62.0% (124 of 200), against 8.0% (16) who say the store brand is not much cheaper.
What we would not
- The exact switching point: we offered 10%, 25% and 40% only, so it lies above 10% and at or below 25%, and could be 15% or 20%.
- The levels for breakfast cereal, laundry detergent and paper towels as category facts: those answers rest mostly on what people said about store brands and prices in general (their own words on the category in 17 to 30 of 200), unlike coffee (130 of 200).
- The shares who say they already buy the store brand (78.5% for paper towels, 36.0% for coffee) as market share: they are self-described habits, and industry figures put store brands at nearly a quarter of US grocery units.
- Suspicion of very steep discounts as a finding: 7 of 67 laundry detergent buyers who chose 25% mentioned it.
- Anything by age or income: most cells of national-brand buyers are under 30.
The main limitation
Each answer is a prediction from what the person said in long-form interviews, not a statement about these exact price gaps: 16 of the 800 category answers rest on direct evidence, and most are inferred from what people said about store brands, prices and the category. Coffee is the best grounded (130 of 200 answers quote the person's own lines about coffee); cereal, laundry detergent and paper towels lean on general store-brand and price talk.
Section 09: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| All clones fielded (no screener) | 200 |
| Women | 110 |
| Men | 90 |
| Aged 18-29 | 29 |
| Aged 30-44 | 60 |
| Aged 45-64 | 70 |
| Aged 65 or over | 41 |
| Buy a national brand of ground coffee | 128 |
| Buy a national brand of breakfast cereal | 78 |
| Buy a national brand of laundry detergent | 94 |
| Buy a national brand of paper towels | 43 |
Question wording as fielded
- In general, when you pick a national brand over the store’s own brand at the grocery store, what is the main reason?
- Think of the national brand of ground coffee you usually buy at the grocery store, at about $10.00. What is the smallest price gap that would get you to buy the store’s own brand of ground coffee instead, in the same size?
- Think of the national brand of breakfast cereal you usually buy at the grocery store, at about $5.00. What is the smallest price gap that would get you to buy the store’s own brand of breakfast cereal instead, in the same size?
- Think of the national brand of laundry detergent you usually buy at the grocery store, at about $14.00. What is the smallest price gap that would get you to buy the store’s own brand of laundry detergent instead, in the same size?
- Think of the national brand of paper towels you usually buy at the grocery store, at about $12.00. What is the smallest price gap that would get you to buy the store’s own brand of paper towels instead, in the same size?
What was not asked, and why
No retailer, store brand or national brand was named, and Ask Brox added no brands or questions of its own: it fielded the five questions as written. We did not test gaps between 10% and 25%, quality claims, packaging or shelf position, and asked about four categories only: ground coffee, breakfast cereal, laundry detergent and paper towels.
What changed from the obvious question
Whether shoppers buy store brands already has a published answer in industry scanner data. We asked 200 clones of US grocery shoppers, for four everyday categories each priced in dollars, the smallest price gap that would get them to buy the store's own brand instead of the national brand they usually buy: 10%, 25% or 40% cheaper, or that they already buy it, or that they would not switch even at 40%. We also asked, first and in general, the main reason they pick a national brand. Study pattern: tipping point.
Fielded through Ask Brox on 13 November 2026.
More on Private label versus brands · Consumer goods & grocery · Groceries (US) panel
Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai