Research study

Right order, wrong volume: six panels of 200 US adults ranked Verity, Other Mommy, and Digger in box office order, but 93% would see none of them in a theater

42, 32 and 6 of 200 US adults rated the premises of Verity, Other Mommy and Digger very appealing, the same order as their $32.0M, $27.8M and $8.0M US opening weekends, though 93% would see none of the three in a theater (six studies of n=200, October 2026).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
US adults, 200 clones, US
When
October 2026 (fielded 15 October 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
rather than asking which film people would see, each study carried the same description of all three films and asked six angles (awareness, premise appeal, reasons, talent, intent, head-to-head), then every per-film measure was compared with each film's share of the combined opening weekend

Section 01: What the study found

  1. #

    42

    people rated Verity's premise very appealing, against 32 for Other Mommy and 6 for Digger, the same order as their US opening weekends ($32.0M, $27.8M, $8.0M); 6 of 12 per-film measures put the films in box office order

    base 200

  2. #

    52%

    of the 80 'very appealing' premise ratings went to Verity, against its 47% share of the three films' combined opening; Other Mommy took 40% (41% of the money) and Digger 8% (12%), an average gap of 4 points

    base 80

  3. #

    93%

    say they would see none of the three in a theater and 47% never go to the movies, so the panel ranks the films well but badly understates how many tickets they sell

    base 200 · caveat

  4. #

    56%

    say Tom Cruise draws them moderately or more, yet 15% would see Digger because of him; dark comedy or satire is enjoyed by 7%

    base 200 · contrast

  5. #

    30

    of the 41 people who would choose Verity are women, close to the 78% female opening-weekend audience reported in the trades

    base 41 · Would choose Verity · contrast

  6. #

    56%

    rate Other Mommy's premise not at all appealing against 16% very appealing, the most divided of the three, while its title alone was the most intriguing (75 of 162)

    base 200 · contrast

people rated Verity's premise very appealing, against 32 for Other Mommy and 6 for Digger, the same order as their US opening weekends ($32.0M, $27.8M, $8.0M); 6 of 12 per-film measures put the films in box office order

Verity
42
Other Mommy
32
Digger
6

Base 200 clones.

02Did a survey of the general public call the box office?

On the order, yes. Six Ask Brox studies of 200 US adults each were shown the same description of three R-rated October releases: Digger (2 October), Verity (2 October) and Other Mommy (9 October). Verity opened to $32.0M, Other Mommy to $27.8M and Digger to $8.0M. Six of the twelve per-film measures put them in that order, including every question about probable viewing, choosing one film or recommending it.

The six that did not were prior awareness (only Verity was known, through the book), three measures of broad interest that all put Digger ahead of Other Mommy, the title on its own (which Other Mommy led) and theater versus waiting, a four-all tie at the top. With three films there is no correlation test to run: any one measure has a one-in-six chance of getting the order right by luck.

03Which measure tracked each film's share of the money?

Intensity, not interest. Of the three films' combined opening, Verity took 47%, Other Mommy 41% and Digger 12%. Of the 80 premise ratings of 'very appealing', the split was 52%, 40% and 8%, an average gap of 4 points. Genre taste alone came within about 1.4 points: psychological thriller 25%, horror 20%, dark comedy or satire 7% (n=200).

Moderate-or-better appeal flattered Digger (34% of those ratings) and the one-film choice overstated Verity (79% of choosers, against 47% of the money). The panel got Other Mommy's size wrong in one direction, because horror's young, frequent moviegoers are thin in a panel where 47% never go.

04Why did Digger fail when its star did not?

Because of the genre. Tom Cruise is the strongest talent draw in the study (56% say he draws them moderately or more, n=200, and nobody said his dramatic turn was a poor fit), yet only 15% would see Digger because of him. Dark comedy or satire is enjoyed by 7%, and 64% say a satire about real-world catastrophe is not something they usually enjoy. The director's name meant nothing to 95%, and 68% avoid premium-format upcharges.

05Did the panel find the right audience for each film?

Broadly, yes. Verity won on the thriller premise and with women: 47% pick its psychological, blurred-reality angle as the most interesting element and 3 of 200 the author connection; 30 of the 41 who would choose it are women, close to the 78% female opening audience reported in the trades. Other Mommy was a young, polarising horror title sold by its name: 21 of its 32 very-appealing ratings came from under-45s, and 56% found it not at all appealing, which fits a number-one opening followed by a D+ CinemaScore and a 54% Monday drop.

Digger had no constituency at all: 2 of 200 would choose it, too few to profile. Chooser counts are under 50 people, so they are reported as counts rather than percentages.

Section 06: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“If I had to pick just one of these to see, I would definitely go with Verity. I love movies, and when it comes to what I like watching most, I love me a good thriller.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“when it comes to my favorite genres when it comes to movies i love me a good thriller or romantic comedy”

Millennial woman, 30 to 44, choosing Verity supports finding 5

“I would choose Verity. I really enjoy reading books in my spare time, so seeing a movie adaptation of such a popular book would interest me the most out of these options.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I enjoy reading books and doing sports and swimming.”

Gen Z woman, 18 to 29, choosing Verity supports finding 5

“I would definitely choose Other Mommy. I am a huge horror fan and I love weird, indie, and arthouse movies. A title like Other Mommy immediately catches my attention because it sounds like a creepy, psychological, and unsettling horror movie.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I love weird, weird movies. I love indie movies, arthouse movies. A24, I'm a huge horror fan.”

Gen X woman, 45 to 64, choosing Other Mommy supports finding 6

“If I were to go see Digger, the single biggest reason would definitely be Tom Cruise. I've always enjoyed his movies over the years, and he's just such a recognizable and reliable actor who usually puts on a good show.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I'm adventuresome, and I like discovering new activities. So pretty much everything appeals to me if people are having a good time.”

Baby Boomer woman, 65 and over, on why she would see Digger supports finding 4

“To be completely honest, I'm just not going out to movie theaters these days. When it comes to watching stuff, I'm pretty content at home, sitting on the couch, catching a game, or relaxing after work.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Hollywood, even though it's a dying industry, right?”

Gen X man, 45 to 64, on why not in a theater supports finding 3

“Generally speaking, dark comedies and political or environmental satire are just not my thing. When I sit down to watch a movie or streaming television in the evening, I want something that helps me unwind and get my mind off of other things.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“And that tends to help me unwind and just get my mind. Off of other things.”

Baby Boomer man, 65 and over, on dark satire supports finding 4

Section 07: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • the ranking: Verity, then Other Mommy, then Digger, on every measure of probable viewing, choosing and recommending
  • the gap in enthusiasm between Verity and Digger, and intensity ('very appealing') tracking share of the money within a few points
  • the genre explanation for Digger's weak result, despite its star
  • the gender skew of Verity's support

What we would not

  • the absolute intent figures as a theatrical forecast: 47% of the panel never go to the movies and 3 of 200 go monthly or more, and clones tend to under-report their own behavior
  • any statistical correlation: with three films this is a check of order and proportion, and a single measure has a one-in-six chance of the right order by luck
  • chooser breakdowns by gender and age as percentages: those bases are under 50 people
  • any pairing of answers across the six studies: each drew its own 200 (648 distinct clones), so nothing is joined person by person

The main limitation

the panel is a general US audience that is light on moviegoing, not a sample of ticket buyers, so it under-counts the frequent young moviegoers who drive horror openings and cannot size the theatrical audience

Section 08: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Six studies of 200 each (648 distinct clones, 7 in all six)200
Women (study 1)104
Aged under 45 (study 1)94

Question wording as fielded

  1. Study 1: How often do you see movies in a theater?
  2. Study 1: Which genres do you typically enjoy? (up to three)
  3. Study 2: How appealing is the premise of Digger to you personally?
  4. Study 2: How appealing is the premise of Verity to you personally?
  5. Study 2: How appealing is the premise of Other Mommy to you personally?
  6. Study 3: Single biggest reason you would want to see Digger
  7. Study 4: In general, how much does word of mouth draw you to a film?
  8. Study 4: How much does Tom Cruise draw your interest?
  9. Study 5: How likely are you to see Verity in any format?
  10. Study 5: How many of the three would you see in a theater?
  11. Study 6: If you could only see one, which would you choose?
  12. Study 6: Which would you most likely recommend to a friend?
  13. Study 6: Which title, on its own, is most intriguing? (answered by 162)
  14. Study 6: What stops you going to the movies more often?

What was not asked, and why

the questionnaire's demographic questions were dropped as redundant: every age and gender cut uses each clone's own record; nothing was asked about ticket prices at specific chains or streaming services

What changed from the obvious question

rather than asking which film people would see, each study carried the same description of all three films and asked six angles (awareness, premise appeal, reasons, talent, intent, head-to-head), then every per-film measure was compared with each film's share of the combined opening weekend

Ask this of your own audience: humans@brox.ai

More in Streaming & entertainment

All in Streaming & entertainment