Research study

Plain talk, same pads: 67% of US period product users prefer franker period ads, but 60% say advertising does not influence what they buy, and absorbency, comfort, and price decide

67% of US period product users prefer franker, destigmatising period advertising, but 60% say a brand's advertising does not influence what they buy at all, and absorbency (99%), comfort (97%) and price (80%) lead their choice (n=200 per part, October 2026).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
US period product users, 200 clones, US
When
October 2026 (fielded 23 October 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
the 29-question study plan ran as two studies because one study fields at most 20 questions; 'None, I don't currently use period products' and 'Not applicable, I haven't switched' were added to routed questions, and the most-used product question was reworded to include past users; Ask Brox split the question on a memorable campaign into a yes or no and a follow-up answered hypothetically, and added six questions of its own to Part 2, five of which are used here and marked in the questions

Section 01: What the study found

  1. #

    67%

    of US period product users prefer the newer, more direct and destigmatising style of period advertising to the older, discreet one (22%), but 60% say a brand's advertising does not influence what they buy at all

    base 200

  2. #

    99%

    put absorbency or leak protection in their top three reasons for choosing a period product, with comfort (97%) and price (80%); brand trust (14%), ingredients (9%) and sustainability (2%) barely feature

    base 200 · contrast

  3. #

    52%

    are not willing at all to pay a premium for organic, non-toxic or sustainable period products and 4% are very willing; 81% have stayed with the same brand and product for two years

    base 200 · contrast

  4. #

    61%

    say period product advertising represents people like them not very well or not at all, from 38% (n=116) of under-45s to 93% (n=82) of those 45 or older, who say the ads are for younger women

    base 200 · contrast

  5. #

    79%

    of Black respondents say it is very important that period product advertising shows a diverse range of skin tones, against 16% (n=113) of white respondents

    base 58 · Black respondents · contrast

  6. #

    39%

    prefer traditional, gender-specific language to 'people who menstruate', 29% support the inclusive wording and 33% have no strong opinion; 70% say it would not change whether they consider a brand

    base 200 · contrast

of US period product users prefer the newer, more direct and destigmatising style of period advertising to the older, discreet one (22%), but 60% say a brand's advertising does not influence what they buy at all

Prefer the newer, more direct style
67%
Prefer realistic red to blue liquid
38%
Direct ads change nothing about their view of a brand
48%
Ads don't influence what they buy at all
60%

Base 200 clones.

02What decides which period product people buy?

Performance and price. Absorbency or leak protection (99%), comfort (97%) and price (80%) fill almost every top three (n=200), while brand trust (14%), ingredients or materials (9%) and sustainability (2%) barely feature. 52% (n=200) are not willing at all to pay a premium for organic, non-toxic or sustainable products and 4% are very willing.

Habit holds the rest. 81% (n=200) have stayed with the same brand and product for two years, and 26 of the 38 who switched brand did it for a lower price; none switched product type. Pads dominate the panel (92% use them most in Part 1, 88% in Part 2), far more than the US market would suggest.

03Which brands do they know, and do they stay loyal?

The heritage brands. Picking from a list of brands they could name, all 200 chose Always, with Tampax (97%) and Kotex (94%) close behind; Diva Cup reached 3%, and Thinx and Rael none. The Honey Pot is the exception, named by 48% (n=66) of Black respondents and 1% (n=111) of white ones, while Playtex belongs to an older generation (85% (n=65) of those 45 or older, 37% (n=134) of under-45s).

Loyalty is habit rather than faith: 50% (n=200) are very loyal and 2% switch often, yet 75% trust brands only slightly or not at all to be open about what is in their products. They hear about new products from advertising (75%) and in-store displays (72%), and buy at the grocery (53%) or big-box store (44%); online purchase is rare and nobody buys by subscription.

04Do franker, destigmatising ads change anything?

They are welcome, and they rarely persuade. 67% (n=200) prefer the newer, more direct and destigmatising style to the older, discreet one (22%), and more prefer realistic red liquid (38%) than traditional blue (21%), though 42% have no preference. Asked what that style does to their view of a brand, 48% say nothing changes.

Attention is low. Nobody in either part pays a great deal of attention to period product ads, 40% of Part 1 (n=200) pay none, only 1 of 200 could name a campaign that stood out, and 60% (n=200) say a brand's advertising does not influence what they buy at all. What would win their consideration is credibility: real, unscripted testimonials (79%) and ingredient facts (78%), not celebrities (4%) or bold campaigns (3%). Misleading claims are the first thing that makes them distrust an ad (46%).

05Who feels represented by period advertising?

Younger users, more than older ones. 61% (n=200) say the ads represent people like them not very well or not at all, but that is 93% (n=82) of those 45 or older against 38% (n=116) of under-45s; older users say the ads speak to teenagers and younger women still menstruating, and 64 of the 69 past users say so.

Black respondents put far more weight on skin tone: 79% (n=58) call a diverse range of skin tones very important against 16% (n=113) of white respondents, and 64% (n=58) say race and ethnicity is the representation that matters most to them, where white respondents choose authentic realism (81% (n=113)). Black respondents are also far more likely to name a brand whose ads come close (43% (n=58), mostly Always).

06How do they feel about 'people who menstruate'?

Divided, and mostly unmoved. 39% (n=200) prefer traditional, gender-specific language, 29% support the inclusive wording and 33% have no strong opinion; traditional language is preferred by 54% (n=82) of those 45 or older and 28% (n=116) of under-45s. 70% say it would not change whether they consider a brand, 17% would be less likely and 13% more likely.

Asked in their own words what brands should do differently, the largest group wants lower prices (33%), then franker, more realistic ads (29%), then politics kept out of advertising (19%); 25 of the 38 in that last group named the 'people who menstruate' wording itself.

07What would you do with this?

Two readings, offered as readings rather than as the panel's own answer. The franker style is safe ground with this audience but not a reason to buy, so the message that moves product is still performance, proof and price, best carried by real users and plain ingredient facts. And the gaps are in who feels seen: older users, who no longer recognize themselves in the category, and Black respondents, who put far more weight on a range of skin tones.

Section 08: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“I would say not at all. When it comes to products like that, I stick to my established habits and go-to items that I know and trust. I really do not pay attention to advertising or marketing messaging; what matters to me is the reliability and function of the product itself, not whatever campaign a brand is running.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“There's really not much that sticks with me about online store advertising because I kind of have my go-tos and I don't pay much attention to most of the advertising.”

White Baby Boomer woman, 65 or older, US, Part 2, on whether ads influence what she buys supports finding 1

“Honestly, I strongly prefer realistic depictions. Nobody bleeds blue liquid. As someone who is pretty completely unfiltered and doesn't care to sugarcoat things, the old blue liquid thing always felt ridiculous and unnecessary. It's a natural biological process, so why act like it's some taboo secret? Just show it like it is.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“for the majority of it, I don't filter at all. I don't care”

White Millennial woman, 30 to 44, US, Part 2, on blue liquid or red supports finding 1

“To be honest, I'm not willing at all. I really hate things that are overly expensive, and money is already pretty tight for me, so having to pay extra or a premium for period products just doesn't make sense. I'd rather just get what works and not spend extra money that I don't have.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I hate things that are like overly expensive. I hate overly expensive things.”

Black Gen Z woman, 18 to 29, US, Part 1, on paying a premium supports finding 3

“Not at all. I am 61 years old and well past that chapter of my life, and period product advertising is almost entirely geared toward teenagers and younger women. Advertisers in that space focus on a much younger demographic, so you never see women of my age or in my stage of life represented in those campaigns. It simply does not represent people like me.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I am currently 61 years old.”

White Gen X woman, 45 to 64, US, Part 2, on whether ads represent her supports finding 4

“To me, that is very important. Representation matters deeply, especially when it comes to products that women use in everyday, vulnerable parts of life. Everyone deserves to see themselves reflected, respected, and included, rather than having just one standard or one type of person shown. When companies show a diverse range of skin tones, it shows they actually recognize the whole community and care about reaching everyone genuinely.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I believe that everybody is a puzzle piece to the whole bigger picture and for us to evolve to higher dimensions.”

Black Millennial woman, 18 to 29, US, Part 2, on skin tones in ads supports finding 5

“I would say I somewhat support it. For me, it comes down to treating everyone with kindness, fairness, and respect. If using more inclusive language helps people feel acknowledged and supported without causing harm, that makes sense and feels like a respectful approach.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“treating others with compassion and respect.”

Black Gen Z woman, 18 to 29, US, Part 2, on 'people who menstruate' supports finding 6

“Well, I would say I prefer the traditional language. To me, women are the ones who have periods, and that's just the natural way it's always been known. Hearing things like 'people who menstruate' just doesn't sound right to me, and it seems like too much hype or confusion when everyone already knows it's for women. So I strongly prefer sticking to the traditional way of saying it. Thank you.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“They got all the big old hype about them, but they not what they say they are.”

Black Baby Boomer woman, 65 or older, US, Part 2, on 'people who menstruate' supports finding 6

Section 09: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • performance and price decide the choice: absorbency, comfort and price lead, and ingredients, sustainability and a premium barely register
  • period advertising draws little attention and rarely moves a purchase, even though the franker, destigmatising style is preferred
  • credibility persuades more than celebrity: testimonials and ingredient facts lead, endorsements and bold campaigns trail
  • older users feel the ads are not for them, and Black respondents put far more weight on a range of skin tones
  • 'people who menstruate' divides opinion but rarely decides whether they consider a brand

What we would not

  • the product mix as the market: this clone panel holds far fewer tampon users than the US market, so pad and tampon shares describe the panel
  • brand recall as unprompted: it was picked from a list, so all 200 naming Always is prompted recognition
  • the all-respondent figures as the picture for all US users: Black respondents are about twice their US share (33% and 29%) and lean warmer on advertising and representation, which lifts some totals
  • age and current use as separate effects: almost all past users are 45 or older, so the two cannot be told apart
  • the switching reasons person by person: 11 who switched brands gave no reason and 11 who had not switched gave one, so reasons are read among the 38 switchers
  • any person-by-person link between the two parts: they are separate samples (106 clones in both) and no answer is joined across them

The main limitation

the clone panel is pad-heavy and holds far fewer tampon users than the US market, so product figures describe the panel; the attitudes to advertising and representation are the reliable part

Section 10: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Part 1: current or past period product users200
Part 2: current or past period product users200
Part 1: current users145
Part 1: past users55
Part 2: current users131
Part 2: past users69
Part 1: aged under 45134
Part 1: aged 45 or older65
Part 2: aged under 45116
Part 2: aged 45 or older82
Part 1: Black respondents66
Part 1: white respondents111
Part 2: Black respondents58
Part 2: white respondents113

Question wording as fielded

  1. Part 1. Do you currently use, or have you in the past used, period products such as pads or tampons? (screener: 599 of 894 qualified; 200 of them were fielded)
  2. Part 1. If you switched period product brands or product types in the past two years, what was the main reason for switching? (Select up to 2)
  3. Part 1. How much attention do you generally pay to period product advertising (TV, social media, print, etc.)?
  4. Part 1. What matters most to you when choosing a period product? (Select up to 3)
  5. Part 1. How willing are you to pay a premium for period products marketed as organic, non-toxic, or sustainably made?
  6. Part 1. Which best describes your household?
  7. Part 1. Where do you typically purchase period products? (Select all that apply) (recorded by Ask Brox as one answer per clone)
  8. Part 1. Which single product type do you use most often (or used most often, if you no longer use period products)?
  9. Part 1. Which period products do you currently use? (Select all that apply)
  10. Part 1. Looking back, how would you rate the quality of the education you received about periods and period products (through school, family, or elsewhere)?
  11. Part 1. How loyal are you to a specific brand of period products?
  12. Part 1. How do you typically learn about new period products or brands? (Select up to 2)
  13. Part 1. Which period product brands can you name, off the top of your head? (Select all that apply) (picked from a list, so prompted recall)
  14. Part 1. How much do you trust period product brands generally to be transparent about what's in their products?
  15. Part 1. Have you switched period product brands in the past two years?
  16. Part 2. Do you currently use, or have you in the past used, period products such as pads or tampons? (screener: 276 of 443 qualified; 200 of them were fielded)
  17. Part 2. For years, period product ads commonly used blue liquid in demonstrations rather than depicting blood realistically. More recently, several brands have shifted to showing red liquid instead. How do you feel about this shift?
  18. Part 2. When you think about period product advertising in general, which brand comes closest to representing people like you? (added by Ask Brox)
  19. Part 2. Which single product type do you use most often (or used most often, if you no longer use period products)?
  20. Part 2. How important is it to you that period product advertising represents a diverse range of skin tones?
  21. Part 2. In your own words, what would you want period product brands to do differently in how they advertise or talk about their products? (open-ended, coded by Ask Brox into its own groups)
  22. Part 2. Thinking about period product ads you have seen, what kind of representation matters most to you personally? (added by Ask Brox)
  23. Part 2. Which of these best describes how direct, destigmatizing advertising affects your perception of a period product brand? (added by Ask Brox)
  24. Part 2. Some brands have shifted toward inclusive language (such as "people who menstruate" rather than exclusively "women") to acknowledge that not everyone who has periods identifies as a woman, and not all women have periods. How do you feel about this kind of language?
  25. Part 2. Which of the following advertising approaches would make you more likely to consider a brand? (Select up to 3)
  26. Part 2. Do you think period product advertising today does a good job representing people like you specifically?
  27. Part 2. Which period product brands have you used, purchased, or seriously considered in the past 12 months? (added by Ask Brox; open answers coded, mostly as Other; not reported)
  28. Part 2. What stood out about it? (Ask Brox's follow-up to the campaign question; asked of all 200 though 1 knew a campaign, so answered hypothetically and not reported)
  29. Part 2. Which best describes your household?
  30. Part 2. How much does a brand's advertising or messaging (as opposed to the product itself) influence your purchasing decisions in this category?
  31. Part 2. What, if anything, makes you less likely to trust a period product ad? (added by Ask Brox)
  32. Part 2. If a period product brand used inclusive language like "people who menstruate," what effect would that have on your likelihood of considering that brand? (added by Ask Brox)
  33. Part 2. Are you aware of any specific period product advertising campaigns that stood out to you, positively or negatively? If so, which campaign, and what stood out about it?
  34. Part 2. How important is it to you that period product advertising represents a diverse range of body types?
  35. Part 2. How much attention do you generally pay to period product advertising (TV, social media, print, etc.)?
  36. Part 2. How do you feel about period product advertising becoming more direct and destigmatizing over the past decade (using plain language, showing real experiences, addressing period-related topics openly), compared to older, more euphemistic advertising styles?

What was not asked, and why

age, gender, race, income and region were not asked: they come from each clone's own profile; household, the product used most and attention to period advertising were asked in both parts

What changed from the obvious question

the 29-question study plan ran as two studies because one study fields at most 20 questions; 'None, I don't currently use period products' and 'Not applicable, I haven't switched' were added to routed questions, and the most-used product question was reworded to include past users; Ask Brox split the question on a memorable campaign into a yes or no and a follow-up answered hypothetically, and added six questions of its own to Part 2, five of which are used here and marked in the questions

Ask this of your own audience: humans@brox.ai

More in Consumer goods & grocery

All in Consumer goods & grocery