Research study
Paapa Essiedu as Severus Snape: 67.5% of US adults react neutrally to the casting, and 89% would simply ignore online criticism of it
67.5% of 200 US adults say their immediate reaction to Paapa Essiedu's casting as Severus Snape is neutral, 87.5% say it does not change their interest in the series, and 89% would ignore online criticism of it (n=200, October 2026).
- Who was asked
- US adults, 200 clones, US
- When
- October 2026 (fielded 1 October 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- Rather than a single 'do you approve' question, the study separated immediate reaction, its driver, what would move opinion and how the respondent would respond to online criticism, so that indifference could be told apart from approval and loud backlash from the typical response.
Section 01: What the study found
- #
67.5%
say their immediate reaction to the casting is neutral; 10.5% react positively and 3.5% negatively
base 200
- #
89%
would ignore online criticism of the casting rather than engage with it, agree with it or amplify it
base 200
- #
48%
say a trailer showing his performance would change their opinion a lot or some, against 9.5% for seeing him in costume
base 200 · contrast
- #
56%
say their reaction will depend on the footage they eventually see; only 33% expect no further change
base 200 · contrast
- #
92.5%
of Baby Boomers react neutrally, with no positive reaction recorded, against 22.2% positive among Gen Z (n=36)
base 53 · Baby Boomers · contrast
- #
6%
name anti-woke backlash as the main driver of their reaction, against 23% acting merit and 21.5% fidelity to the books
base 200 · caveat
say their immediate reaction to the casting is neutral; 10.5% react positively and 3.5% negatively
02Is this a backlash?
No. 67.5% of US adults (n=200) say their immediate reaction is neutral and a further 14% are waiting to see. Positive reactions (10.5%) outnumber negative ones (3.5%) three to one among the few who react at all. The casting is being met with a shrug, not a verdict.
Part of the reason is that the audience knows the franchise without loving it. 61.5% describe themselves as casually familiar with Harry Potter and only 6% call themselves fans (n=200).
03What would actually move opinion?
Substance, not presentation. 49% say hearing that the series preserves Snape's core traits would change their opinion a lot or some, and 48% say the same of a trailer showing his performance. Seeing him in costume moves 9.5%, and HBO explaining its artistic reasoning moves 4.5% (all n=200).
The drivers of reaction point the same way. Acting merit (23%) and fidelity to the books (21.5%) lead, well ahead of politically coded reasons such as anti-woke backlash (6%).
04Where does the answer change, and for whom?
By generation. Baby Boomers are almost entirely neutral (92.5%, n=53) with no positive reaction recorded, and 59.6% say they are not interested in the franchise at all. Positive sentiment rises with each younger generation, to 22.2% among Gen Z (n=36), while Gen X has the largest wait-and-see share (22.6%, n=53).
05What would you do with this on Monday?
- Do not read early social commentary as the audience's view. 89% say they would ignore online criticism of the casting, and 87.5% say the news has not changed their interest in the series (n=200).
- Lead with performance. 56% say their reaction depends on the footage they eventually see (n=200), so opinion is still being formed and the trailer is where it will be won.
- Plan by age, not as one audience. Younger viewers are both more familiar and warmer; older viewers are the least invested.
Section 06: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- the dominant posture is neutral or wait-and-see, not backlash: 81.5% neutral or waiting (n=200)
- performance footage and character fidelity move opinion far more than a costume photo or a studio statement (48% and 49% against 9.5% and 4.5%, n=200)
- interest in the series is essentially unmoved: 87.5% no change (n=200)
What we would not
- the exact generational percentages: the four generation bases are 36 to 57 clones and the two generation tables in the source report sum to 199, not 200
- the ranking of the small driver and concern codes (anything under 6%), and the large 'other' shares of 43.5% and 47.5%, which hide unclassified answers
The main limitation
Self-reported, predicted reaction to a single announcement from one US panel of 200; it measures stated sentiment, not what people will post, watch or share once footage exists.
Section 07: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Baby Boomers | 53 |
| Gen X | 53 |
| Millennials | 57 |
| Gen Z | 36 |
Question wording as fielded
- What is your immediate reaction to the news that Paapa Essiedu has been cast as Severus Snape in HBO's Harry Potter series?
- Which best describes your relationship with the Harry Potter franchise before this announcement?
- What is the main driver of your reaction to this casting news?
- What concerns, if any, do you have about this casting?
- How much would each of the following change your opinion of the casting (a lot, some, a little, not at all)? Hearing the series preserves Snape's core traits; watching a trailer with his performance; hearing positive reactions from trusted fans or critics; seeing him in costume as Snape; seeing HBO explain the artistic reasoning.
- What feels most important for the series to preserve about Snape?
- Has this casting news changed your interest in watching the series?
- How is your reaction likely to evolve between the announcement and the premiere?
- If you came across online criticism of this casting, how would you respond?
What was not asked, and why
Respondents were not shown any footage, stills or press material, were not asked about other cast members, and were not asked about the actor's earlier work.
What changed from the obvious question
Rather than a single 'do you approve' question, the study separated immediate reaction, its driver, what would move opinion and how the respondent would respond to online criticism, so that indifference could be told apart from approval and loud backlash from the typical response.
More on Casting and franchises · Streaming & entertainment
Ask this of your own audience: humans@brox.ai
More in Streaming & entertainment
All in Streaming & entertainment-
Concert fans buy a live stream at $15, split at $30 and turn away at $45, half the price of a $90 ticket
53% 53.0% are likely to buy the stream at $30, a third of the ticket price, down from 85% at $15: the steepest fall on the ladder, with 63 of 200 clones dropping out at exactly that step. (base 200)
Read -
US adults back only the black McQueen dress for Margot Robbie: 44% find it appealing, and 89% dislike its cheap-looking material
44% 44% find the glossy black dress very or somewhat appealing, against 4% for the cream dress with red detailing and 10% for the multicolored embellished gown (base 200)
Read -
UK adults pick the black McQueen dress for Margot Robbie by 91% to 9%, and reject both embellished gowns as overdone
91% 91% would most want her to wear the glossy black dress, 9% the multi-coloured embellished gown and none the cream dress with red detailing (base 164)
Read