Research study
Same favorite, different Bond: Idris Elba is the top choice in the US (49%) and the UK (42%), but Henry Cavill draws 43% of Americans against 17% of Britons
Idris Elba is the top choice for the next James Bond of 49% of US adults (n=200) and 42% of British adults (n=166), but Henry Cavill draws 43% in the US against 17% in Britain, and 58% of Britons want a British actor against 44% of Americans (October 2026).
- Who was asked
- US and British adults, 366 clones, US
- When
- October 2026 (fielded 21 October 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- the same 28-question brief ran as two studies in each country with identical questions and answer options; the optional open question about an actor not on either list did not run comparably (not fielded in the US, a yes or no in Britain) and is not compared; every headline gap was rechecked among under-45s because the British panel is young
Section 01: What the study found
- #
49%
of US adults pick Idris Elba as their top choice for the next James Bond, as do 42% (n=166) of British adults; Henry Cavill is a close second in the US (43%) and a distant one in Britain (17%)
base 200
- #
75%
of British adults know Aaron Taylor-Johnson against 11% (n=200) of US adults, and 43% have followed the casting news against 6%
base 166 · contrast
- #
58%
of British adults say it matters at least moderately that Bond is British, against 44% (n=200) of US adults, and 86% are open to a Bond of a different background against 65%
base 166 · contrast
- #
25%
of US adults want a lighter, more classic Bond, against 6% (n=166) of British adults; in Britain the gritty Craig style edges it (15%)
base 200 · contrast
- #
62%
of British adults will probably or definitely watch the next Bond film, against 48% (n=200) of US adults; men lead in both (83% and 66%)
base 166
- #
92%
of the British panel is under 45, against 46% of the US samples, so every gap above was rechecked among under-45s only, and every one holds
base 166 · caveat
of US adults pick Idris Elba as their top choice for the next James Bond, as do 42% (n=166) of British adults; Henry Cavill is a close second in the US (43%) and a distant one in Britain (17%)
02Do Americans and Britons want the same Bond?
They want the same actor first. Idris Elba is the top choice of 49% of US adults (n=200) and 42% of British adults (n=166). Beyond him the races part: Henry Cavill is an American pick (43% against 17%), while Britons spread their choices to Aaron Taylor-Johnson (12%) and Dev Patel (7%), and 26 of 166 pick a reported frontrunner against 2 of 200 Americans.
Recognition explains much of it. Britons know the shortlist: Taylor-Johnson is familiar to 75% of the British panel and 11% of the American, and 83% of Americans know none of the ten frontrunners against 22% of Britons. 43% of Britons have followed the casting news, against 6% of Americans.
03Where do the two countries part ways?
On identity and tone. A British actor matters at least moderately to 58% of Britons and 44% of Americans, yet Britons are also more open to a Bond of a different background (86% against 65%) and fewer want the role kept consistent with past Bonds (14% against 35%). Americans lean towards a lighter, classic Bond (25% against 6%) and are more divided on age and stardom: 26% oppose casting under 30 and 14% prefer an established star, against 5% and 1% of Britons.
They agree on more than they differ: acting ability comes before looks for 61% of Americans and 70% of Britons, interest in the Villeneuve and Knight direction is low in both (22% and 25%), and the casting is what will make or break the film for half or more (50% and 59%).
04Is the British panel just younger?
It is younger, but that does not explain the gaps. 92% of the British panel is under 45, against 46% of the US samples, so each headline gap was recomputed among under-45s alone, US first (US n=91 in Part 1 and 94 in Part 2, UK n=152): Henry Cavill as top choice, 44% against 18%; following the casting news, 7% against 43%; wanting a British actor, 41% against 57%; openness to a different background, 70% against 88%; wanting a lighter Bond, 15% against 5%; planning to watch, 44% against 62%. Every gap holds; the American lean to a lighter tone narrows the most.
05Who is the audience in each country?
Larger in Britain, and led by men in both. 62% of Britons (n=166) and 48% of Americans (n=200) will probably or definitely watch the next film. Men lead in both (54 of 65 British men, 63 of 96 American men), and women trail in both (43 of 89 and 32 of 104).
Section 06: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“Of all the actors mentioned to play the next James Bond, my personal top choice would be Henry Cavill. Honestly, I'm not familiar with most of the younger or newer actors on this list, but Henry Cavill is a familiar name and face. He has that classic, sharp look and the screen presence that fits a spy or mystery role like James Bond, so I think he would do a great job.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“Watching horror and mystery movies most of the time I spend.”
“I’d probably have to go with Aaron Taylor-Johnson. I’m a big fan of action films, and I think he’s got the right blend of grit, physicality, and charm to carry a modern Bond film. He's proven himself in quite a few action roles already and has the screen presence needed to step into that kind of iconic part without it feeling forced.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“And like I say, I do like action films and series that you can get quite hooked on to.”
“I think it's very important, basically essential to the character. James Bond is the quintessential British secret agent, so having him played by a British actor is just a fundamental part of the whole identity and brand. I'm generally quite brand loyal and I think once you get to know something and it works, you should stick with it. If you cast someone who isn't British, it just wouldn't feel authentic or right for 007.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I'm quite brand loyal and once I get to know something to probably stick with it”
“I'd go with lighter and more classic, similar to earlier Bond eras. My thing with remakes and reboots is, why change something that you're thinking about remaking? It obviously did something right to make you want to bring it back in the first place. Too often they try too hard to change the old, tried-and-true formula instead of sticking to what made it work. Just keep it classic.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“They found it too much to change the old, try the true show that they're even trying to base it on. Why change something that you're thinking about remaking? Thinking about remaking it, it obviously did something to make you want to remake it.”
“I'd go with gritty and grounded, like the Daniel Craig era. I prefer films that have a bit of grit, realistic action, and violence to them rather than something silly or lighthearted. A good, hard-hitting story is what makes an action movie work.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“probably Pulp Fiction because it's extremely violent has a good story to it and gives the perspectives stories of different characters at the same time throughout the film and how they all know each other it's a really good violent film”
Section 07: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- the same favorite in both countries, with Cavill an American pick
- British familiarity with the shortlist and attention to the search
- more weight on a British actor and more openness to a different background in Britain, and a lighter tone wanted in the US
- a larger British audience, led by men in both countries
What we would not
- gaps of a few points as real differences between the countries
- British figures for older adults: the British panel has only 3 clones aged 55 or older
- the exact familiarity figures, which can understate what people know
- Ask Brox's own added questions as comparable: they differed between the two countries and are not compared
The main limitation
the two panels have different shapes: two separate US samples of 200 spread across all ages, and one young British panel of 166 who answered both parts
Section 08: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| US adults, Part 1 | 200 |
| US adults, Part 2 | 200 |
| British adults, both parts (the same clones) | 166 |
| US under-45s, Part 1 | 91 |
| British under-45s | 152 |
Question wording as fielded
- US, Part 1. What is your age?
- US, Part 1. How would you describe your familiarity with the James Bond film franchise?
- US, Part 1. Have you seen the Daniel Craig-era Bond films (2006-2021)?
- US, Part 1. How interested are you in the James Bond franchise's future now that Daniel Craig has departed the role?
- US, Part 1. Before this survey, had you been following the news or speculation around who will play the next James Bond?
- US, Part 1. Were you aware that reports suggest the studio wants to cast a British actor under 30 as the next James Bond?
- US, Part 1. Were you aware that an actor has already been confirmed to voice a young James Bond in a separate audio drama, a different project from the upcoming James Bond film?
- US, Part 1. How interested would you personally be in each of the ten primary contenders playing James Bond, if cast? (one row per actor; shown here as the share familiar with each actor)
- US, Part 1. Beyond the primary contenders most often mentioned as frontrunners (Callum Turner, Jacob Elordi, Harris Dickinson, Aaron Taylor-Johnson, Jack Lowden, Louis Partridge, Tom Francis, Jack Barton, Jack O'Connell, Paul Mescal), a number of other names have also circulated in James Bond casting speculation. Which, if any, of the following secondary contenders would you be excited to see cast as Bond? (Select all that apply)
- US, Part 1. Of all 22 actors mentioned for the role, primary and secondary contenders combined, which would be your personal top choice to play the next James Bond? (Select one)
- US, Part 1. If your personal top choice to play the next James Bond is one of the secondary contenders (Theo James, Henry Cavill, Aaron Pierre, Damson Idris, James Norton, Richard Madden, Tom Holland, Regé-Jean Page, Jonathan Bailey, Dev Patel, Idris Elba, Taron Egerton) rather than one of the primary frontrunners, what makes that choice stand out to you? (open-ended, coded by Ask Brox; shown among those whose top choice is a secondary contender)
- US, Part 1. How closely does your enthusiasm for a potential James Bond actor depend on that specific person, versus just wanting to see the franchise continue regardless of who's cast?
- US, Part 2. What is your age?
- US, Part 2. How would you describe your familiarity with the James Bond film franchise?
- US, Part 2. How important is it to you that James Bond be played by a British actor specifically?
- US, Part 2. Do you support the reported direction of casting a younger actor (under 30) to reboot the James Bond role?
- US, Part 2. Would you rather see a relatively new or rising actor take the role of James Bond, or an established A-list star?
- US, Part 2. How important is an actor's physical resemblance to previous conceptions of James Bond (build, look) compared to their acting ability?
- US, Part 2. Would you be open to the role of James Bond being recast with an actor of a different background than previous Bonds (in terms of race, nationality, or other characteristics), or do you feel strongly the role should stay consistent with past casting?
- US, Part 2. Casting rumors about the next James Bond have generated significant public reaction, including both excitement and criticism of specific rumored candidates online. How do you feel about this kind of public discourse around a casting decision?
- US, Part 2. How much confidence do you have in the studio (which now controls the James Bond franchise's creative direction) to make a good casting choice?
- US, Part 2. How interested are you in the James Bond franchise's new creative direction more broadly (director Denis Villeneuve and writer Steven Knight) independent of who is cast as Bond?
- US, Part 2. Which tone would you most want the rebooted James Bond franchise to take?
- US, Part 2. Overall, how likely are you to watch the next James Bond film once it's released, regardless of who is ultimately cast?
- US, Part 2. In your own words, what would make or break the next James Bond for you? (open-ended, coded by Ask Brox)
- UK, Part 1. What is your age?
- UK, Part 1. How would you describe your familiarity with the James Bond film franchise?
- UK, Part 1. Have you seen the Daniel Craig-era Bond films (2006-2021)?
- UK, Part 1. How interested are you in the James Bond franchise's future now that Daniel Craig has departed the role?
- UK, Part 1. Before this survey, had you been following the news or speculation around who will play the next James Bond?
- UK, Part 1. Were you aware that reports suggest the studio wants to cast a British actor under 30 as the next James Bond?
- UK, Part 1. Were you aware that an actor has already been confirmed to voice a young James Bond in a separate audio drama, a different project from the upcoming James Bond film?
- UK, Part 1. How interested would you personally be in each of the ten primary contenders playing James Bond, if cast? (one row per actor; shown here as the share familiar with each actor)
- UK, Part 1. Beyond the primary contenders most often mentioned as frontrunners (Callum Turner, Jacob Elordi, Harris Dickinson, Aaron Taylor-Johnson, Jack Lowden, Louis Partridge, Tom Francis, Jack Barton, Jack O'Connell, Paul Mescal), a number of other names have also circulated in James Bond casting speculation. Which, if any, of the following secondary contenders would you be excited to see cast as Bond? (Select all that apply)
- UK, Part 1. Of all 22 actors mentioned for the role, primary and secondary contenders combined, which would be your personal top choice to play the next James Bond? (Select one)
- UK, Part 1. If your personal top choice to play the next James Bond is one of the secondary contenders (Theo James, Henry Cavill, Aaron Pierre, Damson Idris, James Norton, Richard Madden, Tom Holland, Regé-Jean Page, Jonathan Bailey, Dev Patel, Idris Elba, Taron Egerton) rather than one of the primary frontrunners, what makes that choice stand out to you? (open-ended, coded by Ask Brox; shown among those whose top choice is a secondary contender)
- UK, Part 1. How closely does your enthusiasm for a potential James Bond actor depend on that specific person, versus just wanting to see the franchise continue regardless of who's cast?
- UK, Part 2. What is your age?
- UK, Part 2. How would you describe your familiarity with the James Bond film franchise?
- UK, Part 2. How important is it to you that James Bond be played by a British actor specifically?
- UK, Part 2. Do you support the reported direction of casting a younger actor (under 30) to reboot the James Bond role?
- UK, Part 2. Would you rather see a relatively new or rising actor take the role of James Bond, or an established A-list star?
- UK, Part 2. How important is an actor's physical resemblance to previous conceptions of James Bond (build, look) compared to their acting ability?
- UK, Part 2. Would you be open to the role of James Bond being recast with an actor of a different background than previous Bonds (in terms of race, nationality, or other characteristics), or do you feel strongly the role should stay consistent with past casting?
- UK, Part 2. Casting rumors about the next James Bond have generated significant public reaction, including both excitement and criticism of specific rumored candidates online. How do you feel about this kind of public discourse around a casting decision?
- UK, Part 2. How much confidence do you have in the studio (which now controls the James Bond franchise's creative direction) to make a good casting choice?
- UK, Part 2. How interested are you in the James Bond franchise's new creative direction more broadly (director Denis Villeneuve and writer Steven Knight) independent of who is cast as Bond?
- UK, Part 2. Which tone would you most want the rebooted James Bond franchise to take?
- UK, Part 2. Overall, how likely are you to watch the next James Bond film once it's released, regardless of who is ultimately cast?
- UK, Part 2. In your own words, what would make or break the next James Bond for you? (open-ended, coded by Ask Brox)
What was not asked, and why
gender, income, region and nationality were not asked: they come from each clone's own record; age and familiarity with the franchise were asked in both parts in both countries
What changed from the obvious question
the same 28-question brief ran as two studies in each country with identical questions and answer options; the optional open question about an actor not on either list did not run comparably (not fielded in the US, a yes or no in Britain) and is not compared; every headline gap was rechecked among under-45s because the British panel is young
More on Casting and franchises · Streaming & entertainment
Ask this of your own audience: humans@brox.ai
More in Streaming & entertainment
All in Streaming & entertainment-
Concert fans buy a live stream at $15, split at $30 and turn away at $45, half the price of a $90 ticket
53% 53.0% are likely to buy the stream at $30, a third of the ticket price, down from 85% at $15: the steepest fall on the ladder, with 63 of 200 clones dropping out at exactly that step. (base 200)
Read -
US adults back only the black McQueen dress for Margot Robbie: 44% find it appealing, and 89% dislike its cheap-looking material
44% 44% find the glossy black dress very or somewhat appealing, against 4% for the cream dress with red detailing and 10% for the multicolored embellished gown (base 200)
Read -
UK adults pick the black McQueen dress for Margot Robbie by 91% to 9%, and reject both embellished gowns as overdone
91% 91% would most want her to wear the glossy black dress, 9% the multi-coloured embellished gown and none the cream dress with red detailing (base 164)
Read