Research study

84% of US adults say a book's length doesn't matter, yet 43% have abandoned a book more than once for being too long

84% of US adults say a book's length doesn't matter to them, yet 43% have abandoned a book more than once because it felt too long and 47.5% would try an unfamiliar author more readily if the book were shorter (n=200, October 2026).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
US adults, 200 clones, US
When
October 2026 (fielded 12 October 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
rather than only asking whether people prefer shorter books, which 84% answer with 'length doesn't matter', the study paired that stated preference with behavior: abandoning a book for length and trying a new author on a shorter book. Ask Brox fields at most 20 questions per study, so the questionnaire ran as two parts, with the books-per-year and length-preference questions repeated in Part 2 as anchors; the anchors land within a few points of each other except the under-200-pages option

Section 01: What the study found

  1. #

    43%

    have abandoned a book more than once because it felt too long, even though 84% say a book's length doesn't matter to them

    base 200 · Part 1

  2. #

    47.5%

    would be more likely to try an author they have never read if the book were shorter, rising to 64.3% of 18 to 29 year olds (n=42)

    base 200 · Part 1

  3. #

    54.8%

    of 18 to 29 year olds have abandoned a book more than once for length, against 24.4% of those 65 and over (n=41)

    base 42 · Aged 18 to 29, Part 1 · contrast

  4. #

    56.5%

    are at least moderately interested in novella-length quick reads or already read them, the only new format with majority interest

    base 200 · Part 2

  5. #

    77.1%

    of Gen Z find choose-your-own-adventure stories for adults at least moderately appealing, against 17.9% of Boomers and older (n=56)

    base 35 · Gen Z, Part 2 · contrast

  6. #

    46.5%

    say they prefer TV, films or games, the top barrier to reading more; only 4% say shorter reads would make them read more

    base 200 · Part 2

have abandoned a book more than once because it felt too long, even though 84% say a book's length doesn't matter to them

Abandoned a book for length more than once
43%
Say length doesn't matter to them
84%
More likely to try a new author if the book is shorter
47.5%
Say length factors in at all when starting a book
22.5%

Base 200 clones.

02If length does not matter, why do so many people put long books down?

Because indifference is what people say and impatience is what they do. 84% of US adults say a book's length doesn't matter to them, yet 43% have abandoned a book more than once because it felt too long, and 47.5% would be more likely to try an unfamiliar author if the book were shorter (all n=200, Part 1).

The contradiction sits inside the same people. Of the 168 who say length doesn't matter, 73 (43.5%) have abandoned a book more than once for being too long. Among those who read at least one book a year the abandonment rate is 49.3% (n=144), and women report it more than men (51.9%, n=104, against 33.3%, n=96).

Length is not a reason to pick a book up. It is a reason to put one down.

03Who feels the length most, and is it about attention span?

The young feel it and the old mostly do not. 54.8% of 18 to 29 year olds have abandoned a book more than once for length (n=42), against 24.4% of those 65 and over (n=41). 38.1% of 18 to 29s say length factors into whether they start a book at all, against 7.3% of the over-65s, and the small drift towards shorter books is concentrated in the young (14.3% of 18 to 29s against 8% overall).

It is about time rather than attention. Asked what makes a shorter book appealing, 73.5% pick the smaller time commitment and 60.5% say it is easier to fit into a busy schedule; only 7% say their attention span for long books has shortened (n=200). The case for long books is immersion: 68% enjoy getting lost in a story for an extended time.

04Which new format has real pull?

Simply a shorter book. Novella-length quick reads are the only format a majority are at least moderately interested in or already read (56.5%, n=200, Part 2), with 21.5% very interested, far ahead of short story collections (44.5%) and audio-first original fiction (38.5%). Women are nearly three times as likely as men to be very interested in novellas (30.8%, n=104, against 11.5%, n=96).

The formats built around new technology land worst. 62.5% have no interest at all in bite-sized fiction for phones and 60% none in chapter-by-chapter serials. Serial platforms are a discovery problem as much as a product one: 72.5% have never heard of them and only 6 of 200 have used one. Nobody says they would definitely pay for a serial subscription, though 42.5% say possibly. Audio-first originals would make 1 of 200 consume more fiction.

05Do new kinds of story appeal beyond Gen Z?

Mostly not. 34.5% find at least one of the new storyline approaches appealing (n=200, Part 2), but that average hides a generational split: 68.6% of Gen Z (n=35) against 12.5% of Boomers and older (n=56). 77.1% of Gen Z find choose-your-own-adventure stories for adults at least moderately appealing, against 17.9% of Boomers and older, and 51.4% of Gen Z pick stories where the reader can influence the plot or ending.

What travels across ages is established craft. Multiple points of view are at least moderately appealing to 67.5% (n=200) and to 79.4% of readers (n=136), and genre-blending tops the list of new approaches at 29%. Real-time, news-feed stories and community-written fiction are chosen by 3 of 200 each.

06What actually competes with reading?

The screen, not the page count. The top barrier to reading more is preferring TV, films or games (46.5%, n=200, Part 2), chosen by 78.1% of those who read no books (n=64). Not enough time comes next (39.5%) and peaks at 30 to 44 (54.7%, n=53); 54.8% of those 65 and over say they already read as much as they want (n=42). Cost (4%) and finding books to enjoy (2%) barely register.

Asked in their own words what would make them read more, 35% say more time and 29.5% say more engaging stories; 4% mention shorter books (n=200).

  1. A reading, not the panel's answer: a shorter first book looks like a cheap way to lower the risk of a new name, since 47.5% would sample an unfamiliar author more readily if the book were shorter (n=200).
  2. A reading: back the novella before the platform; serial apps, phone-native fiction and audio-first originals do not move this audience.
  3. A reading: build interactive storytelling for Gen Z rather than for everyone, and compete with the evening's television rather than with other books.

Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“Yes, this has happened more than once. I love reading, especially suspense and horror books that keep me hooked with plenty of twists and turns, and I even belong to a book club at my library. But reading is supposed to make me feel calm and peaceful, not like I'm doing a chore. If a book just drags on, feels unnecessarily long, and loses its momentum, I have no problem setting it aside and moving on to something else that actually holds my interest.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“And I belong to a local book club at my local library that we meet maybe once every two weeks to discuss a book. And I just love to read. It makes me calm and peaceful.”

Gen X woman, on abandoning a book for length supports finding 1

“I'd say yes, somewhat more likely. I don't usually have an awful lot of free time to begin with being a one-man operation, so committing to a massive book by someone I'm not familiar with is a big ask. I have to really be in the mood to listen to or read a really long story, but if it's on the shorter side, something that can be read or listened to in a couple or three hours, I'm a lot more inclined to give it a shot and see how it goes. If it's good, then I can always go from there.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I have to really be in the mood to listen to a story for a very long one. But if it's a shorter story or book that can be read in a couple, three hours, I'll do it.”

Baby Boomer man, on trying a new author supports finding 2

“Well, me personally, I don't really like to read books at all. I've always preferred other media like movies and TV shows. When I have some downtime, I'm much more into sci-fi, drama, adventure, and superhero movies. So what really keeps me from reading is just that I'd much rather watch a good movie or show than sit down with a book.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Well, me personally, I don't really like to read books, but when it comes to movies and shows, I'm more into sci-fi. I'm into drama. I'm also into adventure. I definitely enjoy superhero movies, things like that.”

Baby Boomer man, on what keeps him from reading supports finding 6

Section 08: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • the direction and the ranking of the main results: stated indifference to length alongside frequent abandoning, the steep age gradient, the novella's lead over every other format tested, Gen Z's appetite for interactive stories and other media as the top barrier
  • the gap between saying and doing on length, which holds inside the same people: 73 of the 168 who say length doesn't matter have abandoned a book more than once for it (Part 1)
  • time rather than attention span as the case for shorter books (73.5% against 7%, n=200)

What we would not

  • the exact percentages, which clone answers bunch: nobody chose 'yes, once' for abandoning a book, nobody now prefers longer books and nobody would definitely pay for a serial subscription; those zeros say more about how answers cluster than about the population, and the 43% is best read as 'has ever abandoned a book for length'
  • the stated preference for short books: 9.5% chose under 200 pages in Part 1 and 0% in Part 2 on the same question, so that figure does not replicate
  • Gen Z figures (n=35) as more than a direction
  • the two 'reason' questions as the reasons of people who prefer that length; every clone answered both, so read them as reasons people find persuasive
  • any figure joining a Part 1 answer to a Part 2 answer; the parts are separate draws with only 67 clones in both, and none is reported

The main limitation

two Ask Brox studies of 200 clones each in which answers bunch on several questions, so exact shares are looser than the directions; and 28% read no books in a typical year, so these are the attitudes of US adults in general, not of book buyers

Section 09: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Part 1, US adults200
Part 2, US adults200

Question wording as fielded

  1. (Part 1) Approximately how many books do you read or listen to in a typical year?
  2. (Part 1) Which formats do you typically use to read? (Select all that apply)
  3. (Part 1) About how much time do you spend reading (or listening to audiobooks) in a typical week?
  4. (Part 1) Which genres do you typically read? (Select up to 3)
  5. (Part 1) Do you have children living in your household?
  6. (Part 1) Generally speaking, what book length do you prefer?
  7. (Part 1) Compared to 5–10 years ago, would you say you now prefer shorter books, longer books, or about the same?
  8. (Part 1) If you prefer shorter books, what's the main reason? (Select up to 2; skip if you don't)
  9. (Part 1) If you prefer longer books, what's the main reason? (Select up to 2; skip if you don't)
  10. (Part 1) How much does a book's length factor into your decision to start reading it?
  11. (Part 1) Have you ever abandoned a book partway through specifically because it felt too long?
  12. (Part 1) Would you be more likely to try an author you've never read before if their book was on the shorter side?
  13. (Part 2) Approximately how many books do you read or listen to in a typical year?
  14. (Part 2) Generally speaking, what book length do you prefer?
  15. (Part 2) How interested would you be in each of the following formats? Rows: Serialized fiction released chapter-by-chapter, like a TV season; Novella-length quick reads; Audio-first original fiction, not adapted from a print book; Interactive or choose-your-own-path stories; Illustrated or graphic-novel hybrid formats; Short story collections instead of full novels; "Bite-sized" fiction designed specifically for phone reading.
  16. (Part 2) Have you ever used a serialized fiction app or platform (such as Wattpad, Radish, Kindle Vella, or similar)?
  17. (Part 2) Would you consider paying a monthly subscription for ongoing serialized fiction, similar to a TV or music streaming service?
  18. (Part 2) How appealing is the idea of a choose-your-own-adventure or branching-narrative story for adult readers (not just children's books)?
  19. (Part 2) Would audio-first storytelling (written and produced specifically for listening, not adapted from print) change how much you read or listen to fiction overall?
  20. (Part 2) Which of the following new storyline or narrative approaches would you find most appealing? (Select up to 3)
  21. (Part 2) How interested are you in genre-blending books (e.g., combining mystery with romance, or fantasy with literary fiction)?
  22. (Part 2) How appealing do you find stories told from multiple characters' points of view within the same book?
  23. (Part 2) Would you be interested in a book series told as shorter, interconnected stories (like a TV anthology series) instead of one continuous, long-running series?
  24. (Part 2) What, if anything, keeps you from reading as much as you'd like to? (Select up to 3)
  25. (Part 2) Compared to a few years ago, has the amount of time you spend reading increased, decreased, or stayed the same?
  26. (Part 2) In your own words, what would make you read more, whether that's a different book length, format, type of story, or something else entirely?

What was not asked, and why

age, gender, income, education, region and employment, which each clone already carries; what people actually buy or finish, and what length the books they abandoned were

What changed from the obvious question

rather than only asking whether people prefer shorter books, which 84% answer with 'length doesn't matter', the study paired that stated preference with behavior: abandoning a book for length and trying a new author on a shorter book. Ask Brox fields at most 20 questions per study, so the questionnaire ran as two parts, with the books-per-year and length-preference questions repeated in Part 2 as anchors; the anchors land within a few points of each other except the under-200-pages option

Ask this of your own audience: humans@brox.ai

More in Streaming & entertainment

All in Streaming & entertainment