US high-net-worth investors choose a human advisor over an app only below a 1% fee: 42.2% would pay 1.0%, 55.0% would pay 0.6%

In October 2026, 55.0% of affluent US investors on the Brox panel (n=109) would choose a human advisor charging 0.6% a year over an investing app at 0.25%, against 42.2% at a 1.0% fee, and 74.3% said tax and estate planning is what they most want from a human that an app cannot give.

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
Brox HNWI, 109 clones, US
When
October 2026 (fielded 11 October 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question lists what wealthy clients value in an advisor, which surveys from 2020 and earlier already answer without a price. This study asked the measurable version: at which of three fees a human advisor beats a 0.25% app on a $2 million portfolio, and which one service investors say only a human can give.

Section 01: What the panel said

  1. #

    55%

    Against an investing app charging 0.25% ($5,000 a year on $2 million), 40.4% of affluent US investors choose a human advisor at 1.25% ($25,000), 42.2% at 1.0% ($20,000) and 55.0% at 0.6% ($12,000): a majority chooses the human only below 1%

    base 109

  2. #

    16

    Self-directed investors are the ones who move: 4 of 61 choose the advisor at 1.25% and at 1.0%, 16 of 61 at 0.6%, while 40 of 48 existing advisor clients stay with the advisor at 1.25% and 44 of 48 at 0.6%

    base 61 · Manage their investments themselves · contrast

  3. #

    74.3%

    74.3% name tax and estate planning across their whole situation as the one thing they most want from a human advisor that an app cannot give, ahead of private investments (9.2%) and help avoiding rash decisions in a fall (4.6%); 11.9% say an app covers what they need

    base 109 · contrast

  4. #

    98

    98 of 109 would be not at all comfortable letting an AI-driven investing app manage $1 million with no human reviewing its decisions, a near-unanimous answer read as direction only

    base 109 · caveat

Against an investing app charging 0.25% ($5,000 a year on $2 million), 40.4% of affluent US investors choose a human advisor at 1.25% ($25,000), 42.2% at 1.0% ($20,000) and 55.0% at 0.6% ($12,000): a majority chooses the human only below 1%

Advisor at 1.25% ($25,000 a year)
40.4%
Advisor at 1.0% ($20,000 a year)
42.2%
Advisor at 0.6% ($12,000 a year)
55%

Base 109 clones.

02At what fee does a human advisor beat an investing app?

Below 1%. We wrote the same choice three times for a $2 million portfolio, each time against an investing app charging 0.25% ($5,000 a year). With the advisor at 1.25% ($25,000), 40.4% of affluent US investors on the Brox panel (n=109) chose the advisor. At 1.0% ($20,000) that barely moved, to 42.2%. At 0.6% ($12,000) it rose to 55.0%, the only rung where a majority chose the human.

So the ladder found a step, and it sits between 1.0% and 0.6%. Taking a quarter of a point off a 1.25% fee won two more investors out of 109; taking it down to 0.6% won fourteen. Each rung was reasoned on its own figure: the 0.6% answers talk about $12,000 a year, not about the dearer cases, and 108 of 109 clones answered the three rungs in a consistent order.

That reading is ours, and the study tested three fee levels, not every one in between, so the exact threshold is not measured. The strictest reading is narrower: a minority chooses the advisor at 1% or more, a majority at 0.6%.

03Who moves when the fee comes down?

The investors who manage their own money. Of the 48 clones who use a paid advisor today (45 alone and 3 alongside an app), 40 chose the advisor at 1.25% and 44 at 0.6%: they are staying whatever the fee. Of the 61 who manage their investments themselves through a brokerage account, 4 chose the advisor at 1.25%, 4 at 1.0% and 16 at 0.6%.

The ladder offered only an advisor or an app, so for self-directed investors "chose the app" means they would not pay the advisor at that price, not that they want an app. Read that way, a 1% fee wins almost none of them and 0.6% wins about a quarter. A low number here is a finding about willingness to start, and it starts at a lower price than the industry charges.

04What do affluent investors want that an app cannot give them?

Tax and estate planning across their whole situation, by a distance. Asked for the one thing they would most want from a human advisor that an app cannot provide, 74.3% (n=109) picked it, ahead of access to private investments and alternatives at 9.2% and someone to stop rash decisions when markets fall at 4.6%. Coordinating an accountant, lawyer and family was picked by none, and 11.9% said an app covers what they need.

The self-directed investors want the same thing: 44 of the 61 picked tax and estate planning, against 37 of the 48 who already pay an advisor. So the need is shared, and what divides the two groups is whether they will pay a percentage of assets to meet it.

One more result points the same way. Asked how comfortable they would be letting an AI-driven app manage $1 million with no human reviewing its decisions, 98 of 109 said not at all comfortable. 55 of the 65 clones who chose the app at the 1.25% rung gave that answer, so we read this as a line about supervision rather than a contradiction: a cheap portfolio engine is acceptable, an unsupervised one is not. Near-unanimity on a scale like this is direction only.

05What would a wealth manager do with this?

  1. A reading, not the panel's answer: price a planning-led service for self-directed investors well below 1%, because a 1% fee won 4 of 61 of them and 0.6% won 16.
  2. Lead with tax and estate planning, which 74.3% name as the thing only a human gives, rather than market timing or behavioral coaching, which few pick.
  3. Keep a human in the loop of any automated offer: the panel will take an app's price but not an app left alone with $1 million.

It sits alongside earlier Brox pages on this panel: affluent advisor clients want fewer check-ins and faster replies, and only a third of high-net-worth investors call a bank their primary financial firm.

06What do people also ask about advisors and investing apps?

  • What share of wealthy investors would pay a 1% advisor fee rather than use an app? 42.2% of affluent US investors (n=109, October 2026) would choose a human advisor at 1.0% a year over an investing app at 0.25%.
  • At what fee do affluent investors prefer a human advisor to an app? At 0.6% a year, 55.0% of affluent US investors (n=109) chose a human advisor over an app at 0.25%, the only fee tested where a majority did.
  • How many affluent investors want tax and estate planning from an advisor? 74.3% of affluent US investors (n=109) named tax and estate planning as the one thing they most want from a human advisor that an app cannot give.

Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“I would choose the human advisor at 0.6% ($12,000 a year). Look, I am a very analytical person, and I know that from a pure math perspective, paying $5,000 versus $12,000 seems like an easy calculation. But once you are dealing with significant assets like $2 million, it is not just about running a portfolio or basic index rebalancing—an app can do that, but an app cannot look at your total financial picture. What frustrates me most about building wealth is the sheer complexity of the US tax structure, account structures, conversions, and estate planning. In my experience working with an advisor, having that relationship where you meet twice a year and have someone available to answer questions and proactively present opportunities is invaluable. That kind of personalized guidance paid off huge for me in the past. To me, paying 0.6% for a human professional who understands your family's overall goals and helps navigate the complex nuances is well worth the extra cost over an algorithm.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“we had a great working relationship where we met twice a year”

Man, 45-64, KY, manages own investments supports finding 1

“I would definitely go with the human advisor. Look, saving money on fees is nice, and my wife and I are certainly judicious about keeping track of our day-to-day spending on our monthly spreadsheet, but when it comes to managing real wealth—like a $2 million portfolio—it’s not about finding the cheapest electronic tool. We don't execute trades electronically. For big stuff, it has to be personalized, and to me, personalized means a live human being conversation. Having someone who is accessible, completely honest, who knows us, and who can guide us through downturns and into investments we wouldn't otherwise have access to is invaluable. At this stage in life, peace of mind, asset protection, and having a trusted professional you can actually talk to far outweigh trying to save a percentage on an app.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“for big stuff, it's it is personalized. And I think personalized is a live human being conversation. It could be, you know, via video like we're doing. It could be in person. Uh, it could be by phone.”

Man, 45-64, FL, uses a paid advisor supports finding 2

“Right now, I do pretty much all of my investing and financial management myself through my accounts, but as I get closer to retirement, tax and estate planning is the one big area where I really need comprehensive, professional guidance. An app or basic brokerage platform is fine for buying dividend stocks or managing accounts, but it doesn't walk you through estate planning or complex tax minimization strategies across your entire portfolio. Getting a proper estate plan in place is on my immediate to-do list, and as I prepare for retirement, having a real professional guide me through taxes and estate setup is where human advice actually matters.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I do need to do the estate planning. I don't know if I don't know if my brokerage if they do estate planning.”

Woman, 45-64, VA, manages own investments supports finding 3

Section 08: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • The step between 1.0% and 0.6%: 46 of 109 chose the advisor at 1.0% and 60 at 0.6%, each rung reasoned on its own dollar figure, and 108 of 109 clones answered the three rungs in a consistent order.
  • That existing advisor clients barely move across the ladder (40 to 44 of 48) while self-directed investors go from 4 to 16 of 61.
  • That tax and estate planning is the service named as uniquely human, by 81 of 109 and by 44 of the 61 self-directed investors.

What we would not

  • An exact break-even fee: only 1.25%, 1.0% and 0.6% were tested, so the threshold lies somewhere between 1.0% and 0.6% and is not measured.
  • Reading 'chose the app' as demand for apps: the ladder offered no do-it-yourself option, none of the panel uses an app as its main arrangement today, and for the 61 self-directed investors it means they would not pay the advisor at that fee.
  • The figures as real-portfolio behavior: the $2 million portfolio is a hypothetical, and income is known for only 47 of the 109 clones.
  • The 98 of 109 discomfort with an unsupervised AI app as more than direction: near-unanimity on a five-point scale.
  • Any split by age, gender or income: demographics are missing for 62 of 109 clones.

The main limitation

These are 109 clones of affluent US investors answering a hypothetical $2 million choice between one advisor and one app at three fee levels; the panel holds no current app users and the ladder offered no do-it-yourself option, so it shows where the advisor wins the room, not a measured price threshold.

Section 09: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Manage their investments themselves through a brokerage account61
Use a paid advisor or wealth manager (3 of them alongside an app)48

Question wording as fielded

  1. Do you currently have any investable assets, such as stocks, bonds, mutual funds, ETFs, retirement accounts, or cash savings set aside for investing?
  2. Who manages most of your investable assets today?
  3. Which ONE of these would you most want from a human financial adviser that an investing app cannot give you?
  4. A human financial adviser charges 1.25% of assets a year, which is $25,000 a year on a $2 million portfolio. An investing app running a similar portfolio charges 0.25% a year, which is $5,000. Which would you choose for your $2 million?
  5. A human financial adviser charges 1.0% of assets a year, which is $20,000 a year on a $2 million portfolio. An investing app running a similar portfolio charges 0.25% a year, which is $5,000. Which would you choose for your $2 million?
  6. A human financial adviser charges 0.6% of assets a year, which is $12,000 a year on a $2 million portfolio. An investing app running a similar portfolio charges 0.25% a year, which is $5,000. Which would you choose for your $2 million?
  7. How comfortable would you be letting an AI-driven investing app manage $1 million of your money with no human adviser reviewing its decisions?

What was not asked, and why

No firm, advisor, platform or app was named. The study did not test flat or subscription advisor fees, fees between 0.6% and 1.0%, a hybrid service, or portfolio sizes other than $2 million, and it did not offer managing the money yourself as a third choice on the fee ladder.

What changed from the obvious question

The obvious question lists what wealthy clients value in an advisor, which surveys from 2020 and earlier already answer without a price. This study asked the measurable version: at which of three fees a human advisor beats a 0.25% app on a $2 million portfolio, and which one service investors say only a human can give.

Fielded through Ask Brox on 11 October 2026.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai

Related insights

All in this topic