A bank is the primary financial firm for only 33.9% of US high-net-worth investors, and the relationship belongs to the advisor more than to the firm

Only 33.9% of US high-net-worth investors call a bank of any kind their primary financial firm, no single type of firm passes 26%, and among the 33 who work with a named advisor 57.6% would follow that advisor to a rival firm (n=62, September 2026).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
Brox HNWI, 62 clones, US
When
September 2026 (fielded 13 September 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question is which bank; we asked which type of firm, because a brand list would have produced a ranking of names on a base of 62 and told a bank nothing about why the relationship moves. The second half of the topic, why it changes, was asked two ways: as the last real trigger, and as a scenario restated three times in full with the advisor leaving and a one-year fee waiver on neither side, the current side and the rival side, so the value of the advisor and the value of a retention offer could be separated. A two-year move-intent question was asked as four categories rather than a 0 to 10 scale, and a forced trade-off put a price of a quarter of a percentage point a year on a named advisor.

Section 01: What the panel said

  1. #

    33.9%

    No single type of firm holds the primary relationship: a full-service brokerage or wealth manager is primary for 25.8%, a discount or online brokerage for 24.2%, a large national bank for 22.6%, a regional or community bank for 8.1%, an independent advisor for 4.8% and a credit union for 3.2%, while 11.3% have no single primary firm; a bank of any kind is primary for 33.9% (21 of 62).

    base 62

  2. #

    57.6%

    Among the 33 who work with a named advisor, 57.6% would follow that advisor to a rival firm of similar size and reputation offering the same services at the same fees; if the rival waives one full year of fees, 72.7% would follow, and if instead their current firm waives one full year of fees to keep them, 48.5% would still follow.

    base 33 · Works with a named advisor or advisory team at the primary firm

  3. #

    41.9%

    A specific advisor or banker they trust is the single most important reason the firm is primary for 41.9%, more than twice the next reason (19.4% say it was simply where their accounts already were), and 59.7% would rather pay about a quarter of a percentage point a year more in fees for one named advisor who knows them than deal with a team and an app for less.

    base 62 · contrast

  4. #

    42.9%

    What has actually moved them is service: among the 35 who have moved, or seriously considered moving, their primary relationship, poor service or slow responses was the biggest single trigger for 42.9% (15 of 35), a life event for 5, an advisor or banker leaving for 4 and fees that felt too high for 4.

    base 35 · Have moved, or seriously considered moving, their primary relationship · caveat

No single type of firm holds the primary relationship: a full-service brokerage or wealth manager is primary for 25.8%, a discount or online brokerage for 24.2%, a large national bank for 22.6%, a regional or community bank for 8.1%, an independent advisor for 4.8% and a credit union for 3.2%, while 11.3% have no single primary firm; a bank of any kind is primary for 33.9% (21 of 62).

Full-service brokerage or wealth manager
25.8%
Discount or online brokerage
24.2%
Large national bank, incl. private bank or wealth arm
22.6%
No single primary firm
11.3%
Regional or community bank
8.1%
Independent advisor (RIA)
4.8%
Credit union
3.2%

Base 62 clones.

02If not a bank, then what holds the primary relationship?

Ask US high-net-worth investors which one firm they treat as primary and no type of firm wins. A full-service brokerage or wealth manager is primary for 25.8% (n=62), a discount or online brokerage for 24.2% and a large national bank for 22.6%. A regional or community bank adds 8.1% and a credit union 3.2%, so a bank of any kind is the primary firm for 21 of 62 (33.9%), against 34 of 62 (54.8%) for a brokerage, a wealth manager or an independent advisor. A further 11.3% say they have no single firm they consider primary. The three leading types are within two respondents of each other, so the order is not the finding; the absence of a dominant type is.

The split runs along one line: whether the investor works with a named advisor. Of the 33 who do, 39.4% call a full-service brokerage or wealth manager primary and 6.1% an online brokerage. Of the 29 who do not, 13 name an online brokerage and 3 a full-service firm. The primary firm is wherever the relationship is, or, when there is no relationship, wherever the platform is.

The relationship is long and partly concentrated. 47 of 62 (75.8%) have been with their primary firm for more than ten years, and 38.7% hold three-quarters or more of their investable assets there, while 24.2% hold less than a quarter. Whichever type of firm it is, 74.2% (n=62) rely on it for everyday banking, so the brokerages and wealth managers in this panel are doing the banking too.

03When the advisor leaves, who leaves with them?

We put the same scenario to the panel three times, restated in full each time: your advisor leaves for a firm of similar size and reputation, same services, same fees, and your current firm assigns you a new advisor. With no incentive on either side, 35.5% (n=62) would follow the advisor, 53.2% would stay and 11.3% would take the chance to compare several firms. When the current firm waives one full year of fees to keep them, 30.6% would still follow and 58.1% would stay. When instead the rival firm waives one full year of fees to bring them across, 50.0% would follow, 27.4% would stay and 22.6% would shop around.

Among the 33 who work with a named advisor today the same ladder reads 57.6%, 48.5% and 72.7% following. Among the 29 who do not, 3, 3 and 7 would follow. Even investors whose reason for being at the firm has nothing to do with an advisor move: of the 36 who gave another reason, 77.8% stay with no offer on the table and 41.7% stay once the rival waives a year of fees, with 33.3% choosing to compare firms instead.

The inertia the panel reports elsewhere does not protect the incumbent here. 90.3% (n=62) say they are not likely to move their primary relationship in the next two years, but of the 31 who say they are not at all likely, 51.6% would follow their advisor to a rival that waived a year of fees.

04Why has the relationship changed before, when it has?

61.3% (n=62) have never moved their primary financial relationship; 29.0% moved more than three years ago and 9.7% within the last three. Asked about the last time they moved or seriously considered it, 35 of the 62 name a trigger, and the biggest single one is poor service or slow responses, for 15 of the 35 (42.9%). A life event such as an inheritance, a business sale, retirement or a divorce comes next for 5, then an advisor or banker leaving for 4 and fees that felt too high for 4. Poor investment performance moved 1 and a better offer from another firm moved 1.

That sits awkwardly beside the ladder above, and we think both are true. Advisors rarely leave, so the departure has not had many chances to be the trigger, and an investor who followed an advisor may not describe that as moving the relationship at all. What the panel's own history says is that the firm loses the relationship by failing at service, not by being out-priced: fees are the trigger for 4 of 35 and a better offer for 1.

Asked what would make them hesitate to switch at all, half name losing the relationship (50.0%, n=62, multiple answers allowed) and a third the hassle of switching (35.5%). Asked what would make them move more assets to the primary firm, 43.5% (n=62) say nothing would, because they prefer to spread their assets across several firms; better tax and estate planning is the one thing that would move a meaningful share, at 19.4%.

05What would a bank or a wealth manager do with this?

  1. Our reading, not the panel's: the retention lever is the advisor, not the fee. A fee waiver offered at the moment of an advisor's exit held back 3 of 62 in this study, and the client base most worth keeping, those with a named advisor, was the least moved by it.
  2. Our reading: the acquisition lever is the advisor plus a first-year incentive. The rival's waiver did not only pull the advisor-loyal; it unsettled a third of the 36 investors whose loyalty was to something other than an advisor, who chose to compare firms rather than stay.
  3. Our reading: the way a bank loses a high-net-worth relationship is slow service on the things that matter to the client, wires, transfers, complex requests, rather than price. The historical triggers in this panel are service failures four times as often as fees.
  4. Our reading: consolidation is a planning conversation. 43.5% will not consolidate on principle; of the reasons that would move the rest, tax and estate planning outscores lower fees for larger balances by three to one (19.4% against 6.5%, n=62).

Section 06: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“My primary financial institution is a wealth management company that not only invests my assets but also handles my trust, estate planning, and tax implications. Because I split my time between upstate New York and Manhattan to manage my tax burden, and because I deal with multiple LLCs and complex returns, I need a sophisticated full-service firm. They have the broad experience to manage all of that seamlessly, which you simply can't get at smaller retail banks.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“So, my main financial institution is a wealth management company that not only um invests but has trust and estate planning.”

Investable assets $5m to $10m; a full-service wealth manager has been the primary firm for 11 to 20 years, with a named advisor supports finding 1

“I would absolutely follow my advisor to the new firm. I actually have a broker who I've worked with for many years, and he's moved around a bit, but I always move with him. For me, it's about the person, not the institution. He's done very well for me, he's a genuinely good person, and we've built a strong level of trust over the years. I want my money managed by someone I personally trust, so I would go wherever he goes.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I've had a broker for many many years and so he continues to I guess move around so to speak but I usually move with him. So it's a particular advisor that I work with.”

Investable assets $5m to $10m; primary firm a full-service brokerage with a named advisor, moved the relationship within the last three years supports finding 2

“The biggest issue for me is poor service and slow responses, particularly when it comes to handling big transactions for my business. I've had situations where I needed money urgently, and the bank wouldn't clear the funds or made the process incredibly complicated. For example, I've had to go in person because they wouldn't listen on the phone, or they told me they needed a few days for a transfer to reflect in the account. When you're running a business and need liquidity quickly, that kind of slow service is incredibly frustrating. It makes me feel like just another account number rather than a valued client they want to support.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“it's a process and you have to go in person. They won't listen to you on call. They won't and if the money has come in, they won't clear it. They're like, 'No, we need a few days to uh reflect it on the account.'”

Investable assets $500k to $2.5m; primary firm a large national bank for 2 to 5 years, no named advisor, has considered moving but never has supports finding 4

Section 07: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • That no single type of firm dominates the primary relationship for US high-net-worth investors, and that a bank of any kind holds it for about a third (21 of 62): the three leading types are within two respondents of each other and the split follows whether the investor has a named advisor.
  • The slope of the advisor-leaves ladder: a year of fees waived by the rival moves far more of the panel than the same year waived by the incumbent (9 of 62 against 3 of 62), and the direction holds in every segment of 30 or more, including the never-moved and those not at all likely to move.
  • That the advisor is the stated reason for the relationship (41.9%, n=62) and that a majority (59.7%) would pay a quarter of a percentage point a year to keep a named one.
  • That poor service, not price, is what has historically triggered a move or a serious consideration of one (15 of 35 against 4 of 35 for fees).

What we would not

  • The order of the top three firm types (25.8% / 24.2% / 22.6%, n=62): one or two respondents would reorder them.
  • The absolute follow rates (35.5% overall, 57.6% of the 33 with a named advisor) as an attrition rate a firm would actually see: the scenario strips out every reason to stay except the new advisor, and stated intent is not behavior.
  • Any figure for an asset band: the three bands are 26, 17 and 19 respondents, so they are counts, and we did not use them for a finding.
  • The tension between the ladder and the past triggers (an advisor leaving was the biggest trigger for only 4 of 35): we read it as advisors rarely leaving and followers not counting the move, but the study cannot show that.
  • The everyday-banking share (74.2%, n=62): a multiple-answer question Ask Brox added, quoted as direction only.

The main limitation

A panel of 62 clones of US high-net-worth investors, which is enough for the whole-panel figures but leaves every segment except those of 30 or more as a count; the panel exposes no demographics, so its composition is described by investable-asset band only; the study asked about types of firm and never named one, so it cannot say which brand holds the relationship.

Section 08: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Investable assets $500k-$2.5m26
Investable assets $2.5m-$5m17
Investable assets $5m-$10m19

Question wording as fielded

  1. Which ONE type of firm do you consider your primary financial firm today, meaning the firm that holds the largest share of your investable assets or the one you would turn to first with an important financial decision?
  2. Roughly what share of your total investable assets is held at your primary financial firm?
  3. How long have you been with your primary financial firm?
  4. What is the single most important reason this firm is your primary financial firm?
  5. Have you ever moved your primary financial relationship from one firm to another?
  6. Think about the last time you moved, or seriously considered moving, your primary financial relationship. What was the single biggest trigger?
  7. The adviser you work with at your primary financial firm leaves to join a different firm of similar size and reputation, which offers the same services at the same fees. Your current firm assigns you a new adviser. What would you do?
  8. The adviser you work with at your primary financial firm leaves to join a different firm of similar size and reputation, which offers the same services at the same fees. Your current firm assigns you a new adviser and offers to waive one full year of your fees if you stay. What would you do?
  9. The adviser you work with at your primary financial firm leaves to join a different firm of similar size and reputation, which offers the same services at the same fees. Your current firm assigns you a new adviser. The firm your adviser has joined offers to waive one full year of your fees if you move with them. What would you do?
  10. How likely are you to move your primary financial relationship to a different firm in the next two years?
  11. If you had to choose one, which would you rather have as your primary financial firm?
  12. What would most make you move more of your assets to your primary financial firm?
  13. If you left your primary financial firm tomorrow, which type of firm would you most likely move to?
  14. Do you currently work with a named adviser or advisory team at your primary financial firm?
  15. When you think about moving your primary financial relationship, what concerns or frictions would make you hesitate to switch?
  16. What services do you currently rely on your primary financial firm for?

What was not asked, and why

No bank, brokerage, wealth manager or advisor firm was named in any question or answer option, and the study context asked Ask Brox not to add any, which it honored: the topic asks which bank, and the study answers which kind of firm. We did not ask about assets held away from the primary firm in dollar terms, about fee levels actually paid, or about performance relative to a benchmark. The seven questions Ask Brox added (hesitations about switching, preferred relationship structure, whether they work with a named advisor, other reasons they stay, improvements that would make them consolidate, services relied on, and who decides) are in the data table; the named-advisor question is the axis most of the page turns on, and the multiple-answer ones are used as direction only.

What changed from the obvious question

The obvious question is which bank; we asked which type of firm, because a brand list would have produced a ranking of names on a base of 62 and told a bank nothing about why the relationship moves. The second half of the topic, why it changes, was asked two ways: as the last real trigger, and as a scenario restated three times in full with the advisor leaving and a one-year fee waiver on neither side, the current side and the rival side, so the value of the advisor and the value of a retention offer could be separated. A two-year move-intent question was asked as four categories rather than a 0 to 10 scale, and a forced trade-off put a price of a quarter of a percentage point a year on a named advisor.

Fielded through Ask Brox on 13 September 2026.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai

Related insights

All in this topic