Research study
Winning first: all 200 US sports fans say the Chiefs' Justin Tucker signing puts winning ahead of doing the right thing, and 98% say accused athletes get more lenient treatment
All 200 US sports fans asked agree the Chiefs' October 2026 signing of Justin Tucker suggests winning matters more than doing the right thing, 98% of another 200 say accused athletes are treated more leniently than ordinary employees, and 95% of a third 200 say it tells people weighing a misconduct report that fame can outweigh allegations (n=200 each, October 2026).
- Who was asked
- US sports fans, 200 clones, US
- When
- October 2026 (fielded 28 October 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- the 64-question study plan ran as seven studies of 200 sports fans, each opening with a sports-fan screener, how closely the respondent follows the NFL and whether they support or oppose the signing; the neutral news summary (and, in Part 7, the study plan's summary of the Deshaun Watson case) was given to Ask Brox as study background so every respondent carried it into every answer; the questions about awareness and opinion of the Chiefs before the news came from a separate first fielding of Part 1, asked before any description; Ask Brox added five to seven questions of its own to each part with an open-ended question and replaced one open question, 'what does the decision make you think about the organization?', with closed questions; 'select all that apply' questions were fielded as 'select up to N, choosing every one that applies'
Section 01: What the study found
- #
100%
of US sports fans agree the Chiefs' decision to sign Justin Tucker suggests winning is more important than doing the right thing (75% strongly), and all 200 say it shows the Chiefs are willing to overlook controversy if a player can help the team
base 200
- #
98%
say athletes accused of sexual misconduct are treated more leniently than ordinary employees facing similar allegations (97% much more leniently), and asked whether the Chiefs would have made the same decision for a player who was not a well-known star, all 200 in another sample said no
base 200 · contrast
- #
99%
agree the decision makes it seem as though women's allegations can be overlooked when someone is talented enough, and 79% agree a woman accused of misconduct in the same circumstances would be less likely to receive the same opportunities
base 200 · contrast
- #
95%
say the signing could tell people considering whether to report sexual misconduct that someone's fame or professional value can outweigh the allegations, and 83% believe decisions like it could discourage people from reporting
base 200 · contrast
- #
72%
of men say Tucker deserves another opportunity to play in the NFL, against 27% (n=115) of women; 66% (n=76) of men in another sample say the decision is primarily about football and says nothing about women, against 23% (n=124) of women
base 85 · Men · contrast
- #
56%
became less supportive of the signing when reminded that Tucker served a 10-game NFL suspension, and 2% more supportive; 109 of the 113 who grew less supportive pointed to the suspension or the policy violation behind it
base 200 · contrast
of US sports fans agree the Chiefs' decision to sign Justin Tucker suggests winning is more important than doing the right thing (75% strongly), and all 200 say it shows the Chiefs are willing to overlook controversy if a player can help the team
02How did sports fans react to the signing?
Against it, and almost nobody for it. In late October 2026 several outlets reported that the Kansas City Chiefs were signing the former Baltimore Ravens kicker Justin Tucker to their practice squad. Every respondent read the same neutral summary before the survey: Tucker was accused of sexual misconduct by 16 massage therapists, allegations he has denied; the NFL suspended him for 10 games for violating its personal conduct policy; he served that suspension and was not criminally charged; and the signing followed struggles by the Chiefs' current kicker. In a separate sample asked before any description, none of 200 sports fans had heard of the signing and none of 185 knew of the allegations.
Given that summary, between 50% and 61% of US sports fans opposed the signing in each of seven samples of 200, no more than 8 of 200 supported it in any sample, and nobody strongly supported it. In the first sample (n=200), 38% called it an unacceptable decision given the nature of the allegations, against 13% who saw a reasonable decision to give a player a second chance. Asked in their own words what the decision says the Chiefs value most, 83% of another sample (n=199) answered winning first.
03Do they think a star is being treated differently?
Yes, and they do not want a higher bar for athletes, only the same one. 98% of US sports fans (n=200) say athletes accused of sexual misconduct are treated more leniently than ordinary employees facing similar allegations, and in another sample all 200 said the Chiefs would not have made the same decision for a player who was not a well-known star. Yet 95% (n=200) say the expectations for personal conduct should be the same for athletes as for ordinary employees.
In a third sample (n=200), all 200 agree that successful men can face serious allegations and still keep opportunities ordinary people would lose, and all 200 that organizations tolerate allegations of misconduct when someone is valuable enough. 74% of another sample (n=200) say the decision shows the Chiefs' leadership does not take allegations of sexual misconduct seriously; 6 of 200 say it does.
04What does it say to women, and to people who report misconduct?
That their allegations can be outweighed. 99% of US sports fans (n=200) agree the decision makes it seem as though women's allegations can be overlooked when someone is talented enough, and 79% that a woman accused of misconduct in the same circumstances would be less likely to receive the same opportunities. Women and men read it differently: 62% (n=124) of women say it sends a negative message to women, while 66% (n=76) of men say it is primarily about football and says nothing about women.
For people deciding whether to come forward, 95% of another sample (n=200) say it could tell them that someone's fame or professional value can outweigh the allegations, 83% believe decisions like this could discourage people from reporting, and 199 of 200 agree it can make speaking up feel pointless. In a further sample (n=200), 95% say it tells young men that sexual misconduct allegations do not necessarily end a career.
05Does a served suspension settle it?
No. Asked whether Tucker deserves another opportunity to play in the NFL, 46% of US sports fans (n=200) said yes, most of them only if certain conditions are met (39%), 33% said he should not return and 21% were unsure. Men and women divide sharply: 72% (n=85) of men said yes, against 27% (n=115) of women.
Reminding them of the suspension did not help the Chiefs. Told that Tucker served a 10-game NFL suspension for violating the league's personal conduct policy, 56% became less supportive of the signing and 2% more supportive. 66% said serving a suspension should allow an athlete to return but teams should still consider the ethical implications, against 9% who said teams should be free to sign him without criticism.
06What does it say about the NFL?
That the culture puts winning first. 199 of 200 US sports fans agree the NFL has a culture that prioritises winning over accountability, only 14% that its disciplinary processes are sufficient to decide when players should return, and 65% want stricter rules for signing players who have faced serious misconduct allegations.
Set beside the Cleveland Browns' 2022 acquisition of Deshaun Watson, who also faced allegations of sexual misconduct involving massage therapists, denied wrongdoing and served an 11-game suspension, 50% of another sample (n=200) said the two decisions reflect equally negatively on the organizations' values, 47% said the Browns' was worse and nobody said the Chiefs' was worse; 98% agree the Browns' decision was more concerning because of the size and guarantee of Watson's contract, and 91% that the Chiefs' decision shows the NFL has not learned from the Watson controversy.
Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“To me, it clearly shows they put winning first above everything else. Their kicker was struggling, so they're doing whatever it takes to win games, even if it means bringing in someone with serious allegations hanging over their head. At the end of the day, it's all about performance and getting results for them, rather than standing up for morals or doing the right thing.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“Because at the end of the day, it's go big or go home.”
“I strongly oppose this decision. Hearing that sixteen different people accused someone of sexual misconduct is just terrible, embarrassing, and honestly makes me mad. Bringing someone like that onto the team just because your kicker is struggling feels like prioritizing a game over basic human decency and the safety and respect of women. It makes me really not want to support an organization when they overlook things like that.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“care about other people in, like, a public kind of way”
“Yes athletes are treated much more leniently: In most ordinary workplaces, an employee facing serious allegations from multiple individuals would be terminated immediately and likely never work in that field again. In professional sports, talent and the desire to win often overshadow personal conduct, meaning athletes are frequently given second chances or minimal suspensions that an average worker would never receive.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“Looking for equal rights for everyone.”
“I think this decision sends a message that winning and athletic performance are being prioritized over the dignity, respect, and safety of women. When a team brings in someone with that background simply because they need immediate help on the field, it gives the impression that sports success and results come before ethical principles and taking women's experiences seriously.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I would also stand firmly for my values and integrity, even if it comes with personal costs because staying true to who I am is important. Ultimately, anything that protects life, dignity and justice is worth strong commitment and sacrifice.”
“I would have to tell her that it shows how unequal power really is in our society. To me, nobody is supposed to be above anybody else, but when you look at situations like this, it feels like famous men with money and status get protected no matter what, while women end up bearing the cost. It sends a terrible message that talent or celebrity outweighs accountability and women's safety.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“fairness. I believe that everybody should have to follow the same rules. Nobody's above somebody else.”
“Yes, significantly. When high-profile sports teams give a platform and a paycheck to someone facing serious allegations like that, it sends a horrible message to survivors and victims. It basically tells people that accountability doesn't matter as long as someone has talent or helps an organization win, which makes it even harder for folks to feel safe enough to step forward and report harassment or misconduct.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I think it's incredibly important for people to call out, um, this type of behavior and a lack of respect, um, for folks.”
“I believe Justin Tucker deserves another opportunity to play in the NFL, yes without reservations. He already served the 10-game suspension that the league gave him, and he wasn't criminally charged with anything, plus he denied the allegations. To me, it's just logical and common sense that if you serve the punishment the league handed down and there are no legal charges against you, you should be allowed to go back to work and play.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“We'll have more rules about it and be strict with them.”
“Knowing that he was suspended for violating the personal conduct policy makes me much less supportive of the Chiefs signing him. I enjoy watching sports, but I was raised to believe in doing the right thing, honesty, and justice. When a team looks past serious misconduct violations just to win games, that's just not right in my book.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I was raised to respect the law and be honest. I would do the right thing.”
Section 08: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- opposition to the signing: between 50% and 61% opposed in each of seven samples, and nobody strongly supported it in any
- the reading of what it communicates: winning ahead of doing the right thing and overlooking controversy for a player who can help were near-unanimous in every group of 30 or more
- the star's-privilege reading: 98% say accused athletes are treated more leniently, at least 93% in every group of 30 or more
- the gender divide on a second chance: 72% of men (n=85) against 27% of women (n=115)
- the served suspension making fans less supportive, not more (56% against 2%)
What we would not
- the exact figures on near-unanimous items (winning over doing the right thing, overlooking controversy, the NFL culture, valuable men keeping opportunities): the agreement is the finding, not the decimal
- anything about Chiefs supporters specifically: 97% of one sample did not support the Chiefs before, so the watching, merchandise and sponsor questions mostly did not apply
- the size of the gaps between women and men as population estimates: there are 73 to 85 men in each sample
- any person-by-person link between the seven parts: they are separate samples drawn from a small pool of sports fans (250 different clones in all, any two sharing 159 to 179), and no answer is joined across them
- the figures from questions Ask Brox added of its own as if they were the study plan's: they are reported in their own words and marked in the data table
The main limitation
no respondent knew of the signing or the allegations beforehand, so every answer is a reaction to a short neutral summary read in the survey, not to news coverage; women are about six in ten of each sample, so overall figures lean toward their view, and the reliable part is the shape of the reading (winning first, different rules for stars, a message to women and to people who report) rather than exact percentages
Section 09: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Part 1: US sports fans (first reactions and what the decision communicates) | 200 |
| Part 2: US sports fans (second chances and what the Chiefs should do) | 200 |
| Part 3: US sports fans (fandom, sponsors and the NFL) | 200 |
| Part 4: US sports fans (gender and the message to women) | 200 |
| Part 5: US sports fans (reporting misconduct and credibility) | 200 |
| Part 6: US sports fans (power, survivors and young people) | 200 |
| Part 7: US sports fans (the Deshaun Watson comparison) | 200 |
| Before-survey sample: US sports fans asked before any description | 200 |
| Part 2: women | 115 |
| Part 2: men | 85 |
| Part 4: women | 124 |
| Part 4: men | 76 |
Question wording as fielded
- Before-survey sample (first fielding of Part 1, asked before any description). How would you describe your opinion of the Kansas City Chiefs?
- Before-survey sample (first fielding of Part 1, asked before any description). Before today, had you heard about the Kansas City Chiefs signing Justin Tucker?
- Before-survey sample (first fielding of Part 1, asked before any description). Before today, were you aware of the sexual misconduct allegations made against Justin Tucker?
- Part 1. Do you consider yourself a fan of any professional or college sports? (Screener; the fielded wording named the NFL, four other leagues and college football as examples. Big fans and casual fans took the survey.)
- Part 1. How closely do you follow the NFL?
- Part 1. What is your immediate reaction to the Kansas City Chiefs signing Justin Tucker?
- Part 1. To what extent do you support or oppose the Chiefs' decision to sign Justin Tucker?
- Part 1. Which of the following best describes your opinion of the Chiefs' decision?
- Part 1. Which of the following messages, if any, do you believe the Chiefs are communicating by signing Justin Tucker? (Select up to 15, choosing every one that applies)
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The Chiefs' decision suggests winning is more important than doing the right thing
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The Chiefs' decision makes me question the organization's values
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The Chiefs' decision shows that talented athletes can escape lasting career consequences
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The Chiefs' decision suggests the organization is indifferent to the experiences of those who reported misconduct
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The Chiefs' decision reflects a broader problem with accountability in professional sports
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The Chiefs have a responsibility to consider what signing a player communicates beyond the football field
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Tucker should be allowed to resume his career after serving his suspension
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The Chiefs should not be criticized for signing a player who is eligible to compete under NFL rules
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The Chiefs are being unfairly judged for a decision other NFL teams might also make
- Part 1. Which aspect of the Chiefs' reputation, if any, is most negatively affected by this decision?
- Part 2. Do you consider yourself a fan of any professional or college sports? (Screener; the fielded wording named the NFL, four other leagues and college football as examples. Big fans and casual fans took the survey.)
- Part 2. How closely do you follow the NFL?
- Part 2. To what extent do you support or oppose the Chiefs' decision to sign Justin Tucker?
- Part 2. Do you believe Justin Tucker deserves another opportunity to play in the NFL?
- Part 2. Which of the following factors should matter most when an NFL team considers signing a player accused of sexual misconduct? (Select up to 3)
- Part 2. Justin Tucker has served a 10-game NFL suspension for violating the league's personal conduct policy. How does knowing this affect your opinion of the Chiefs signing him?
- Part 2. Which statement comes closest to your opinion?
- Part 2. Should the expectations for personal conduct be higher for professional athletes than for ordinary employees?
- Part 2. What would you most like to see the Chiefs do in response to public concerns about this decision? (Select up to 3)
- Part 2. If Tucker performs well for the Chiefs, how would that affect your opinion of the signing?
- Part 2. Which is more important to you when deciding whether to support a professional sports team?
- Part 2. In your own words, what does the Chiefs' decision to sign Justin Tucker tell you about what the organization values most? (open-ended, coded by Ask Brox into its own themes)
- Part 3. Do you consider yourself a fan of any professional or college sports? (Screener; the fielded wording named the NFL, four other leagues and college football as examples. Big fans and casual fans took the survey.)
- Part 3. How closely do you follow the NFL?
- Part 3. To what extent do you support or oppose the Chiefs' decision to sign Justin Tucker?
- Part 3. How has the Chiefs' decision to sign Justin Tucker affected your overall opinion of the team?
- Part 3. Has this decision affected your willingness to support the Kansas City Chiefs?
- Part 3. As a result of this decision, how likely are you to take any of the following actions?: Watch fewer Chiefs games
- Part 3. As a result of this decision, how likely are you to take any of the following actions?: Stop watching Chiefs games entirely
- Part 3. As a result of this decision, how likely are you to take any of the following actions?: Avoid purchasing Chiefs merchandise
- Part 3. As a result of this decision, how likely are you to take any of the following actions?: Stop following the Chiefs on social media
- Part 3. As a result of this decision, how likely are you to take any of the following actions?: Express criticism of the Chiefs publicly
- Part 3. As a result of this decision, how likely are you to take any of the following actions?: Discuss the decision negatively with friends or family
- Part 3. As a result of this decision, how likely are you to take any of the following actions?: Support a different NFL team
- Part 3. As a result of this decision, how likely are you to take any of the following actions?: Continue supporting the Chiefs regardless of the decision
- Part 3. As a result of this decision, how likely are you to take any of the following actions?: Continue following the controversy to see how the Chiefs respond
- Part 3. How would you feel about brands continuing to sponsor or partner with the Chiefs following this decision?
- Part 3. Would this decision make you more or less likely to purchase products from brands that sponsor the Chiefs?
- Part 3. To what extent does this decision affect your opinion of the NFL as a whole?
- Part 3. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The NFL has a culture that prioritizes winning over accountability
- Part 3. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The NFL does not do enough to address sexual misconduct involving players
- Part 3. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: NFL teams are more concerned with public relations than ethical conduct
- Part 3. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The NFL's disciplinary processes are sufficient for determining when players should return
- Part 3. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The NFL should hold teams accountable for signing players with serious misconduct allegations
- Part 3. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Fans have a responsibility to challenge teams that make ethically questionable decisions
- Part 3. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: I can separate my enjoyment of NFL football from the personal conduct of individual players
- Part 3. Do you believe the NFL should introduce stricter rules governing the signing of players who have faced serious misconduct allegations?
- Part 3. Which of the following best describes your view of how professional sports organizations handle allegations of sexual misconduct?
- Part 4. How closely do you follow the NFL?
- Part 4. To what extent do you support or oppose the Chiefs' decision to sign Justin Tucker?
- Part 4. To what extent do you believe the Chiefs' decision communicates each of the following messages to society?: Allegations of sexual misconduct are less important when someone is professionally successful
- Part 4. To what extent do you believe the Chiefs' decision communicates each of the following messages to society?: Men in positions of power are often protected from career consequences
- Part 4. To what extent do you believe the Chiefs' decision communicates each of the following messages to society?: Women's allegations are taken less seriously when they involve famous athletes
- Part 4. To what extent do you believe the Chiefs' decision communicates each of the following messages to society?: Professional success can be treated as more important than personal conduct
- Part 4. To what extent do you believe the Chiefs' decision communicates each of the following messages to society?: People who face misconduct allegations can still be given second chances
- Part 4. To what extent do you believe the Chiefs' decision communicates each of the following messages to society?: Employers should judge people by their professional abilities rather than allegations about their personal behavior
- Part 4. To what extent do you believe the Chiefs' decision communicates each of the following messages to society?: Serving a professional suspension should allow a person to return to work
- Part 4. To what extent do you believe the Chiefs' decision communicates each of the following messages to society?: Professional sports operate under different standards of accountability from other workplaces
- Part 4. Do you believe the Chiefs' decision sends a negative message to women?
- Part 4. Which of the following statements best reflects your opinion?
- Part 4. How much do you agree or disagree with the statement: "If a woman accused of misconduct faced the same circumstances, she would be less likely to receive the same professional opportunities as Justin Tucker"?
- Part 4. Do you believe professional athletes accused of sexual misconduct are treated differently from ordinary employees facing similar allegations?
- Part 4. In your own words, what message, if any, do you believe this decision sends to women who have experienced sexual harassment or misconduct? (open-ended, coded by Ask Brox into its own themes)
- Part 4. What message, if any, do you believe the Chiefs' decision to sign Justin Tucker sends about how society values women? (Select up to 11, choosing every one that applies)
- Part 4. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The Chiefs' decision suggests that women's experiences matter less than men's professional achievements
- Part 4. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The decision reinforces the idea that powerful men are protected from consequences
- Part 4. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The decision makes it seem as though women's allegations can be overlooked when someone is talented enough
- Part 4. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The decision reflects a society that often prioritizes men's careers over women's well-being
- Part 4. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The decision sends the message that women's concerns are secondary to business interests
- Part 4. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The decision risks normalizing the dismissal of allegations involving sexual misconduct
- Part 4. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The decision suggests that organizations value what successful men can contribute more than the concerns of women who accuse them
- Part 4. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The decision demonstrates that allegations should not automatically prevent someone from earning a living
- Part 4. Do you believe the NFL's repeated willingness to give prominent players accused of sexual misconduct professional opportunities contributes to a culture in which women are less likely to feel believed, protected, or respected?
- Part 5. Do you consider yourself a fan of any professional or college sports? (Screener; the fielded wording named the NFL, four other leagues and college football as examples. Big fans and casual fans took the survey.)
- Part 5. How closely do you follow the NFL?
- Part 5. To what extent do you support or oppose the Chiefs' decision to sign Justin Tucker?
- Part 5. If you were someone who had experienced sexual misconduct, how do you think you might interpret the Chiefs' decision? (Select up to 11, choosing every one that applies)
- Part 5. Do you believe decisions like the Chiefs signing Tucker could discourage people from reporting sexual harassment or misconduct?
- Part 5. Which of the following messages do you think the signing could send to people considering whether to report sexual misconduct? (Select up to 3)
- Part 5. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Decisions like this can make people who have experienced sexual misconduct feel that speaking up is pointless
- Part 5. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Allowing accused public figures to return to prominent positions can make survivors feel unheard
- Part 5. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Organizations should consider how their hiring decisions may affect people who have experienced sexual misconduct
- Part 5. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: When multiple people report similar allegations, organizations have a greater responsibility to demonstrate how they assessed the situation
- Part 5. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Giving someone a second chance does not necessarily mean dismissing the experiences of those who made allegations
- Part 5. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Public criticism of someone accused of misconduct should not replace a fair investigation
- Part 5. What does the Chiefs' decision communicate about how seriously allegations of sexual misconduct are taken when multiple women come forward?
- Part 5. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Women who report sexual misconduct are often expected to provide more evidence than is reasonably available
- Part 5. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Famous men are more likely to receive the benefit of the doubt than women who accuse them
- Part 5. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Multiple independent allegations should carry greater weight in an organization's hiring decisions
- Part 5. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Public figures accused of misconduct are often able to rehabilitate their reputations more easily than those who make allegations
- Part 5. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Women who speak out about misconduct often face greater reputational damage than the men they accuse
- Part 5. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: An individual's professional opportunities should not be restricted solely because multiple people have made allegations
- Part 5. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Believing that allegations deserve serious investigation is compatible with respecting the presumption of innocence
- Part 5. Which statement comes closest to your view?
- Part 5. Which of the following statements best summarizes the message you personally take away from the Chiefs' decision?
- Part 5. In your own words, what does the Chiefs' decision reveal, if anything, about how women and people who report sexual misconduct are treated in American society? (open-ended, coded by Ask Brox into its own themes)
- Part 6. Do you consider yourself a fan of any professional or college sports? (Screener; the fielded wording named the NFL, four other leagues and college football as examples. Big fans and casual fans took the survey.)
- Part 6. How closely do you follow the NFL?
- Part 6. To what extent do you support or oppose the Chiefs' decision to sign Justin Tucker?
- Part 6. Which of the following broader societal problems, if any, does the Chiefs' decision reflect? (Select up to 11, choosing every one that applies)
- Part 6. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Successful men can face serious allegations and still retain opportunities unavailable to ordinary people
- Part 6. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Organizations are willing to tolerate allegations of misconduct when someone is sufficiently valuable
- Part 6. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Women who report misconduct often have more to lose professionally than the people they accuse
- Part 6. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The reputations of powerful men are often treated as more important than the well-being of those making allegations
- Part 6. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The Chiefs' decision reinforces the perception that there are different rules for celebrities and ordinary people
- Part 6. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The ability to return to work after disciplinary action should not depend on someone's fame or financial value
- Part 6. What emotional reaction, if any, do you believe the Chiefs' decision could provoke among people who have experienced sexual misconduct? (Select up to 12, choosing every one that applies)
- Part 6. Do you believe the decision could undermine people's confidence that organizations will protect them if they report sexual misconduct?
- Part 6. In your opinion, what responsibility do organizations have toward people who report allegations of sexual misconduct when deciding whether to hire or rehire the accused individual? (Select up to 10, choosing every one that applies)
- Part 6. What message do you believe this decision sends to young men? (Select up to 9, choosing every one that applies)
- Part 6. What message do you believe this decision sends to young women? (Select up to 9, choosing every one that applies)
- Part 6. If a teenage girl asked you what the Chiefs' decision says about how society treats women who report sexual misconduct, what would you tell her? (open-ended, coded by Ask Brox into its own themes)
- Part 7. Do you consider yourself a fan of any professional or college sports? (Screener; the fielded wording named the NFL, four other leagues and college football as examples. Big fans and casual fans took the survey.)
- Part 7. How closely do you follow the NFL?
- Part 7. To what extent do you support or oppose the Chiefs' decision to sign Justin Tucker?
- Part 7. Before today, how familiar were you with the controversy surrounding the Cleveland Browns signing Deshaun Watson?
- Part 7. How similar do you believe the Chiefs' decision to sign Justin Tucker is to the Browns' decision to acquire Deshaun Watson?
- Part 7. Which of the following messages, if any, do you believe BOTH decisions communicate about the NFL? (Select up to 11, choosing every one that applies)
- Part 7. Which organization's decision do you believe reflects more negatively on its values?
- Part 7. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The Chiefs' decision shows the NFL has not learned from the controversy surrounding Deshaun Watson
- Part 7. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The Browns' decision to acquire Watson established a precedent that other NFL teams are now following
- Part 7. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Both situations reinforce the perception that allegations made by women are secondary to men's professional success
- Part 7. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: When multiple NFL teams make similar decisions, it suggests a broader cultural problem rather than isolated poor judgment
- Part 7. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The NFL's treatment of players accused of sexual misconduct discourages women from coming forward
- Part 7. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The Browns' decision was more concerning because of the size and guaranteed nature of Watson's contract
- Part 7. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The Chiefs' decision is more understandable because Tucker has already served his suspension
- Part 7. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Both players should have the opportunity to continue their careers after completing the NFL's disciplinary requirements
- Part 7. Does seeing the Chiefs make this decision after the controversy surrounding Deshaun Watson change your perception of how seriously the NFL takes allegations of sexual misconduct?
- Part 7. When you consider both the Chiefs' and Browns' decisions, which of the following do you believe best describes how women who report sexual misconduct are treated within professional sports?
- Part 7. In your own words, what do the situations involving Justin Tucker and Deshaun Watson, taken together, tell you about how the NFL treats allegations of sexual misconduct involving its players? (open-ended, coded by Ask Brox into its own themes)
- Part 7. What factors make one team's decision more or less acceptable than the other's? (Select up to 3)
- Part 2. Does this decision make you think the Chiefs' leadership takes allegations of sexual misconduct seriously? (a question Ask Brox added)
- Part 5. Do you think the Chiefs would have made the same decision if Justin Tucker were not a well-known NFL player with a strong record? (a question Ask Brox added)
- Part 4. Thinking about the Kansas City Chiefs as an organization, what does this decision suggest to you about the team's values? (a question Ask Brox added)
What was not asked, and why
age, gender, income and region were not asked: they come from each clone's own profile; nobody was asked whether Tucker was guilty, and no person who made an allegation was named
What changed from the obvious question
the 64-question study plan ran as seven studies of 200 sports fans, each opening with a sports-fan screener, how closely the respondent follows the NFL and whether they support or oppose the signing; the neutral news summary (and, in Part 7, the study plan's summary of the Deshaun Watson case) was given to Ask Brox as study background so every respondent carried it into every answer; the questions about awareness and opinion of the Chiefs before the news came from a separate first fielding of Part 1, asked before any description; Ask Brox added five to seven questions of its own to each part with an open-ended question and replaced one open question, 'what does the decision make you think about the organization?', with closed questions; 'select all that apply' questions were fielded as 'select up to N, choosing every one that applies'
More on When a story breaks · Brand trust · Public opinion · Sports & live events
Ask this of your own audience: humans@brox.ai
More in Sports & live events
All in Sports & live events-
100% of US adult clones call a secret, sexual AI affair cheating, against 1% when a partner discloses flirting with an AI that is not sexual
100% 100% rate a partner's secret, sexual relationship with an AI companion as cheating (6 or 7 of 7), against 1% when the partner told them about flirting that was not sexual (base 200)
Read -
89% strongly praise weight lost through diet and exercise, against 1% when the same weight is lost on medication
89% 89% give strong praise to Diet-and-Exercise Jordan, against 1% for Medication Jordan, who lost the same 60 pounds (separate samples) (base 200)
Read -
82% of US men would not get a hair transplant, and 98% of those who see their hair thinning rule one out
82% 82% of US men are not open to getting a hair transplant, and none say they are very open (base 200)
Read