Research study

US Independents: 2% say other Independents are mostly similar to them, and independence is their second value

Of 200 US clones who identify as political Independents, 2% say other Independents are mostly similar to them, while 26% say it depends and 22.5% say mostly different (n=200, September 2026).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
US independents, 200 clones, US
When
September 2026 (fielded 28 September 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
Rather than asking which way Independents lean, the study asked whether they see other Independents as like them at all, and had them rate how well each part of their self-description fits.

Section 01: What the study found

  1. #

    2%

    say other Independents are mostly similar to them, against 36.5% somewhat similar, 26% it depends and 22.5% mostly different

    base 200

  2. #

    63%

    name family as a value most important to who they are, with independence second at 13.5% and faith at 12%

    base 200 · contrast

  3. #

    41%

    describe themselves as kind or caring, more than double the 16% who say friendly or outgoing

    base 200 · contrast

  4. #

    88%

    say their values describe them extremely well, against 16.5% for their identities and 8.5% for their aspirations

    base 200 · contrast

  5. #

    43.5%

    say family upbringing most shaped who they are, well ahead of parenting or caregiving at 15.5%

    base 200 · contrast

  6. #

    3%

    name political ideology as the part of their identity that shapes how they see themselves; family role leads at 44.5%

    base 200 · contrast

say other Independents are mostly similar to them, against 36.5% somewhat similar, 26% it depends and 22.5% mostly different

Somewhat similar (base 200)
36.5%
Depends (base 200)
26%
Mostly different (base 200)
22.5%
Other (base 200)
12.5%
Mostly similar (base 200)
2%

Base 200 clones.

02Do Independents see themselves as a group?

Hardly at all. Asked whether other Independents are similar to them or different, 4 of 200 (2%) said mostly similar. The rest spread across somewhat similar (73 of 200), it depends (52) and mostly different (45).

03What do they value, if not a shared label?

Family first, then independence itself. 126 of 200 (63%) name family as a core value and 27 (13.5%) independence, ahead of faith (24 of 200). Asked what is most central to who they are at their core, 114 of 200 (57%) said family first and 18 (9%) an independent mind.

Political ideology shapes how they see themselves for 6 of 200; family role does for 89 of 200 (44.5%).

04How sure are they of who they are?

Very, when it comes to values and character. 176 of 200 (88%) say their values describe them extremely well and 162 (81%) their personal qualities. For identities the figure is 33 of 200 (16.5%) and for aspirations 17 of 200 (8.5%).

Kind or caring is the self-description for 82 of 200 (41%), more than double friendly or outgoing (32 of 200).

05What would you do with this?

  1. A reading, not the panel's answer: Independent is a poor segment on its own. Messages built on a shared Independent identity have little to stand on here.
  2. A second reading: self-reliance is a value to speak to directly, and language that respects autonomy fits how these clones describe themselves.

Section 06: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • Almost none feel part of a cohesive group: 4 of 200 say other Independents are mostly similar, and 97 of 200 say it depends or mostly different.
  • Independence is a named value here: 27 of 200 name it as a core value, second only to family (126 of 200), and 18 of 200 call an independent mind the most central thing about them.
  • They describe themselves confidently through values (176 of 200 say extremely well) and qualities (162 of 200), far more than through identities (33) or aspirations (17).

What we would not

  • Generation and gender splits: the readout gives percentages without stating the bases.
  • A direct comparison of the 'extremely well' ratings with the Republican and Democrat studies, which asked a single forced choice instead.
  • Any sum across the values, qualities or identity questions: answers were coded into several themes each.

The main limitation

The page is built from the published readout, not a fresh pull of the per-clone answers, so the data table is the readout's own coding and the question wording is its headings.

Section 07: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Self-identified political Independents200

Question wording as fielded

  1. Screener: identify as a political Independent (200 fielded)
  2. Which values feel most important to who you are?
  3. What feels most central to who you are at your core?
  4. Which personal qualities do you see in yourself?
  5. Which parts of your identity shape how you see yourself?
  6. Are other Independents similar to you, or different?
  7. How well does each of these describe who you are: values, personal qualities, life experiences, identities, aspirations? (share saying extremely well, each on 200)
  8. What kinds of life experiences have most shaped who you are?
  9. What are you most hoping to become or live out more fully?

What was not asked, and why

Clones were not asked which party they lean towards, how they vote or about specific policies, and the readout does not report the size of the screener. The readout does not give the exact question wording, the per-clone rows or the interview lines behind its quotes, so this page carries no quotes and the questions are listed as the readout headed them. Generation and gender splits in the readout are left out because their bases are not stated. Open answers were coded into themes and one answer can carry more than one theme, so on the values, qualities and identity questions the shares add to more than 100% and cannot be summed.

What changed from the obvious question

Rather than asking which way Independents lean, the study asked whether they see other Independents as like them at all, and had them rate how well each part of their self-description fits.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai

More in Public affairs & society

All in Public affairs & society