Research study

US baseball fans: 93% have never bought because of a brand's baseball tie-in, and high prices are the top turn-off for 50%

93% of qualified US baseball fans say they have never bought from a brand because of its baseball connection, and 50% say high prices are what most make them less likely to buy from a brand that markets to them (n=200, September 2026).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
US baseball fans, 400 clones, US
When
September 2026 (fielded 29 September 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
Rather than asking whether sponsorship works, the brand study asked separately what puts fans off, what they welcome, what decides whether a partnership feels positive and whether a baseball tie-in has ever driven a purchase, so price, trust and the tie-in itself could be separated.

Section 01: What the study found

  1. #

    50%

    50% of qualified US baseball fans say high prices make them less likely to buy from a brand that markets to baseball fans, more than misaligned values (19.5%) and untrustworthy marketing (14%) combined.

    base 200

  2. #

    93%

    93% have never bought from a brand specifically because of its baseball connection, and 86.5% cannot name a brand's baseball messaging they like.

    base 200

  3. #

    32.5%

    Brand trust (32.5%) is what most decides whether fans see a baseball partnership positively, ahead of good values (20%), fan loyalty (15.5%) and supporting the team (2%).

    base 200 · contrast

  4. #

    45.5%

    Sportswear is the brand category most likely to drive a purchase (45.5%), more than double media and streaming (16.5%).

    base 200 · contrast

  5. #

    53.5%

    53.5% usually follow baseball on broadcast TV; highlights clips (20%) and social media (19%) each reach about a fifth.

    base 200 · contrast

  6. #

    62%

    62% rarely (41%) or never (21%) attend a game in person; 1.5% go several times a month.

    base 200 · caveat

50% of qualified US baseball fans say high prices make them less likely to buy from a brand that markets to baseball fans, more than misaligned values (19.5%) and untrustworthy marketing (14%) combined.

High prices (base 200)
50%
Misaligned values (base 200)
19.5%
Untrustworthy marketing (base 200)
14%
Overexposure / annoyance (base 200)
6.5%
Bad customer service (base 200)
5.5%
Poor product quality (base 200)
2.5%

Base 200 clones.

02Does a baseball tie-in make fans buy?

Almost never, on this panel. 186 of 200 qualified US baseball fans (93%) say they have never bought from a brand specifically because of its baseball connection, and 173 of 200 (86.5%) cannot name a brand's baseball messaging they particularly like.

The strictest reading is that a baseball partnership is not, on its own, a conversion channel for this audience. What it can do is earn attention and trust, which is how the fans themselves describe what they want from it.

03What stops a fan buying, and what earns the sale?

Price, by a wide margin. 50% (n=200) say high prices are what make them less likely to buy from a brand that markets to baseball fans, more than misaligned values (19.5%) and untrustworthy marketing (14%) put together.

The positive side mirrors it. Deals and value are the most welcomed kind of partnership (30%, n=200), just ahead of community impact (27%), and well ahead of authentic brand fit (9%) or player stories (3%). When fans judge whether a partnership feels positive at all, brand trust (32.5%) and good values (20%) outweigh fan loyalty (15.5%) and directly supporting the team (2%) combined. Asked what actually drives a purchase, product fit (24%) leads good deals (18%) and proof and details (15%).

04Where do fans actually meet baseball?

On a screen, mostly at home. Broadcast TV is how 53.5% (n=200) usually follow the game, with highlights clips (20%) and social media (19%) each reaching about a fifth. Among social platforms, Facebook (31.5%) and YouTube (25.5%) lead Instagram (14.5%) and X (9%).

Going to the ballpark is the exception. 41% rarely attend in person and 21% never do, while 1.5% go several times a month. The fandom is old and quiet: 70% became fans in early childhood or have been fans for as long as they can remember, and the single most common way of engaging with it is privately (34%), ahead of watching with others (22%). Only 3% participate in baseball on social media.

05Which teams and categories carry the audience?

No single team or player does. The most-named favorite team is picked by 10% (n=200), and 63% name a team outside the top nine. Players fragment the same way: the two most-named, Aaron Judge (14%) and Shohei Ohtani (13.5%), sit in a field where 61.5% name someone else entirely.

Among brand categories one stands apart. Sportswear is the category most likely to drive a purchase (45.5%, n=200), more than double media and streaming (16.5%), with fast food (6.5%), beer and alcohol (5%) and sports betting (1.5%) far behind. Online, fans engage most positively with their favorite team itself (39.5%) rather than any brand. Betting is a minority habit: 14.5% (n=200) bet on MLB games.

06What would a sponsor do differently on Monday?

These are readings of the findings, not the panel's own answers.

  1. Lead with value, not prestige. High prices are the top turn-off (50%) and deals the most welcomed partnership (30%), so a discount-forward activation fits this audience better than premium positioning.
  2. Earn trust before leaning on the tie-in. Brand trust (32.5%) matters more than team loyalty, so an established, credible brand gains more from a baseball partnership than an unfamiliar one.
  3. Buy reach across the league, not one club. With the top team at 10% and the top player at 14%, a single-team or single-player deal reaches a narrow slice.
  4. Judge it on awareness. With 93% never having bought because of a baseball connection, direct sales attribution will understate what the partnership does.

Section 07: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • Price is the dominant turn-off: 100 of 200 name high prices, more than the next two reasons together.
  • A baseball connection rarely drives a purchase: 186 of 200 have never bought because of one.
  • This is a screen-first fandom: 107 of 200 usually follow on broadcast TV, and 124 of 200 rarely or never attend.

What we would not

  • Any link between the viewing and the brand figures for the same person: they are two separate samples of 200, so a claim such as 'TV watchers are the price-sensitive ones' is not supported.
  • A single weekly-viewing figure: the source readout's '57.5% watch at least weekly' does not reconcile with its own frequency table (daily, several times a week and weekly sum to 37.5%).
  • The small options to the decimal, where 'Other' takes 47.5% to 63% of the favorite team, favorite player, social platform and online engagement questions.
  • Any cut by generation, gender or region: the studies do not tabulate them and sub-groups would fall under 30.
  • The screener pass rates (34.5% and 37.1%) as an estimate of how many US adults follow baseball.

The main limitation

Two US panels of 200 qualified baseball fans each, screened from 746 and 736; every figure is stated intent or self-description, not observed purchasing.

Section 08: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Screened for the viewing habits study746
Qualified baseball fans, viewing habits study200
Screened for the brand partnership study736
Qualified baseball fans, brand partnership study200

Question wording as fielded

  1. Screener (both studies): do you follow Major League Baseball? 746 adults screened for the viewing study, 736 for the brand study
  2. When did you first become a baseball fan?
  3. How do you engage with baseball fandom socially?
  4. How do you usually follow baseball content? (multi-select)
  5. Which social platforms do you use to keep up with baseball? (multi-select)
  6. How often do you watch baseball during the season?
  7. How often do you attend games in person?
  8. Who is your favourite MLB team?
  9. Who is your favourite MLB player?
  10. Do you bet on MLB games?
  11. Which brands do you engage with most positively online as a baseball fan?
  12. Which brand categories are most likely to drive a purchase from you?
  13. Which types of brand partnership do you view most positively?
  14. What matters most in whether you see a brand's baseball partnership positively?
  15. What makes you less likely to buy from or engage with a brand that markets to baseball fans?
  16. What actually drives you to buy from a brand?
  17. Have you ever bought from a brand specifically because of its baseball connection?
  18. Is there a brand's baseball messaging you particularly like?
  19. Which everyday brand categories do you buy from most?

What was not asked, and why

No sponsor or specific brand was put in front of respondents, and the studies did not ask about spend, ticket prices or pay-TV and streaming costs.

What changed from the obvious question

Rather than asking whether sponsorship works, the brand study asked separately what puts fans off, what they welcome, what decides whether a partnership feels positive and whether a baseball tie-in has ever driven a purchase, so price, trust and the tie-in itself could be separated.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai

More in Sports & live events

All in Sports & live events