Research study

Safety, not a surcharge: 57% of US women say a price premium on a women-driver safety option feels exploitative, and 93% want a guaranteed price match to standard rides

57% of US women say a price premium on Uber's Women Drivers safety option feels exploitative and 93% say a guaranteed price match to standard rides would win their confidence, though only 7 of 600 had heard of the option before the survey (three studies of n=200, October 2026).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
US women, 200 clones, US
When
October 2026 (fielded 23 October 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
the 38-question study plan ran as three studies because one study fields at most 20 questions; questions for women who had used the option carried a 'Not applicable' option because Ask Brox asks everyone every question; Ask Brox showed every respondent the study's background (the option, Uber's no-extra-charge position, reported prices of up to double, the one-in-five driver share and the lawsuit); Ask Brox added five questions of its own to Part 3, marked in the questions

Section 01: What the study found

  1. #

    57%

    of US women say a price premium on a women-driver safety option feels exploitative, 35% would accept a modest one and 8% call it fair; in a separate sample 62% say a safety feature should always cost the same as a standard ride or less

    base 200

  2. #

    91%

    say getting into a car with a male stranger is a safety concern the option addresses for them, with riding alone (70%) far ahead of late-night or early-morning rides (12%)

    base 200 · contrast

  3. #

    75%

    say Uber describing the match as 'a preference, not a guarantee' reduces how safe the option makes them feel, 22% significantly

    base 200 · contrast

  4. #

    93%

    say a guaranteed price match to standard rides would make them trust and use the option more confidently, ahead of more women drivers (53%) and an upfront warning of a price increase (52%); 88% are less likely to use it when the final price is uncertain

    base 200 · contrast

  5. #

    70%

    are somewhat skeptical of Uber's claim that the option carries no extra charge, 29% largely or completely distrust it and 2% mostly trust it; 85% say the inconsistency affects their trust in Uber as a company

    base 200 · contrast

  6. #

    7

    women across the three studies had heard of the Women Drivers option before the survey and none had used it, so every answer is a reaction to the option as described, not experience of it

    base 600 · caveat

of US women say a price premium on a women-driver safety option feels exploitative, 35% would accept a modest one and 8% call it fair; in a separate sample 62% say a safety feature should always cost the same as a standard ride or less

Feels exploitative: charging more for a safety feature is wrong
57%
Feels acceptable if the premium is modest
35%
Feels fair: safety is worth paying for
8%

Base 200 clones.

02Had US women heard of the Women Drivers option?

Almost none. Only 7 of the 600 women across three studies of 200 had heard of Uber's Women Drivers option before the survey, and none had used it. Every question meant for women who had used it came back 'Not applicable', nobody had seen the reports of higher prices, the one-in-five driver share or the California lawsuit, and 95% (n=200) were not sure how the option is priced.

They ride little, too: 57% of Part 1 (n=200) never use ride-hailing apps, and 6 of 200 use them a few times a month or more. Below, riders are the women who use the apps at all (43% [n=200] in Part 1, 36% [n=200] in Part 3).

03What does a women-driver option answer for women?

The fear of a male stranger. Personal safety weighs significantly in ride-hailing decisions for 97% (n=200), and 90% feel only moderately safe using the apps, none of them very safe. Getting into a car with a male stranger (91%) and riding alone (70%) are the concerns the option addresses, far ahead of late-night rides (12%); the male-stranger concern is near universal under 45 (99% [n=95], against 84% [n=103] of those 45 or older).

The reassurance is conditional. Told it is 'a preference, not a guarantee', 75% (n=200) say the option feels less safe, 22% significantly. Knowing the option exists makes 47% (n=86) of riders feel somewhat safer, against 4% (n=114) of women who never ride.

04Should a safety feature cost more?

No. 57% (n=200) say a price premium for a safety feature feels exploitative, 35% would accept a modest one and 8% call it fair. Asked again in Part 3 (n=200), 62% say a safety feature should always cost the same as a standard ride or less, 39% accept a higher price if it is clearly disclosed in advance, and nobody accepts it regardless of disclosure. The disclosed-premium camp is larger among riders (47% [n=72], against 34% [n=128] of non-riders).

The driver shortage explains the price without excusing it. Told that only about one in five US Uber drivers are women, 86% (n=200) find the price variability more understandable and 14% more frustrated, with under-45s the most likely to be frustrated (20% [n=96], against 9% [n=102]).

05Do they believe Uber's no-extra-charge claim?

Mostly not. Given the reported price inconsistency, 70% (n=200) are somewhat skeptical of the claim, 29% largely or completely distrust it and 2% mostly trust it; women who never ride distrust it more (35% [n=128], against 18% [n=72] of riders).

They see a planning failure rather than a deception: 73% (n=200) say the price increases are something Uber should have anticipated and fixed before launch, 20% a genuine side effect of driver supply and 3% intentionally misleading marketing. It reaches the company: 85% say it affects their trust in Uber as a company (39% significantly), and 93% say Uber has handled the rollout and pricing unfairly, most of them somewhat (88%).

06What would win them, and where do they stand on the lawsuit?

Certainty. 88% (n=200) say not knowing the final price makes them less likely to use the option, 77% significantly. A guaranteed price match to standard rides would build their confidence for 93%, then more women drivers (53%) and an upfront warning (52%); a consistent, stated surcharge appeals to 1%. All 200 want Uber required to show a price comparison before a rider confirms, and asked in their own words what Uber should do, 173 of the 200 say keep the no-extra-charge promise. In a question Ask Brox added, 90% would switch to a standard ride if the fare shown were higher, rising to 95% (n=128) of non-riders.

Nobody sides with the lawsuit. None had heard of the California lawsuit arguing the option discriminates against male drivers; once told, 60% (n=200) call the option a reasonable safety measure and the lawsuit misguided, 38% see valid points on both sides and none say the lawsuit has merit. Riders are the firmest (68% [n=72], against 55% [n=128] of non-riders).

07What would you do with this?

Two readings, offered as readings rather than as the panel's own answer. The option answers a real fear, but its promise is only as good as its price: with almost nobody aware of it yet, the first impression most women will form is of the fare, so price parity, or a firm price shown before booking, matters more than any message about safety. And the match itself needs to be more certain, because 'a preference, not a guarantee' takes back part of the reassurance the option exists to give.

Section 08: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“To me, that feels exploitative. Safety shouldn't be treated like some luxury add-on that you have to pay extra for. If something is a basic necessity for a person's well-being and security, charging more for it just feels like the company is taking advantage of people. A woman shouldn't have to pay a higher price just to feel secure.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“It depends on what the product or service is and how I would react if it's something that I necessarily need to survive. And I guess I would pay it, but just think that they're taking advantage of me.”

Baby Boomer woman, 65 or older, US, Part 1, on a price premium supports finding 1

“I think it's acceptable as long as it's clearly disclosed in advance. Honesty and transparency from a company are really important to me, so as long as riders are fully aware of any price differences upfront and there are no hidden surprises, people can decide for themselves whether it fits their budget and is worth the cost.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Well, I would first consider whether it's still worth the cost, if it still fits my budget and needs.”

Gen X woman, 45 to 64, US, Part 3, on whether it should ever cost more supports finding 1

“Basically, I would have to say concerns about getting into a car with a male stranger and concerns about riding alone generally. Nowadays, it is really hard to trust anyone, especially people you don't know, so being alone in a vehicle with a strange man definitely makes you worry about your safety.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“it's really hard to trust anyone nowadays, especially if you don't know them”

Gen X woman, 45 to 64, US, Part 1, on the concerns it addresses supports finding 2

“If I was using something like that, I would want to know for sure that it's actually going to happen. Knowing it isn't guaranteed kind of takes away from the point, so I'd say it somewhat reduces how safe it makes you feel. I like things that are guaranteed, but having the option is probably still better than nothing.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I would flip a coin and do the one that I'm guaranteed to win something.”

Gen X woman, 45 to 64, US, Part 1, on 'a preference, not a guarantee' supports finding 3

“Personally, I would definitely switch to the standard ride. I really hate overly expensive things, especially when something is more expensive than the regular price. I don't really have money to just throw away like that, so if picking a woman driver costs more, I'm just going to choose the standard option to get the cheaper fare.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Personally, I wouldn't really take it well because I hate things that are like overly expensive. I hate overly expensive things.”

Gen Z woman, 18 to 29, US, Part 3, on a higher fare supports finding 4

“Honestly, it makes me more frustrated and Uber should solve this before charging more. Prices are already high and they keep going up as it is, so having to pay potentially double just to feel safe because there aren't enough women drivers isn't right. Uber needs to fix that imbalance instead of passing the extra cost onto us.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I wouldn't react in a good way because prices are already high and they're still going up.”

Gen Z woman, 18 to 29, US, Part 3, on the one-in-five driver share supports finding 4

“I think Uber should keep their promise and make sure there really is no extra charge. If they advertise that it doesn't cost anything extra, they should stick to their word and make sure the price doesn't go up for women who just want to feel safe.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I do stick to a strict budget.”

Gen X woman, 45 to 64, US, Part 3, on what Uber should do supports finding 5

“I think the feature is a reasonable safety option and the lawsuit is misguided. Women just want to feel safe when they're getting a ride, especially when they're alone. Making sure people are safe and taken care of is just common sense to me, and filing a lawsuit over something meant to protect women seems ridiculous.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“The most important thing in my life is my family and their happiness. Making sure everyone is okay and taken care of.”

Gen X woman, 45 to 64, US, Part 3, on the lawsuit supports finding 5

Section 09: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • women see a women-driver option as an answer to a real fear: a male stranger in the car, above all when riding alone
  • paying more for a safety feature is widely rejected, and a clearly disclosed premium is the most a minority will accept
  • price uncertainty deters more than the price itself, and a guaranteed price match is the confidence builder almost everyone names
  • skepticism about the no-extra-charge claim is the norm once the reported pricing is known, and it reaches trust in the company
  • the lawsuit against the option finds no support

What we would not

  • any figure as experience of the option: 7 of 600 had heard of it and none had used it, so every question for users came back 'Not applicable'
  • the answers as uninfluenced: every respondent saw the study's background, and 107 of 200 Part 1 answers on a price premium mention doubling or surge pricing, which that question does not
  • riders as frequent riders: 57% to 65% never use ride-hailing apps, so 'riders' means anyone who rides at all
  • near-unanimous answers as exact: a required price comparison (all 200) and safety weighing significantly in ride decisions are best read as direction
  • the all-respondent figures as the picture for all US women: Black women are 30%, 30% and 28% of the three samples, about twice their US share
  • any person-by-person link between the parts: they are separate samples (224 different women, 170 in all three) and no answer is joined across them

The main limitation

the clones had not heard of an option launched in 2026 and saw the study's background before answering, so the figures are reactions to the option and its reported pricing as described, not experience of it

Section 10: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Part 1: women200
Part 2: women200
Part 3: women200
Part 1: ride-hailing riders (at least rarely)86
Part 1: never use ride-hailing apps114
Part 3: ride-hailing riders (at least rarely)72
Part 3: never use ride-hailing apps128
Part 1: aged under 4595
Part 1: aged 45 or older103
Part 3: aged under 4596
Part 3: aged 45 or older102

Question wording as fielded

  1. Part 1. Do you identify as a woman? (screener: 255 of 382 qualified; 200 of them were fielded)
  2. Part 1. How often do you use ride-hailing apps like Uber or Lyft?
  3. Part 1. Do you typically ride alone or with others when you use ride-hailing apps?
  4. Part 1. Do you live primarily in an urban, suburban, or rural area?
  5. Part 1. Were you aware that Uber offers a "Women Drivers" or "Women Preferences" option that matches women riders with women drivers?
  6. Part 1. Have you personally used Uber's "Women Drivers" option?
  7. Part 1. In general, how safe do you feel using ride-hailing apps like Uber or Lyft?
  8. Part 1. How much does personal safety factor into your decisions about using ride-hailing apps (such as time of day or riding alone versus with others)?
  9. Part 1. Does simply knowing a Women Drivers option exists make you feel safer about using ride-hailing apps in general, even on rides where you don't use it?
  10. Part 1. If you have used the Women Drivers option, did using it make you personally feel safer during that specific ride, compared to a standard ride?
  11. Part 1. Which specific safety concerns, if any, does the Women Drivers feature help address for you? (Select up to 2)
  12. Part 1. Uber describes its Women Drivers option as a "preference," not a guarantee, meaning a match with a woman driver isn't certain every time. Does knowing it isn't guaranteed affect how safe the feature makes you feel?
  13. Part 1. Given that safety is the Women Drivers feature's stated purpose, how does the idea of a potential price premium for it make you feel?
  14. Part 2. Do you identify as a woman? (screener: 229 of 342 qualified; 200 of them were fielded)
  15. Part 2. How often do you use ride-hailing apps like Uber or Lyft?
  16. Part 2. Were you aware that Uber offers a "Women Drivers" or "Women Preferences" option that matches women riders with women drivers?
  17. Part 2. Have you personally used Uber's "Women Drivers" option?
  18. Part 2. Before this survey, were you aware that Uber states its Women Drivers option does not carry an extra charge compared to a standard ride?
  19. Part 2. Where, if anywhere, did you learn about this pricing claim or the Women Drivers feature generally? (Select up to 2) (recorded by Ask Brox as one answer per clone)
  20. Part 2. Thinking about your own experience of the Women Drivers option, if you have used it, how did the price compare to a standard ride (UberX) at the same time and location?
  21. Part 2. Have you ever experienced a lower price with the Women Drivers option, compared to a standard ride at the same time and place?
  22. Part 2. Have you ever experienced a higher price with the Women Drivers option, compared to a standard ride at the same time and place?
  23. Part 2. When you used the Women Drivers option, did the app clearly show you, before you confirmed the ride, that the price might differ from a standard ride?
  24. Part 2. If you have used the Women Drivers option, how did any price difference (if you experienced one) affect how you felt about the feature?
  25. Part 2. Have you seen anecdotal reports, screenshots, or social media posts about Uber's Women Drivers option costing more than a standard ride?
  26. Part 2. Based on everything you know, what's your honest guess about how the Women Drivers option is priced in practice, on average?
  27. Part 3. Do you identify as a woman? (screener: 241 of 359 qualified; 200 of them were fielded)
  28. Part 3. How often do you use ride-hailing apps like Uber or Lyft?
  29. Part 3. Were you aware that Uber offers a "Women Drivers" or "Women Preferences" option that matches women riders with women drivers?
  30. Part 3. How much do you trust Uber's claim that its Women Drivers option carries no extra charge, given the pricing inconsistency that's been reported?
  31. Part 3. Do you think the price increases some riders have experienced with the Women Drivers option are: (Select one)
  32. Part 3. Does this kind of pricing inconsistency affect your overall trust in Uber as a company, beyond just this specific feature?
  33. Part 3. Do you think Uber should be required to show a clear price comparison (standard fare vs. the Women Drivers option's fare) before a rider confirms the request?
  34. Part 3. Were you aware that only about 1 in 5 Uber drivers in the U.S. are women, which limits how often this matching feature can find a driver?
  35. Part 3. Knowing that only about 1 in 5 Uber drivers in the U.S. are women, does the price variability of the Women Drivers option feel more understandable to you, or does it not change your view?
  36. Part 3. In general, do you think a safety-oriented feature like this should ever be allowed to cost more than a standard ride, regardless of the underlying reason?
  37. Part 3. Were you aware that a lawsuit has been filed in California arguing that Uber's women-only matching feature is discriminatory, since it excludes male drivers from those rides?
  38. Part 3. Regardless of your awareness, what's your view on this kind of legal challenge to Uber's women-only matching feature?
  39. Part 3. Does uncertainty about the final price affect your likelihood of using the Women Drivers feature, or would it if you haven't tried it?
  40. Part 3. What would make you trust and use the Women Drivers feature more confidently? (Select up to 2)
  41. Part 3. Overall, how fairly do you think Uber has handled the rollout and pricing of the Women Drivers feature?
  42. Part 3. In your own words, what should Uber do, if anything, to resolve the gap between its "no extra charge" promise and what riders have actually experienced? (open-ended, coded by Ask Brox into its own groups)
  43. Part 3. What concerns, if any, would you have about using Uber's Women Drivers feature? (added by Ask Brox; open answers coded into its own groups)
  44. Part 3. If Uber clearly explained before booking that Women Drivers may cost more at times because the pool of women drivers is smaller, how would that affect your view of the feature? (added by Ask Brox)
  45. Part 3. If you used Uber's Women Drivers feature and the fare shown was higher than a standard Uber ride, what would you be most likely to do? (added by Ask Brox)
  46. Part 3. Which change from Uber would do the most to reassure you about using Women Drivers? (added by Ask Brox; open answers coded into its own groups)
  47. Part 3. Thinking about Uber's Women Drivers feature, how well do you think it actually helps women riders feel safer? (added by Ask Brox)

What was not asked, and why

age, income and region were not asked: they come from each clone's own profile; how often they use ride-hailing apps and whether they knew of the option were asked in all three parts, and use of it in Parts 1 and 2

What changed from the obvious question

the 38-question study plan ran as three studies because one study fields at most 20 questions; questions for women who had used the option carried a 'Not applicable' option because Ask Brox asks everyone every question; Ask Brox showed every respondent the study's background (the option, Uber's no-extra-charge position, reported prices of up to double, the one-in-five driver share and the lawsuit); Ask Brox added five questions of its own to Part 3, marked in the questions

Ask this of your own audience: humans@brox.ai

More in Technology & devices

All in Technology & devices