Research study
Trusted more than politicians, elected by almost no one: 90% of US adults say a cat would be more trustworthy than most politicians, but 3% would vote for one
90% of US adults say a cat would be more trustworthy than most politicians, yet 3% would vote for one and 19% would vote for neither candidate (n=200 per sample, November 2026).
- Who was asked
- US adults, 200 clones, US
- When
- November 2026 (fielded 3 November 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- the 49 respondent-facing questions ran as six parts of 9 or 10: the trust baseline first, with no mention of the cat, and every clone in Parts 2 to 6 given the full hypothetical scenario before any question; party identification was asked in every part and the cat or human vote in Parts 2 to 6, so every part can be cut by both; the question on reasons to consider the cat carried a Not applicable option instead of being shown only to those open to it; 'select all that apply' was fielded as 'select up to N, choosing every one that applies'
Section 01: What the study found
- #
90%
of US adults agree a cat would be more trustworthy than most politicians; in the same sample 94% say a cat mayor would be much better than a typical human mayor on honesty, and 99% say the human would be much better on competence
base 200
- #
3%
would vote for the cat in a hypothetical mayoral election against a conventional human candidate, while 19% would vote for neither candidate and 93% definitely would not consider voting for a cat
base 200 · contrast
- #
85%
say any support for a cat would reflect dissatisfaction with politicians a great deal, and none say it would reflect genuine confidence in the candidate; asked before the cat was mentioned, in a separate sample, 55% are very dissatisfied with US political leadership
base 200 · contrast
- #
99%
choose an honest, well-intentioned but inexperienced mayoral candidate over a highly competent one with a documented history of misleading voters; in the same sample 90% would trust neither a cat nor a politician who has broken campaign promises
base 200 · contrast
- #
92%
say demonstrated success managing local services would increase their trust in a human mayoral candidate a great deal, the highest of nine measures; in a separate sample 34% say no listed reform would make them reconsider a candidate they distrusted
base 200 · contrast
- #
52%
of Independents with no party leaning would vote for neither the cat nor the human, against 12% of Republicans and 2% of Democrats, including leaners
base 44 · Independents with no party leaning · contrast
of US adults agree a cat would be more trustworthy than most politicians; in the same sample 94% say a cat mayor would be much better than a typical human mayor on honesty, and 99% say the human would be much better on competence
02Would Americans really rather elect a cat?
No. Offered a domestic cat, supported by professional city staff, against a conventional human candidate with local government experience, 3% of US adults (n=200) would choose the cat and 79% the human. 93% definitely would not consider voting for a cat, and on a 0 to 10 scale of trust as a leader a house cat averages 0.1, against 3.4 for an experienced politician and 4.2 for a first-time independent candidate.
The protest that does show up is voting for no one: 19% would vote for neither candidate. In a separate sample (n=200), with a cat actually on a local ballot, 14% would leave the race blank and 1% would vote for the cat as a symbolic protest.
03Then why does the cat beat politicians on trust?
Because the only thing they credit it with is not lying. 90% of US adults (n=200) agree a cat would be more trustworthy than most politicians, 94% say it would be much better than a typical human mayor on honesty and 98% much better on corruption risk. The same clones give the human competence (99% much better), public safety (98%) and the quality of decisions (96%).
The joke is read as a message, not a vote. 94% agree the idea is funny because it reflects something genuinely wrong with politics, and asked what any support for a cat would reflect, 85% say dissatisfaction with politicians a great deal and none say genuine confidence in the candidate.
04How far has trust in politicians fallen?
Close to the floor. Asked before the cat was mentioned, 1% of US adults (n=200) have a great deal of trust in elected politicians and 88% have not very much or none; 55% are very dissatisfied with the quality of political leadership in the US and 32% somewhat dissatisfied, and 99% agree most politicians put their own interests before the public's. Local government employees fare best, with 51% giving them at least some trust.
Honesty is the quality most often named for a good mayor (84%), and dishonesty the top concern about politicians today (66%, n=181).
05Do they want honesty instead of competence?
They want both, but honesty is the price of entry. In one sample (n=200), 99% choose an honest, well-intentioned but inexperienced candidate who depends on advisors over a highly competent one with a documented history of misleading voters, yet 93% say both honesty and competence are essential. Offered a cat that cannot deceive voters but cannot make informed decisions, or a politician who can but has broken campaign promises, 90% would trust neither.
06What would win their trust back?
A record, not a promise. Demonstrated success managing local services would raise trust in a human mayoral candidate a great deal for 92% of US adults (n=200), ahead of independent financial audits (82%) and term limits (30%). In a separate sample (n=200), 99.5% would definitely choose a human candidate with a strong record of honesty, competence and independence from donors over the cat, and the preferred style of leadership is an honest leader who relies on experts (33%).
Some are past persuading: 34% say no listed reform would make them reconsider a candidate they distrusted. As a purely ceremonial mayor, with elected officials keeping all real authority, a respected local teacher is chosen by 73%, a domestic cat by 11% and a conventional politician by 1% (n=200).
Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“To me, the idea of electing a cat just shows complete distrust in politicians. The truth is, people look at the system and see that politicians on both sides are crooks who are looking out for themselves instead of doing what's right for the people. When folks would consider voting for a household animal over a human leader, it highlights that our leaders have zero credibility left and people view them as corrupt and dishonest.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“The Democrats and the Republicans are both crooks. They should all be thrown out.”
“To be honest, I would choose neither candidate. I've never voted in my life and I don't really have any political views or care about politics or elections at all. A cat obviously can't run a city, but I don't really trust or care about regular politicians either, so there's no reason for me to pick one over the other.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I really have no political views, nor do I care about political views or any of that, to be honest.”
“I would say it's an amusing way to express dissatisfaction with politics. To be honest, politics really isn't my thing, and when you look at politicians, it feels like they're pretty much all liars and crooks anyway. So seeing a cat running for mayor is kind of funny and definitely feels like a good way for people to show just how fed up they are with the usual politicians.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I think that when they're in the office, they're all liars and they're all crooks.”
“For me, the biggest thing is just being honest and straightforward. It feels like people in politics these days are very flippant with the truth, and it's gotten really hard to know who or what to believe. If a politician wants to earn my trust, they need to stop spinning things, tell the truth plainly, and take a more rational, sensible approach to governing rather than making misleading claims.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“Well, it's getting harder all the time to know who to believe and who not to believe. People are very flippant with the truth these days, it seems.”
“For me, to earn my trust, a politician would need to actually care about the everyday people instead of just focusing on advancing themselves. Right now, it feels like neither side really cares about us and the big guy always wins. If they want my trust, they just need to put other people first, listen to what regular folks need, and genuinely focus on helping us.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“Just please focus on other people and help us, otherwise at this point, this country will fall soon.”
“I would just abstain or leave the race blank. The last time I voted was a long time ago, and I don't bother turning out anymore because it's all a show, even at the local level. It doesn't matter if it's two corrupted politicians or a domestic cat on the ticket, it's all just part of the same game. If I was handed a ballot, it would be left blank.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“And how'd you cast your ballot? It's going to be blank because I don't trust politicians.”
Section 08: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- the split the title rests on, within one sample: a cat more trustworthy than most politicians (90%, 81% to 94% across party, gender and age groups) and much more honest (94%), with the human much more competent (99%)
- the cat's vote share (3%, 0% to 6% in every group) against voting for neither candidate (19%)
- the low trust in elected politicians, asked before the cat was mentioned (1% a great deal; 55% very dissatisfied with US political leadership)
- Independents as the group most likely to vote for no one, in two separate samples (52% would vote for neither candidate; 60% would not vote if every candidate disappointed them)
What we would not
- the exact figures on unanimous or near-unanimous items (experience does not make a good leader, the honest candidate over the misleading one, the honest human over the cat, the cat's zero trust as a leader): the agreement is the finding, not the decimal
- the party splits as precise: Independents with no leaning are 37 to 45 clones per sample
- comparisons joined across parts: each part is a separate sample, so the trust baseline in Part 1 and the cat questions in Parts 2 to 6 are read side by side, never as one group's answers
- the headline test as evidence for any headline's claim: the most attention-grabbing headline, chosen by 65%, says Americans would rather elect a cat, which this study finds they would not
The main limitation
clones cluster on shared norms, so several measures came back at or near 100% and carry little spread, and the six samples are separate draws of 200 that share between 58 and 80 clones in any pair, so figures from different parts are read side by side and never joined
Section 09: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Part 1: political trust baseline, before the cat | 200 |
| Part 2: the cat candidate | 200 |
| Part 3: honesty versus competence | 200 |
| Part 4: arrangements and alternatives | 200 |
| Part 5: winning back trust | 200 |
| Part 6: protest and humour | 200 |
Question wording as fielded
- Part 1. How much trust do you currently have in the following institutions or groups?: Your local government
- Part 1. How much trust do you currently have in the following institutions or groups?: Your city's mayor
- Part 1. How much trust do you currently have in the following institutions or groups?: Elected politicians generally
- Part 1. How much trust do you currently have in the following institutions or groups?: The federal government
- Part 1. How much trust do you currently have in the following institutions or groups?: Local government employees
- Part 1. How much trust do you currently have in the following institutions or groups?: Political candidates
- Part 1. How much trust do you currently have in the following institutions or groups?: Your local news media
- Part 1. How would you describe your overall satisfaction with the quality of political leadership in the United States today?
- Part 1. Which three qualities do you believe are most important in a good mayor? (select all that apply)
- Part 1. Which of the following concerns you most about politicians today? (select all that apply)
- Part 1. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Most politicians prioritize their own interests over the public's.
- Part 1. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Political experience does not necessarily make someone a good leader.
- Part 1. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: I would prefer an honest but inexperienced leader over a dishonest but experienced one.
- Part 1. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: I sometimes feel that voting makes little difference.
- Part 1. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: I believe my local government generally acts in residents' best interests.
- Part 1. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: I would consider voting for an unconventional candidate to express dissatisfaction with traditional politics.
- Part 1. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: I trust my local elected officials to make decisions that benefit my community.
- Part 1. How satisfied are you with the performance of your current mayor or equivalent local executive?
- Part 1. How would you describe your political identification?
- Part 1. How would you describe your political views overall?
- Part 1. Which best describes your voting participation in local elections?
- Part 2. If a cat were hypothetically allowed to run for mayor, how seriously would you consider voting for it?
- Part 2. Which candidate would you choose in the following entirely hypothetical election?
- Part 2. How confident are you in your selection of candidate in that hypothetical election?
- Part 2. How would you describe your response to the idea of electing a cat as mayor?
- Part 2. How much trust would you place in each of the following hypothetical leaders, on a scale from 0 (no trust at all) to 10 (complete trust)?: A house cat
- Part 2. How much trust would you place in each of the following hypothetical leaders, on a scale from 0 (no trust at all) to 10 (complete trust)?: A golden retriever
- Part 2. How much trust would you place in each of the following hypothetical leaders, on a scale from 0 (no trust at all) to 10 (complete trust)?: An experienced politician
- Part 2. How much trust would you place in each of the following hypothetical leaders, on a scale from 0 (no trust at all) to 10 (complete trust)?: A first-time independent candidate
- Part 2. How much trust would you place in each of the following hypothetical leaders, on a scale from 0 (no trust at all) to 10 (complete trust)?: An AI-assisted city management system
- Part 2. How much trust would you place in each of the following hypothetical leaders, on a scale from 0 (no trust at all) to 10 (complete trust)?: Your current mayor or equivalent local leader
- Part 2. How likely do you think each of these hypothetical leaders would be to act in the public's best interests?: A house cat
- Part 2. How likely do you think each of these hypothetical leaders would be to act in the public's best interests?: A golden retriever
- Part 2. How likely do you think each of these hypothetical leaders would be to act in the public's best interests?: An experienced politician
- Part 2. How likely do you think each of these hypothetical leaders would be to act in the public's best interests?: A first-time independent candidate
- Part 2. How likely do you think each of these hypothetical leaders would be to act in the public's best interests?: An AI-assisted city management system
- Part 2. How likely do you think each of these hypothetical leaders would be to act in the public's best interests?: Your current mayor or equivalent local leader
- Part 2. Which of the following, if any, make the idea of a cat as mayor appealing to you? (select all that apply)
- Part 2. If you would consider voting for a cat at all: what is the single biggest reason you would consider voting for a cat? (If you would not consider it, choose Not applicable.)
- Part 2. What is the single biggest reason you would oppose a cat becoming mayor?
- Part 3. Which statement comes closest to your own view?
- Part 3. How strongly do you agree or disagree with the following?: A cat would be less likely to intentionally harm the public than a politician.
- Part 3. How strongly do you agree or disagree with the following?: A cat's inability to lie is an advantage over human candidates.
- Part 3. How strongly do you agree or disagree with the following?: A leader can cause serious harm without intending to.
- Part 3. How strongly do you agree or disagree with the following?: An incompetent but well-intentioned leader can be more dangerous than a competent but self-interested one.
- Part 3. How strongly do you agree or disagree with the following?: A cat would be more trustworthy than most politicians.
- Part 3. How strongly do you agree or disagree with the following?: The idea of a cat as mayor is funny because it reflects something genuinely wrong with politics.
- Part 3. How do you think a cat mayor would compare with a typical human mayor in the following areas?: Honesty
- Part 3. How do you think a cat mayor would compare with a typical human mayor in the following areas?: Integrity
- Part 3. How do you think a cat mayor would compare with a typical human mayor in the following areas?: Competence
- Part 3. How do you think a cat mayor would compare with a typical human mayor in the following areas?: Empathy
- Part 3. How do you think a cat mayor would compare with a typical human mayor in the following areas?: Transparency
- Part 3. How do you think a cat mayor would compare with a typical human mayor in the following areas?: Corruption risk
- Part 3. How do you think a cat mayor would compare with a typical human mayor in the following areas?: Accountability
- Part 3. How do you think a cat mayor would compare with a typical human mayor in the following areas?: Public safety
- Part 3. How do you think a cat mayor would compare with a typical human mayor in the following areas?: Quality of decisions
- Part 3. How do you think a cat mayor would compare with a typical human mayor in the following areas?: Ability to unite residents
- Part 3. How much of your hypothetical support for a cat would reflect each of the following?: Genuine confidence in the candidate
- Part 3. How much of your hypothetical support for a cat would reflect each of the following?: Dissatisfaction with politicians
- Part 3. How much of your hypothetical support for a cat would reflect each of the following?: Desire to send a message
- Part 3. How much of your hypothetical support for a cat would reflect each of the following?: Amusement
- Part 3. How much of your hypothetical support for a cat would reflect each of the following?: Belief that professional city employees could perform most governing duties
- Part 3. In your own words, what does the idea of electing a cat reveal, if anything, about how you feel toward politicians today? (open-ended; answers grouped)
- Part 3. Which would you prefer as mayor?
- Part 3. Which candidate would you trust more?
- Part 4. Imagine your city must decide how to allocate $10 million in public funding. Which decision-making arrangement would you trust most?
- Part 4. If the cat were the symbolic mayor, who should hold actual authority over city decisions?
- Part 4. Which hypothetical mayoral arrangement would you prefer?
- Part 4. How much would each of the following increase your trust in a human mayoral candidate?: Independent financial audits
- Part 4. How much would each of the following increase your trust in a human mayoral candidate?: Public disclosure of donor relationships
- Part 4. How much would each of the following increase your trust in a human mayoral candidate?: Binding ethics rules
- Part 4. How much would each of the following increase your trust in a human mayoral candidate?: Transparent voting records
- Part 4. How much would each of the following increase your trust in a human mayoral candidate?: Regular public question-and-answer sessions
- Part 4. How much would each of the following increase your trust in a human mayoral candidate?: Independent investigations of misconduct
- Part 4. How much would each of the following increase your trust in a human mayoral candidate?: Term limits
- Part 4. How much would each of the following increase your trust in a human mayoral candidate?: Demonstrated success managing local services
- Part 4. How much would each of the following increase your trust in a human mayoral candidate?: Citizen oversight committees
- Part 4. Which would concern you more?
- Part 4. If you had to choose one of the following as your city's ceremonial mayor, with elected officials retaining all substantive governing authority, whom would you select?
- Part 4. Which of these hypothetical candidates would you trust most to represent your community's values?
- Part 4. Imagine a candidate with no political experience, no party affiliation, and no connections to major donors. How appealing is that candidate compared with a traditional politician?
- Part 5. Imagine a candidate you initially distrusted introduced the following changes. Which would make you reconsider supporting them? (select all that apply)
- Part 5. Which would do the most to improve your trust in your current local political leadership?
- Part 5. Suppose a human mayoral candidate demonstrated a strong record of honesty, competence, and independence from donors. How likely would you be to choose this person over the cat?
- Part 5. How much would you trust a candidate who openly admitted, "I don't know the answer, but I will consult qualified experts before making a decision"?
- Part 5. Which statement best describes your preferred style of political leadership?
- Part 5. Imagine you were genuinely dissatisfied with every candidate in a local election. What would you be most likely to do?
- Part 5. How likely would you be to vote for a human mayoral candidate if they met all three conditions: a strong ethical record, demonstrated administrative competence, and a commitment to independent oversight?
- Part 5. In your own words, what would a human politician need to do to earn more of your trust? (open-ended; answers grouped)
- Part 6. Which of the following would make you most willing to support an unconventional candidate? (select all that apply)
- Part 6. How concerned would you be about each of the following if a cat became ceremonial mayor?: The symbolic role trivializing local government
- Part 6. How concerned would you be about each of the following if a cat became ceremonial mayor?: Unelected advisers accumulating power
- Part 6. How concerned would you be about each of the following if a cat became ceremonial mayor?: Public policy receiving less attention
- Part 6. How concerned would you be about each of the following if a cat became ceremonial mayor?: Residents feeling more disconnected from politics
- Part 6. How concerned would you be about each of the following if a cat became ceremonial mayor?: Residents becoming more interested in local government
- Part 6. How concerned would you be about each of the following if a cat became ceremonial mayor?: The arrangement distracting from important local issues
- Part 6. Have you ever voted for, considered voting for, or supported a candidate primarily to express dissatisfaction with other candidates?
- Part 6. If a cat actually appeared on a hypothetical local ballot, which of the following best describes what you would do?
- Part 6. How likely would you be to share a news story about a cat running for mayor?
- Part 6. Which headline would most capture your attention?
- Part 6. How seriously did you approach the questions about electing a cat?
What was not asked, and why
the study plan's three optional randomised experiments (honesty against competence profiles, three governing arrangements for the cat, three campaign-finance candidates) were not run, and its information cards for experimental arms were not supplied; the question on the area where respondents live was fielded but is not reported because it did not appear on the dashboard; age, gender and race come from each clone's own profile
What changed from the obvious question
the 49 respondent-facing questions ran as six parts of 9 or 10: the trust baseline first, with no mention of the cat, and every clone in Parts 2 to 6 given the full hypothetical scenario before any question; party identification was asked in every part and the cat or human vote in Parts 2 to 6, so every part can be cut by both; the question on reasons to consider the cat carried a Not applicable option instead of being shown only to those open to it; 'select all that apply' was fielded as 'select up to N, choosing every one that applies'
More on Public opinion · Public affairs & society
Ask this of your own audience: humans@brox.ai
More in Public affairs & society
All in Public affairs & society-
100% of US adult clones call a secret, sexual AI affair cheating, against 1% when a partner discloses flirting with an AI that is not sexual
100% 100% rate a partner's secret, sexual relationship with an AI companion as cheating (6 or 7 of 7), against 1% when the partner told them about flirting that was not sexual (base 200)
Read -
89% strongly praise weight lost through diet and exercise, against 1% when the same weight is lost on medication
89% 89% give strong praise to Diet-and-Exercise Jordan, against 1% for Medication Jordan, who lost the same 60 pounds (separate samples) (base 200)
Read -
82% of US men would not get a hair transplant, and 98% of those who see their hair thinning rule one out
82% 82% of US men are not open to getting a hair transplant, and none say they are very open (base 200)
Read