Research study
Make it right, quietly: 74% of US adults want Martha Stewart to take charitable action privately after her Halloween costume
74% of US adults want Martha Stewart to take charitable action privately rather than make more statements, and an employment and training initiative would improve the opinion of 93% while carrying on as usual would improve nobody's (n=200 per sample, November 2026).
- Who was asked
- US adults, 200 clones, US
- When
- November 2026 (fielded 2 November 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- the study plan staged three statements (the post, her first statement, her second apology) and asked for every clone to see the full context before every question, so all three were given to every clone up front, and questions on her first statement were answered knowing about the second; the 40 questions ran as five parts with prior opinion asked first in each, the closing open question fielded on its own, and the study plan's five recovery scenarios ran as five separate studies so each clone judged only one; 'select all that apply' was fielded as 'select up to N, choosing every one that applies'
Section 01: What the study found
- #
74%
of US adults would prefer Martha Stewart to take meaningful charitable action privately, without further publicity, after her Halloween costume; 85% say a donation would feel sincere if it were not publicized, and nobody chooses another, more detailed apology
base 200
- #
99.5%
say her main motive for the costume was to generate publicity for her products, and in the same sample 100% find her explanation that it was meant to raise awareness of homelessness not at all believable
base 200
- #
94%
call her first statement not at all sincere; every clone in the same sample finds her second apology more convincing, yet 86% read it as primarily motivated by public pressure
base 200 · contrast
- #
78%
say the controversy worsened their opinion of her, and 85% now see her as much less in touch with ordinary Americans; in a separate sample, 97% expect only minor, temporary damage to her reputation
base 200 · contrast
- #
54%
say she has already done enough to deserve forgiveness and 39% that she possibly has, depending on her future actions; 4% say the incident has permanently changed their opinion
base 200 · contrast
- #
93%
would think better of her if she set up an employment and training initiative for people facing housing insecurity, the best of five hypothetical responses each shown to its own sample; treating her apology as enough and carrying on would improve nobody's opinion and worsen it for 38%
base 200 · contrast
of US adults would prefer Martha Stewart to take meaningful charitable action privately, without further publicity, after her Halloween costume; 85% say a donation would feel sincere if it were not publicized, and nobody chooses another, more detailed apology
02What do Americans want Martha Stewart to do now?
Act, quietly. Given the full account of the costume and both of her statements, 74% of US adults (n=200) would prefer she take meaningful charitable action privately, without further publicity; 7% want a substantial public commitment. A donation would feel sincere rather than a publicity stunt if it were made without publicizing it (85%) and recurred over several years (64%).
The actions that would most improve their opinion are a substantial donation to homelessness charities (72%), donating proceeds from her product sales (66%) and funding housing or employment initiatives (52%); nobody picks another, more detailed apology. Asked in their own words in a separate sample (n=200) for the single most important thing she could do, 75% name a donation to homelessness causes.
03Which way back works best?
Building something lasting. Five separate samples of 200 were each shown one hypothetical response. An employment and training initiative would improve the opinion of 93%, is very or extremely sincere to 35% and would make 38% more willing to buy or recommend her products, the highest of the five on all three. A multi-year partnership with homelessness organizations follows (88% improve; 23% very or extremely sincere).
A one-off donation improves opinion for 78% but is very or extremely sincere to only 6%, and 96% name a PR stunt as their main remaining concern. Treating her apology as enough and resuming business as usual improves nobody's opinion, worsens it for 38% and is not at all sincere to 71%.
04What did they think the costume was for?
Selling candles. 99.5% of US adults (n=200) say her main motive was to generate publicity for her products, and 89% say the candle promotion made their opinion more negative. Every clone in Part 1 (n=200) calls the costume inappropriate, and 96% strongly agree homelessness should never be treated as a Halloween costume.
They read it as careless rather than cruel: 76% say she exercised poor judgment but did not intend to harm anyone. That does not lift the blame, as 99% hold her entirely or mostly responsible for the reaction.
05How did her two statements land?
The first made things worse and the second only partly repaired it. Her first statement, which explained her intentions and her charity work, is not at all sincere to 94% of US adults (n=200), and 76% say it worsened their opinion. Every clone agrees the second apology, which called the costume insensitive and not funny, was more convincing, and 58% say it somewhat improved how they feel; 86% still read it as primarily motivated by public pressure.
06How much has it cost her?
Some standing, not much custom. 78% of US adults (n=200) say the controversy worsened their opinion of her, and the sharpest loss is on being in touch with ordinary Americans (85% much less). In another sample (n=200), 97% expect only minor, temporary damage, 86% would take none of the listed actions against her, and 54% say she has already done enough to deserve forgiveness.
Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“I think she should just take meaningful charitable action privately without making a whole big publicity spectacle out of it. We've seen enough public words, excuses, and self-promotion. At the end of the day, actions speak louder than words, and if you really care about helping people who are struggling rather than just saving face or selling products, you do the right thing quietly. Doing good shouldn't be about staging another public performance.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“actions speak louder than words.”
“Honestly, that makes it so much worse. Using a serious struggle like homelessness just to push a promotion and sell candles is not taking things seriously at all. In business and professional life, you have to be responsible and care about people, not exploit a bad situation for marketing. Seeing that attached to a product pitch definitely makes my opinion significantly more negative.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“They would describe me as a very responsible person, a person that would take things serious.”
“Not at all sincere. Dressing up like that just to sell candles and then claiming you were trying to raise awareness for homelessness is pure nonsense. She screwed up, and she was just trying to sugarcoat it.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I would react like they're trying to sugarcoat their screwed up thing.”
“Much less. There is a serious financial crisis going on right now that everyday people across the country are dealing with firsthand, trying to manage and keep afloat. To take something as painful as homelessness and economic hardship and turn it into a costume to promote candles is completely insensitive and shows she has no understanding of what ordinary Americans are actually experiencing day to day.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“There is a major financial crisis that I am experiencing and a lot of us in the United States are experiencing, whether they want to admit it or not.”
“I think she has already done enough to deserve forgiveness. She realized what she did was wrong, deleted the picture, and came out and gave an honest apology admitting it was insensitive and not funny. People make mistakes in life, but she owned up to it, and that's really what matters most to me.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I mean, I don't really get mad at things if somebody has to cancel. Plans will be because life happens and things happen, so sometimes you can't always make it to certain events.”
“I would say it would somewhat improve my opinion of her. I really like to hear about things that create more opportunities for people to have jobs, especially programs that help people who are struggling to find stable housing and become financially stable. While the costume was insensitive, taking real action to help people get back on their feet and make a positive difference is a good thing to do.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I like to hear about things that make more opportunities for people to have jobs.”
Section 08: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- the preference for private charitable action (74%, 66% to 81% across gender and age groups) and a donation as the most important step in their own words (75%, 68% to 83%), from two separate samples
- the reading of her motive as product publicity (99.5%, 98% to 100% in every group) and the rejection of the awareness explanation (100%)
- the order of the two statements: the first not at all sincere to 94%, the second more convincing to every clone, and still read as public pressure by 86%
- the order of the five recovery scenarios: the employment initiative first and carrying on as usual last in every gender and age group
What we would not
- the exact figures on unanimous or near-unanimous items (the costume inappropriate, the awareness explanation not believable, the second apology more convincing): the agreement is the finding, not the decimal
- the scenario results as a randomised experiment: the five samples are separate draws from one audience and share some clones
- the prior-opinion and association questions as a true before-measure: every clone read the full account before answering, so these are recalled views
- the brand-damage figures as resilience: most clones did not buy her products before, so there was little to lose among them
The main limitation
almost no clone had heard of the controversy beforehand, so every answer reacts to the same written account of the post and her two statements rather than to the coverage, and the ten samples are separate draws of 200 that share between 58 and 83 clones in any pair, so figures from different parts are read side by side and never joined
Section 09: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Part 1: awareness and the costume | 200 |
| Part 2: motive and accountability | 200 |
| Part 3: the two statements and reputation | 200 |
| Part 4: brand damage and recovery | 200 |
| Part 5: rebuilding trust, in their own words | 200 |
| Scenario A: a substantial donation to homelessness organizations | 200 |
| Scenario B: a multi-year partnership with homelessness organizations | 200 |
| Scenario C: meeting people who have experienced homelessness and sharing what she learned | 200 |
| Scenario D: an employment and training initiative | 200 |
| Scenario E: treating her apology as enough and resuming business as usual | 200 |
Question wording as fielded
- Part 1. Before today, how familiar were you with Martha Stewart?
- Part 1. Before learning about this controversy, what was your overall opinion of Martha Stewart?
- Part 1. Which of the following do you most closely associate with Martha Stewart? (select all that apply)
- Part 1. Before taking this survey, had you heard about Martha Stewart's 2026 Halloween costume controversy?
- Part 1. After learning about the costume, how appropriate or inappropriate do you consider Martha Stewart's decision?
- Part 1. Which of the following best describes your reaction to the costume? (select all that apply)
- Part 1. What specifically, if anything, do you find objectionable about the costume? (select all that apply)
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Homelessness should never be treated as a Halloween costume.
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Stewart's costume was offensive regardless of her intentions.
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: People are overreacting to the costume.
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Public figures should be held to a higher standard when depicting vulnerable communities.
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Stewart's wealth makes the costume more offensive.
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The costume might have been received differently if she had not used it to promote products.
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The controversy reflects how disconnected wealthy celebrities can be from ordinary Americans.
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: Halloween should allow people to joke about difficult subjects.
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: The criticism has become more damaging than the costume itself.
- Part 1. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?: People should be allowed to make mistakes without facing widespread public backlash.
- Part 2. How much does Martha Stewart's wealth influence your opinion of the costume?
- Part 2. Does the fact that the costume appeared alongside a promotion for Stewart's candles change your opinion?
- Part 2. Which aspect of the controversy do you find most concerning, if any?
- Part 2. In your own words, what do you think Martha Stewart failed to understand, if anything, when choosing this costume? (open-ended; answers grouped)
- Part 2. What do you believe was Martha Stewart's primary motivation for wearing the costume?
- Part 2. How believable do you find Stewart's explanation that the costume was intended to raise awareness about homelessness?
- Part 2. Do you believe Martha Stewart understood that the costume could be offensive before she posted it?
- Part 2. Which statement best reflects your view of Stewart's actions?
- Part 2. How responsible should Martha Stewart be held for the negative reaction to her costume?
- Part 2. Do you believe celebrities sometimes use the phrase "raising awareness" to justify decisions that were originally intended as jokes or publicity?
- Part 3. How sincere do you find Martha Stewart's initial explanation of the costume?
- Part 3. How does her initial explanation affect your opinion of the controversy?
- Part 3. How sincere do you believe Martha Stewart's second apology was?
- Part 3. Which of the following best describes your interpretation of her second apology?
- Part 3. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements about Stewart's response?: She took meaningful responsibility for her actions.
- Part 3. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements about Stewart's response?: Her initial explanation sounded defensive.
- Part 3. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements about Stewart's response?: Her second apology was more convincing than her first statement.
- Part 3. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements about Stewart's response?: She appeared more concerned about public criticism than the people affected.
- Part 3. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements about Stewart's response?: A public apology should be enough for people to move on.
- Part 3. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements about Stewart's response?: She should demonstrate her sincerity through concrete actions.
- Part 3. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements about Stewart's response?: Her apology has made me view her more favorably.
- Part 3. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements about Stewart's response?: Her explanation that she intended to raise awareness was convincing.
- Part 3. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements about Stewart's response?: She deserves an opportunity to learn from this mistake.
- Part 3. How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements about Stewart's response?: The public is expecting too much from her.
- Part 3. Has Stewart's second apology changed how you feel about the controversy?
- Part 3. What, if anything, was missing from Martha Stewart's apologies? (select all that apply)
- Part 3. In your own words, what would Martha Stewart need to say or do for you to believe she genuinely understands why people were upset? (open-ended; answers grouped)
- Part 3. How has the controversy affected your overall opinion of Martha Stewart?
- Part 3. How has the incident affected your perception of Martha Stewart across the following characteristics?: Trustworthy
- Part 3. How has the incident affected your perception of Martha Stewart across the following characteristics?: Relatable
- Part 3. How has the incident affected your perception of Martha Stewart across the following characteristics?: Compassionate
- Part 3. How has the incident affected your perception of Martha Stewart across the following characteristics?: Authentic
- Part 3. How has the incident affected your perception of Martha Stewart across the following characteristics?: Socially aware
- Part 3. How has the incident affected your perception of Martha Stewart across the following characteristics?: Likable
- Part 3. How has the incident affected your perception of Martha Stewart across the following characteristics?: Respectable
- Part 3. How has the incident affected your perception of Martha Stewart across the following characteristics?: In touch with ordinary Americans
- Part 3. How has the incident affected your perception of Martha Stewart across the following characteristics?: Worth supporting
- Part 4. Which statement best describes the overall impact you expect this incident to have on Martha Stewart's reputation?
- Part 4. Do you believe this incident reflects Martha Stewart's broader character and values, or was it an isolated lapse in judgment?
- Part 4. How has the controversy changed how likely you are to engage with Martha Stewart in the following ways?: Watch her television or online content
- Part 4. How has the controversy changed how likely you are to engage with Martha Stewart in the following ways?: Follow her on social media
- Part 4. How has the controversy changed how likely you are to engage with Martha Stewart in the following ways?: Purchase Martha Stewart products
- Part 4. How has the controversy changed how likely you are to engage with Martha Stewart in the following ways?: Recommend her products to others
- Part 4. How has the controversy changed how likely you are to engage with Martha Stewart in the following ways?: Support brands that collaborate with her
- Part 4. How has the controversy changed how likely you are to engage with Martha Stewart in the following ways?: Engage positively with content featuring her
- Part 4. Which of the following actions, if any, would you consider taking because of this controversy? (select all that apply)
- Part 4. Do you believe Martha Stewart should be forgiven for the costume controversy?
- Part 4. Which of the following actions would most improve your opinion of Martha Stewart following this controversy? (select all that apply)
- Part 4. What would make a charitable donation from Martha Stewart feel like a sincere effort to help rather than a publicity stunt? (select all that apply)
- Part 4. Which of the following approaches would you prefer Martha Stewart to take next?
- Part 4. If Martha Stewart took meaningful steps to support people experiencing homelessness, how likely would you be to reconsider any negative opinion you currently hold of her?
- Part 5. In your own words, what is the single most important thing Martha Stewart could do now to rebuild public trust and move forward from the controversy? (open-ended; answers grouped)
- Scenario A (financial restitution). How would this response (her hypothetical substantial donation to homelessness organizations) affect your overall opinion of Martha Stewart?
- Scenario A (financial restitution). How sincere would you consider this response (her hypothetical substantial donation to homelessness organizations)?
- Scenario A (financial restitution). How likely would you be to view the controversy as resolved if Martha Stewart took this approach (her hypothetical substantial donation to homelessness organizations)?
- Scenario A (financial restitution). How would this response (her hypothetical substantial donation to homelessness organizations) affect your willingness to purchase or recommend Martha Stewart products?
- Scenario A (financial restitution). What, if anything, would make this response (her hypothetical substantial donation to homelessness organizations) feel more credible or effective? (open-ended; answers grouped)
- Scenario B (long-term commitment). How would this response (her hypothetical multi-year partnership with homelessness organizations) affect your overall opinion of Martha Stewart?
- Scenario B (long-term commitment). How sincere would you consider this response (her hypothetical multi-year partnership with homelessness organizations)?
- Scenario B (long-term commitment). How likely would you be to view the controversy as resolved if Martha Stewart took this approach (her hypothetical multi-year partnership with homelessness organizations)?
- Scenario B (long-term commitment). How would this response (her hypothetical multi-year partnership with homelessness organizations) affect your willingness to purchase or recommend Martha Stewart products?
- Scenario B (long-term commitment). What, if anything, would make this response (her hypothetical multi-year partnership with homelessness organizations) feel more credible or effective? (open-ended; answers grouped)
- Scenario C (listening and education). How would this response (her hypothetical meetings with people who have experienced homelessness and sharing what she learned) affect your overall opinion of Martha Stewart?
- Scenario C (listening and education). How sincere would you consider this response (her hypothetical meetings with people who have experienced homelessness and sharing what she learned)?
- Scenario C (listening and education). How likely would you be to view the controversy as resolved if Martha Stewart took this approach (her hypothetical meetings with people who have experienced homelessness and sharing what she learned)?
- Scenario C (listening and education). How would this response (her hypothetical meetings with people who have experienced homelessness and sharing what she learned) affect your willingness to purchase or recommend Martha Stewart products?
- Scenario C (listening and education). What, if anything, would make this response (her hypothetical meetings with people who have experienced homelessness and sharing what she learned) feel more credible or effective? (open-ended; answers grouped)
- Scenario D (economic opportunity). How would this response (her hypothetical employment and training initiative) affect your overall opinion of Martha Stewart?
- Scenario D (economic opportunity). How sincere would you consider this response (her hypothetical employment and training initiative)?
- Scenario D (economic opportunity). How likely would you be to view the controversy as resolved if Martha Stewart took this approach (her hypothetical employment and training initiative)?
- Scenario D (economic opportunity). How would this response (her hypothetical employment and training initiative) affect your willingness to purchase or recommend Martha Stewart products?
- Scenario D (economic opportunity). What, if anything, would make this response (her hypothetical employment and training initiative) feel more credible or effective? (open-ended; answers grouped)
- Scenario E (apology and moving forward). How would this response (her hypothetical decision to treat her apology as enough and resume her usual activities) affect your overall opinion of Martha Stewart?
- Scenario E (apology and moving forward). How sincere would you consider this response (her hypothetical decision to treat her apology as enough and resume her usual activities)?
- Scenario E (apology and moving forward). How likely would you be to view the controversy as resolved if Martha Stewart took this approach (her hypothetical decision to treat her apology as enough and resume her usual activities)?
- Scenario E (apology and moving forward). How would this response (her hypothetical decision to treat her apology as enough and resume her usual activities) affect your willingness to purchase or recommend Martha Stewart products?
- Scenario E (apology and moving forward). What, if anything, would make this response (her hypothetical decision to treat her apology as enough and resume her usual activities) feel more credible or effective? (open-ended; answers grouped)
What was not asked, and why
the original photograph was described in words rather than shown; the questions for clones already aware of the controversy are not reported because almost none were; Ask Brox's own added questions are not tabulated, and three are cited in the story only where named (her intent, image repair and a PR stunt); age and gender come from each clone's own profile
What changed from the obvious question
the study plan staged three statements (the post, her first statement, her second apology) and asked for every clone to see the full context before every question, so all three were given to every clone up front, and questions on her first statement were answered knowing about the second; the 40 questions ran as five parts with prior opinion asked first in each, the closing open question fielded on its own, and the study plan's five recovery scenarios ran as five separate studies so each clone judged only one; 'select all that apply' was fielded as 'select up to N, choosing every one that applies'
More on Public opinion · Public affairs & society
Ask this of your own audience: humans@brox.ai
More in Public affairs & society
All in Public affairs & society-
100% of US adult clones call a secret, sexual AI affair cheating, against 1% when a partner discloses flirting with an AI that is not sexual
100% 100% rate a partner's secret, sexual relationship with an AI companion as cheating (6 or 7 of 7), against 1% when the partner told them about flirting that was not sexual (base 200)
Read -
89% strongly praise weight lost through diet and exercise, against 1% when the same weight is lost on medication
89% 89% give strong praise to Diet-and-Exercise Jordan, against 1% for Medication Jordan, who lost the same 60 pounds (separate samples) (base 200)
Read -
82% of US men would not get a hair transplant, and 98% of those who see their hair thinning rule one out
82% 82% of US men are not open to getting a hair transplant, and none say they are very open (base 200)
Read