Research study
The death penalty on trial: 43% of US adults support it, but 70.5% have no trust at all that executions are carried out without error
43% of US adults support the death penalty for murder against 37% who oppose it, yet 70.5% have no trust at all that executions are carried out without error, and after Christa Pike's failed execution 68% would commute her sentence to life without parole (n=200, October 2026).
- Who was asked
- US adults, 200 clones, US
- When
- October 2026 (fielded 9 October 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- Rather than asking support or oppose alone, the study separated the principle from the practice (trust, methods, wrongful execution) and then tested both against two live cases pulling in opposite directions: a failed execution and a mass-casualty terrorism case. It ran as two Ask Brox waves of 200 on the same day, wave 2 repeating the general support question as an anchor; several wave 2 questions were added by Ask Brox, and the closing open question ran as a closed list of changes.
Section 01: What the study found
- #
70.5%
have no trust at all that executions are carried out reliably and without error, including 53.5% of death penalty supporters (n=86)
base 200
- #
43%
support the death penalty for murder, against 37% who oppose it; a second wave of 200 came back at 46% against 36.5%
base 200
- #
100%
of supporters name a just or deserved punishment as a main reason; 1 of 86 names deterrence
base 86 · Death penalty supporters · contrast
- #
68%
would commute Christa Pike's sentence to life without parole after the failed execution, including 48.8% of supporters (n=86); nobody wants lethal injection tried again
base 200
- #
82.5%
say Nidal Hasan's crime makes them more supportive of the death penalty in his case, including 52 of 73 general opponents
base 200 · contrast
- #
84.5%
say the two cases together have no real effect on their overall view, and 90% oppose broadcasting Hasan's execution
base 200 · caveat
have no trust at all that executions are carried out reliably and without error, including 53.5% of death penalty supporters (n=86)
02Do Americans support the death penalty?
Narrowly, and along party lines. In the first wave 43% (n=200) support the death penalty for murder, 37% oppose it and 20% are neutral; a second, separate wave of 200 came back almost the same (46% against 36.5%). The split is political: 89.4% of conservatives (n=47) support it and 89.3% of liberals (n=56) oppose it, with moderates in between (47.6% support, n=82).
Support depends on the crime. 81% (n=200) support it for a mass shooting or terrorism with multiple deaths and 81% for murder involving torture, 63% for the murder of a law enforcement officer, and below half for murder during another crime (48.5%) or drug trafficking resulting in deaths (39%).
It is about justice, not deterrence. Every supporter (86 of 86) names a just or deserved punishment as a main reason and 53.5% (n=86) add that it keeps the person from ever harming anyone again; one names deterrence. Across the sample, 61% (n=200) say it is not at all effective at deterring serious crime. Opponents name the risk of executing an innocent person (70.3%, n=74) and moral or religious objection (66.2%).
03Do people trust how executions are carried out?
Almost nobody does, supporters included. 70.5% (n=200) have no trust at all that executions are carried out reliably and without error, and 89.5% are very concerned about an innocent person being executed. Among supporters, 53.5% (n=86) have no trust at all and 77.9% are very concerned about a wrongful execution.
Where the two sides part is on what to do about it. Every opponent (n=74) says the risk of a botched execution is by itself a reason to reconsider policy, against 31.4% of supporters (n=86). If a state's method fails, 55.5% (n=200) would pause executions until a reliable method is confirmed. Life without parole is very or completely acceptable to 94.5% (n=200), including 88.4% of supporters.
Lethal injection is the only method most will accept, and only just. 67.5% (n=200) rate it moderately humane and 0.5% very humane, while 88.5% call the firing squad not at all humane, and electrocution and hanging fare worse still (99.5% each).
04What should happen after a failed execution?
For most, it should stop. After reading about Christa Pike's failed execution in September 2026, 68% (n=200) would commute her sentence to life without parole, 11.5% would carry it out by a different method and nobody wants lethal injection tried again. That includes 48.8% of death penalty supporters (n=86) and every opponent (n=74). Conservatives are the exception: 42.6% (n=47) would commute and 38.3% would use a different method.
The failure decides it, not the crime. In the second wave, 58% (n=200) say the execution failure most shapes their view of what should happen next, against 36.5% for the brutality of the crime and 2.5% for her mental health. Yet 97% (n=200) say the Pike case has not changed their overall view of the death penalty.
05Does a terrorism case change minds?
In that case, yes. 82.5% (n=200) say the nature of Nidal Hasan's 2009 Fort Hood attack makes them more supportive of the death penalty in his case, and nobody says less. That includes 52 of the 73 second-wave respondents who oppose the death penalty in general (71.2%).
The method and the place stay divided. 46.5% (n=200) call the firing squad appropriate for Hasan and 35% inappropriate, and 54% call Fort Hood an appropriate location. Support for both runs with general views: 88% of supporters (n=92) call the firing squad appropriate, against 6.8% of opponents (n=73).
Broadcasting is rejected outright. 90% (n=200) oppose broadcasting or livestreaming Hasan's execution and 91% want media access to executions to stay as it is. Among the 191 who oppose broadcasting executions, 85.9% fear it would be sensationalised or exploited, against 12% who cite the dignity of the condemned. Victims' families are widely seen as entitled to attend: 62% (n=200) would give them unrestricted access.
06Do the two cases move overall opinion?
Barely. 84.5% (n=200) say the two cases together have no real effect on their overall view. The few who moved dug in: the 25 who became more opposed were all existing opponents, and the 4 who became more supportive were all existing supporters.
Each side wants a different fix. Asked what should change, 91.8% of opponents (n=73) want abolition and 70.7% of supporters (n=92) want a faster process; more humane methods is the only common ground, named by 19% overall (n=200).
- Treat the legitimacy gap as one of process, not principle: supporters doubt the machinery almost as much as opponents. This is a reading of the findings, not a panel answer.
- Expect case coverage to harden views rather than change them. Two vivid cases moved almost nobody overall.
- Read the near-unanimous answers (broadcasting, media access, the Pike case changing views) as the direction of opinion rather than exact shares.
Section 07: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- A near-even split on the principle, reproduced across two separate waves (43% against 37%, then 46% against 36.5%, n=200 each).
- Deep doubt about the process across both sides: 70.5% no trust at all (n=200), 53.5% among supporters (n=86).
- Justice and incapacitation, not deterrence, as the reasons for support (86 of 86 against 1 of 86).
- The two cases pulling in opposite directions while leaving overall opinion where it was (84.5% no real effect, n=200).
What we would not
- The near-unanimous figures (91% media access unchanged, 90% against broadcasting, 97% Pike changed nothing) as exact shares: read them as direction.
- Any person-by-person comparison between waves: they are different draws (66 people in both) and are only compared side by side.
- Reactions to the cases as reactions to the news: only 4% had heard of the Pike execution and 14.5% of the Hasan order beforehand, so answers rest on the neutral background everyone read.
- The reasons of the 9 who support or are neutral on broadcasting, which are counts, not shares.
The main limitation
Every answer is a clone predicting its person's view after reading the same neutral background on both cases, which almost none had heard of; the case reactions reflect that briefing, not prior news exposure.
Section 08: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Wave 1 | 200 |
| Wave 2 (66 also in wave 1) | 200 |
Question wording as fielded
- (Wave 1) In general, do you support or oppose the death penalty for persons convicted of murder?
- (Wave 1) Main reasons for supporting the death penalty (up to 2; shown among supporters only)
- (Wave 1) Main reasons for opposing the death penalty (up to 2; shown among opponents only)
- (Wave 1) How effective is the death penalty at deterring serious crime?
- (Wave 1) How concerned are you that an innocent person could be wrongfully executed?
- (Wave 1) How much do you trust that executions are carried out reliably and without error?
- (Wave 1) If a state's primary execution method fails or is ruled unconstitutional, what should happen?
- (Wave 1) How acceptable is life without parole as an alternative to execution?
- (Wave 1) How humane is lethal injection as a method of execution?
- (Wave 1) After the botched execution, Christa Pike's sentence should now be...
- (Wave 2) In general, do you support or oppose the death penalty for persons convicted of murder? (anchor)
- (Wave 2) Does the nature of Nidal Hasan's crime change your support for the death penalty in his case?
- (Wave 2) How appropriate is the firing squad as the method for Hasan's execution?
- (Wave 2) Should media access to executions be expanded, reduced or stay the same?
- (Wave 2) Do you support or oppose broadcasting or livestreaming Hasan's execution?
- (Wave 2) Do the Pike and Hasan cases together change your view of capital punishment?
- (Wave 2) What change would you most want to see in how the death penalty is carried out? (run as a closed list)
What was not asked, and why
Respondents were not routed, so everyone answered the reasons-for-support and reasons-for-opposition questions; they are reported only among supporters (n=86) and opponents (n=74) on the general question. Facts about both cases are as given in the background document. No question tested a specific state or bill.
What changed from the obvious question
Rather than asking support or oppose alone, the study separated the principle from the practice (trust, methods, wrongful execution) and then tested both against two live cases pulling in opposite directions: a failed execution and a mass-casualty terrorism case. It ran as two Ask Brox waves of 200 on the same day, wave 2 repeating the general support question as an anchor; several wave 2 questions were added by Ask Brox, and the closing open question ran as a closed list of changes.
More on Public opinion · Public affairs & society
Ask this of your own audience: humans@brox.ai
More in Public affairs & society
All in Public affairs & society-
100% of US adult clones call a secret, sexual AI affair cheating, against 1% when a partner discloses flirting with an AI that is not sexual
100% 100% rate a partner's secret, sexual relationship with an AI companion as cheating (6 or 7 of 7), against 1% when the partner told them about flirting that was not sexual (base 200)
Read -
89% strongly praise weight lost through diet and exercise, against 1% when the same weight is lost on medication
89% 89% give strong praise to Diet-and-Exercise Jordan, against 1% for Medication Jordan, who lost the same 60 pounds (separate samples) (base 200)
Read -
82% of US men would not get a hair transplant, and 98% of those who see their hair thinning rule one out
82% 82% of US men are not open to getting a hair transplant, and none say they are very open (base 200)
Read