Add-ons at checkout: 40% of US insurance customers find the offer helpful, 35% call it an upsell or worse, and roadside assistance is the one they take

40% of US auto and home insurance customers find add-on offers at checkout helpful and 35% find them annoying or suspicious, and roadside assistance is the add-on most often taken, held by 46% (n=200, September 2026).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
US insurance customers, 200 clones, US
When
September 2026 (fielded 17 September 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question is whether customers like add-ons. This study separated the feeling about the offer from what the customer did the last time they were offered one and what they hold now, and asked for the single main reason for a no rather than a rating, so the feeling can be read against the behavior: the people who call the offer an upsell are, by a wide margin, the people who declined it.

Section 01: What the panel said

  1. #

    40%

    40% find add-on offers at checkout helpful and 25% ignore what they do not want, while 25.5% say the offer feels like an upsell and 9.5% say it makes them wonder what the base policy leaves out

    base 200

  2. #

    46%

    46% added at least one add-on the last time they bought or renewed a policy; 33.5% were offered add-ons and declined them all, 8.5% were not offered any and 12% do not remember

    base 200

  3. #

    46%

    Roadside assistance is the add-on most often held, by 46%, then rental car reimbursement at 36% and accident forgiveness at 15.5%; identity theft protection is held by 1%, and 42% hold none of the four

    base 200

  4. #

    44.8%

    The offer reads as an upsell to the people who declined it: 44.8% of those who were offered add-ons last time and took none call it annoying, against 9.8% of those who added one

    base 67 · Offered add-ons the last time they bought or renewed and declined them all · contrast

40% find add-on offers at checkout helpful and 25% ignore what they do not want, while 25.5% say the offer feels like an upsell and 9.5% say it makes them wonder what the base policy leaves out

Helpful
40%
Neutral
25%
Annoying, an upsell
25.5%
Suspicious
9.5%

Base 200 clones.

02Which add-ons do US insurance customers actually take?

The ones they can picture using at the side of the road. Of 200 US auto and home insurance customers, 46% (92 of 200) added at least one optional add-on the last time they bought or renewed a policy, and 58% (116 of 200) hold at least one of the four we listed. Roadside assistance leads at 46% (92 of 200), rental car reimbursement while the car is repaired follows at 36% (72 of 200), and accident forgiveness sits at 15.5% (31 of 200). Identity theft protection, the add-on furthest from the car, is held by 1% (2 of 200).

The remaining 42% (84 of 200) hold none of the four. That is none of these four, not none at all: the study did not list glass cover, gap cover or equipment breakdown, and 9 of the 92 who added an add-on last time hold none of the four listed, so they added something else.

03Where does the reaction to the offer change, and for whom?

It changes with what the customer did last time. Among the 92 who added an add-on the last time they bought or renewed, 62.0% (57 of 92) call the offer helpful and 9.8% (9 of 92) call it an upsell. Among the 67 who were offered add-ons and took none, it is the other way round: 44.8% (30 of 67) call it an upsell, 13.4% (9 of 67) say it makes them suspicious of the base policy, and 14.9% (10 of 67) call it helpful.

Men were more likely to say they added one, 62.5% (35 of 56) against 39.2% of women (56 of 143). Customers with auto insurance only were more likely to find the offer annoying, 38.7% (12 of 31), than customers holding both auto and home or renters cover, 21.0% (34 of 162). None of the 7 customers with only a home or renters policy added an add-on, which is too few to read as more than a direction.

04Why do customers say no to an add-on?

Price against likely use, not confusion. Asked for the main reason they decline an add-on, 80% (160 of 200) say it costs more than it is worth to them. A further 12.5% (25 of 200) already have the cover somewhere else, through an auto club, a credit card or the maker of their car, and that is where roadside assistance in particular gets declined. Only 4% (8 of 200) say they do not trust the insurer to pay out on it, and 1% (2 of 200) say they do not understand what it covers. Just 2.5% (5 of 200) say they usually say yes.

The question asked everyone for the reason they say no, including the 46% who said yes last time, so 80% is the reason when they decline, not the share who decline.

05How do they want add-ons put in front of them?

Given one choice, 78.5% (157 of 200) would rather an insurer showed every add-on at checkout with its price and let them choose. Building the most common add-ons into the base price was chosen by 9% (18 of 200), offering none at checkout and letting the customer add later by 6.5% (13 of 200), and showing only the one or two that fit the customer's situation by 6% (12 of 200). Even among the 67 who declined every add-on last time, 70.1% (47 of 67) chose the full menu with prices, and 14.9% (10 of 67) chose none at checkout.

This is a stated preference with no price or effort attached, and the full-menu option was listed first, so it is a direction rather than a measure of what people would do. The direction is still clear: a short, tailored list, which is what many checkout flows now do, was the least chosen of the four.

06What would a brand manager do with this?

  1. Our reading: lead the add-on offer with roadside assistance and rental car reimbursement, the two that 46% and 36% of customers already hold (n=200), and expect identity theft protection on an auto or home checkout to convert close to nowhere.
  2. Our reading: the 44.8% of past decliners who now call the offer an upsell (30 of 67) is the cost of a pushy checkout, so let the price of each add-on sit beside it and make declining one click. The panel asked for the full menu with prices, not a curated one.
  3. Our reading: the 12.5% who already hold the cover elsewhere (25 of 200) are not a lost sale but a duplicate one, so asking whether a customer has an auto club membership before offering roadside assistance would cost little and remove the most obvious reason for the offer to feel like a grab.

Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“I currently pay for roadside assistance, rental car reimbursement, and accident forgiveness on my auto policy. I think those three are very important features to have, and I've actually used all of them in the past when I needed them.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I do like roadside assistance, rental car coverage, and accident forgiveness. I have used all three of those in my current plan.”

Woman, 45 to 64, Pennsylvania, auto and home insurance, added an add-on at her last renewal supports finding 3

“I would find it annoying, because it just feels like an upsell. My wife and I live simply and we aren't interested in consumerism or buying things we don't need. When I'm setting up my policy, I want a low deductible and peace of mind. I just need the basics that will keep me safe. I don't want bells and whistles, especially not any extra technology tracking me. Whenever a company starts offering extra things, I feel like they're just pushing things on me to make an extra buck. It strikes me as more bad advertising, which I have no patience for.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I want the low deductible and then I don't need any other bells and whistles.”

Man, 45 to 64, Indiana, auto and home insurance, holds none of the four add-ons supports finding 1

“I think it would be helpful, because I actually like seeing what is available. I've said before that I wish you could just go to their website and have a listing of what all you can get, and then only pick the stuff that you want. Even if you just have a basic policy, it would be so nice to pick exactly what you'd like for them to cover and know how much it costs. So being offered those optional things where I can pick and choose what fits my budget would be great.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Yeah, go to their website and have listings of what all you can get and only pick the stuff that you want. You know, even if you have basic, just pick what would you like for them to pay.”

Woman, 65 or over, Tennessee, auto and home insurance, holds none of the four add-ons supports finding 1

Section 08: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • The split in how the offer lands: 40% helpful, 25% neutral, 25.5% annoying, 9.5% suspicious (n=200), which holds in both large policy segments (both auto and home n=162, auto only n=31).
  • 46% added at least one add-on the last time they bought or renewed (n=200): 48.1% among those with both auto and home cover (78 of 162) and 45.2% among auto-only customers (14 of 31).
  • Roadside assistance is the most held of the four add-ons listed, at 46% (n=200), and leads in every segment with 30 or more clones.
  • The direction of the contrast between takers and decliners: 62.0% of the 92 who added one call the offer helpful, 44.8% of the 67 who declined call it an upsell, a gap that holds against every other answer option.

What we would not

  • The exact 44.8% among decliners (n=67): a base above 30, but a handful of clones moves it several points, so read it as roughly two in five.
  • 78.5% wanting every add-on shown with its price (n=200) as a measure of behavior: it is a forced choice with no price or effort attached, and that option was listed first.
  • 80% saying an add-on costs more than it is worth (n=200) as the share who decline: the question asked everyone for the reason they say no, including the 46% who said yes last time, and only 2.5% took the 'I usually say yes' answer.
  • Anything about customers with only a home or renters policy (7 clones, 0 of 7 added an add-on) or under-30s (3 clones).
  • 42% holding none of the four listed add-ons as 42% holding no add-ons at all: glass, gap and equipment breakdown cover were not listed.

The main limitation

The panel is the Brox Insurance audience in the US, 200 clones of the 402 who passed the screener, skewing female (143 of 200) and over 45 (151 of 200); it is not nationally representative, and the study measures recalled behavior and stated preference, not observed checkout behavior.

Section 09: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Both auto and home or renters insurance162
Auto insurance only31
Home or renters insurance only7

Question wording as fielded

  1. Do you currently pay for an auto insurance policy or a home or renters insurance policy in your own name?
  2. The last time you bought or renewed an auto, home or renters insurance policy, were you offered optional add-ons, such as roadside assistance, rental car reimbursement, accident forgiveness or identity theft protection?
  3. Which of these optional add-ons do you currently pay for on any of your insurance policies?
  4. How do you feel when an insurer offers you optional add-ons at the point of buying or renewing a policy?
  5. What is the main reason you say no to an add-on when an insurer offers one?
  6. If you had to choose one, which would you rather an insurer did with optional add-ons?

What was not asked, and why

No price was attached to any add-on, so nothing here is a demand curve. Only four add-ons were listed (roadside assistance, rental car reimbursement, accident forgiveness, identity theft protection), so 'none of these' means none of those four; 9 of the 92 who said they added an add-on last time hold none of the four, so they added something off the list. The study did not ask whether an add-on was pre-ticked or opt-in, or whether the offer came from an agent or a website. No insurer was named in any question and Ask Brox added no questions of its own.

What changed from the obvious question

The obvious question is whether customers like add-ons. This study separated the feeling about the offer from what the customer did the last time they were offered one and what they hold now, and asked for the single main reason for a no rather than a rating, so the feeling can be read against the behavior: the people who call the offer an upsell are, by a wide margin, the people who declined it.

Fielded through Ask Brox on 17 September 2026.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai

Related insights

All in this topic