Asked about a risk-free yield, 55.7% of US high-net-worth investors said they would move some money out of stocks at 6%, against 22.4% at 4.5%
Only 22.4% of US high-net-worth investors would move any money out of stocks for a risk-free 4.5% yield, rising to 55.7% at 6% and 79.2% at 7.5%, and most of those moves are trims rather than exits (n=107, September 2026).
- Who was asked
- Brox HNWI, 107 clones, US
- When
- September 2026 (fielded 24 September 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- Rather than asking whether higher rates would make investors sell, which invites a vague yes, the study asked about the September 2026 rise as it happened, then put three specific risk-free yields against their stock holdings to find where the answer changes.
Section 01: What the panel said
- #
55.7%
55.7% of US high-net-worth investors would move some money out of stocks for a risk-free 6% yield, against 22.4% at 4.5% and 79.2% at 7.5%
base 106
- #
35.8%
Even at a 7.5% risk-free yield only 35.8% would move more than a fifth of their stock holdings; 43.4% would move a smaller share
base 106 · contrast
- #
3
After the September 2026 rate increase to 3.75-4.00%, 3 of 107 plan to reduce their share in stocks over the next year and 100 plan to keep it about the same
base 107 · caveat
55.7% of US high-net-worth investors would move some money out of stocks for a risk-free 6% yield, against 22.4% at 4.5% and 79.2% at 7.5%
02Does the September 2026 rate increase change what wealthy investors plan to do?
Hardly at all. After the Federal Reserve raised its benchmark rate to 3.75-4.00%, 100 of the 107 stock-holding clones said they would keep the share of their assets in stocks about the same over the next 12 months, 4 would increase it and 3 would reduce it a little. Nobody chose to cut it by more than 10 points. A result that lopsided is a direction, not a precise share, but the direction is clear: a rate around 4% is not the level that moves this money.
03Where is the tipping point?
Somewhere between a 4.5% and a 6% risk-free yield. At 4.5%, 77.6% (n=107) would move nothing out of stocks. At 6%, 55.7% (n=106) would move some money, so the majority flips inside that gap. At 7.5%, 79.2% (n=106) would move something. The ladder had three rungs, so the page can say which side of 6% the cliff sits on, not the exact rate.
04Is it a trim or an exit?
Mostly a trim. Even at 7.5%, 43.4% (n=106) would move a smaller share and 35.8% would move more than a fifth of their stock holdings. At 6%, only 8.5% would move more than a fifth. And 21 of the 107 clones said no at all three rates. Asked why they keep money in stocks when safe assets pay more, 62.6% (n=107) said stocks beat cash and bonds over the long run after tax and inflation, and 21.5% said they do not try to time the market.
05What should a wealth manager take from this?
- A reading, not the panel's answer: a rate near 4% is unlikely to start an outflow from equities among these investors, so conversations about cash yields are about new money and idle cash more than about selling stocks.
- A second reading: if safe yields approach 6%, expect a majority of clients to ask about trimming, and plan for partial rebalancing rather than wholesale moves.
Section 06: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“No, I wouldn't move anything out of stocks for 4.5%. Right now, I'm still very much in growth mode, not preservation mode. My focus is on accelerating my financial wealth and investing consistently to build up assets, looking for things with real upside that can beat the market over time. Locking money into a one-year Treasury bill at 4.5% doesn't align with where I'm trying to go financially, so I'd leave my stock holdings right where they are.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“anything that I can do to accelerate my financial wealth is something that, you know, I definitely want to do and want to be a part of”
“A guaranteed, risk-free 6% yield is definitely attractive enough to take advantage of given current market conditions. I wouldn't overhaul my entire core strategy or move a huge portion like a fifth or more out of equities, because I'm younger and have the time horizon to ride out market cycles with low-cost index funds and long-term growth assets. But I believe inaction is no decision, and I do like to trade bonds and adjust based on where the world is. So I'd definitely step my toes in and shift a smaller share of my stock holdings over to lock in that return.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I feel like in action is no decision. So at least, you know, stepping your toes in, maybe it's not as much as you originally wanted to do, but just something to kind of play the game um has been really important.”
“Yes, more than a fifth of my stock holdings: A guaranteed 7.5% return with zero risk to my capital is an incredible offer, especially with how unpredictable and wild things have felt lately. I am naturally much more cautious and risk-averse with money than my husband is. In fact, we already sold a lot of our stocks recently because the market looked so volatile, shifting funds into safe securities that offer guaranteed returns for myself and our kids. Getting a solid 7.5% locked in without having to worry about downside risk fits right into my goal of keeping our core assets safe while still making our money work for us. I'd have no hesitation moving a significant portion over.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“we sold sold a lot of our um dots. The market was looking kind of wild. So, we've been sitting in some pretty safe securities right now that are offering some guaranteed returns on my money and the kids money.”
Section 07: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- The direction of the ladder: willingness to move money rises from 22.4% (n=107) to 55.7% (n=106) to 79.2% (n=106), and no clone moved in the opposite direction up the ladder.
- The majority flips between a 4.5% and a 6% safe yield.
- Most of the movement is partial: at 6% only 8.5% (n=106) would move more than a fifth of their stocks.
What we would not
- An exact tipping-point rate: there were three rungs, so the point lies somewhere between 4.5% and 6%.
- That these investors would actually sell: this is stated intent on a hypothetical, not observed behavior.
- The 93.5% 'keep the same' share as a precise figure: near-unanimity is a direction only.
- Any split by age, wealth band or region: no segment breakdown was captured for this study.
The main limitation
The three yields were asked one after another, so answers may climb partly because the ladder climbs, and no demographic breakdown was captured, so every figure is for the whole panel.
Section 08: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Holds stocks or stock funds (screened in) | 107 |
| Holds no stocks (screened out) | 2 |
Question wording as fielded
- Do you currently hold stocks or stock funds, directly or through funds, outside of cash and bonds?
- Over the next 12 months, what are you most likely to do with the share of your investable assets held in stocks? (after the September 2026 Federal Reserve rise to 3.75-4.00%)
- Suppose a one-year US Treasury bill paid this rate a year with no risk to your capital. Would you move any of your stock holdings into it? (4.5%, 6%, 7.5% a year)
- When safe investments pay more than they used to, what is the main reason you keep money in stocks?
What was not asked, and why
We did not ask how large a move would be in dollars, where the money would go other than a one-year Treasury bill, or what clones have actually done since rates rose. No brands were asked about.
What changed from the obvious question
Rather than asking whether higher rates would make investors sell, which invites a vague yes, the study asked about the September 2026 rise as it happened, then put three specific risk-free yields against their stock holdings to find where the answer changes.
Fielded through Ask Brox on 24 September 2026.
More on Alternatives, risk and allocation · Wealth & HNWI · Brox HNWI (US) panel
Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai