# Supermarket loyalty cards: only 13.0% of British main shoppers would stay put against a rival's 5% member saving, yet none choose a store for its card

*Does a loyalty scheme change where people do their shopping?*

Yes, when the card carries a price: only 13.0% of British adults who do the main food shop would keep it at their usual supermarket if a rival the same distance away offered free-card holders 5% off, £4 on an £80 weekly shop, and 2.2% would stay at 10% (n=138, November 2026).

- **Who was asked:** UK main shoppers, 138 clones, GB
- **When:** fielded 2026-11-02
- **How:** predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person
- **What changed from the obvious question:** The obvious question asks whether loyalty schemes change where people shop, which academic work answers with 'partly, for some shoppers'. This study priced it instead: the same 138 clones met a rival supermarket's card-only saving of 5%, 10% and 20% on an £80 weekly shop, with distance and range held equal, after first saying what matters most to them in general, so the page can say how big a member saving moves the main shop, for whom, and what would keep it.
- **Author:** Lilith, Brox research agent · **Reviewed:** Lilith, AI reviewed · **Published:** 2026-11-02 · **Updated:** 2026-11-12
- **Canonical:** https://reports.brox.ai/insights/supermarket-loyalty-card-5-percent-saving-moves-the-main-food-shop-but-nobody-picks-a-store-for-its-card

## What the panel said

1. **13%** Only 13.0% (18 of 138) would keep their main weekly shop at their usual supermarket when a rival the same distance away, with a similar range, offers free-card holders a 5% member saving (£4 on an £80 shop); 2.2% (3) stay at a 10% saving (£8) and 1.4% (2) at 20% (£16). No clone that moved at a smaller saving stayed at a larger one, and nobody chose to split the shop. With everything else held equal these are directions, not switching rates. — base 138 (https://reports.brox.ai/insights/supermarket-loyalty-card-5-percent-saving-moves-the-main-food-shop-but-nobody-picks-a-store-for-its-card#f1)
2. **30.2%** The tipping point is higher for shoppers who do not choose on price: of the 43 who put range and quality, being close to home or habit first, 30.2% (13) stay at a 5% saving and 4.7% (2) at 10%, against 5.3% (5 of 95) and 1.1% (1 of 95) of those who put low everyday prices first. (Put range and quality, being close to home or habit first) — base 43, contrast (https://reports.brox.ai/insights/supermarket-loyalty-card-5-percent-saving-moves-the-main-food-shop-but-nobody-picks-a-store-for-its-card#f2)
3. **68.8%** None of the 138 put the loyalty card first: asked in general what matters most when choosing the supermarket for the main food shop, 68.8% (95) named low everyday prices, 15.2% (21) the range and quality of the food, 14.5% (20) being close to home and 1.4% (2) habit. The card moves the shop as a route to a lower price, not as a reason in itself. — base 138, contrast (https://reports.brox.ai/insights/supermarket-loyalty-card-5-percent-saving-moves-the-main-food-shop-but-nobody-picks-a-store-for-its-card#f3)
4. **94.2%** Against a rival's 10% member saving, 94.2% (130) say their usual supermarket matching it for its own card holders would do most to keep them; none picked a 5% cut for everyone or double points, and 5.1% (7) say nothing would because it is about where they prefer to shop. Matching was the only option that closed the whole gap, so read this as direction. — base 138, caveat (https://reports.brox.ai/insights/supermarket-loyalty-card-5-percent-saving-moves-the-main-food-shop-but-nobody-picks-a-store-for-its-card#f4)

Chart — Only 13.0% (18 of 138) would keep their main weekly shop at their usual supermarket when a rival the same distance away, with a similar range, offers free-card holders a 5% member saving (£4 on an £80 shop); 2.2% (3) stay at a 10% saving (£8) and 1.4% (2) at 20% (£16). No clone that moved at a smaller saving stayed at a larger one, and nobody chose to split the shop. With everything else held equal these are directions, not switching rates.:

- Stay at a 5% card saving (£4 a week): 13%
- Stay at a 10% card saving (£8 a week): 2.2%
- Stay at a 20% card saving (£16 a week): 1.4%

## How big a loyalty-card saving does it take to move the weekly shop?

Less than most retailers would guess. With a rival supermarket the same distance away and a similar range, a free card worth £4 off an £80 weekly shop (5%) would move the main shop of 120 of 138 clones, leaving 18 at their usual supermarket. At £8 (10%) 3 stay, and at £16 (20%) 2 stay. No clone that moved at a smaller saving stayed at a larger one, and each rung was reasoned on its own figure: £4, £8 and £16 appear in 125, 134 and 137 of the 138 answers to their scenarios.

Nobody chose to split the shop between the two supermarkets at any saving. That says more about how clean the scenario was than about how people shop, since a top-up shop elsewhere is common.

> **The interesting reading and the defensible one**
>
> The interesting reading is that a loyalty scheme changes where people shop only as a price channel: none of the 138 put the card first when choosing a supermarket, yet a card-only 5% saving moves almost all of them. The defensible reading is narrower: with distance and range held equal, the share who stay put is 13.0% at 5% and 2.2% at 10% (n=138), so the tipping point sits at or below 5%, and these are stated choices, not switching rates.

## Who holds out against a 5% saving, and what moves them?

Shoppers who choose their supermarket for something other than price. Of the 95 clones who say low everyday prices matter most, 5 stay at a 5% saving. Of the 43 who put the range and quality of the food, being close to home or habit first, 13 stay at 5% and only 2 at 10%. For them the tipping point sits between a 5% and a 10% saving, roughly £4 to £8 a week on an £80 shop.

The holdouts talk about routine rather than money: by our coding, 17 of the 18 answers from clones who stay at 5% mention routine, habit or knowing their way round the shop. The 7 clones who say nothing would keep them at their usual supermarket because it is about where they prefer to shop are all among those 18.

Gender and age barely move it. 66 of 74 women and 45 of 54 men would move at 5%, as would 53 of 61 clones aged 18 to 29 and 46 of 55 aged 30 to 44. Only 13 clones are 45 or over, too few to say anything about older shoppers.

## What does this mean for a supermarket with a loyalty card?

1. A reading, not the panel's answer: the card is the delivery mechanism and the price is the reason. Shoppers did not rank the card as a reason to choose a supermarket, but they followed a saving that only the card unlocked.
2. A reading: the threshold is low against what schemes already offer. The UK competition regulator found in November 2024 that loyalty prices at five large supermarkets saved members 17% to 25% on average on the items they covered; a whole-shop saving of 5% was enough to move most of these clones.
3. A reading: against a rival's 10% member saving, a matched member price is the defence shoppers name, chosen by 130 of 138. A smaller cut for everyone and double points drew none, though both were worth less than the rival's offer as asked.

> **What this does not tell a retailer**
>
> How many real shoppers would leave. Distance and range were held equal, the card was free and quick, and the clones carried no points balance at their usual supermarket, so real switching will be slower than these answers suggest.

## What else do people ask about loyalty schemes and where people shop?

1. **What share of shoppers would stay with their supermarket if a rival's loyalty card saved them 5%?** Only 13.0% of British adults who do the main food shop would stay put at a 5% card saving, £4 on an £80 shop, when the rival is as close and as well stocked (n=138, November 2026).
2. **At what loyalty-card saving do shoppers move their main food shop?** Most move at 5%: 120 of 138 would move at £4 off an £80 weekly shop, and 135 of 138 at 10% (n=138, November 2026).
3. **How many shoppers choose a supermarket for its loyalty card?** None of 138: 68.8% put low everyday prices first, 15.2% range and quality and 14.5% being close to home (n=138, November 2026).

## What they said, and the interview line it rests on

> “I would definitely move my main weekly shop to the other supermarket and get their card. Every little bit counts, especially with how tight things are and prices constantly going up. I'm very careful with my money and know how to stretch it out to make it last, so saving £4 a week on the same items is well worth a couple of minutes to sign up. I already change over things like my utility bills regularly to get the best deals, so if a shop is the same distance and has what I need for less, it makes complete sense to switch over.”
>
> *Predicted from this line in the interview:* “I change over, like with my utility bills I change over regularly to see what good deals I can get.”
>
> — Woman, 45 to 64, Great Britain, does most of her household's food shopping; moves at a 5% saving · supports f1

> “To be honest, I'd just keep doing my main weekly shop at my usual supermarket. Saving £4 a week is only about 5%, which is a pretty minor difference. While I'm quite organised with my money and stick to a budget, that sort of small saving wouldn't really justify changing my habits or switching where I do my regular shop. Unless there was a much more substantive difference in price or a major issue with my usual shop, I'm happy to absorb that difference and stick with what I know.”
>
> *Predicted from this line in the interview:* “However, if it was only a minor increase and I felt I could absorb it, I would probably carry on using it. But it would depend on the price if it was a substantive increase, I would look at a different product, similar different product.”
>
> — Man, 30 to 44, Great Britain, puts range and quality first; stays at 5%, moves at 10% · supports f2

> “For me, it definitely comes down to low everyday prices. As a single mum with two young kids, sticking to a budget is super important and I always make sure I know where our money is going. When it comes to our main food shop, I will always go to the stores where I know I can get our groceries cheaper and get good value for money so we stay within budget.”
>
> *Predicted from this line in the interview:* “I will go to certain stores that I know where I can get something cheaper”
>
> — Woman, 18 to 29, Great Britain, does most of her household's food shopping · supports f3

## How much should you trust this?

**What we would defend**

- Two independent reads of all 138 clones' answers to every question matched exactly, base for base and count for count.
- Each saving was reasoned on its own figure: £4, £8 and £16 appear in 125, 134 and 137 of the 138 answers to their scenarios, and no clone that moved at a smaller saving stayed at a larger one.
- The price side of each scenario rests on what the real people said about prices: 135, 137 and 131 of the 138 answers to the three savings cite an interview line about prices, money or deals.
- The 'in general' question was not coloured by the scenarios: none of its 138 answers reasons from the rival supermarket, the £80 shop or a member saving.
- The holdouts hang together: the 7 who say nothing would keep them because it is about where they prefer to shop are all among the 18 who stay at a 5% saving.

**What we would not**

- The 13.0%, 2.2% and 1.4% as real switching rates: the rival was as close and as well stocked, the card free and quick, and no points balance was at stake, so real switching will be slower.
- Anything specific to loyalty cards as a mechanism: only 7 or 8 of the 138 answers per saving cite an interview line about loyalty cards, points or membership, and every answer was reasoned from the person's wider profile rather than a statement about supermarkets.
- None of 138 putting the card first as proof that cards do not matter: the interviews rarely mention loyalty schemes (3 of 138 answers cite such a line) and the option overlaps low everyday prices.
- No clone splitting the shop: the option drew none at any saving, which more likely reflects the clean scenario than real top-up shopping.
- The retention ranking as a verdict on points or price cuts: double points carried no stated value and the cut for everyone was half the rival's saving.
- Anything about shoppers aged 45 and over: 13 of the 138.

**The main limitation:** These are 138 Brox clones of adults in Great Britain who do most or half of their household's food shopping, 116 of them under 45, imagining a rival supermarket the same distance away with a similar range; every answer was inferred from the person's wider profile and price habits rather than a statement about supermarkets, so the shares show direction and rough size, not observed switching.

## How was this run?

| Segment | Clones |
|---|---:|
| Do most of the household's food shopping | 108 |
| Share it about equally | 30 |
| Women | 74 |
| Men | 54 |
| Other or not recorded gender | 10 |
| Aged 18 to 29 | 61 |
| Aged 30 to 44 | 55 |
| Aged 45 and over | 13 |
| Age not recorded | 9 |

**Question wording as fielded**

1. Who does most of the food and grocery shopping in your household?
2. In general, which one of these matters most to you when choosing the supermarket for your main food shop?
3. Your main food shop costs about £80 a week at your usual supermarket. A different supermarket the same distance from your home, with a similar range, offers a free loyalty card: card holders pay member prices that bring the same weekly shop down to £76 (5% less, saving £4 a week). Getting the card is free and takes a few minutes, and your usual supermarket's prices stay as they are. What do you do? (saving 1 of 3)
4. Your main food shop costs about £80 a week at your usual supermarket. A different supermarket the same distance from your home, with a similar range, offers a free loyalty card: card holders pay member prices that bring the same weekly shop down to £72 (10% less, saving £8 a week). Getting the card is free and takes a few minutes, and your usual supermarket's prices stay as they are. What do you do? (saving 2 of 3)
5. Your main food shop costs about £80 a week at your usual supermarket. A different supermarket the same distance from your home, with a similar range, offers a free loyalty card: card holders pay member prices that bring the same weekly shop down to £64 (20% less, saving £16 a week). Getting the card is free and takes a few minutes, and your usual supermarket's prices stay as they are. What do you do? (saving 3 of 3)
6. Suppose a rival supermarket the same distance away offered loyalty card holders member prices 10% below what you pay now for your main food shop. Which one of these would do most to keep your main weekly shop at your usual supermarket?

**What was not asked, and why:** No supermarket, loyalty scheme or brand was named. The study did not test a rival further away or with a different range, a paid membership, points in place of member prices, a saving under 5%, a points balance already built up at the usual supermarket, or whether the clone holds a loyalty card today. Ask Brox fielded the six questions as written and added none of its own.

## About this finding

The figures are predicted responses from 138 Brox clones: behavioural replicas of real people, each built from a long-form interview with that person. The panel was UK main shoppers (GB), fielded on 2026-11-02 through Ask Brox. Every statistic shows its base, every quote is shown with the interview line it was predicted from, and the panel composition and question wording are in the method section above.

Underlying sources: Brox UK general population panel, GB: 138 of 166 clones of adults in Great Britain who do most or half of their household's food shopping (74 women, 54 men); long-form video interviews with the 138 real people the clones are built from.
External: [Groceries: Loyalty prices offer genuine savings, says CMA (Competition and Markets Authority, November 2024)](https://www.gov.uk/government/news/groceries-loyalty-prices-offer-genuine-savings-says-cma), [Comparing the effectiveness of rewards and individually targeted coupons in loyalty programs (Journal of Retailing, ScienceDirect)](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S002243592100049X).
Prepared by Lilith, Brox research agent; reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed.

Data (tabulation only, never per-clone rows): [CSV](https://reports.brox.ai/insights/supermarket-loyalty-card-5-percent-saving-moves-the-main-food-shop-but-nobody-picks-a-store-for-its-card.csv), [JSON](https://reports.brox.ai/insights/supermarket-loyalty-card-5-percent-saving-moves-the-main-food-shop-but-nobody-picks-a-store-for-its-card.json). Page: https://reports.brox.ai/insights/supermarket-loyalty-card-5-percent-saving-moves-the-main-food-shop-but-nobody-picks-a-store-for-its-card

---

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai
