Phone trade-in deals decide when, not which: a free upgrade moves 40.7%, a $500 credit 4.5%, and only 6.0% would switch brand for a free phone

In October 2026, only 6.0% of clones on Brox's US Tech panel (n=200) would switch to a free phone from another brand when a new model from their own brand costs $1,000, and 4.5% say a trade-in credit or carrier deal matters most when they choose a phone.

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
US smartphone owners, 200 clones, US
When
October 2026 (fielded 28 October 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question asks people how much deals matter, which invites a polite yes. We separated the two things a deal could decide: when someone upgrades (the same working phone and the same $1,000 model, with only the trade-in credit changed across three levels) and which phone they choose (a free phone from another brand against their own brand at full price), and asked the same clones both.

Section 01: What the panel said

  1. #

    40.7%

    A trade-in credit barely moves owners of a working phone until it makes the new model free: with a $1,000 phone, the share likely to upgrade in the next month is 2.0% with $200 of credit, 4.5% with $500 and 40.7% when a $1,000 credit means it costs nothing.

    base 199

  2. #

    6%

    A free phone does not buy a brand switch: offered a free phone from another brand while their own brand's new model costs $1,000, 6.0% would take it and 93.0% would keep their current phone; of the 81 clones likely to upgrade when their own brand's model is free, 86.4% (70) would keep their phone instead.

    base 200

  3. #

    4.5%

    Asked what matters most when they choose their next smartphone, 4.5% name the trade-in credit or carrier deal, against 39.0% staying with the brand and apps they already use, 32.0% the total price and 24.5% the phone's features.

    base 200 · contrast

  4. #

    51.8%

    iPhone users are the most loyal and the keenest on a free upgrade: none of the 83 would take a free phone from another brand, against 10.3% of the 117 on other brands, while 51.8% (43 of 83) would upgrade when their own brand's new model is free, against 32.8% (38 of 116).

    base 83 · Clones who use an iPhone · contrast

A trade-in credit barely moves owners of a working phone until it makes the new model free: with a $1,000 phone, the share likely to upgrade in the next month is 2.0% with $200 of credit, 4.5% with $500 and 40.7% when a $1,000 credit means it costs nothing.

$200 of trade-in credit (base 200)
2%
$500 of trade-in credit (base 200)
4.5%
$1,000 of credit (the phone is free) (base 199)
40.7%

Base 199 clones.

02Does a trade-in credit get people to upgrade a phone that still works?

Only when the credit makes the phone free. Brox gave 200 clones on its US Tech panel the same situation three times: the phone they use now still works well, a new model from their own brand costs $1,000, and their carrier offers trade-in credit paid as monthly bill credits over 36 months. Only the size of the credit changed. With $200 of credit, 2.0% (4 of 200) were likely to upgrade in the next month. With $500, half the price, 4.5% (9 of 200). With $1,000, so the new model cost nothing, 40.7% (81 of 199).

The curve is flat and then it jumps. Raising the credit from $200 to $500 brought 5 more clones into the likely group; making the phone free brought in 73 more. No clone became less likely to upgrade as the credit grew.

03Does a free phone get people to switch brand?

Rarely. Offered a free phone from a different brand for trading in their current phone and staying on their plan for 36 months, while a new model from their own brand would cost $1,000, 6.0% (12 of 200) would take the free phone and 93.0% (186) would keep the phone they have. 1.0% (2) would pay the $1,000 and none would buy a cheaper model from their own brand.

The same clones who jump at a free upgrade turn down a free switch. Of the 81 likely to upgrade when their own brand's new model was free, 86.4% (70 of 81) would keep their current phone rather than take a free one from another brand, and 9 would take it. The clones who keep their phone give the working phone, the system they already know and the 36-month tie as their reasons, often all three at once.

04Who takes the free upgrade, and who never switches?

iPhone users are both the most loyal and the keenest on a free upgrade. 57.8% (48 of 83) put staying with their brand and apps first, against 25.6% (30 of 117) of clones on other brands. None of the 83 would take a free phone from another brand, against 10.3% (12 of 117) of everyone else, yet 51.8% (43 of 83) would upgrade when their own brand's new model was free, against 32.8% (38 of 116).

The people who say price matters most are the least moved by a free phone. 23.4% (15 of 64) of them would take the free upgrade, against 50.0% (24 of 48) of those who put features first and 46.2% (36 of 78) of those who put their brand first. Age divides the free upgrade too: 56.6% (30 of 53) of clones aged 30 to 44 would take the free upgrade, against 26.9% (14 of 52) aged 65 or over. The panel holds only 7 clones under 30, 4 of whom would take it.

05What would a phone maker or carrier do with this?

  1. A reading, not the panel's answer: a trade-in credit that stops short of free buys very little among owners of a working phone, so the money is better spent getting the offer to zero for fewer people than shaving the price for everyone.
  2. A second reading: a free phone is a retention tool, not a conquest tool. It brings forward an upgrade within the brand people already use and almost never moves them across, so a brand trying to win switchers needs a reason other than the price.
  3. A third: the price-first buyer is the hardest to move with a free phone, because a 36-month tie is a cost to them too. An offer for that buyer may need to be free without the lock-in, which this study did not test.

06What do people also ask about phone trade-in deals?

  • What share of people would switch phone brand for a free phone? 6.0% (12 of 200 clones on Brox's US Tech panel, October 2026) would take a free phone from another brand when a new model from their own brand costs $1,000, while 93.0% (186) would keep their current phone.
  • At what trade-in credit do people upgrade a phone that still works? Only when the credit makes it free: 40.7% (81 of 199, October 2026) would upgrade with $1,000 of credit on a $1,000 phone, against 4.5% (9 of 200) with $500 and 2.0% (4 of 200) with $200.
  • How many people choose a phone mainly for the carrier deal? 4.5% (9 of 200, October 2026) say a trade-in credit or carrier deal matters most when they choose a smartphone, against 39.0% (78) who put staying with their brand and apps first.

Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“I would say I am very likely to do that. Usually, I play it pretty smart with technology and I really don't tend to upgrade unless something completely stops working. But I've always said that if my phone carrier sends me a deal where it's basically a free upgrade for a smartphone, I would definitely take advantage of that. If the new model costs me nothing after the credits and it's the brand I already use and love, it's a great opportunity that I wouldn't pass up.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Or also if my phone carrier sends me a deal where it's like a free upgrade for a smartphone, I would also take advantage of that as well.”

Woman, 18-29, South Carolina, iPhone user, very likely to take a free upgrade supports finding 1

“I would just keep my current phone. If it's still working fine, there's really no reason for me to change anything. I'm pretty frugal and like to hold onto my devices for as long as possible until they start having actual problems or the hardware starts going out. Plus, I really prefer iOS and I'm used to how it works, so getting locked into a 36-month contract with another brand just for a free device isn't worth it, and spending $1,000 on a new model when my phone works great doesn't make any financial sense.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“It's a good system, but it's easy to use. And Android's okay, but I just prefer iOS.”

Woman, 30-44, Alabama, iPhone user, would take a free upgrade but not a free switch supports finding 2

“For me, it really comes down to the carrier deal or what's offered with the phone plan. When I bought my current phone, it basically came with the plan so I spent close to nothing on the phone itself. If I had to switch or get my next smartphone, my first move would definitely be going back to the plan to see if I can get a smartphone included. Getting a phone through the carrier plan is just an extra bonus and makes it so much easier to buy.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Thinking ahead in the future if I had to switch your phone, I would definitely go back to this plan See if I get a smartphone there. I like when phones come with the phone plan. It makes it easier to buy”

Man, 45-64, New York, Samsung user, puts the carrier deal first supports finding 3

Section 08: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • The shape of the ladder: no clone became less likely to upgrade as the credit grew (0 of 200 moved down the scale), and the jump comes only at the level that makes the phone free: 4 of 200 likely at $200, 9 of 200 at $500, 81 of 199 at $1,000.
  • That a free phone buys an upgrade far more readily than a brand switch, on the same clones: 70 of the 81 likely to take a free new model from their own brand would keep their current phone rather than take a free one from another brand.
  • That the deal ranks last of the four reasons for choosing a phone, among iPhone users (3 of 83) and everyone else (6 of 117) alike. This question has the most direct evidence on the page: 52 of 200 answers rest on something the person said about choosing a phone.

What we would not

  • The exact share at each credit level. The answers to the three trade-in scenarios are reasoned from what each person said about when they replace a phone (145 of 199 answers at the free level cite such a line), not from anything they said about a credit of that size: 2, 2 and 0 of the answers rest on a direct statement. Read 2.0%, 4.5% and 40.7% as a shape, not as take-up rates.
  • The size of the gap between 40.7% and 6.0%. The two questions were asked differently: one on a likelihood scale, the other as a forced choice that offered keeping the current phone, which draws more answers to the status quo.
  • That a deal does not matter at all. One forced choice records what matters most; a trade-in credit can still be a strong second reason, which this study did not measure.
  • The age split as a US estimate. The panel holds 7 clones under 30 and 52 aged 65 or over, and 139 of the 200 are women, so younger buyers, the ones carrier offers target hardest, are barely here. Ask Brox gave 5 of the 200 clones a different age band on different questions; this page cuts age on the first question's record.

The main limitation

These are stated answers to hypothetical offers from 200 clones on Brox's US Tech panel, which skews older and female, and the three trade-in scenarios were reasoned from what people said about replacing phones rather than from a direct statement about such an offer, so the page measures the shape of the response, not take-up.

Section 09: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Aged 18-297
Aged 30-4454
Aged 45-6487
Aged 65 and over52

Question wording as fielded

  1. Does your current smartphone still work?
  2. In general, when you choose your next smartphone, which ONE of these matters most to you?
  3. The smartphone you use now still works well. A new model from the brand you use now costs $1,000. Your carrier offers you $200 of trade-in credit for your current phone towards it, paid as monthly bill credits over 36 months while you stay on your plan. How likely are you to upgrade to the new model in the next month?
  4. The smartphone you use now still works well. A new model from the brand you use now costs $1,000. Your carrier offers you $500 of trade-in credit for your current phone towards it, paid as monthly bill credits over 36 months while you stay on your plan. How likely are you to upgrade to the new model in the next month?
  5. The smartphone you use now still works well. A new model from the brand you use now costs $1,000. Your carrier offers you $1,000 of trade-in credit for your current phone towards it, paid as monthly bill credits over 36 months while you stay on your plan, so the new model costs you nothing. How likely are you to upgrade to the new model in the next month?
  6. The smartphone you use now still works well. Your carrier offers you a new phone from a different brand from the one you use now for free when you trade in your current phone and stay on your plan for 36 months. A new model from the brand you use now would cost you $1,000. What would you most likely do?
  7. Which of the following smartphone brands do you currently use?

What was not asked, and why

No phone maker or carrier was named in the questions. Ask Brox added a screener on whether the current phone still works (681 of 687 said yes, so it did not narrow the panel) and a question on which brand each clone uses now, which this page uses only to split the results; one brand on that list appears in the data table as "Another named brand" (31 of 688). We did not test a credit paid upfront rather than over 36 months, a credit between $500 and $1,000, an offer without a plan commitment, or a trade-in when the phone is broken, and we did not ask how people bought their last phone, because a clone's recall of a past purchase is not held as data.

What changed from the obvious question

The obvious question asks people how much deals matter, which invites a polite yes. We separated the two things a deal could decide: when someone upgrades (the same working phone and the same $1,000 model, with only the trade-in credit changed across three levels) and which phone they choose (a free phone from another brand against their own brand at full price), and asked the same clones both.

Fielded through Ask Brox on 28 October 2026.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai

Related insights

All in this topic