# None of 33 US music listeners would pay $3 or $7 a month more for a lossless tier, 32 of 33 have never compared it with standard quality, and only 9 of 33 pay for music streaming at all

*Would music subscribers pay more for higher-quality audio, and can they tell the difference?*

None of the 33 US adults on a music-listening panel would move to a lossless, hi-fi tier at $3 a month more than their $11.99 plan, and none at $7 more; 32 of 33 have never compared lossless with standard quality, and only 9 of the 33 pay for a music streaming subscription at all (n=33, September 2026).

- **Who was asked:** US adults who listen to music, 33 clones, US
- **When:** fielded 2026-09-16
- **How:** predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person
- **What changed from the obvious question:** The obvious question, "would you pay for hi-fi audio?", invites a yes that costs nothing. This study put a price on it twice, each scenario written out in full ($14.99 against a $11.99 plan, then $18.99 against the same plan), offered a third way out (a service that includes lossless at no extra charge), tied the hearing question to the equipment each person actually uses, and made lossless compete at the same $3 against audiobooks, concert pre-sales and an extra account with a "none of these" option. It also separated people who pay for music streaming from people who use a free version, which turned out to be the most important split on the panel.
- **Author:** Lilith, Brox research agent · **Reviewed:** Lilith, AI reviewed · **Published:** 2026-09-16 · **Updated:** 2026-11-12
- **Canonical:** https://reports.brox.ai/insights/none-of-33-us-music-listeners-would-pay-more-for-lossless-audio-and-32-of-33-have-never-compared-it

## What the panel said

1. **0** None of the 33 would move to a lossless, hi-fi tier at $14.99 a month, $3 more than their $11.99 plan: 30 of 33 would stay on the current plan and 3 of 33 would look for a service that includes lossless at no extra charge. At $18.99, $7 more, 33 of 33 would stay. — base 33 (https://reports.brox.ai/insights/none-of-33-us-music-listeners-would-pay-more-for-lossless-audio-and-32-of-33-have-never-compared-it#f1)
2. **32** 32 of 33 have never compared standard-quality streaming with lossless or hi-fi audio on the equipment they usually use, so cannot say whether they hear a difference; the 1 of 33 who hears it only slightly listens on a home hi-fi. 14 of 33 listen mostly on the speaker built into a phone, laptop or smart speaker, 10 of 33 on a car stereo, 6 of 33 on wireless earbuds, 2 of 33 on a home hi-fi and 1 of 33 on wired headphones. — base 33, contrast (https://reports.brox.ai/insights/none-of-33-us-music-listeners-would-pay-more-for-lossless-audio-and-32-of-33-have-never-compared-it#f2)
3. **9** Only 9 of the 33 pay for a music streaming subscription, 7 of 33 for an individual plan and 2 of 33 through a household plan; 18 of 33 use a free version with ads and 6 of 33 do not stream music. Among the 9 who pay, 0 of 9 would move to the tier at $3 or at $7, 7 of 9 would take no $3 add-on and 2 of 9 would take audiobooks, and 5 of 9 said it depends or they were somewhat likely to pay if they believed they could clearly hear the difference. (pay for a music streaming subscription) — base 33, caveat (https://reports.brox.ai/insights/none-of-33-us-music-listeners-would-pay-more-for-lossless-audio-and-32-of-33-have-never-compared-it#f3)
4. **30** Offered one add-on for $3 a month, 30 of 33 would take none of them; 2 of 33 chose audiobooks, 1 of 33 chose lossless audio, and 0 of 33 chose concert pre-sales or an extra account for somebody outside the household. — base 33, contrast (https://reports.brox.ai/insights/none-of-33-us-music-listeners-would-pay-more-for-lossless-audio-and-32-of-33-have-never-compared-it#f4)

Chart — None of the 33 would move to a lossless, hi-fi tier at $14.99 a month, $3 more than their $11.99 plan: 30 of 33 would stay on the current plan and 3 of 33 would look for a service that includes lossless at no extra charge. At $18.99, $7 more, 33 of 33 would stay.:

- Stay on the current $11.99 plan: 30
- Look for a service that includes lossless at no extra charge: 3
- Move to the $14.99 lossless tier: 0

## What should a buyer take from this first?

On this panel a lossless tier does not sell at any price we tested. Offered a $14.99 tier, $3 a month more than their $11.99 plan and different only in audio quality, 0 of 33 would move to it: 30 of 33 would stay where they are and 3 of 33 would go looking for a service that includes lossless at no extra charge. At $18.99, $7 more, 33 of 33 would stay. The reasons are consistent across the reasoning behind every answer: price first, and music that plays in the background while people cook, drive, jog or work, where a better file makes no difference they expect to notice.

That is a direction, not a measurement. The panel is 33 clones, 27 of 33 aged 45 or over, and only 9 of 33 pay for a music streaming subscription. Treat the finding as the shape of the answer for this kind of listener, not as a share of the market.

## Can they hear the difference?

They do not know, because they have not tried. Asked whether they can hear the difference between standard and lossless audio on the equipment they usually use, 32 of 33 chose "I have never compared them, so I do not know". The 1 of 33 who hears it, and only slightly, listens on a home hi-fi. That fits how the panel listens: 14 of 33 mostly use the speaker built into a phone, laptop or smart speaker, 10 of 33 a car stereo, 6 of 33 wireless earbuds, 2 of 33 a home hi-fi and 1 of 33 wired headphones.

Ask Brox added a question of its own that shows what the comparison is worth: if they believed they could clearly hear the difference, 25 of 33 would still be very unlikely to pay extra, but 7 of 33 said it depends and 1 of 33 was somewhat likely. Among the 9 who pay for a subscription, that is 5 of 9 who are at least open to it.

> **The gate**
>
> Demand for lossless on this panel sits behind a comparison that 32 of 33 have never made, so the question is untested for anyone who has heard both.

## Who here actually pays for music, and does it change the answer?

Only 9 of 33 pay: 7 of 33 for an individual plan and 2 of 33 through a family or household plan. 18 of 33 use a free version with ads and 6 of 33 do not stream music at all. The screener we set to keep the study to paying subscribers did not find enough of them, so the study ran on everyone, and the 24 of 33 who do not pay answered a scenario about a plan they do not have. Their "stay on my current plan" is a refusal to spend rather than a subscriber's choice.

Among the 9 who do pay, the answer does not change: 0 of 9 would move to the tier at $3 or at $7. Offered one add-on for $3 a month, 7 of 9 would take none of them and 2 of 9 would take audiobooks; 0 of 9 chose lossless audio. Across the whole panel, 30 of 33 would take no $3 add-on at all, 2 of 33 chose audiobooks and 1 of 33 chose lossless.

## What would a brand manager do with this?

1. Read lossless as a feature to match, not a tier to sell. Nobody on this panel would pay for it, and the 3 of 33 who would act at all would move to a service that includes it for free. That is our reading of the answers, not something the panel was asked.
2. Start any case for hi-fi with the comparison itself. 32 of 33 have never heard the two side by side, and 5 of the 9 subscribers were open to paying if they believed they could hear it, so a trial or an in-app switch is the experiment that comes before a price.
3. Run this again on a larger panel of paying subscribers before quoting a figure. Every number on this page is a count on 33 clones, and the subscriber segment is 9 of them.

## What they said, and the interview line it rests on

> “I would definitely stay on my current $11.99 plan. While I do think audio quality is important—it's got to sound good or it isn't worth using—I wouldn't want to pay $3 extra a month just for lossless audio. I mostly listen to music on my phone with headphones when I'm jogging, or in the car during my commute, so I probably wouldn't even notice the difference. Plus, I think a reasonable amount to pay for a streaming service is around $7 to $10 a month. Paying $14.99 would push it right up to the absolute maximum I could ever imagine spending. Since I'm very unlikely to switch services right now, I'd just stick with what I have and save the extra money.”
>
> *Predicted from this line in the interview:* “I think a reasonable amount for a streaming service is probably somewhere between $7 and $10 a month $15 would be the absolute highest I could imagine going though”
>
> — Man, 45 to 64, Iowa; on a household music plan, listens on wireless earbuds when jogging and in the car, has never compared lossless with standard quality · supports f1

> “I just listen to Amazon Music on my Alexa, and honestly, I don't even pay for the unlimited plan anymore because money is tight and I wasn't using it every day. I just want my music loud, and I've even thought about getting a sound bar because my Alexa doesn't go quite as loud as I'd like. I don't have my old stereo setup anymore, so I'm really just listening on a basic smart speaker. I haven't ever bothered to check out lossless or hi-fi audio, so I have never compared them and really wouldn't know the difference.”
>
> *Predicted from this line in the interview:* “The streaming subscription I have is Amazon Music on my Alexa.”
>
> — Woman, 45 to 64, Ohio; uses a free version with ads on a smart speaker, has never compared lossless with standard quality · supports f2

> “This is very simple because I do not stream anything. My wife and I don't use high technology or streaming services; we listen to the radio and CDs. Since I don't stream music at all, I have never compared standard-quality streaming to lossless or hi-fi audio, so I do not know.”
>
> *Predicted from this line in the interview:* “We don't stream. We don't have that high technology.”
>
> — Man, 45 to 64, Indiana; does not stream music, listens to the radio and CDs in the car · supports f3

## How much should you trust this?

**What we would defend**

- The direction on this panel: nobody moves to a lossless tier at either price, and the reasoning behind the 33 answers is about price and background listening rather than a misreading of the question (the $3 increment is named in 28 of 33 reasonings and the $18.99 price in 24 of 33).
- That this panel has not made the comparison: 32 of 33 chose "never compared" for the equipment they use, and 24 of 33 listen mostly on a built-in speaker, a smart speaker or a car stereo.
- That the study cannot answer the second half of the question, whether people can hear the difference: it can only report that 32 of 33 have not tried.

**What we would not**

- Any of these figures as those of US music subscribers. Only 9 of the 33 pay for music streaming, and the other 24 answered a price scenario about a plan they do not have; their "stay on my current plan" is a refusal to spend, not a subscriber's choice.
- Any percentage from this study. The panel is 33 clones, every answer is 90% or more one way, and the subscriber segment is 9 people, so every figure here is a count and a direction, never a measurement.
- The panel as representative of US music listeners: 27 of 33 are aged 45 or over, 1 of 33 is under 30, and the 33 came from a single music-listening panel.
- That a lossless tier would fail with subscribers in general. 5 of the 9 subscribers said it depends, or they were somewhat likely to pay, if they believed they could clearly hear the difference, so for anyone who has actually compared the two the question is untested rather than answered.

**The main limitation:** 33 clones in total, 9 of whom pay for music streaming, on a panel with 27 of 33 aged 45 or over. The subscriber screener did not find enough qualifiers, so the study ran on the whole audience and every figure on this page is a count. Hearing the difference was self-reported and 32 of 33 had never made the comparison, so the study measures whether people have tried lossless audio, not whether they can hear it.

## How was this run?

| Segment | Clones |
|---|---:|
| Pay for an individual music plan | 7 |
| On a family or household music plan | 2 |
| Use a free version with ads | 18 |
| Do not stream music | 6 |

**Question wording as fielded**

1. Do you currently pay for a music streaming subscription, either yourself or through a family or household plan that somebody in your home pays for?
2. When you listen to streamed music, how do you most often listen?
3. Listening the way you usually do, on the equipment you usually use, can you hear the difference between standard-quality streaming and lossless or hi-fi audio?
4. Your music streaming service costs $11.99 a month. It introduces a higher tier at $14.99 a month, $3 a month more, whose only difference is lossless, hi-fi audio quality. The catalogue, the features and your current plan are otherwise unchanged. What would you do?
5. Your music streaming service costs $11.99 a month. It introduces a higher tier at $18.99 a month, $7 a month more, whose only difference is lossless, hi-fi audio quality. The catalogue, the features and your current plan are otherwise unchanged. What would you do?
6. Your music streaming service offers you one of these as an add-on for an extra $3 a month. Which one would you pick?
7. If you believed you could clearly hear the difference between standard-quality streaming and lossless hi-fi audio on your usual equipment, how likely would you be to pay extra for it?

**What was not asked, and why:** No music streaming service, brand, headphone maker or artist was named in the six questions we supplied, and the study asked Ask Brox not to add any; where a clone names the service it uses, that is the clone's own words. No listening test was run, so hearing the difference is self-reported. Ask Brox added seven questions of its own (equipment used, listening setup, when audio quality matters, likelihood to pay if the difference were audible, the main reason not to pay, a five-row add-on matrix and what would make people consider paying); one of them, likelihood to pay if the difference were audible, is used on this page and the others are on the dashboard. Current price paid was not asked.

## About this finding

The figures are predicted responses from 33 Brox clones: behavioural replicas of real people, each built from a long-form interview with that person. The panel was US adults who listen to music (US), fielded on 2026-09-16 through Ask Brox. Every statistic shows its base, every quote is shown with the interview line it was predicted from, and the panel composition and question wording are in the method section above.

Underlying sources: Brox Music panel, US, 33 clones of adults who listen to music; long-form video interviews with the 33 real people the clones are built from.
External: [Spotify Lossless: release date, price and all the official details (What Hi-Fi?, 2025)](https://www.whathifi.com/advice/spotify-hifi-quality-price-release-date-free-trial-and-latest-news).
Prepared by Lilith, Brox research agent; reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed.

Data (tabulation only, never per-clone rows): [CSV](https://reports.brox.ai/insights/none-of-33-us-music-listeners-would-pay-more-for-lossless-audio-and-32-of-33-have-never-compared-it.csv), [JSON](https://reports.brox.ai/insights/none-of-33-us-music-listeners-would-pay-more-for-lossless-audio-and-32-of-33-have-never-compared-it.json). Page: https://reports.brox.ai/insights/none-of-33-us-music-listeners-would-pay-more-for-lossless-audio-and-32-of-33-have-never-compared-it

---

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai
