Time-of-use tariffs: 70.2% of British bill payers say a never-pay-more guarantee would do most to make them shift

70.2% of British bill payers (n=114, September 2026) say a guarantee they would never pay more than on a standard tariff would do most to make them move electricity use to cheaper times of day, while only 21.1% are very likely to switch for a saving of £50 a year.

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
UK bill payers, 114 clones, GB
When
September 2026 (fielded 26 September 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
Rather than ask whether people would shift their use (which nearly everyone says yes to), the study wrote out the same tariff three times at £50, £150 and £300 a year to find where willingness tips, then asked for the single biggest barrier and the single biggest remedy as forced choices. Only people who choose the tariff and pay the bill, alone or jointly, answered.

Section 01: What the panel said

  1. #

    70.2%

    70.2% of British bill payers say a guarantee they would never pay more than on a standard tariff would do most to make them move electricity use to cheaper times of day; 16.7% chose self-scheduling appliances and nobody chose one-off peak payments.

    base 114

  2. #

    64.9%

    64.9% name their routine (work, children, cooking) as the main thing that would put them off; 21.1% name the risk of a higher bill and nobody names safety.

    base 114

  3. #

    21.1%

    Only 21.1% are very likely to switch and change when they run appliances for a saving of £50 a year; at £150 a year that rises to 89.5%.

    base 114 · contrast

  4. #

    63

    Stated intent runs ahead of practice: 63 of the 74 who say their routine does not allow shifting still rated themselves likely or very likely to switch for £50 a year.

    base 74 · Bill payers whose main barrier is their routine · caveat

70.2% of British bill payers say a guarantee they would never pay more than on a standard tariff would do most to make them move electricity use to cheaper times of day; 16.7% chose self-scheduling appliances and nobody chose one-off peak payments.

A never-pay-more guarantee
70.2%
Appliances that switch on at the cheap time
16.7%
An app showing the weekly saving
11.4%
None of these
1.8%
One-off payments for cutting peak use
0%

Base 114 clones.

02What is the first thing a supplier should take from this?

The fear is the bill, not the chore. Asked what would do most to make them move electricity use away from the 4pm to 7pm peak, 70.2% of British bill payers (n=114) chose a guarantee that they would never pay more than on a standard tariff. Appliances that switch themselves on at the cheap time came a distant second at 16.7%, and one-off payments for cutting peak use drew nobody at all.

The guarantee led in every age group and for men and women alike, and it led even among people whose main objection was their routine: 52 of the 74 who said work, children and cooking get in the way still picked the guarantee over automation.

03Where does the answer change, and for whom?

Among the 24 people whose main worry was the bill going up if they got the timing wrong, 22 chose the guarantee, and 15 were already very likely to switch for as little as £50 a year. That is the reading a researcher would find most interesting: the most anxious bill payers are the keenest to try, once the downside is taken away. It rests on 24 people, so it is a count to explore, not a share to plan on.

Older bill payers answer differently, although the numbers are small. Of the 12 aged 45 to 64, 7 named the risk of a higher bill as the main barrier and 5 named their routine, where every younger group put routine first by a wide margin.

04How much saving does it take?

Each saving was asked as a separate, fully written question. At £50 a year only 21.1% of bill payers (n=114) said they were very likely to switch and change when they run the washing machine, dishwasher and tumble dryer, though most said they were likely. At £150 a year that rose to 89.5%, and at £300 a year it was everyone.

The defensible reading is the direction: somewhere between £50 and £150 a year, a time-of-use tariff stops being something people would consider and becomes something they say they would do. The near-unanimous answers at the higher savings are the kind a stated-intent question produces, and we would not plan a take-up rate on them.

05What would a supplier or a regulator do with this?

  1. Our reading, not the panel's answer: lead a time-of-use offer with bill protection, a cap at the standard tariff for the first year, before automation or an app, because protection answers the objection most people actually have.
  2. Our reading: sell the tariff on an annual saving nearer £150 than £50, and say plainly which appliances it assumes will move, because routine is the barrier a guarantee does not remove.
  3. Our reading: with the price cap rising 4% from 1 October 2026, the appetite to save is there, but a saving that needs every weekday evening rearranged will be heard as a risk rather than an offer.

Section 06: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“For me, having a guarantee that I would never pay more than on a standard tariff would do the most. I work very hard for my money as a healthcare assistant doing night shifts, and I have to plan every pound carefully to make sure my family and children are looked after. Between 4pm and 7pm is usually when I bring my children home from school and prepare their meals, so it is a busy time in the house. If I were to try moving what electricity use I could to cheaper times, I would need peace of mind knowing that it won't backfire and make my bills higher than they normally are.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I would say my approach to money is I don't just spend my money because I work so hard to get the money. What I spend is I have to plan.”

Woman, 30 to 44, pays the bill on her own, works night shifts supports finding 1

“Definitely that my routine doesn't allow it with work, the children, and cooking. I work six nights a week, so my schedule has to be strictly organized. I get home at 6 in the morning, sort the kids' breakfast and school lunches, sleep from 9 until 3 in the afternoon, and then once I'm up, I have to shower, get dinner sorted for the family, and head straight back out to work. That peak window between 4pm and 7pm is right when I have to be up, getting dinner cooked and sorting the family before my night shift starts, so there's just no way we could shift all that around.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Obviously routine is very important. My daily routine, I work nights, finish at 6 in the morning, make sure my family's got breakfast, make sure they've got lunches before they go to school, make sure wife's happy and then I go to sleep 9 till 3 in the daytime and then wake up, I have a shower and then do dinner and then I go to work.”

Man, 30 to 44, married with two children, works nights supports finding 2

“I'd say 4. Being a single parent, I have to be careful with my money, and as I always say, you save wherever you can. Fifty pounds a year might not sound like a huge fortune to some people, but it's fifty pounds back in your pocket that could go towards food, heat, or something for my daughter. The 4pm to 7pm window is usually when I'm getting home, helping my daughter, and sorting out dinner anyway, so it wouldn't be too much trouble to wait and put the washing machine or tumble dryer on later in the evening after she goes to bed, or just do it at the weekend.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Being a single parent, I'm careful with my money and quite often have to prioritise what needs to come”

Woman, 30 to 44, Essex, single parent working part time supports finding 3

Section 07: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • The guarantee is the leading lever at 70.2% (n=114), and it leads in every age group, for men and women, and among those whose main barrier is their routine (52 of 74).
  • Routine is the main barrier at 64.9% (n=114), ahead of the risk of a higher bill (21.1%); nobody named safety.
  • At £50 a year only 21.1% (n=114) are very likely to switch.

What we would not

  • The 89.5% at £150 a year and the 100% at £300 a year as take-up forecasts: near-unanimous stated intent is direction only.
  • Any split by age above 44: only 13 of the 114 bill payers were 45 or older, so the older answers are counts (7 of 12 aged 45 to 64 named the risk of a higher bill).
  • The 15 of 24 worriers who were very likely at £50 a year: an interesting count, too small to size.

The main limitation

The qualifying bill payers are young (95 of 114 are under 45) and the saving questions measure stated intent, which runs ahead of what people do: 63 of the 74 who said their routine does not allow shifting still said they were likely to switch at £50 a year.

Section 08: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Aged 18 to 2941
Aged 30 to 4454
Aged 45 to 6412
Aged 65 and over1
Age not recorded6

Question wording as fielded

  1. Who in your household chooses the energy tariff and pays the electricity bill? (screener: me on my own, or jointly with someone else, qualified)
  2. Imagine your electricity supplier offers a tariff where electricity between 4pm and 7pm on weekdays costs more and electricity at all other times costs less. If moving your washing machine, dishwasher and tumble dryer out of 4pm to 7pm would save your household £50 a year, how likely would you be to switch to that tariff and change when you use them? 1 to 5, where 1 is very unlikely and 5 is very likely.
  3. Imagine your electricity supplier offers a tariff where electricity between 4pm and 7pm on weekdays costs more and electricity at all other times costs less. If moving your washing machine, dishwasher and tumble dryer out of 4pm to 7pm would save your household £150 a year, how likely would you be to switch to that tariff and change when you use them? 1 to 5, where 1 is very unlikely and 5 is very likely.
  4. Imagine your electricity supplier offers a tariff where electricity between 4pm and 7pm on weekdays costs more and electricity at all other times costs less. If moving your washing machine, dishwasher and tumble dryer out of 4pm to 7pm would save your household £300 a year, how likely would you be to switch to that tariff and change when you use them? 1 to 5, where 1 is very unlikely and 5 is very likely.
  5. Which one of these would most put you off moving your household electricity use to cheaper times of day?
  6. Which one of these would do most to make you move your household electricity use to cheaper times of day?

What was not asked, and why

We did not ask whether anyone is already on a time-of-use tariff, owns a smart meter, an electric vehicle or a heat pump, or how their bill is set today, and we did not name any supplier or tariff. The peak window was fixed at 4pm to 7pm on weekdays and the appliances at the washing machine, dishwasher and tumble dryer.

What changed from the obvious question

Rather than ask whether people would shift their use (which nearly everyone says yes to), the study wrote out the same tariff three times at £50, £150 and £300 a year to find where willingness tips, then asked for the single biggest barrier and the single biggest remedy as forced choices. Only people who choose the tariff and pay the bill, alone or jointly, answered.

Fielded through Ask Brox on 26 September 2026.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai