Medicare Advantage members would stay for their doctors, not a lower price: 12 of 23 name keeping their providers

Asked what would most keep them with their insurer if their plan ended, 12 of 23 US Medicare Advantage members on the panel named keeping their own doctors and 2 named lower costs, September 2026.

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
US Medicare Advantage members, 200 clones, US
When
September 2026 (fielded 26 September 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question is which benefits win at open enrollment. This asked instead what a member would do when the choice is forced on them by their own plan ending, because that is the moment a switch actually happens.

Section 01: What the panel said

  1. #

    12

    For the Medicare Advantage members on this panel, keeping their own doctors is the one thing that would hold them to their insurer.

    base 23

  2. #

    20

    Continuity is the default: almost every Medicare Advantage member on the panel would take the replacement plan their insurer offers rather than shop.

    base 22

  3. #

    43.5%

    Off the Medicare Advantage base the ranking reverses: among the panellists not on such a plan, lower costs leads at 43.5%.

    base 177 · contrast

  4. #

    12

    Among the Medicare Advantage members, keeping their doctors is named more often than costs, trust, coverage and service put together.

    base 23

Among the Medicare Advantage members, keeping their doctors is named more often than costs, trust, coverage and service put together.

Keep my doctors (base 23)
12
Familiarity and trust (base 23)
6
Lower costs (base 23)
2
Better coverage (base 23)
2
Customer service (base 23)
1

Base 23 clones.

02What is the first thing a plan should take from this?

When a health plan ends, the people who are actually on one do not reach for the price first. Asked what would most keep them with their insurer, 12 of the 23 Medicare Advantage members on this panel named keeping their own doctors. Two named lower costs.

That order matters because a replacement offer is usually written around the premium and the out-of-pocket maximum. On this evidence the first thing a member wants to know is whether their own doctors and hospital are still in the network.

03Where does the answer change, and for whom?

It reverses completely off that base. Among the 177 panellists who are not on a Medicare Advantage plan, lower costs led at 43.5% and keeping doctors followed at 30.5%. The same question, the same fielding, the opposite ranking.

The wider panel is answering about a plan they do not hold, which is exactly why the headline number a study like this produces can point the wrong way. Cost is what people say about insurance in the abstract. Doctors are what they say when the plan is their own.

04What would a retention team do with this?

  1. Lead the replacement offer with the network, not the premium. This is a reading of a small base, not the panel's instruction: 23 clones answered, so it is a signal to test rather than a settled number.
  2. Treat staying as the default and protect it. Of the Medicare Advantage members asked, 20 of 22 would take the replacement plan their insurer offers rather than shop, though that option was the status quo and was named first, so some of it is inertia rather than loyalty.
  3. Watch the small group that would leave. Two of the 22 would move to a rival plan and none chose Original Medicare with a Medigap policy, which suggests the risk at a forced re-shop is losing people to another plan of the same kind.

Section 05: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“My oncologist, my primary care physician and the hospital clinic system know my history inside and out. That continuity of care is vital to my life. If our plan were discontinued and we had to pick another plan from the same insurer, making sure I do not lose access to those doctors would be the deciding factor.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“It's specific to the hospital and medical clinic system that we utilize all of the time. So our providers that we are familiar with and comfortable with are always covered in the plan.”

Woman, 65 plus, Illinois, on a Medicare Advantage plan, transplant survivor supports finding 1

Section 06: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • The ranking inside the Medicare Advantage group: doctors first, cost near the bottom.
  • The direction of the gap between the two groups, which is large and identical across both pulls of the data.

What we would not

  • Any percentage for Medicare Advantage members, because the base is under 30.
  • The 20 of 22 read as a retention rate: the insurer's own plan was the status quo option and was named first in the question.
  • A 65 plus reading, because age could not be cut independently of enrollment.

The main limitation

Only 82 of 779 panellists screened were on a Medicare Advantage plan and 23 of them answered the retention question, so every Medicare Advantage figure here is a count on a small base.

Section 07: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
On a Medicare Advantage plan23
Not on a Medicare Advantage plan177

Question wording as fielded

  1. Are you currently enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan?
  2. If the Medicare Advantage plan you are on were discontinued for next year and you had to choose again during open enrolment, would you take the replacement plan your current insurer offers you, move to a different insurer's Medicare Advantage plan, or go back to Original Medicare with a Medigap policy?
  3. What would most make you stay with your current insurer?

What was not asked, and why

Nobody was asked to compare named insurers or named plans, and nobody was given premiums in dollars, so this shows what people reach for first, not what they would pay.

What changed from the obvious question

The obvious question is which benefits win at open enrollment. This asked instead what a member would do when the choice is forced on them by their own plan ending, because that is the moment a switch actually happens.

Fielded through Ask Brox on 26 September 2026.

If you work on plan retention and think this is wrong, tell us, and we will run it again on a Medicare-only panel.

Related insights

All in this topic