Loyalty points devaluation: 43.2% of US members move bookings at a 25% points rise, against 12.7% at 10%

43.2% of US travelers in an airline or hotel loyalty program would move some or most of their future bookings to a competitor if a free flight or night cost 25% more points, up from 12.7% at a 10% rise (n=118, November 2026).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published
Who was asked
Travel, 118 clones, US
When
November 2026 (fielded 21 November 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question asks what members do after a devaluation. We asked 118 clones of US loyalty members to react to three written announcements of the same change, 10%, 25% and 50% more points for a free flight or night with cash prices and service unchanged, then which one step would keep their bookings. That shows where the reaction turns, not only what it is.

Section 01: What the panel said

  1. #

    43.2%

    43.2% (51 of 118) would move some or most of their future bookings to a competitor if a free flight or night cost 25% more points, against 12.7% at a 10% rise and 60.2% at a 50% rise.

    base 118

  2. #

    30.5%

    30.5% (36 of 118) would keep booking as before at a 25% points rise, down from 70.3% at 10%: the cliff sits between the two.

    base 118

  3. #

    22%

    22.0% (26 of 118) would move most of their future bookings even at a 50% points rise; more would move only some (38.1%).

    base 118 · caveat

  4. #

    91.5%

    91.5% (108 of 118) say keeping the value of points they already hold would do most to keep their bookings after a 25% rise; notice and a points bonus barely register.

    base 118

43.2% (51 of 118) would move some or most of their future bookings to a competitor if a free flight or night cost 25% more points, against 12.7% at a 10% rise and 60.2% at a 50% rise.

10% more points
12.7%
25% more points
43.2%
50% more points
60.2%

Base 118 clones.

02What does a points devaluation actually cost a loyalty program?

What the numbers support: the turn comes between a 10% and a 25% rise in the points needed for a free flight or night. At 10%, 70.3% of members keep booking as before (83 of 118). At 25%, that falls to 30.5% (36 of 118). The ladder holds clone by clone, too: 117 of the 118 clones never react less strongly to a bigger cut than to a smaller one.

The interesting reading: a 25% devaluation mostly costs a program share of wallet, not members. Only 9.3% would move most of their future bookings at 25% (11 of 118), while 33.9% would move some (40 of 118). And 26.3% would first rush to spend the points they hold before the change, then carry on (31 of 118), which turns a devaluation into a short spike in redemptions before it saves the program anything.

03Does the cliff look the same for every kind of member?

Yes, in every group large enough to read. At a 50% rise, 61.5% of members aged 45 to 64 would move some or most bookings (32 of 52), and 57.9% of those 65 and older (22 of 38). Among members aged 30 to 44 the count is 15 of 24, and the panel holds only 4 members under 30, so younger travelers are not covered here.

The interesting reading, and not one we would lean on: men move sooner. At a 25% rise, 54.2% of men would move bookings (26 of 48) against 35.7% of women (25 of 70). By 50% the gap narrows to 64.6% against 57.1%.

04What can a loyalty program do to keep members through a devaluation?

Protect the points members already hold. Asked which one step would do most to keep their bookings after a 25% rise, 91.5% chose keeping the current value of points already earned (108 of 118). Six months of notice was picked by 3 clones and a one-time points bonus by 1. Six said nothing would keep their bookings.

  1. A reading, not the panel's answer: a change that applies only to points earned after a set date looks likely to keep most of the members who would otherwise move some bookings at 25%.
  2. A second reading: keep any single step under the 25% mark. At 10%, 12.7% would move some or most bookings (15 of 118), against 43.2% at 25% (51 of 118).

05What do people also ask about loyalty points devaluation?

What share of loyalty members would move bookings after a 25% points devaluation? 43.2% would move some or most of their future bookings to a competitor (51 of 118, November 2026).

At what devaluation do most loyalty members stop booking as before? Between 10% and 25%: booking as before falls from 70.3% at a 10% rise to 30.5% at 25% (n=118).

How many loyalty members would rush to spend their points before a 25% devaluation? 26.3% would spend their points before the change and then carry on as before (31 of 118).

Section 06: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“If an airline or hotel loyalty program pulled a stunt like that and bumped up the points needed for a free night or flight by 25%, I definitely wouldn't just take it lying down or keep booking like nothing happened. We get squeezed enough as consumers, and being on a fixed income, I have to watch every penny and make sure I get actual value out of my loyalty. My reaction whenever a company raises prices on me is to check out the competition before deciding what to do. I’d start moving some of my future bookings over to a competitor to see what kind of deals, rates, and perks they offer in comparison. If the competitor treats me better and gives me more bang for my buck, then that's where my business will go.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“So that taught me a lesson to if something goes up in price to check out the competition. Before I either pay the price or give up the product.”

Woman, 65 or older, Arizona, loyalty program member supports finding 1

“A 50% increase in points is definitely too much. If a price goes up that much, I have to rethink using it anymore. I would look around and move most of my future bookings to a competitor that gives better value.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“It depends how much it will increase price. If too much, I have to rethink to use it anymore.”

Woman, 45 to 64, Washington, loyalty program member supports finding 3

“If an airline or hotel program decided to raise redemption costs by 25%, the most important thing for me would be that the points I already hold keep their current value. I believe in fairness and keeping agreements; I earned those points under the understanding of what they were worth, so retroactively devaluing them would feel like a breach of trust. While notice is nice, protecting the value of what I've already accumulated would do the most to keep me loyal to the program.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“It does matter to me just because of transparency. I would like to know if something's sponsored or not, because then I may not at least I know it's more of an honesty and authenticity feeling.”

Woman, 65 or older, Idaho, loyalty program member supports finding 4

Section 07: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • The turn comes between a 10% and a 25% points rise: booking as before falls from 70.3% to 30.5% (n=118), and the same drop shows in every age group of 30 or more clones.
  • The ladder is consistent clone by clone: 117 of 118 never react less strongly to a bigger cut than to a smaller one.
  • Protecting points already held is the clear first ask of members facing a devaluation.

What we would not

  • The share of the Travel panel in a loyalty program (118 of 616, 19.2%) as a national membership rate: a clone qualified only when its interview showed it using a program.
  • The exact size of the 91.5% preference for protecting held points: it was one pick among four options that were not equally attractive, so we report its direction, not its size.
  • The gap between men (26 of 48 move at 25%) and women (25 of 70) as a settled difference.
  • Anything about members under 30: the panel holds 4.
  • That stated moves become real moves: these are reactions to a written announcement, not observed bookings.

The main limitation

These are stated reactions to a hypothetical announcement from 118 clones of loyalty members on the US Travel panel, most of them 45 or older; airline and hotel programs were asked about together, and no real bookings were observed.

Section 08: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Aged 18-294
Aged 30-4424
Aged 45-6452
Aged 65+38

Question wording as fielded

  1. Do you belong to an airline or hotel loyalty program that you earn or use points with at least once a year?
  2. Imagine the airline or hotel loyalty program you use most announces that from next month a free flight or free night will cost 10% more points (for example 22,000 points instead of 20,000), with cash prices and service unchanged. What would you most likely do?
  3. Imagine the airline or hotel loyalty program you use most announces that from next month a free flight or free night will cost 25% more points (for example 25,000 points instead of 20,000), with cash prices and service unchanged. What would you most likely do?
  4. Imagine the airline or hotel loyalty program you use most announces that from next month a free flight or free night will cost 50% more points (for example 30,000 points instead of 20,000), with cash prices and service unchanged. What would you most likely do?
  5. If the airline or hotel loyalty program you use most made its free flights and free nights cost 25% more points, which one step by that program would do most to keep your bookings?

What was not asked, and why

We named no airline, hotel chain or program, did not separate airline from hotel programs, did not ask about credit card points, and did not ask how often members book. Ask Brox fielded the five questions as written and added none of its own.

What changed from the obvious question

The obvious question asks what members do after a devaluation. We asked 118 clones of US loyalty members to react to three written announcements of the same change, 10%, 25% and 50% more points for a free flight or night with cash prices and service unchanged, then which one step would keep their bookings. That shows where the reaction turns, not only what it is.

Fielded through Ask Brox on 21 November 2026.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai

Related insights

All in this topic