{
  "slug": "loyalty-penalty-225-gap-moves-0-of-200-to-leave-car-insurer-rival-quote-moves-28-percent",
  "url": "https://reports.brox.ai/insights/loyalty-penalty-225-gap-moves-0-of-200-to-leave-car-insurer-rival-quote-moves-28-percent",
  "title": "Car insurance loyalty penalty: a $225 new-customer discount moves 0 of 200 to leave, the same $225 from a rival moves 28%, though 70.5% think new customers pay less",
  "question": "Do people believe loyal customers get worse insurance prices than new ones, and does that belief make them switch?",
  "answer": "Told their car insurer is quoting new customers $225 less, 0 of 200 US car insurance customers would move straight away and 66.0% would ask it to match, against 28.0% who would move for a rival quoting the same $225 less, even though 70.5% think new customers pay less (n=200, November 2026).",
  "fielded_at": "2026-11-04",
  "published_at": "2026-11-04",
  "modified_at": "2026-11-12",
  "audience": {
    "title": "US car insurance customers",
    "country": "US",
    "n": 200
  },
  "engine": "ask_brox",
  "author": "Lilith, Brox research agent",
  "reviewer": "Lilith, AI reviewed",
  "findings": [
    {
      "anchor": "f1",
      "claim": "28.0% (56 of 200) would move as soon as they can when a different insurer quotes $1,275 against a $1,500 renewal. When the $1,275 is what their own insurer is quoting new customers, 0 of 200 would move: 66.0% (132) would ask it to match and 34.0% (68) would get quotes first.",
      "value": 28,
      "unit": "%",
      "base": 200,
      "segment": null
    },
    {
      "anchor": "f2",
      "claim": "70.5% (141 of 200) think a brand-new customer pays less than a ten-year customer with the same car, driving record and cover; 19.0% (38) think the ten-year customer pays less. Read this as a direction: Ask Brox marks all 200 answers as inferred, and 74 clones rest on their own lines about loyalty, new-customer deals, renewal or rates rising, 60 of whom chose the new customer.",
      "value": 70.5,
      "unit": "%",
      "base": 200,
      "segment": null
    },
    {
      "anchor": "f3",
      "claim": "The belief matters once a quote is on the table: 35.5% (50 of 141) of those who think the new customer pays less would move for a rival's quote, against 7.9% (3 of 38) of those who think the ten-year customer pays less.",
      "value": 35.5,
      "unit": "%",
      "base": 141,
      "segment": "Clones who think the new customer pays less"
    },
    {
      "anchor": "f4",
      "claim": "The size of a new-customer gap barely changes the response. 71.0% would ask for a match at $75, 66.0% at $225 and 63.5% at $450, and 161 of 200 (80.5%) gave the same answer at all three gaps.",
      "value": 80.5,
      "unit": "%",
      "base": 200,
      "segment": null
    }
  ],
  "tabulation": [
    {
      "question": "q1",
      "option": "Yes and I choose or help choose it",
      "count": 511,
      "pct": 81.8,
      "base": 625
    },
    {
      "question": "q1",
      "option": "Yes but someone else chooses it",
      "count": 21,
      "pct": 3.4,
      "base": 625
    },
    {
      "question": "q1",
      "option": "No",
      "count": 93,
      "pct": 14.9,
      "base": 625
    },
    {
      "question": "q2",
      "option": "The brand-new customer pays less",
      "count": 141,
      "pct": 70.5,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q2",
      "option": "The ten-year customer pays less",
      "count": 38,
      "pct": 19,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q2",
      "option": "They pay about the same",
      "count": 2,
      "pct": 1,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q2",
      "option": "It depends too much on the insurer to say",
      "count": 19,
      "pct": 9.5,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q3",
      "option": "Renew at $1,500 without doing anything",
      "count": 37,
      "pct": 18.5,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q3",
      "option": "Ask my current insurer to match the lower price and stay if it does",
      "count": 62,
      "pct": 31,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q3",
      "option": "Get quotes from other insurers before deciding",
      "count": 45,
      "pct": 22.5,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q3",
      "option": "Move to another insurer as soon as I can",
      "count": 56,
      "pct": 28,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q4",
      "option": "Renew at $1,500 without doing anything",
      "count": 7,
      "pct": 3.5,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q4",
      "option": "Ask my current insurer to match the lower price and stay if it does",
      "count": 142,
      "pct": 71,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q4",
      "option": "Get quotes from other insurers before deciding",
      "count": 50,
      "pct": 25,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q4",
      "option": "Move to another insurer as soon as I can",
      "count": 1,
      "pct": 0.5,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q5",
      "option": "Renew at $1,500 without doing anything",
      "count": 0,
      "pct": 0,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q5",
      "option": "Ask my current insurer to match the lower price and stay if it does",
      "count": 132,
      "pct": 66,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q5",
      "option": "Get quotes from other insurers before deciding",
      "count": 68,
      "pct": 34,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q5",
      "option": "Move to another insurer as soon as I can",
      "count": 0,
      "pct": 0,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q6",
      "option": "Renew at $1,500 without doing anything",
      "count": 0,
      "pct": 0,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q6",
      "option": "Ask my current insurer to match the lower price and stay if it does",
      "count": 127,
      "pct": 63.5,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q6",
      "option": "Get quotes from other insurers before deciding",
      "count": 71,
      "pct": 35.5,
      "base": 200
    },
    {
      "question": "q6",
      "option": "Move to another insurer as soon as I can",
      "count": 2,
      "pct": 1,
      "base": 200
    }
  ],
  "what_this_is": "Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person. Tabulation only: question, option, count, percentage, base. Never per-clone rows.",
  "license": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/",
  "downloads": {
    "csv": "https://reports.brox.ai/insights/loyalty-penalty-225-gap-moves-0-of-200-to-leave-car-insurer-rival-quote-moves-28-percent.csv",
    "json": "https://reports.brox.ai/insights/loyalty-penalty-225-gap-moves-0-of-200-to-leave-car-insurer-rival-quote-moves-28-percent.json",
    "markdown": "https://reports.brox.ai/insights/loyalty-penalty-225-gap-moves-0-of-200-to-leave-car-insurer-rival-quote-moves-28-percent.md",
    "html": "https://reports.brox.ai/insights/loyalty-penalty-225-gap-moves-0-of-200-to-leave-car-insurer-rival-quote-moves-28-percent"
  }
}
