# Life insurance: 71.5% would buy through an advisor at the same price, but 10% cheaper online ($4 a month) moves 58% to buy on their own

*How do people choose a life insurer or an annuity, and what makes them buy through a financial advisor rather than direct?*

73.0% of US adults who hold or recently shopped for life insurance say price would most decide their insurer, and while 71.5% would take a financial advisor over buying online at the same price, 58.0% would buy online on their own at 10% cheaper and 80.0% at 25% cheaper (n=200, October 2026).

- **Who was asked:** US life insurance and annuity owners, 200 clones, US
- **When:** fielded 2026-10-20
- **How:** predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person
- **What changed from the obvious question:** The obvious question asks how people choose a life insurer or annuity and why they buy through an advisor rather than direct. Industry surveys already report whether buyers prefer an advisor or online, so this study priced the choice instead: the same policy through an advisor at $40 a month or online on their own at $40, $36 and $30, each written out in full, so the page can name the discount at which buyers give up the advisor. It screened for adults who own an individual policy or annuity, shopped for one in the last three years or have life cover through work (249 of 598 qualified, 200 sampled).
- **Author:** Lilith, Brox research agent · **Reviewed:** Lilith, AI reviewed · **Published:** 2026-10-21 · **Updated:** 2026-11-12
- **Canonical:** https://reports.brox.ai/insights/life-insurance-advisor-or-online-10-percent-cheaper-moves-58-percent-to-buy-alone

## What the panel said

1. **58%** Offered the same $500,000, 20-year term life policy through a financial advisor at $40 a month or online on their own, 28.0% would buy online at the same price, 58.0% at 10% cheaper ($36 a month) and 80.0% at 25% cheaper ($30 a month). — base 200 (https://reports.brox.ai/insights/life-insurance-advisor-or-online-10-percent-cheaper-moves-58-percent-to-buy-alone#f1)
2. **73%** 73.0% say the price of the cover would most decide which life insurer they chose; 10.0% name its financial strength or rating, 10.0% an advisor's or agent's recommendation, 7.0% a company name they already know, and none the ease of applying online. — base 200 (https://reports.brox.ai/insights/life-insurance-advisor-or-online-10-percent-cheaper-moves-58-percent-to-buy-alone#f2)
3. **44.9%** Clones aged 65 or over hold on to the advisor longest: 44.9% would buy online on their own at 10% cheaper and 69.4% at 25% cheaper, against 63.3% and 81.6% of those aged 45 to 64. (Aged 65 or over) — base 49, contrast (https://reports.brox.ai/insights/life-insurance-advisor-or-online-10-percent-cheaper-moves-58-percent-to-buy-alone#f3)
4. **46%** 46.0% say someone they can call with questions would most make them want an advisor, 18.5% buying an annuity or planning retirement income and 27.5% nothing at all, yet 62 of the 92 who want someone to call would still buy online on their own at 25% cheaper. — base 200, contrast (https://reports.brox.ai/insights/life-insurance-advisor-or-online-10-percent-cheaper-moves-58-percent-to-buy-alone#f4)

Chart — Offered the same $500,000, 20-year term life policy through a financial advisor at $40 a month or online on their own, 28.0% would buy online at the same price, 58.0% at 10% cheaper ($36 a month) and 80.0% at 25% cheaper ($30 a month).:

- Same price ($40 a month): 28%
- 10% cheaper online ($36): 58%
- 25% cheaper online ($30): 80%

## At what discount do life insurance buyers give up the advisor?

At the first one tested. Offered the same $500,000, 20-year term life policy through a financial advisor at $40 a month or online on their own, 71.5% of the 200 clones would take the advisor when both cost $40. When the online policy cost $36, 10% cheaper, the advisor's share fell to 42.0%. At $30, 25% cheaper, it fell to 20.0%.

The biggest single move is the first $4 a month. Of the 143 clones who would take the advisor at the same price, 59 would buy online on their own at $36 and 103 would at $30. 40 of the 200 keep the advisor at every price, and 15 would still definitely choose the advisor at $10 a month more. No clone moved towards the advisor as the online price fell, and each rung's reasoning cites its own price.

> **Which reading is which**
>
> The defensible reading is the ladder: every step in the online discount costs the advisor buyers. The more interesting reading is how little the help is worth in money. Most buyers want an advisor when it costs nothing, but to 59 of the 143 who want one, that help is worth less than $4 a month, or $48 a year.

## Who holds on to the advisor longest?

Buyers aged 65 or over. 81.6% of the 49 clones aged 65 or over would take the advisor at the same price, and at 10% cheaper online only 44.9% would buy on their own, the only age group of 30 or more where the first discount does not move a majority. At 25% cheaper, 69.4% would. Among the 98 aged 45 to 64, 63.3% go online at 10% cheaper and 81.6% at 25%.

Men start further from online than women. 81.8% of the 66 men would take the advisor at the same price, against 66.4% of the 134 women, but by 25% cheaper the gap has closed: 77.3% of men and 81.3% of women would buy online on their own.

Owning a policy changes the picture only a little. Among the 143 clones who own an individual life insurance policy or an annuity, 55.2% would buy online on their own at 10% cheaper and 76.9% at 25%, against 66.7% and 83.3% of the 36 whose only life cover comes through work.

The 20 clones who say an advisor's recommendation would most decide their insurer are the firmest: 13 of the 20 keep the advisor even at $30 a month online.

## What decides which life insurer people choose?

Price, by a distance. 73.0% (n=200) say the price of the cover would most decide which insurer they chose for an individual policy. 10.0% name the insurer's financial strength or rating, 10.0% an advisor's or agent's recommendation and 7.0% a company name they already know. Price leads in every age, gender and region group of 30 or more, and is lowest among those aged 65 or over, at 53.1%.

The answer predicts the ladder. 129 of the 146 clones who put price first would buy online on their own at 25% cheaper.

> **Which reading is which**
>
> The defensible reading is that price decides. The more interesting reading is about online buying: not one clone chose the ease of applying online as the deciding factor, yet 80.0% would apply online on their own for 25% off. Buying direct wins on price, not on convenience.

## What makes people want a financial advisor for life insurance or an annuity?

A person to call. 46.0% (n=200) say wanting someone they can call with questions would most make them want an advisor's help, ahead of buying an annuity or planning retirement income at 18.5% and a complicated situation, such as owning a business or a health condition, at 8.0%. 27.5% say nothing would; they would rather buy on their own. Not one clone chose needing a large amount of life cover.

The wish for a person to call is real, but it is not worth $10 a month to most people who have it. 62 of the 92 who want someone to call would still buy the $30 online policy on their own, and 32 would buy the $36 one. Among those aged 65 or over, 29 of 49 want someone to call, which goes some way to explaining why they hold on to the advisor longest.

1. A reading, not a panel answer: for most buyers the advisor's value is access to a person, not expertise on how much cover to buy, so an advisor competing with a cheaper direct policy is competing on a phone number.
2. A second reading: the annuity and retirement-income trigger (18.5%) is where the advisor's case rests on more than reassurance, and this study did not price it.

## What do people also ask about buying life insurance through an advisor or online?

- **What share of life insurance buyers would buy online without an advisor to save 10%?** 58.0% (116 of 200) in October 2026, for the same $500,000, 20-year term policy at $36 a month online against $40 through an advisor, up from 28.0% when both cost $40.
- **At what price do most buyers give up a financial advisor for life insurance?** At 10% cheaper online ($4 a month on a $40 policy) a majority, 58.0%, would buy on their own; at 25% cheaper ($10 a month), 80.0% would and only 20.0% (40 of 200) keep the advisor.
- **How many people choose a life insurer on price?** 73.0% (146 of 200) say the price of the cover would most decide which insurer they chose, and none named the ease of applying online.

## What they said, and the interview line it rests on

> “I would probably choose the policy bought online on my own. For me, everything comes down to cost and getting the best rate. I live pretty much day-to-day right now, so any money I can save on the exact same coverage is important. As long as the policy and coverage limits are identical, cheaper is better. I admit that I'm a bit old school and generally prefer talking directly to a person to make sure I'm doing things right, which makes the advisor tempting, but saving 10% every single month would push me toward doing it online myself.”
>
> *Predicted from this line in the interview:* “I feel like I'm a little old school and I always want to talk to someone to make sure I'm doing it correctly.”
>
> — Woman, 45-64, Colorado; definitely the advisor at the same price, online on her own at 10% cheaper · supports f1

> “I would say probably the policy through the advisor. Now, saving ten bucks a month by doing it online sounds nice on paper, and Lord knows I try to be frugal and watch my spending. But when it comes to something like a life policy, I really prefer dealing with a live person. With an advisor, you have someone to answer your questions and walk you through it so you know it gets done right. Doing it completely on my own online, I could make a mistake, and I'd be very unhappy with myself if that ended up messing up my coverage down the road. So paying a few dollars more each month to have a real person guide me through it is worth it.”
>
> *Predicted from this line in the interview:* “Okay, when it comes to my auto policy, my life policy, those type of policies, I like to, if I can, talk to my agent over the phone. Or, you know, or depending on if he's available, I don't mind talking to him, you know, in person.”
>
> — Man, 65 or over, Kansas; keeps the advisor even at 25% cheaper online · supports f3

> “For me, it would definitely be wanting someone I can call with questions. Insurance can be so confusing with all their charts, graphs, and fine print that feels impossible to understand on your own, and I hate feeling like I'm just at the mercy of the internet. I'd much rather be able to pick up the phone, talk to an actual person who knows what they're doing, get straightforward answers to my questions, and be done with it without spending all day trying to figure it out by myself.”
>
> *Predicted from this line in the interview:* “I find it difficult to understand their charts and graphs about when you're going to die.”
>
> — Woman, 45-64, North Carolina; wants someone to call, yet buys online on her own at 10% cheaper · supports f4

## How much should you trust this?

**What we would defend**

- The ladder: 28.0%, 58.0% and 80.0% (n=200) would buy online on their own at the same price, 10% cheaper and 25% cheaper; the same 200 clones answered every rung, none moved towards the advisor as the online price fell, and each rung's reasoning cites its own price ($36 in 105 of the 200 answers at 10% cheaper, $30 in 133 of 200 at 25%).
- The headline holds among those who own an individual policy or annuity: 55.2% of the 143 would buy online on their own at 10% cheaper and 76.9% at 25%, so it does not rest on the 36 clones with cover only through work or the 21 who have shopped without buying.
- Price as the deciding factor: 73.0% (n=200), and it leads in every age, gender and region group of 30 or more.
- The age contrast: 22 of 49 clones aged 65 or over would buy online at 10% cheaper, against 62 of 98 aged 45 to 64.

**What we would not**

- 10% or 25% as a general rule: the gap was tested on one policy at $40 a month, so 10% was $4 a month and 25% was $10. On a larger premium the same percentage is more money and may move more buyers.
- A forecast of how life insurance is sold: these are stated choices between two written policies, with no underwriting, no commission or fee shown, and an advisor described only as helping to apply and answering questions, not as advising on how much cover to buy.
- Anything about how people choose an annuity: annuities appear only as a reason for wanting an advisor (18.5%), and no annuity was priced.
- The zeros as proof that something does not matter: no clone named the ease of applying online as the deciding factor, or needing a large amount of cover as the reason for an advisor, but in a single forced choice those options were crowded out, not measured as unimportant.
- Any figure for clones aged 18 to 29 (1 clone), the West (20) or any single income band under 30, or for the 20 clones led by an advisor's recommendation beyond the count (13 of 20 keep the advisor at 25% cheaper).

**The main limitation:** Every answer is a stated choice between two written versions of one $40-a-month term policy, and the panel is two-thirds women with a single clone under 30, so the ladder shows how fast an advisor loses buyers as a direct discount grows, not what share of real life insurance sales would move online.

## How was this run?

| Segment | Clones |
|---|---:|
| Own an individual life insurance policy or an annuity | 143 |
| Life cover through an employer only | 36 |
| Shopped for life insurance or an annuity in the last three years, own none | 21 |
| Aged 45-64 | 98 |
| Aged 30-44 | 52 |
| Aged 65 or over | 49 |
| Aged 18-29 | 1 |
| Women | 134 |
| Men | 66 |

**Question wording as fielded**

1. Which of these best describes your life insurance or annuity situation? (screener: 249 of 598 qualified, 200 sampled)
2. If you were choosing a company for an individual life insurance policy today, which one thing would most decide which insurer you chose?
3. A financial adviser offers you a 20-year term life insurance policy with $500,000 of cover for $40 a month, and will help you apply and answer your questions. The same 20-year, $500,000 policy is also sold directly online, with no adviser, and you apply on your own. Which would you choose? (fielded as one grid with three rows: online at $40 a month, the same price; at $36, 10% cheaper; at $30, 25% cheaper)
4. Which one of these would most make you want a financial adviser's help rather than buying life insurance or an annuity on your own?

**What was not asked, and why:** No insurer, advisor firm or brand was named, and no commission, fee, underwriting step or advice on how much cover to buy was described. The price ladder used one policy, a $500,000, 20-year term policy at $40 a month through an advisor, against three online prices; no annuity was priced, and annuities were asked about only as a reason for wanting an advisor. Clones were not asked how they bought their own policies. Ask Brox fielded the three price questions as one grid and added no questions or brands of its own.

## About this finding

The figures are predicted responses from 200 Brox clones: behavioural replicas of real people, each built from a long-form interview with that person. The panel was US life insurance and annuity owners (US), fielded on 2026-10-20 through Ask Brox. Every statistic shows its base, every quote is shown with the interview line it was predicted from, and the panel composition and question wording are in the method section above.

Underlying sources: Brox Insurance panel, US: 200 clones of adults who own an individual life insurance policy or annuity, shopped for one in the last three years, or have life cover through work; long-form video interviews with the 200 real people the clones are built from.
External: [LIMRA and Life Happens, 2025 Insurance Barometer Study (US attitudes to buying life insurance)](https://www.limra.com/en/research/insurance-barometer/).
Prepared by Lilith, Brox research agent; reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed.

Data (tabulation only, never per-clone rows): [CSV](https://reports.brox.ai/insights/life-insurance-advisor-or-online-10-percent-cheaper-moves-58-percent-to-buy-alone.csv), [JSON](https://reports.brox.ai/insights/life-insurance-advisor-or-online-10-percent-cheaper-moves-58-percent-to-buy-alone.json). Page: https://reports.brox.ai/insights/life-insurance-advisor-or-online-10-percent-cheaper-moves-58-percent-to-buy-alone

---

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai
