Heat pump rebates: 72.0% of US homeowners would be very likely to choose a heat pump when $6,000 off matches the price of a standard system, against 1.5% with $2,000 off
In November 2026, the government rebate that tips US homeowners towards a heat pump lay between $2,000 and $6,000: of homeowner clones on Brox's U.S. panel (n=200), 1.5% were very likely to choose a $15,000 heat pump over a $9,000 standard system with $2,000 off, and 72.0% with $6,000 off, which made the two prices equal.
- Who was asked
- US homeowners, 200 clones, US
- When
- November 2026 (fielded 5 November 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- The obvious question, whether grants and tax credits make people upgrade, already has its answer from program evaluations: yes, depending on design. This study turned it into a threshold: one replacement decision written out in full with no help, a $2,000 tax credit paid next spring, a $2,000 rebate off the bill and a $6,000 rebate that closed the price gap, then what would still stop them at equal price. Very likely was read apart from somewhat likely to separate commitment from politeness.
Section 01: What the panel said
- #
72%
Offered a $9,000 standard system or a $15,000 heat pump that cuts energy bills by about $300 a year, 0.5% were very likely to choose the heat pump with no government help, 1.5% with $2,000 off and 72.0% with $6,000 off, which made the two prices equal
base 200
- #
13.5%
At $2,000 the form made no visible difference: 12.0% (24 of 200) were somewhat or very likely to choose the heat pump with a tax credit paid next spring and 13.5% (27) with a rebate off the installer's bill, and 158 clones gave the same answer to both
base 200 · contrast
- #
16
With $2,000 off the bill, 16 of 75 clones in households on $100,000 or more were somewhat or very likely to choose the heat pump, against 2 of 49 on under $50,000; with $6,000 off, 67 of 75 and 45 of 49
base 75 · Household income $100,000 or more · contrast
- #
39%
With the price equal, 39.0% (78 of 200) named worry about electricity bills as the main thing still stopping them, 33.5% (67) said nothing would stop them, and 13.0% (26) remained unlikely to choose the heat pump
base 200 · caveat
Offered a $9,000 standard system or a $15,000 heat pump that cuts energy bills by about $300 a year, 0.5% were very likely to choose the heat pump with no government help, 1.5% with $2,000 off and 72.0% with $6,000 off, which made the two prices equal
02Where does the heat pump tipping point sit?
Between $2,000 and $6,000 off. Brox asked 200 clones of US homeowners who decide their home's heating and cooling about one replacement written out in full: a standard furnace and air conditioner at $9,000 installed, or an electric heat pump at $15,000 that cuts energy bills by about $300 a year. With no government help, 0.5% (1 of 200) were very likely to choose the heat pump. With $2,000 off the installer's bill, 1.5% (3). With $6,000 off, which made the two prices equal, 72.0% (144).
The same clones answered every version, so the move can be followed person by person. 171 moved up at least one step between $2,000 and $6,000 and none moved down. The clones did the sum themselves. A $6,000 premium at $300 a year takes 20 years to pay back, and $4,000 takes over 13. Payback came up in 185 of 200 answers with no help and 136 with $2,000 off. At equal prices it came up in 1, and 177 cited the $300 saving instead.
03Does a tax credit do less than a rebate of the same size?
Not at $2,000. As a tax credit paid back next spring, with the full $15,000 due to the installer now, 12.0% (24 of 200) were somewhat or very likely to choose the heat pump. As a rebate off the installer's bill, 13.5% (27). The gap is 3 clones: 158 gave the same answer to both, 22 rated the rebate higher and 20 rated the credit higher.
That is a finding about size, not a verdict on form. $2,000 is small against a $6,000 premium, so neither version lifted many clones, and a larger tax credit was not tested. It is also the size that has gone: the US federal credit of up to $2,000 a year for a heat pump covered improvements made through 31 December 2025. Canada is moving the other way, with a national rebate of C$2,000 for households above median income and up to C$10,000 below it, covering eligible installs from 1 November 2026, with applications due to open in early 2027.
04Which households does a small rebate reach?
Mostly the better-off. With $2,000 off the bill, 2 of 49 clones in households on under $50,000 were somewhat or very likely to choose the heat pump, 9 of 76 on $50,000 to $99,999 and 16 of 75 on $100,000 or more. With $6,000 off, the bands close up: 45 of 49, 62 of 76 and 67 of 75.
All 47 clones on under $50,000 who stayed unlikely with the tax credit gave the upfront cost as a reason, and a credit paid months later does not change that bill. These are small counts, so read them as a direction.
05What still holds homeowners back at equal price?
Running costs more than the kit. Asked for the main thing still stopping them once a rebate had made the prices equal, 39.0% (78 of 200) named worry about electricity bills, 14.5% (29) repair bills or how long it would last, 10.5% (21) whether it would keep the home warm enough and 2.5% (5) finding an installer they trust. 33.5% (67) said nothing would stop them. Worry about electricity bills came from 38 of 49 clones on under $50,000 and 15 of 75 on $100,000 or more.
That question did not restate the $300 saving, and no clone's answer to it mentioned one. Where the saving was stated, most clones relied on it. So the worry measures what clones assume when no bill figure is in front of them. 66 of the clones who named it were still somewhat or very likely to choose the heat pump at equal prices.
13.0% (26 of 200) stayed unlikely even at equal prices. On a reading of those answers, 15 object to the rebate itself, through distrust of government promises, a suspected catch or the use of taxpayer money, and 11 prefer the system they know. For that group a bigger rebate is the wrong tool.
06What would an energy brand do with this?
- A reading, not the panel's answer: quote the price gap left after any help, because that gap and the years it takes to pay back are what these clones reasoned from.
- A second reading: put a yearly bill figure next to the rebate. The worry about electricity bills appeared where no figure was given.
- A third reading: for lower-income households, take the money off the installer's bill or close the whole gap, because a small sum paid later reached 2 of 49.
07What do people also ask about heat pump rebates?
- What share of US homeowners would choose a heat pump with a $6,000 rebate? 72.0% of homeowner clones on Brox's U.S. panel (144 of 200, November 2026) were very likely to when $6,000 off made it the same price as a standard system.
- How many homeowners would choose a heat pump for a $2,000 tax credit? 24 of 200 (12.0%) were somewhat or very likely to choose a $15,000 heat pump over a $9,000 system, and 3 of 200 (1.5%) were very likely.
- What share of homeowners would refuse a heat pump even at the same price as a furnace? 13.0% (26 of 200) stayed unlikely to choose the heat pump at equal prices.
Section 08: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“Very likely. That is pretty much a no-brainer to me. I've already taken advantage of government incentives through the Inflation Reduction Act to install solar panels on my house and a heat pump water heater for my hot water. If a rebate brings the upfront cost of an electric heat pump down to the exact same $9,000 as a standard system, and on top of that it cuts energy bills by $300 a year, I would jump on that in a heartbeat. It's better value, efficient, and good for saving resources.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I used several parts of that to buy things like solar for my house and a heat pump water heater for my hot water supply.”
“I would be very unlikely to choose the heat pump. Things are really tough financially right now, and my priority has to be getting through day to day and making sure the basic bills are covered. Coming up with $15,000 out of pocket right upfront when a standard system costs $9,000 is just not something I could justify or afford. Waiting until next year to get a $2,000 tax credit doesn't help you pay the installer today, and saving $300 a year would take way too long to ever make up the difference. As long as you have the basics to keep the house running, that's what matters.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“When it comes to handling money, the bills always have to come first because they are definitely the priority.”
“I would be very unlikely to go with the heat pump. Anything involving government rebates or credits feels like a promise that never comes to fruition. The last time I had an HVAC replaced, there was some loophole and I never got the credit, and the same thing happened when I had an expensive window put in. Even if they say it comes right off the installer's bill, I don't trust that there wouldn't be some catch or fine print where I end up on the hook for a $15,000 bill. I've come to distrust just about everybody and everything, especially when it comes to promises like that. I'd rather take the safe bet and stick with the standard furnace and AC for $9,000.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“The last time I had an HVAC, there was a loophole. I did not get the credit. Last time I had a big expensive window installed, I just missed getting the tax credit. So, it feels like a promise that never comes to fruition. So, no, that would not entice me at all.”
Section 09: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- The jump in very likely to choose the heat pump from 3 of 200 with $2,000 off to 144 with $6,000 off: the same clones answered every version, 171 moved up at least one step between the two and none moved down, and no answer at $6,000 off mentioned the $2,000 version.
- That a $2,000 tax credit and a $2,000 rebate showed no visible difference: 24 and 27 of 200 somewhat or very likely, 158 clones gave the same answer to both, 22 rated the rebate higher and 20 rated the credit higher.
- That the shape holds across subgroups: very likely with $6,000 off for 95 of 140 women and 49 of 60 men, 35 of 42 aged 30 to 44, 68 of 93 aged 45 to 64 and 39 of 63 aged 65 or over.
What we would not
- Any figure here as heat pump demand. 2 of 200 somewhat or very likely with no help answers this one offer, a $6,000 premium and a $300 yearly saving, which pays back over 20 years; the clones did that sum. In the real market more heat pumps than gas furnaces were shipped in the US in 2025 (3.64 million against 3.25 million) and 69% of homeowners in a 2023 trade survey would consider one.
- The size of the yes at equal price: 174 of 200 somewhat or very likely is near-unanimous on an offer that is simply the better deal as written, so it is direction only.
- That tax credits work as well as rebates in general: both $2,000 versions sit near the floor, a larger credit was not tested, and the panel does not show who could carry $15,000 until the spring.
- The exact tipping amount: nothing between $2,000 and $6,000 was tested.
- The ranking of what still stops people: the question did not restate the $300 saving, 5 of 200 named installers although the interviews hold almost nothing about them, and 107 of the 174 likely at equal price still named a worry when the list invited one.
- The gap between women (69 of 140) and men (9 of 60) on worry about electricity bills: it holds inside income bands, but no interview line explains it, so it is reported here and not as a finding.
- These figures as a US population estimate: 140 of the 200 clones are women, 156 are aged 45 or over and 2 are under 30.
The main limitation
Ask Brox classed every answer to the main questions as inferred rather than evidenced (0 of 200 evidenced on each): the interviews hold almost nothing about choosing a heating system, and only 1 of the 200 clones has a line naming a heat pump, a water heater. Answers are reasoned from the person's own words about money and, on the tax credit, about credits (84 of 200 rest on such a line, mostly the $7,500 electric vehicle credit). The $15,000, $9,000 and $300 are round figures written for this study, not quotes or averages, and a different premium or saving would move every rung. Read the ladder as the shape of the response to this offer, not as a measured rate.
Section 10: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Aged 18 to 29 | 2 |
| Aged 30 to 44 | 42 |
| Aged 45 to 64 | 93 |
| Aged 65 and over | 63 |
Question wording as fielded
- Which of these describes the home you live in?
- Imagine your home's heating and cooling system has to be replaced this year. A standard furnace and air conditioner would cost you $9,000 installed. An electric heat pump, which does both jobs, would cost you $15,000 installed and would cut your energy bills by about $300 a year. There is no government rebate or tax credit for it. How likely would you be to choose the heat pump?
- Imagine your home's heating and cooling system has to be replaced this year. A standard furnace and air conditioner would cost you $9,000 installed. An electric heat pump, which does both jobs, would cost you $15,000 installed and would cut your energy bills by about $300 a year. A government tax credit gives you $2,000 back when you file your taxes next spring, so you pay the installer the full $15,000 now. How likely would you be to choose the heat pump?
- Imagine your home's heating and cooling system has to be replaced this year. A standard furnace and air conditioner would cost you $9,000 installed. An electric heat pump, which does both jobs, would cost you $15,000 installed and would cut your energy bills by about $300 a year. A government rebate takes $2,000 off the installer's bill, so you pay the installer $13,000 now. How likely would you be to choose the heat pump?
- Imagine your home's heating and cooling system has to be replaced this year. A standard furnace and air conditioner would cost you $9,000 installed. An electric heat pump, which does both jobs, would cost you $15,000 installed and would cut your energy bills by about $300 a year. A government rebate takes $6,000 off the installer's bill, so you pay the installer $9,000 now, the same as the standard system. How likely would you be to choose the heat pump?
- Imagine a government rebate makes an electric heat pump cost you the same as a standard furnace and air conditioner for your home. What would be the main thing still stopping you from choosing the heat pump?
What was not asked, and why
No brand or installer was named. Rebates between $2,000 and $6,000 were not tested, nor a tax credit larger than $2,000, financing, a state program or an income limit. Climate and the home's current system were not asked. The screener removed 782 of 1,434 clones (607 rent, 163 live with family or friends, 12 own but someone else decides); 652 qualified and Ask Brox fielded 200 of them. Ask Brox fielded the six questions as written and added none of its own. The stated costs and the $300 saving are round figures chosen for the study.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question, whether grants and tax credits make people upgrade, already has its answer from program evaluations: yes, depending on design. This study turned it into a threshold: one replacement decision written out in full with no help, a $2,000 tax credit paid next spring, a $2,000 rebate off the bill and a $6,000 rebate that closed the price gap, then what would still stop them at equal price. Very likely was read apart from somewhat likely to separate commitment from politeness.
Fielded through Ask Brox on 5 November 2026.
More on Solar panels, heat pumps and the home upgrade · Energy & utilities · U.S. nat. rep. (US) panel
Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai