Energy price cap rises in Great Britain: at a 16% rise only 19.9% of households would stay put, against 45.8% at 4%, and almost none would fix with their supplier

In October 2026, 45.8% of British households on Brox's Great Britain panel (n=166) would stay on their tariff and do nothing after the real 4% price cap rise, but only 19.9% would after a further 16% rise to £1,999 a year, with most of the rest cutting their use or switching supplier rather than fixing.

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
UK households, 166 clones, GB
When
October 2026 (fielded 15 October 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question is whether the October rise will make people fix or switch, which a 4% rise mostly does not. This study turned it into a threshold: the same households faced the real 4% rise and then a further 16% and 30% rise in January 2027, each written out with its annual bill, and chose between staying put, fixing, switching or cutting back.

Section 01: What the panel said

  1. #

    19.9%

    Asked what they would do about each price cap rise, 45.8% would stay on their tariff and do nothing different at October's 4% rise, 19.9% at a further 16% rise and 13.3% at a further 30% rise

    base 166

  2. #

    52.4%

    At a 30% rise, 52.4% would cut how much gas and electricity they use and 34.3% would switch supplier; at 16% the split is 42.2% and 37.3%

    base 166 · contrast

  3. #

    43.4%

    Asked what would hold them back most from fixing or switching, 43.4% chose exit fees and being locked in if prices later fall, and 32.5% said nothing would

    base 166 · contrast

  4. #

    1

    Fixing with the current supplier was chosen by 1 of 166 at a 4% rise, 1 at 16% and none at 30%; a fix with a new supplier would have been answered as switching, so this is a floor

    base 166 · caveat

Asked what they would do about each price cap rise, 45.8% would stay on their tariff and do nothing different at October's 4% rise, 19.9% at a further 16% rise and 13.3% at a further 30% rise

Stay put at +4% (£1,723)
45.8%
At +16% (£1,999)
19.9%
At +30% (£2,240)
13.3%

Base 166 clones.

02At what size of price cap rise do British households stop doing nothing?

Somewhere between 4% and 16%. Brox asked 166 clones on its Great Britain general population panel what they would do about three price cap rises, each written out in full: October's real 4% rise to £1,723 a year, then a further 16% in January 2027 to £1,999, then a further 30% to £2,240. At 4%, 45.8% (76 of 166) would stay on their tariff and do nothing different. At 16%, 19.9% (33). At 30%, 13.3% (22).

The same clones answered all three, so the movement can be followed person by person: 43 of the 76 who would sit tight at 4% would act at 16%, while only 11 more move between 16% and 30%. The cap's next level is due from Ofgem by 25 November, and forecasts published in October put the January rise at somewhere between about 14% and 21%, which is past the point where this panel stops staying put.

03Do British households fix, switch or cut back when the cap rises?

They cut back or switch; they almost never fix with their current supplier. At a 16% rise, 42.2% (70 of 166) would cut how much gas and electricity they use and 37.3% (62) would switch supplier. At 30%, cutting back reaches 52.4% (87) and switching 34.3% (57). Fixing with the current supplier was chosen by 1 of 166 at 4% and at 16%, and by none at 30%.

Switching peaks at 16% and then gives way to cutting back, which suggests that a very large rise reads to many households as a problem no tariff can solve. Among the 67 clones who pay the bill themselves, 29 would switch at a 16% rise, the largest single response in that group.

04What stops British households fixing or switching when prices rise?

Fear of being locked in. Asked what would hold them back most, 43.4% (72 of 166) chose exit fees and being locked in if prices later fall, 16.9% (28) said comparing deals and switching feels like too much hassle, and 7.2% (12) worried about a new supplier's customer service. 32.5% (54) said nothing would hold them back. No clone chose the reason that fixed deals often cost more than the cap at the time.

The 22 clones who would stay put even at a 30% rise are where the hassle and service answers sit: 9 of them chose hassle and 6 customer service, against 7 exit fees.

  1. A reading, not the panel's answer: a fixed tariff is being heard as a bet that prices will keep rising, so a fix sold on flexibility (low or no exit fees) answers the biggest objection directly.
  2. A second reading: suppliers trying to keep customers through a January rise are competing with cutting back as much as with each other, so usage help may hold more customers than a price promise.

05What do people also ask about the price cap and switching?

  • What share of British households would switch energy supplier if the price cap rose 16%? 37.3% of clones on Brox's Great Britain panel (62 of 166, October 2026) would switch to a different supplier at a 16% rise to £1,999 a year.
  • At what price cap rise do most British households act? At 16%: 80.1% (133 of 166) would fix, switch or cut back, against 54.2% (90) at October's 4% rise.
  • How many British households would fix their energy tariff after a cap rise? Almost none with their current supplier: 1 of 166 at a 4% or 16% rise and none at 30%.

Section 06: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“I would definitely look at switching to a different energy supplier to see if I could find a cheaper deal. Whenever the price of something goes up, my immediate reaction is that it's ridiculous, but because gas and electricity are essentials that we need to live and keep the kids warm, it's not like I can just stop paying for it. I always try to shop around when prices rise because looking for better deals and comparing prices is really the only way to deal with everything getting so expensive. As the adult in the house, I make all the decisions on our energy providers, so I'd be checking around to find wherever it might be cheaper.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“because I need it, it's not like I can get out of paying it either. But I do try to shop around when I do find that something I always have goes up but it tends to just be around the same price.”

Woman, 18-29, Derbyshire; pays the household energy bill supports finding 1

“Honestly, bills are already ridiculous and so bloody expensive as it is. We're already feeling the pinch where everything just goes straight on household bills and shopping, leaving us with nothing left at the end of it. If energy bills were to jump up by that much more, we simply couldn't afford to just carry on as normal or let the bills shoot up even higher. The only realistic thing for us to do day-to-day would be to strictly cut back on how much gas and electricity we're using around the house.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“A basic bill would cost a fortune now. And that is hard, especially for those families who are struggling.”

Woman, 18-29, Leicestershire; shares the household energy bill supports finding 2

“For me, the biggest concern with fixing a tariff or switching would be getting trapped with exit fees if energy prices drop later on. I am very cautious when it comes to money and managing the household bills, and I believe it is always better to avoid situations where you stand to lose out. If I commit to a fixed contract and then market rates go down, being stuck paying high rates or heavy exit fees to leave would feel like losing money for nothing. So exit fees and being locked in would definitely be what holds me back most.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“So it's better to lose nothing than to lose something.”

Man, 30-44, Great Britain; pays the household energy bill supports finding 3

Section 07: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • The fall in staying put from 76 of 166 at a 4% rise to 33 at 16% and 22 at 30%: the same clones answered all three rises, each written out in full, and each scenario's reasoning carried its own figure (£66, £276 or £517) and never another level's.
  • That the step from 4% to 16% moves far more households (43 of the 76 who would stay put at 4%) than the step from 16% to 30% (11 more).
  • That the shape holds among the 125 clones who pay or share the bill: staying put falls from 58 to 24 to 15.
  • That exit fees and lock-in is the leading objection to fixing or switching, at 72 of 166.

What we would not

  • The switching shares as a forecast of real switching volumes: this is stated intent with no effort, deal availability or exit fee attached, and real switching also depends on there being cheaper deals to switch to.
  • The near-zero fix figure as a verdict on fixed tariffs: the option said fix with the current supplier, so a fix with a new supplier was answered as switching.
  • The zero for 'fixed deals often cost more than the cap' as a real absence: it is a true market condition no clone picked, which suggests the panel does not hold tariff pricing knowledge.
  • Any segment split as a measurement: the 16 clones whose bill is in their rent and the 25 whose bill someone else pays are counts, and gender differences are direction only.
  • These figures as a GB population estimate: 141 of the 166 clones are under 45 and 83 are aged 18 to 29.

The main limitation

This is stated intent from 166 clones on a Great Britain panel that skews young (83 aged 18 to 29), about a real 4% rise and two hypothetical January 2027 rises; it measures what they say they would do, not what they did.

Section 08: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Pay the household energy bill themselves67
Share the cost with others in the household58
Someone else in the household pays25
Included in rent or paid by a landlord16

Question wording as fielded

  1. Who pays the gas and electricity bill for the home you live in?
  2. The energy price cap in Great Britain rose 4% on 1 October 2026, taking a typical household's gas and electricity bill to £1,723 a year, about £66 a year more than before. Faced with that rise, what would you most likely do?
  3. Suppose the energy price cap in Great Britain rises a further 16% in January 2027, taking a typical household's gas and electricity bill to £1,999 a year, about £276 a year more than it is now. Faced with that rise, what would you most likely do?
  4. Suppose the energy price cap in Great Britain rises a further 30% in January 2027, taking a typical household's gas and electricity bill to £2,240 a year, about £517 a year more than it is now. Faced with that rise, what would you most likely do?
  5. What would hold you back most from fixing your energy tariff or switching to a different energy supplier when prices rise?

What was not asked, and why

No supplier or brand was named. The study did not test rises between 4% and 16%, did not offer a fix with a different supplier as a separate option, and did not ask which tariff clones are on now or what they did after past rises, which the panel does not hold as data. Ask Brox added no questions of its own.

What changed from the obvious question

The obvious question is whether the October rise will make people fix or switch, which a 4% rise mostly does not. This study turned it into a threshold: the same households faced the real 4% rise and then a further 16% and 30% rise in January 2027, each written out with its annual bill, and chose between staying put, fixing, switching or cutting back.

Fielded through Ask Brox on 15 October 2026.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai

Related insights

All in this topic