Buying in a shop or online: 80.8% of US online shoppers would buy a $1,200 sofa online to save 10%, and only fresh produce is a majority must-buy in store
55.5% of US online shoppers name fresh fruit and vegetables as the purchase they would most insist on making in a shop, but even a sofa leaves the showroom on price: 80.8% would buy an identical $1,200 sofa online for $1,080, 10% less, with free delivery and free returns (n=146, November 2026).
- Who was asked
- US online shoppers, 146 clones, US
- When
- November 2026 (fielded 9 November 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- The obvious question asks which categories people prefer to buy in a shop, which published retail research already lists. This study asks for the one purchase people most insist on making in a shop, then puts a price on that insistence for a sofa, a purchase with a strong case for a showroom, to find the saving at which shoppers give the showroom up.
Section 01: What the panel said
- #
80.8%
80.8% of US online shoppers would buy an identical $1,200 sofa online for $1,080 (10% less), with free delivery and free returns, rather than in a showroom near them; 93.2% would at 20% less and 95.2% at 30% less.
base 146
- #
55.5%
55.5% name fresh fruit and vegetables as the one purchase they would most insist on making in a physical shop rather than online, ahead of a sofa, running shoes or a laptop.
base 146
- #
14
14 of the 30 clones who say sitting on the sofa and feeling the fabric matters most would still buy it online at 10% less, and 24 of the 30 at 20% less.
base 30 · Put sitting on it and feeling the fabric first · contrast
- #
10
10 of the 31 clones aged 65 and over would keep the showroom at 10% less, against 15.8% (18 of 114) of those under 65.
base 31 · Aged 65 and over · contrast
80.8% of US online shoppers would buy an identical $1,200 sofa online for $1,080 (10% less), with free delivery and free returns, rather than in a showroom near them; 93.2% would at 20% less and 95.2% at 30% less.
02How much cheaper does online have to be before shoppers give up the showroom?
10% is enough for most. With a $1,200 sofa in a showroom near them and the identical sofa online with free delivery in two weeks and free returns within 30 days, 80.8% of US online shoppers (118 of 146) would buy it online for $1,080. At $960 (20% less) that rises to 93.2%, and at $840 (30% less) to 95.2%. No clone that went online at a smaller saving went back to the showroom at a larger one: 18 more move between 10% and 20% less, 3 between 20% and 30% less, and 7 keep the showroom at all three prices.
03What do people still insist on buying in a shop?
Fresh food, far ahead of anything else. Asked which one of five purchases they would most insist on making in a physical shop rather than online, 55.5% (81 of 146) named fresh fruit and vegetables, 6.2% (9) a pair of running shoes and 0.7% (1) a laptop, while 8.2% (12) would buy all of them online. The produce answers are well grounded: 74 of the 81 rest on the person's own interview lines about groceries or produce.
A sofa came second at 29.5% (43 of 146), but we do not defend that figure: 25 of those 43 answers lean on the study's own description of a sofa showroom rather than on anything the person said. Even where the insistence is real, it gives way to a price. Of the 21 clones who picked the sofa and whose own interviews talk about sofas, couches or furniture, 11 would still buy the online sofa at 10% less.
04Who holds out for the showroom, and why?
Older shoppers and those who want to sit on it first. 10 of the 31 clones aged 65 and over would keep the showroom at 10% less, against 15.8% (18 of 114) of those under 65, and 4 of the 7 who keep it even at 30% less are 65 or over. Women and men differ less: 16 of 96 women and 12 of 49 men keep the showroom at 10% less.
Asked what matters most when choosing between the showroom and the identical sofa online for less, 77.4% (113 of 146) said the price difference and 20.5% (30) sitting on it and feeling the fabric first. 2.1% (3) chose seeing its true color and size in person, and none chose advice from a salesperson or not having to arrange a return. Even among the 30 who put sitting on it first, 14 would buy online at 10% less and 24 at 20% less.
05What would a furniture retailer do with this?
- A reading, not the panel's answer: the showroom's job is the trial, not the till. If shoppers will sit on a sofa in a showroom and order the same sofa online, a retailer selling in both places keeps the sale by holding one price across them, rather than handing it to an online rival.
- A reading: the gap that loses the sale is small. Most of these clones moved for $120 on a $1,200 sofa, so a 10% difference between a showroom and a rival's website is enough.
- A reading: the case for the showroom is comfort and fabric, not service. No clone put advice from a salesperson first.
06What else do people ask about buying in a shop or online?
- What share of shoppers would buy a sofa online rather than in a showroom to save 10%? 80.8% of US online shoppers would buy an identical $1,200 sofa online for $1,080 with free delivery and free returns rather than in a showroom near them (n=146, November 2026).
- At what online saving do most shoppers give up the furniture showroom? At 10% or less: 80.8% go online at 10% less, 93.2% at 20% less and 95.2% at 30% less on a $1,200 sofa (n=146, November 2026).
- What share of shoppers most insist on buying fresh fruit and vegetables in a shop? 55.5% of US online shoppers name fresh fruit and vegetables as the one purchase they would most insist on making in a shop, ahead of a sofa, running shoes or a laptop (n=146, November 2026).
Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“I would definitely buy it online for $1,080. If I can check it out or know it's the exact same sofa, I'm always looking to see if it's cheaper online or if there's a deal. Since it's identical, saves me over a hundred dollars, and comes with free delivery and a 30-day return policy, buying it online just makes the most sense.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I do check to see if it's cheaper online or if there's a deal. If not, then I can just get it either way, in person or not.”
“I would definitely buy it online for $1,080. The main reason I like going into a physical store for furniture is so I can sit in it and feel the fabric to make sure of the quality and comfort before committing, because ordering blindly can be a little scary. But if it's the exact same sofa and I already know I like it and have had the chance to sit on it, saving that $120 makes a big difference. I always try to save money where I can, especially on big-ticket items. Plus, having it delivered right to the door for free with a 30-day return policy makes it completely hassle-free and convenient.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“Physical store, I kind of prefer more because you can sit in it. Check out the material it's made in.”
“I would definitely buy it in the showroom for $1,200. While saving 30% sounds appealing on paper, a sofa is a major piece of furniture that you plan to live with for years. You really need to sit on it, feel the texture and quality of the fabric, check the dimensions and comfort, and know exactly what you're getting before bringing it into your home. Shopping online for big-ticket furniture feels sterile, and even with free returns, dealing with returning an entire sofa that isn't quite right would be a massive headache. We're fortunate that we can afford to spend more for quality and peace of mind, and higher-end purchases like that are just better done in person.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“The big difference in the physical store is you can actually sit on the furniture. You can feel the texture. You can feel the quality. Online is kind of sterile.”
Section 08: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- Two reads of all 146 clones' answers, taken two minutes apart, matched base for base and count for count, and a separate read of the report agreed.
- Each price was reasoned on its own figure: $1,080, $960 and $840 appear in 129, 139 and 145 of the 146 answers to their scenarios, and no clone that went online at a smaller saving went back to the showroom at a larger one.
- The price side rests on what the real people said: 130, 138 and 138 of the 146 answers to the three prices cite the person's own interview line about prices, money, saving or deals.
- Fresh produce as the purchase most insisted on in a shop: 74 of the 81 clones who chose it cite their own interview lines about groceries or produce, and none of the 81 reasons from the sofa scenario.
What we would not
- The 29.5% (43 of 146) who named a sofa as the purchase they most insist on making in a shop: 25 of those 43 answers lean on the study's own description of a sofa showroom rather than the person's interviews, which inflates the sofa share and, if anything, understates fresh produce.
- Where the tipping point sits below 10%: there was no rung at the same price or at 5% less, so the share who would pay the showroom price at parity is unknown.
- The 80.8% as the share of real furniture buyers who buy online: the online offer was the identical sofa with free delivery and free returns within 30 days, the best case for online.
- The furniture-specific reasons: every answer on the price ladder was inferred from the person's wider profile, and only 46, 43 and 42 of the 146 answers to the three prices cite the person's own words about sofas, couches or furniture.
- The showrooming share as an exact figure: the figure of at least 14.4% (17 of 118) comes from the clones' written explanations, not from a question that asked it.
- The 93.2% and 95.2% at 20% and 30% less as more than direction, and anything about shoppers under 30 (12 of the 146).
The main limitation
These are 146 Brox clones of US online shoppers, 96 of them women and 93 aged 45 or over, imagining an identical sofa offered online with free delivery and free returns; every answer on the price ladder was inferred from the person's wider profile and price habits rather than a statement about buying a sofa, so the shares show direction and rough size, not observed buying.
Section 09: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Women | 96 |
| Men | 49 |
| Gender not recorded | 1 |
| Aged 18 to 29 | 12 |
| Aged 30 to 44 | 40 |
| Aged 45 to 64 | 62 |
| Aged 65 and over | 31 |
| Age not recorded | 1 |
Question wording as fielded
- Which one of these purchases would you most insist on making in a physical shop rather than online?
- A sofa you like costs $1,200 in a furniture showroom near you, where you can sit on it before buying. The identical sofa, same fabric and colour, costs $1,080 online (10% less), with free delivery in two weeks and free returns within 30 days. Where would you buy it?
- A sofa you like costs $1,200 in a furniture showroom near you, where you can sit on it before buying. The identical sofa, same fabric and colour, costs $960 online (20% less), with free delivery in two weeks and free returns within 30 days. Where would you buy it?
- A sofa you like costs $1,200 in a furniture showroom near you, where you can sit on it before buying. The identical sofa, same fabric and colour, costs $840 online (30% less), with free delivery in two weeks and free returns within 30 days. Where would you buy it?
- When choosing between buying a $1,200 sofa in a furniture showroom and ordering the identical sofa online for less, which one thing matters most to you?
What was not asked, and why
No retailer or brand was named. The study did not test the sofa at the same price online and in the showroom, a 5% gap, a delivery charge, a return fee, a longer delivery time or any other piece of furniture, and it did not ask whether the clone has bought furniture online before. Ask Brox fielded the five questions as written and added none of its own.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question asks which categories people prefer to buy in a shop, which published retail research already lists. This study asks for the one purchase people most insist on making in a shop, then puts a price on that insistence for a sofa, a purchase with a strong case for a showroom, to find the saving at which shoppers give the showroom up.
Fielded through Ask Brox on 9 November 2026.
More on Online or in store? · Pricing and price sensitivity · Retail & e-commerce · E-commerce (US) panel
Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai
Related insights
All in this topic-
AI shopping agents with pre-set limits: only 14.4% of US online shoppers would let one buy without asking, and 43.4% say a maximum budget is the limit that matters most
85.6% Pre-set instructions do not unlock autonomous buying: 85.6% (125 of 146) would not let the agent complete a purchase without asking them again. (base 146)
Read -
Health plan pharmacy benefits: 56.5% of members judge them on the price per prescription, and 73.5% would give up their local pharmacy for mail delivery to save $5 a month
56.5% 56.5% of health plan members (113 of 200) say what they pay at the pharmacy for each prescription is the part of their drug coverage that matters most, 41.0% (82) say whether their medicines are covered at all, and 1.5% (3) say using the pharmacy they want near home. (base 200)
Read -
Paying to keep photos and messages out of AI training: 37% would pay $1 a month, 2% would pay $10
37% 37% of US tech users would pay $1 a month to keep their photos and messages out of a free app's AI training (74 of 200), falling to 13.5% at $5 (27) and 2% at $10 (4). (base 200)
Read -
Patient out-of-pocket cost and prescribing: US physicians keep a preferred brand at $25 a month, split at $75, and 62.9% switch to a generic at $150
37.1% 37.1% (26 of 70) would still prescribe the brand-name medicine they prefer when it costs the patient $150 a month against $5 for an older generic, down from 95.7% (67 of 70) at $25 and 55.7% (39 of 70) at $75; none of the 70 moves back to the brand as the price rises. (base 70)
Read