Free returns lead 62% of US online clothes shoppers to order two sizes; a $5 return fee cuts that to 1 in 200, and most walk away rather than order one

61.5% of US adults who buy clothes online would order two sizes of a $60 pair of jeans and send one back when returns are free, none would order three, and a $5 fee for each item sent back cuts two-size orders to 1 of 200 (n=200, October 2026).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
US online clothes shoppers, 200 clones, US
When
October 2026 (fielded 19 October 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question asks what share of shoppers order several sizes, which industry returns reports already estimate at between a third and two thirds. This study asked the measurable part they leave open: whether shoppers would order several sizes and send most back, and the return fee at which ordering two sizes stops, on the same 200 clones.

Section 01: What the panel said

  1. #

    61.5%

    With free returns, 61.5% would order both sizes of a $60 pair of jeans from a retailer they have not used before and send one back, 34.0% would order one size and none would order three. A $5 fee for each item sent back cuts two-size orders to 1 of 200 (0.5%), and a $10 fee to none.

    base 200

  2. #

    59.5%

    Most shoppers who stop ordering two sizes do not switch to one: with a $5 return fee 59.5% would not buy the jeans at all and 14.0% would go to a store instead, against 1.5% who would not buy with free returns; at a $10 fee 82.0% would not buy. Of the 119 who would not buy at $5, 45 said they would look elsewhere.

    base 200 · contrast

  3. #

    84.3%

    Ordering two sizes with free returns rises with income: 84.3% in households on $100,000 a year or more (43 of 51), 72.5% between $50,000 and $99,999 (50 of 69) and 36.7% under $50,000 (29 of 79).

    base 51 · Household income $100,000 and over (n=51) · contrast

  4. #

    38.2%

    Of the 123 who would order two sizes with free returns, a $5 fee turns 47 (38.2%) into single-size buyers, sends 14 (11.4%) to a store and leads 61 (49.6%) not to buy.

    base 123 · Would order two sizes with free returns (n=123) · caveat

With free returns, 61.5% would order both sizes of a $60 pair of jeans from a retailer they have not used before and send one back, 34.0% would order one size and none would order three. A $5 fee for each item sent back cuts two-size orders to 1 of 200 (0.5%), and a $10 fee to none.

Order two sizes, free returns
61.5%
Order two sizes, $5 per return
0.5%
Order two sizes, $10 per return
0%

Base 200 clones.

02Why does a $5 fee stop two-size orders almost completely?

Because ordering two sizes turns a possible fee into a certain one. Of the 47 clones who would switch from two sizes to one when a $5 fee applies, 41 said in their own words that ordering both would guarantee paying it. The fee was the thing they reasoned about: it appears in 196 of the 200 answers to the $5 scenario.

Most clones who stop ordering two sizes do not become careful single-size buyers, though. Of the 119 who would not buy the jeans at a $5 fee, 45 said they would look for them elsewhere, which makes "not buy" partly a lost sale for this retailer rather than a lost purchase.

03Who orders two sizes when returns are free?

Mostly people who can afford to pay for both pairs while they wait for a refund. Ordering two sizes rises from 36.7% in households under $50,000 a year (n=79) to 84.3% at $100,000 and over (n=51). Of the 46 clones under $50,000 who would order one size even with free returns, 45 talked about spending double, paying $120 up front or tying money up on a card.

Men are more likely than women to order two sizes, 70.3% (n=64) against 57.4% (n=136). Among the 19 clones who buy clothes online at least once a month, 15 would order two sizes; they are too few for a percentage.

04What would make shoppers order one size without charging them?

Fit reviews from shoppers of a similar height and build are the only alternative to a fee that registered: 29 of 200 (14.5%) picked them as the thing most likely to make them order one size. A size recommendation based on clothes they had already bought and kept drew no picks, and nor did "nothing would change me".

The other 170 (85.0%) picked a $10 fee for each item sent back. That question came after two fee scenarios, so we read it as direction, not as a share: a price stops two-size orders, and fit reviews are the softer lever worth testing.

05What else do people ask about bracketing and return fees?

  1. What share of online shoppers order more than one size? 61.5% of US adults who buy clothes online would order two sizes of a $60 pair of jeans when returns are free, and none of 200 would order three (October 2026).
  2. At what return fee do shoppers stop ordering two sizes? At $5 for each item sent back, two-size orders fall from 123 of 200 clones to 1.
  3. How many shoppers walk away when a retailer charges for returns? 59.5% would not buy the jeans from an unfamiliar retailer charging $5 a return, and 82.0% at $10 (n=200).

Section 06: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“Since returns are completely free, I would go ahead and order both sizes and then just send back whichever one doesn't fit. In the past, I used to be really hesitant about ordering clothes and shoes online because I hated the hassle of ordering a single size, having it turn out too big or too small, and then having to waste time dealing with the return process. But nowadays, returnability has gotten so much easier and more convenient. With free returns, that pressure is gone. It makes total sense to test them both out at home, keep the pair that fits right, and return the other one without any stress.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I think the most important factor for me when choosing to buy a shoe online is the ease of returnability.”

Man, 30-44, California, would order both sizes with free returns supports finding 1

“I'm definitely not buying the jeans. If I've never ordered from them before, don't even know what size fits, and they want to charge me five bucks just to return something that doesn't fit, that's not worth it. Plain and simple, I'll cancel and find something cheaper or better from somewhere else. Why would I risk throwing away five dollars on odds like that?”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Well, if it increases too much and it's not worth it, cancel. Plain and simple, I'll buy something cheaper, probably even better. So don't do it.”

Man, 30-44, Georgia, would not buy at a $5 return fee supports finding 2

“So in this situation, I would definitely order one size and return it if it does not fit. For me, I would look at which size I feel is most likely to fit best and just start with that one. That way, if it fits, I don't have to pay that extra five dollars at all, which is better for me in my pocket. But if it turns out it doesn't fit, a $5 fee is just a couple of dollars, and that wouldn't hurt me too much to send it back. I just wouldn't want to order both sizes right off the bat because then I know for sure I'm going to have to return one and automatically lose five dollars.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“But a couple of dollars would not hurt me at all.”

Woman, 30-44, Georgia, would switch from two sizes to one at a $5 fee supports finding 4

Section 07: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • Free returns make ordering two sizes the majority choice: 123 of 200 (61.5%), with every option offered and none of 200 ordering three.
  • Each fee scenario was reasoned on its figure: $5 appears in 196 of 200 answers to the $5 scenario and $10 in all 200 answers to the $10 scenario, and two independent reads of every clone's answer matched exactly.
  • Within the same 123 clones, a $5 fee ends two-size orders for all but one, and more of them stop buying (61) than switch to one size (47).
  • The income gradient rests on bases of 51 to 79, and 45 of the 46 single-size choosers under $50,000 give paying for two pairs as the reason.

What we would not

  • The 59.5% and 82.0% who would not buy as real-world lost-sale rates: most US retailers already charge for some returns and shoppers still buy from them. This is stated intent at a retailer the shopper has not used before, and 45 of the 119 would buy elsewhere.
  • The 85.0% who pick a $10 fee as what would make them order one size: it came after two fee scenarios and is near-unanimous, so it is direction only.
  • No picks for a size recommendation as a verdict on fit tools: the option assumed purchase history a new retailer would not hold.
  • Any percentage for the 19 clones who buy clothes online monthly or more, or for the 16 aged 18-29: they are counts only.
  • The page as a picture of frequent online clothes buyers: 181 of the 200 buy online only a few times a year, and 136 of 200 are women.

The main limitation

These are 200 Brox clones of US adults who buy clothes or shoes online, most of them only a few times a year, answering one hypothetical $60 jeans purchase at a retailer they have not used before; the study measures how a return fee changes what they say they would do, not observed return rates.

Section 08: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Buy clothes or shoes online a few times a year181
Buy clothes or shoes online about once a month7
Buy clothes or shoes online several times a month12
Household income under $50,00079
Household income $50,000 to $99,99969
Household income $100,000 and over51

Question wording as fielded

  1. How often do you buy clothes or shoes online?
  2. You are buying a pair of jeans priced at $60 online from a retailer you have not bought from before, and you are not sure which of two sizes fits you. Returns are free. What do you do?
  3. You are buying a pair of jeans priced at $60 online from a retailer you have not bought from before, and you are not sure which of two sizes fits you. The retailer charges $5 for each item you send back. What do you do?
  4. You are buying a pair of jeans priced at $60 online from a retailer you have not bought from before, and you are not sure which of two sizes fits you. The retailer charges $10 for each item you send back. What do you do?
  5. Which of these would most likely make you order only one size of a $60 pair of jeans online, rather than two or more?

What was not asked, and why

No retailer or brand was named. The study did not ask about a retailer the shopper already uses, prices other than $60, a fee only after a first free return, free returns in store, or how often the clone has ordered several sizes in the past, which the panel does not hold as data.

What changed from the obvious question

The obvious question asks what share of shoppers order several sizes, which industry returns reports already estimate at between a third and two thirds. This study asked the measurable part they leave open: whether shoppers would order several sizes and send most back, and the return fee at which ordering two sizes stops, on the same 200 clones.

Fielded through Ask Brox on 19 October 2026.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai

Related insights

All in this topic