76% of US fans who follow a local team expect to stop watching full games once the only way in is a paid streaming add-on

76% of US streaming viewers who follow a local team (102 of 135) expect to stop watching full games once a paid add-on is the only way in, September 2026.

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
US fans who follow a local team, 200 clones, US
When
September 2026 (fielded 26 September 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question is how many fans would subscribe. That was asked, but it is the weaker number, because a stated yes to a subscription is cheap. The question was widened to what fans would do INSTEAD, which is where the finding turned out to be: the same person who will not pay is not leaving the team, they are dropping to highlights and team news.

Section 01: What the panel said

  1. #

    76%

    76% of fans expect to stop watching full games once a paid add-on is the only way in (102 of 135).

    base 135

  2. #

    15%

    Asked plainly, 15% would pay for the add-on at all (20 of 135).

    base 135

  3. #

    13%

    Of the fans who named a monthly ceiling, 13% would go above $20 (12 of 91), so a $19.99 pass sits at the top of the tolerated band rather than inside it.

    base 91

  4. #

    63%

    63% of those who say they are not sports fans would stop following the team altogether (41 of 65), against 15% of the fans, so the paywall loses the lapsed viewer and downgrades the committed one.

    base 65 · Says they are not a sports fan · contrast

Of the fans who named a monthly ceiling, 13% would go above $20 (12 of 91), so a $19.99 pass sits at the top of the tolerated band rather than inside it.

Would pay nothing
44%
Under $10
17%
$10 to $14.99
26%
$15 to $19.99
36%
$20 to $24.99
12%

Base 91 clones.

02What is the first thing a rights holder should take from this?

The paywall does not cost you the fan. It costs you the full game. Of the 135 panellists who follow a local team, 102 (76%) said that moving their team's games to a paid add-on would stop them watching full games, and yet only 20 of the same 135 (15%) said they would stop following the team at all.

The fan who will not pay does not disappear. They drop a rung. Asked what they would do instead, 35 of the 135 went to highlights only and 30 to team news, against 20 who would stop following. Minutes watched is where the change lands first, not the size of the fanbase.

03Where does the answer change, and for whom?

It changes sharply with how attached the viewer already was. Among the 65 panellists who said outright that they are not sports fans, 41 (63%) would stop following the team altogether. Among the 135 who do follow a team, 20 (15%) would.

Read together, those two numbers say the paywall sorts the audience rather than shrinking it evenly. The casual viewer at the edge leaves and does not come back. The committed one stays and watches less.

04What does the price ladder actually say?

That roughly $20 a month is a ceiling, not a midpoint. Of the 91 fans who named any monthly price they would accept, only 12 (13%) went above $20. The largest single group, 36 of the 135, caps out between $15 and $19.99, and 44 of the 135 would pay nothing at all.

The season figure points the same way from the other side. 36 of the 135 would pay between $100 and $149 for a full season, which is more per month than most of them would agree to month by month. A season price gets a better answer than a monthly one at the same annualised cost.

05What should be read as a finding, and what only as a reading?

One caution belongs on the face of this. 81 of the 200 panellists said they would not pay and then named a monthly price they would accept anyway. A stated refusal to subscribe is soft, so the 15% should be read as the shape of resistance rather than as a forecast of take-up.

  1. A reading, not the panel's answer: if the loss is full games rather than fans, the measure to watch in the first season is minutes and full-game completion per local household, not subscriptions sold.
  2. A reading, not the panel's answer: the group that drops to highlights is large enough that a free highlights and news tier inside the paid product may retain more attention than a discount on the pass itself.
  3. A reading, not the panel's answer: pricing the season rather than the month tested better here, which is worth a direct head to head before a renewal cycle sets the default.

Section 06: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“If I can't watch the games live without paying extra, I'd most likely just watch the highlights after the game. I already watch highlights and listen to sports news to keep up with the team anyway.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“I've watched some of their games, watched the highlights, listened to sports news, and so forth to keep up with the team.”

Man, 65 or over, Indiana supports finding 1

Section 07: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • 76% of the 135 fans expect to stop watching full games (102 of 135), and 15% would pay for the add-on at all (20 of 135). Both figures come from the same 135 panellists and were identical across two independent pulls of the data.
  • The gap between the groups: 41 of the 65 who say they are not sports fans would stop following the team, against 20 of the 135 fans.

What we would not

  • Any forecast of take-up for a real pass. 81 of the 200 said they would not pay and still named a monthly price they would accept, so stated refusal here is soft.
  • Anything about hockey specifically. The panel is US streaming viewers and no league or sport was named (n=200).

The main limitation

The panel is US streaming viewers, not sports fans. 65 of the 200 said outright that they are not sports fans, so every headline figure is reported on the 135 who did not, and only 37 of the 421 screened had actually lived through a move like this.

Section 08: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Follows a local team135
Says they are not a sports fan65

Question wording as fielded

  1. Thinking about this new setup for your local team's games, would you personally pay for the paid streaming add-on at all?
  2. If you were deciding month to month, what is the highest monthly price you would still be willing to pay to watch your local team's games through the add-on?
  3. If you were deciding for the full season, what is the highest total season price you would still be willing to pay for access to your local team's games?
  4. If you would not pay for the add-on, how would you most likely keep up with your local team instead?
  5. Compared with when your local team's games were on regional cable television, how would this paid add-on change how often you expect to watch full games?
  6. What is the main reason you would or would not pay for the add-on to watch your local team's games?

What was not asked, and why

No sport, league or club was named, and nobody was asked whether they already pay for the streaming service that would carry the pass. The pass was therefore priced as a standalone cost rather than as an add-on to a subscription a household already holds, which is the harder reading of the price.

What changed from the obvious question

The obvious question is how many fans would subscribe. That was asked, but it is the weaker number, because a stated yes to a subscription is cheap. The question was widened to what fans would do INSTEAD, which is where the finding turned out to be: the same person who will not pay is not leaving the team, they are dropping to highlights and team news.

Fielded through Ask Brox on 26 September 2026.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai

Related insights

All in this topic